# How to read Material Insights

Source page: https://www.materialinsights.org/guide/

Architecture of the site

## How to read Material Insights

A guide to what this site is for, the pieces it is built from, how they connect, how the facts are checked, the sustainability analysis being built on top, and how to get the most out of it, whether you invest, build technology or make policy.
 Commodities 120 what is mined and grown Chemicals 117 what is made from them Energy 27 natural sources and fuels Technologies 516 on the periodic table Science 131 principles and discoveries Industries 36 408 enterprise types Products 100 researched so far, more in batches **On this page**

1. Why this site exists
2. The big picture: one graph
3. The node types
4. The relationships
5. Facts, sources and checking
6. The sustainability framework
7. How to use the site
8. A worked example
9. What is built and what is coming
10. Glossary
11. Reference: what each node and link holds

### 1. Why this site exists

Every product, every factory and every service rests on a small number of physical things: rocks, crops, molecules and energy. A phone needs copper, tin, gallium and rare earths. A loaf of bread needs wheat, fertiliser made from natural gas, diesel and electricity. A data centre needs steel, concrete, copper and a great deal of power. When one of these physical inputs becomes scarce, expensive, polluting or politically risky, the effect travels up through every industry that depends on it.

Most information about this is scattered. Mining data sits in one place, chemical industry data in another, energy statistics in a third, and technology history somewhere else again. Investors see company accounts, policy makers see national statistics, and technologists see their own field. Few people see the whole chain.

Material Insights joins the pieces into **one connected map of the material world**: what things are made of, how they are made, who makes and uses them, how they depend on each other, and where the risks and opportunities sit. It is built for three groups:

- **Investors**, including those who back technology: to see the physical dependencies behind a company, a sector or a theme, where supply is concentrated, which prices move together, and which technologies are rising.
- **Technologists**: to see the science a technology rests on, the materials and energy it needs, how it evolved, and the industries that use it.
- **Policy makers**: to see chokepoints, critical materials, where a country stands, and (with the sustainability layer) which interventions could cut emissions and waste while staying economically viable.

### 2. The big picture: one graph

The site is built as a **graph**: a set of **nodes** (things) joined by **relationships** (how one thing depends on or affects another). Each node has its own page with tabs of facts and explanations. Each relationship has a type, a direction and, where it matters, numbers.

Chart: How the node types connect: science explains technologies; technologies turn commodities, chemicals and energy into products; products are made and used by industries; interventions change the links.
The whole site is one graph. Science explains how technologies work. Technologies turn commodities, chemicals and energy into products. Industries make and use those products. Interventions (being built next) change the numbers on the links to make the system more sustainable.

Read the picture from left to right: raw materials and energy flow into products, products flow into industries. Read it from top to bottom: science explains why a technology works, and the technology is how materials and energy become products. Interventions sit above everything: they are proposed changes to the links, such as using more recycled steel or switching a furnace to electricity.

### 3. The node types

Each node type answers a different question. Every node page opens with a **summary** (what it is, why it matters, key numbers and where it happens), followed by tabs that go deeper. Most tables can be coloured by a measure (criticality, concentration, era and so on) so patterns stand out.

#### Commodities

Raw materials that are mined, drilled, grown or harvested and traded in bulk. They sit on the Periodic Table of Commodities, grouped into families such as base metals, battery metals, precious metals, fertilisers, grains and softs.

**Examples:** copper, lithium, iron ore, rare earths, wheat, cotton, timber, water.

**On its page:** seven lenses: extraction, production, stocks, cycles, trading, movement and criticality, plus price links, emissions, a quiz and good resources to follow.

**Questions it answers:** Where does it come from and how concentrated is supply? Whose prices move with it? How critical is it, and to whom?

#### Chemicals

Substances and families of substances made from commodities and energy, from bulk acids and plastics to speciality molecules. They sit on the Periodic Table of Chemicals.

**Examples:** ammonia, sulphuric acid, ethylene, polyethylene, chlorine, urea, silicones.

**On its page:** feedstocks and production routes, where the money goes, trading, criticality, regulation, emissions and the industries that use them.

**Questions it answers:** What is it made from, by which route, and what does it go into? Which rules apply to it?

#### Energy

Natural sources of energy and the fuels made from them: what is captured from nature, and what carries energy to where it is used. The machines that capture, move, store and convert energy are technologies, so they live in the Technologies section.

**Examples:** sunlight, wind, coal, crude oil, natural gas, uranium, biomass, petrol, hydrogen, electricity as a carrier.

**On its page:** how the energy resides in nature, abundance, how it varies over time, geography, impact on nature, and the fuels and carriers made from it.

**Questions it answers:** How much is there, where, how variable is it, and what does using it do to the environment?

#### Technologies

Distinct working principles used for a purpose: methods and capabilities, not brands or models. They sit on the Periodic Table of Technologies: columns are twelve purposes (making materials, energy, food, health, building, transport, communication, computing, sensing, making things, defence, space) and rows are eras of first practical use, from prehistory to today.

**Examples:** the blast furnace, the Haber-Bosch process, the transistor, the lithium-ion battery, satellite navigation, large language models.

**On its page:** thirteen tabs: overview, science, engineering, evolution, materials, energy footprint, industries, economics, geography, impacts and the research frontier.

**Questions it answers:** How does it work, what does it need, when did it first work in practice, who leads it, and what comes next?

#### Science

The principles and discoveries that technologies rely on, or are limited by. They sit on their own table, grouped by field.

**Examples:** Newton's laws, electromagnetic induction, the laws of thermodynamics, fracture mechanics, the Haber equilibrium.

**On its page:** the idea in plain words, the discovery and who made it, its limits, and the technologies that use it.

**Questions it answers:** Why does this technology work, and what physical limit will it eventually hit?

#### Industries and enterprise types

36 industries arranged as the Pyramid of Industries: the base turns matter and energy into usable inputs, and each higher stratum builds on those below. Each industry opens as a value chain of stages, and each stage holds **enterprise types** (408 in all), such as contract foundries or cold-chain operators.

**Examples:** semiconductors, construction, food and beverage, healthcare, vehicles.

**On its page:** the value chain, cost mix (where each ₹100 goes), materials drawn on, unit economics, chokepoints and risks, geopolitics and regulation, and flows of what each industry buys and sells (for India, from input-output tables).

**Questions it answers:** Which industries rest on which? Where are the chokepoints? What does a whole chain draw on?

#### Products

Classes of goods that are sold, mapped to international trade codes (HS headings). A base product is made directly from materials and energy; a composite product is made from other products. Bulk materials stay commodities or chemicals.

**Examples:** a lithium-ion battery, a passenger car tyre, a solar module, a smartphone, a battery electric car.

**On its page:** what it is made of (a drill-down tree and totals), how it is made, who uses it and in which industrial processes, its evolution, market and risks.

**Questions it answers:** What is inside it, how much, from where, and which industries depend on it?

#### Interventions being designed

Sustainability levers recorded as precise changes to the links: use less material, substitute, change route, recycle, save energy, electrify, capture, design for longer life, or change the business model.

**Examples:** more scrap in steelmaking, heat pumps for low-temperature process heat, design for disassembly, recycled content in packaging.

**On its page:** which links change and by how much, the technologies that enable it, who must act and who is affected, preconditions and evidence from real deployments.

**Questions it answers:** Which changes cut emissions or waste while staying viable at market prices, and what happens if they scale?

Chart: A battery electric car drills down to a battery pack, tyres and steel; the pack to cells; the cells to cathode material and electrolyte; the cathode to nickel, lithium and cobalt.
Drilling into a composite product. A product made from other products opens like a tree. The site will add up every path, so you can see the total material in one unit, and every material page will list the products it ends up in. (Product nodes are the next build; this picture shows the design.)

Every tab, field and attribute of each node type is listed in the reference at the end of this guide.

**A note on defence.** Weapons are technologies like any other and appear on the table, because they shape industries, materials and policy. Their pages stay at the level of history, the general principle, law, arms control and economics. The same rule applies to chemicals, biology and nuclear technologies that could be misused: no designs, recipes or specifications.

### 4. The relationships

A relationship says how one node depends on or affects another. Relationships are grouped into families. Some are calculated from data (for example, prices that move together); others are researched and written with sources (for example, a technology that relies on a scientific principle).

Chart: Lithium-ion batteries require lithium, nickel and cobalt; rely on electrochemistry; store electricity; are used by the vehicles industry; and replaced nickel-based batteries. Nickel and cobalt are often mined together.
A small corner of the graph. One technology connects to materials (what it needs), science (why it works), energy (what it does with energy), industries (who uses it) and other technologies (what it grew out of). Two commodities connect to each other because they come out of the same mines.

| Family | What it means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Physical flow | Material or energy moves from one node into another: feedstock, direct input, a step in a chain, a fuel, energy use, scrap returning. | Natural gas is the feedstock for ammonia. |
| Material needs | A technology requires, processes, recovers, uses, is made of, produces or emits a material or chemical. | A wind turbine requires rare earths for its magnets. |
| Energy role | A technology consumes, embodies, converts, stores, wastes or recovers energy. | A heat pump converts electricity into heat. |
| Industry use | A technology or material is used by, made by, transforms or created an industry. | Photolithography is used by semiconductor makers. |
| Technology lineage | How technologies relate over time: builds on, evolved from, enables, substitutes, complements, converges into. | The transistor replaced the vacuum tube. |
| Science basis | A technology relies on a principle, or is limited by one. | A rocket is limited by the rocket equation. |
| Cost and price | Prices move together, one price feeds into another, or a margin sits between input and output. | Fertiliser prices follow natural gas. |
| Substitution | One can replace the other, or two routes compete for the same output. | Aluminium can replace copper in some cables. |
| Joint production | Produced together: by-products, co-products, the same geology or the same site. | Cobalt is mostly a by-product of copper and nickel mining. |
| Shared risk | A shared chokepoint, a single supplier or a shared customer. | Many critical minerals are refined mostly in one country. |
| Policy | The same rules or the same regulated use. | Mercury rules affect lighting and chlor-alkali plants. |
| Transition | Demand drivers and shifts linked to the energy transition. | Electric vehicles drive lithium demand. |
| Geography and ownership | The same countries or the same companies. | Platinum and palladium come largely from the same places. |

The product layer adds **made from**, **component of**, **energy to make**, **energy in use**, **made with**, **embodies**, **made by** and **used by** (with the industrial process written on the link). The sustainability layer adds **recovered as**, which closes the loop from used products back to materials. Every one of the relationship types, with what it means and an example, is listed in the reference at the end of this guide.

### 5. Facts, sources and checking

Numbers are only useful if you can trust them and trace them. The site follows a few firm rules:

- **Every figure and date has a source**, shown on the page, and researched content carries the exact words from the source that support it.
- **Independent checking.** Researched content is written by one researcher and checked by a different one, who opens every source, corrects or removes anything unsupported, and records what changed. Only checked content is published.
- **Dates are tested, not copied.** "Invented" means the first showing of the working principle; "first practical use" means first use in real service. Many catalogue dates were corrected this way, and the corrections are recorded.
- **Years are honest.** A figure's year comes from the sentence that states it, never from a page's publication date. Where a page gives no data year, the site says so.
- **Ranges, not false precision.** Where sources disagree, the page gives the range and says why. Calculated figures are marked as calculated.
- **Quality labels.** Estimates, forecasts, single-company figures and older data are labelled as such.

Sources include the US Geological Survey, World Mining Data, FAOSTAT, the International Energy Agency, the Energy Institute, the World Bank, UN Comtrade, national statistics, museums, universities and peer-reviewed journals.

### 6. The sustainability framework

being designed This layer sits on top of the whole graph, including products. It asks one question: **how can our industries use materials, chemicals and energy more sustainably, in ways that are economically viable today and can scale?**

#### The goals

- Less virgin material, and more reuse and recycling of commodities.
- Safer, recyclable and bio-based chemicals.
- More efficient use of energy.
- Lower emissions across making and using products, in every industry.

#### Three choices that shape it

- **India first.** Every figure is for India where an Indian source exists (for example the Central Electricity Authority, the Bureau of Energy Efficiency and the Annual Survey of Industries). Where none exists, a world figure fills in and is marked as a stand-in, so gaps in Indian data stay visible.
- **Ten-year windows.** Scenarios cover the next ten years (2026 to 2036) by default, and can be extended in ten-year steps.
- **Market prices only.** Viability is judged at today's market prices and sourced price projections, plus policies already in force in India where they change what a firm pays or earns. There is no hypothetical carbon price.

#### The core idea: the graph as a model

When every link carries an amount per unit (kilograms of material, kilowatt-hours of energy, tonnes of emissions, money), the graph becomes a model of the economy's physical flows. The baseline is how things are done today. An intervention is a set of changes to some of those amounts. A what-if recalculates every chain the change touches.

Chart: An illustration with made-up numbers: switching part of steelmaking to scrap lowers iron ore, coal and emissions per car while scrap use rises.
The idea behind the sustainability analysis, with made-up numbers. Every link carries an amount per unit. An intervention (here: making more of a car's steel from scrap) changes some of those amounts. The model recalculates every chain it touches, so the effect shows up in materials, energy, emissions and cost at once.

#### Discovering opportunities

1. **Find hotspots**: the products, routes and industries with the most emissions, energy, virgin material, waste, hazardous chemicals or exposure to critical materials, counting what is embodied in components.
2. **Match interventions** that apply to each hotspot.
3. **Score each one** on five tests, and show why it scores as it does:

| Test | What it looks at |
|---|---|
| Impact | Emissions avoided, energy saved, virgin material avoided, hazard reduced: per unit and at Indian scale. |
| Viable | Change in cost at each stage, payback, cost per tonne of emissions avoided, and the green premium as it passes down the chain. |
| Scalable | How mature it is, how fast its cost falls, supply limits (scrap, clean power, land, water, critical minerals), years to build capacity. |
| Plausible | Deployments in India and elsewhere, quality of evidence, how wide the uncertainty is. |
| Fair to stakeholders | Who pays and who gains: miners, makers, users, recyclers (including the informal sector), government, workers and communities. |

Chart: An illustration with made-up numbers: a 25 percent premium on low-carbon steel becomes about 6 percent on a car body and about 1 percent on the whole car.
The green premium cascade, with made-up numbers. A cleaner material can cost much more per tonne, yet add very little to the price of the final product. Showing the premium at every stage shows who in the chain can carry the cost, which is often the difference between "too expensive" and "viable".

#### What-if analysis

A scenario is a set of interventions, each with an adoption path, plus stated assumptions about prices, the electricity grid, learning rates and demand. The model reports, year by year and against the baseline: material demand (virgin and recycled), energy by carrier, emissions, cost and price at each stage, and industry totals. It flags broken limits and second-order effects, such as one intervention raising demand for another material. Every result carries a range, and you can save and compare scenarios.

Chart: An adoption curve rising over ten years from 2026 to 2036 until it meets a dashed line marking a supply limit, where it levels off.
A what-if scenario. Each intervention is adopted along an S-curve over the window. The model checks limits such as how much scrap, clean electricity or critical minerals exist, and flags any year where a scenario asks for more than is available. Here adoption levels off when it reaches the limit.

### 7. How to use the site

#### The tools

- **Search** (press /): find any commodity, chemical, energy source, technology, science node or industry, and jump straight to a tab.
- **The tables**: the periodic tables of commodities, chemicals, energy and technologies, and the science table. Colour them by a measure to see patterns; click a tile to open its page.
- **Node pages and tabs**: start with the summary, then open the tab that matches your question.
- **The Pyramid of Industries**: click an industry to see its value chain and everything it depends on; select an industry to light up its suppliers and customers.
- **Explore**: the whole graph on one screen. Search for a node, then follow its links one step at a time; filter by node type and relationship family.
- **Relationships**: researched pages on pairs of nodes that are closely linked, such as metals that are mined together or prices that move together.
- **Learn**: five courses (Understanding Commodities, Chemicals, Energy, Science and Engineering) with 71 modules, for building the background step by step.

#### Routes for different readers

#### If you invest

1. Start from a theme (say, electrification) and open the technologies behind it on the Technologies table.
2. Open their **Materials** and **Geography** tabs to see what they need and who leads.
3. Follow the materials to their commodity pages: the **Criticality**, **Trading** and **Price links** lenses show concentration and what moves together.
4. Check the **Industries** pyramid for chokepoints in the chains you hold.

#### If you build technology

1. Open your technology on the table and read **Science** and **Frontier**: what it relies on and what limits it.
2. Read **Evolution** for what it replaced and what may replace it.
3. Use **Materials** and **Energy footprint** to see your exposure to scarce inputs.
4. Use **Explore** to find neighbouring technologies that complement yours.

#### If you make policy

1. Colour the commodity table by **criticality** and open the red tiles.
2. Read their **Movement** and **Criticality** lenses for import dependence and chokepoints.
3. Open the industries that rest on them in the pyramid, and the **flows** view for India.
4. Use the sustainability layer, when ready, to test interventions at Indian scale over ten years.

#### Tips for deeper study

- Read the sources: every page lists them, and most claims link to the exact passage that supports them.
- Compare like with like: check the year and the unit before comparing two figures.
- Follow a chain both ways: down to its materials and energy, and up to the industries and products that depend on it.
- Use the Markdown version at the foot of each page to quote or take notes.

### 8. A worked example: from a lithium mine to a car

1. **Commodity.** Open [Lithium](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/) on the commodities table. The **Extraction** and **Production** lenses show where it is mined and refined; **Criticality** shows how concentrated that is.
2. **Technology.** From lithium, follow the link to the lithium-ion battery technologies. Their **Science** tab explains the electrochemistry; **Materials** shows nickel, cobalt, graphite and lithium; **Evolution** shows how they replaced nickel-based batteries.
3. **Industry.** Open the vehicles industry in the [Pyramid of Industries](https://www.materialinsights.org/industries/). Its value chain shows the cell makers and pack assemblers, and the panel "What the whole chain draws on" lists every material it needs.
4. **Relationships.** In [Explore](https://www.materialinsights.org/explore/), select cobalt to see that it is mostly mined alongside copper and nickel, so its supply depends on theirs.
5. **Product.** Open the [passenger car](https://www.materialinsights.org/products/p_passenger_car/) and the [lithium-ion battery](https://www.materialinsights.org/products/p_lithium_ion_battery/): what each is made of, by mass, who supplies it and its footprint.
6. **Analyse.** On the [Analyse page for lithium](https://www.materialinsights.org/analyse/lithium/), pick your view (technologist, investor or policy maker) and read the answers in a line: who produces it, where India ranks, what would feel a shortage.
7. **Sustainability (being designed).** Test an intervention, such as more battery recycling in India, and see what it does to lithium and cobalt imports, emissions and cost over the next ten years.

### 9. What is built and what is coming

| Part | Status |
|---|---|
| Commodities, chemicals and energy tables, with their pages and courses | Built |
| Pyramid of Industries, value chains and India flows | Built |
| Explore graph and relationship pages | Built |
| Technologies and science tables | Built, every node sourced and independently checked; a deeper second pass on the most important ones comes later |
| Products (50, from a syringe to an aeroplane) | Built, every fact checked against its source |
| Analyse: ask about something, and nine data tools | Built; ready-made question sets for each kind of reader come next |
| Sustainability analysis and interventions | Being built next; starts with two Indian chains (a passenger car and a building) |

### 10. Glossary

**Node**
: One thing on the map: a commodity, chemical, energy source, technology, science principle, industry, product or intervention.

**Relationship**
: A typed, directed link between two nodes, sometimes with numbers.

**Criticality**
: How hard it would be to cope if a supply were cut: high when supply is concentrated, hard to substitute and important to many industries.

**Chokepoint**
: A stage in a chain where a few suppliers or a single country can halt the whole chain.

**Era of first practical use**
: The period when a technology first worked in real service, which sets its row on the technology table.

**Base and composite product**
: A base product is made directly from materials and energy; a composite product is made from other products.

**HS heading**
: A code from the Harmonized System used in world trade statistics to classify goods.

**Roll-up**
: Adding up every path through a composite product to get its total material, energy and emissions per unit.

**Intervention**
: A sustainability lever written as precise changes to the links of the graph.

**Green premium**
: The extra cost of a cleaner way of doing something, compared with today's way.

**Baseline**
: How things are done today, against which a scenario is compared.

**Dual use**
: A technology or material with both civil and military uses; its pages stay at history, principle and policy level.

### 11. Reference: what each node and link holds

For readers who want the detail. Open any block to see what that node type holds (its identity, attributes, tabs and the items inside each tab) or what each type of relationship means, which kinds of node it joins and an example.

#### Node types

**What every node has**identity, attributes, tabs, content items, facts and sources

- **Identity.** A short permanent id (used in addresses, such as copper in /commodities/copper/), a name, a symbol shown on its tile, and its **path**: its place in the taxonomy, from node type to family to group (for example Commodities, then Metals, then Base metals).
- **Tags.** Labels such as membership of the US, EU or Indian lists of critical minerals, used for colouring tables and filtering.
- **Parent.** Only for enterprise types: the industry they belong to.
- **Attributes.** A few fixed facts used to place and colour the node, such as a technology's era or a science node's field.
- **Tabs.** The reading sections of its page. Each node type has its own set of tabs, listed below.
- **Content items.** Each tab holds items. An item has a kind: a paragraph of text, a list, a table, a record (a small group of named values), a number with low and high values, a map from places to values, or a set of links to other nodes. Every item carries the date it was written or checked, a quality label where it matters (estimate, forecast, calculated) and its sources.
- **Version history.** When an item changes, the old version is kept with its date, so changes can be traced.
- **Facts.** Measured series, such as production by country and year or monthly prices, are kept separately as facts: a measure, a unit, a place, a year, a value and a source. Charts and tables are drawn from them.
- **Sources.** A register of every source (title, publisher, year, address). Items cite sources with the exact place inside them (a page, a table, a section).

**Commodities**groups, tags and sixteen tabs

- **Groups:** metals (base, precious, battery, minor and others), minerals, agriculture, water, and energy commodities such as coal, crude oil and natural gas.
- **Tags:** critical-mineral lists (US, EU, India) and similar labels.
- **Example:** copper sits under Metals, then Base metals; it is tagged as critical in some lists; its tabs cover everything below.

**Tabs and what they hold**

- **Summary**: the opening view.

  - a one-line hook; three big numbers (the page adds a fourth from data, such as price or criticality); the journey from source to use in four to six steps; up to six producing countries on a map; three things to know; four short story cards (where it comes from, who makes it, price drama, why it matters); a card for every deeper tab

- **Overview**: what it is and what it is used for.

  - tagline; main uses with shares, volumes, why this commodity and the alternatives; the value chain as numbered steps; three things to know

- **Price links**: the other tiles whose prices tend to move with it.

  - an introduction; each linked tile with an explanation and the measured correlation; a note when there is no public price

- **Extraction**: how it is mined, grown or made.

  - an opening lesson; extraction and processing methods compared in a table; supply that comes as a by-product of other metals

- **Production**: who produces it and how much.

  - figures from the US Geological Survey (or FAO for water); the companies doing the work

- **Stocks**: reserves, stocks and recycling.

  - reserves, output and years of supply for the top countries

- **Cycles**: price history and what drives it.

  - the supercycle story; booms and busts on a timeline; drivers; metrics to track

- **Trading**: how and where it is bought and sold.

  - buyers and sellers; exchanges and benchmarks; contract types; trading houses; how prices are discovered

- **Movement**: trade flows between countries.

  - an opening lesson on exports, imports and routes

- **Criticality**: critical-mineral listings and exposure.

  - an opening lesson; one line per region on its position (for example India's import dependence)

- **Characteristics**: the material and its supply.

  - kind of commodity; properties that set grade, price and use; a supply table: production volume, stocks, capacity use, concentration, supply elasticity, project pipeline, logistics

- **Emissions**: its environmental footprint.

  - the functional unit (what the figures are per); total emission intensity; global annual emissions; emissions by life-cycle phase; other impacts; levers to cut emissions; India's position

- **Quiz**: questions to test understanding.

  - each with options, the answer and an explanation

- **Good resources to follow**: expert channels.

  - name, by whom, address, type, access and focus

- **Sources**: everything cited on the page.
- **Relationships**: the checked relationship cards that involve this commodity.

**Chemicals**families and fourteen tabs

- **Families:** commodity chemicals (bulk acids, alkalis, petrochemicals, polymers and more), pseudo-commodities, speciality chemicals, fine chemicals and bio-based chemicals.
- **Example:** ammonia, a commodity chemical made from natural gas, used mainly for fertiliser.

**Tabs and what they hold**

- **Summary**: the same opening view as commodities.
- **Overview**: what it is.

  - a summary line; an introduction; market size

- **Price links**: prices that move with it.
- **Production route**: how it is made.

  - an introduction; the routes compared in a table and described one by one

- **Production**: how much and where.

  - world capacity, output and capacity use; production by country; concentration; new capacity; position by region

- **Feedstocks**: what goes in and what comes out.

  - inputs per tonne (each linked to its tile); who is low-cost and why; what it is made into

- **Cycles**: the margin to watch.

  - the spread between its price and its inputs

- **Trading**: how it is priced.

  - price benchmarks; traders and distributors; how Indian buyers price it; recent price points

- **Movement**: how it travels.

  - share traded across borders; form and shipping; largest exporters and importers; routes and chokepoints; India's trade; hazards in transit

- **Regulation**: the rules on it.

  - hazards; main rules; rules in India; trade measures such as anti-dumping duties; supply risk

- **Characteristics**: grades.

  - commercial grades

- **Emissions**: footprint and cleaner routes.

  - low-carbon routes; a box for climate investors

- **Good resources to follow**: expert channels.
- **Relationships**: checked relationship cards.

**Energy**natural sources and carriers, with tabs by kind

- **Groups:** natural sources (what is captured from nature, such as sunlight, wind, coal, uranium) and energy carriers (what moves energy to where it is used, such as electricity and hydrogen). Fuels that are also commodities or chemicals (crude oil, natural gas, petrol) appear on the Energy table as links to those nodes.
- **Every energy node** has a summary, an overview, price links and relationships.
- **Example:** wind, a natural source, with tabs on how its energy resides in moving air, how much there is, how it varies hour to hour and season to season, where it is strongest and its effects on nature.

**Extra tabs by kind**

- **Natural sources**: five tabs.

  - **How energy resides**: its physical form, its ultimate origin, the chain that put it there, how concentrated it is
  - **Abundance**: whether it is a finite stock or a renewed flow, and how much there is
  - **Fluctuation in time**: variation by time scale, how predictable it is, capacity factors, a typical profile
  - **Across the Earth**: the geographic pattern, rich and poor regions, top countries
  - **Impact on nature**: effects, life-cycle emissions, land use

- **Energy commodities**: an energy overview plus the five natural-source tabs.
- **Biofuels**: an energy overview, efficiency, techniques, resources and labour, and impact on the biosphere.
- **Energy-transition chemicals**: an energy overview, science and limits, value chain, unit economics, engineering methods, and equipment and suppliers.

The machines that capture, move, store, convert and recover energy are technologies. They keep stage-specific tabs, such as "Science and technology", "Engineering and performance", "Economics" and "Impact and additionality" for storage, and "Science and thermodynamics" and "Economics and contracts" for recovery, alongside the technology tabs below.

**Technologies**ten attributes and thirteen tabs

**Attributes**

- **Column and sub-purpose** (from its path): one of twelve purposes, such as making materials or moving information.
- **Era**: the row on the table, from the era of first practical use.
- **Invented**: the year the working principle was first shown.
- **First practical use**: the year it first worked in real service (laboratory use counts for scientific instruments).
- **Circa**: marks dates that are approximate.
- **Readiness**: technology readiness level, from 1 (idea) to 9 (proven in use).
- **Layer**: where it sits in the technology stack, from basic materials and components to whole systems.
- **Science fields** and **patent class** (the CPC class used for counting patents).
- **On the table**: whether it has its own tile, and a **one-line description**.

**Tabs and what they hold**

- **Summary**: hook, big numbers, journey, places, three things, story cards and a card for each tab.
- **Overview**: what it does and how.

  - what it does; how it works step by step; key figures (each with value, unit, year and source); where it is used; scale today (installed, made per year, users)

- **Science**: why it works.

  - links to science nodes, as "relies on" or "limited by"; discoveries that made it possible (year, who, what); physical limits (the limit, today's best, the gap); the science explained

- **Engineering**: how it is built.

  - main parts and what each does; bill of materials (part, amount, unit, share); how it is made; engineering breakthroughs; trade-offs; standards

- **Evolution**: how it changed.

  - a timeline; performance then and now; adoption; lineage links to other technologies; main variants

- **Materials**: what it needs.

  - links to commodities and chemicals with a role, an amount per unit, its share of that material's world demand and how critical each is; critical materials; using less; substitutes and their trade-offs

- **Energy footprint**: its energy story.

  - embodied energy (energy to make one unit, with a low and high range); energy in use and efficiency; losses; end of life; energy return; links to the energy it uses, holds, converts, loses or gets back

- **Industries**: who uses and makes it.

  - links to industries and enterprise types (used by, made by, transformed, created); industries created or disrupted; productivity

- **Economics**: cost and market.

  - cost curve over time; learning rate (cost fall each time output doubles); market size and growth; leading companies and shares; patents by country

- **Geography**: where and who.

  - where it is made and shares; trade codes and main flows; export controls; chokepoints in its supply chain

- **Impacts**: effects on people and planet.

  - life-cycle emissions with their boundary; health and safety; jobs; regulation; how it changed society

- **Frontier**: what comes next.

  - research directions with readiness and who leads; recent advances; research activity (papers and patents a year); outlook; roadmaps

- **Quiz, good resources and sources**: as for commodities.

**Example:** the transistor sits in the computing column and the electronic era (first practical use 1952, invented 1947); its Science tab links to band theory and the p-n junction, and shows it is limited by quantum tunnelling; its Evolution tab shows it evolved from the vacuum tube.

**Science**six attributes and four tabs

- **Attributes:** field and subfield (physics, chemistry, biology and their branches); the year it was established; a circa flag; the era; a one-line description; the people behind it.
- **Example:** the second law of thermodynamics, physics, established 1850 (Clausius).

**Tabs and what they hold**

- **The idea**: in plain words.

  - the idea without jargon; the key equation with every symbol explained; an everyday analogy

- **Discovery**: how it was found.

  - the story; the people, their years and contributions; milestones by year

- **Limits**: what it caps.

  - the technologies it limits, the limit and its value; open questions

- **Technologies**: who uses it.

  - links to the technologies that rely on it or are limited by it, each with how it uses the idea

**Industries and enterprise types**seven strata, nine industry tabs and one enterprise profile

- **Strata of the pyramid:** first transformations, assembled goods, complex manufacturing and the built world, networks and systems, information and capital, integrated services, and the apex (public administration).
- **Enterprise types** sit under their industry (their parent), one group per industry.

**Industry tabs**

- **Overview**: size and India.

  - industry size with its source; India's position

- **Where ₹100 goes**: the cost mix: what the industry spends each ₹100 of output on, from input-output tables.
- **Price links**: prices that move its costs.
- **Example story**: one real product followed through the chain.

  - title; a line under it; where it is set; steps that follow the value chain; what the chain shows

- **Linked industries**: which industries it buys from and sells to.
- **Value chain**: the stages from upstream to customer, each with its enterprise types.
- **Materials drawn on**: every commodity, chemical and energy tile the whole chain depends on, with how many enterprise types rely on each.
- **Chokepoints and risks**: the few suppliers or places that can halt the chain.
- **Sources**: everything cited.

**Enterprise type profile**

- what they do; the technologies they use; **criticality** from 1 to 5 (5 means the chain stops without them and nothing can replace them soon, counted as a chokepoint); example companies; a share or concentration figure; what they depend on (commodities, chemicals, energy and other industries); sources
- **Example:** in semiconductors, wafer-fab equipment makers rate 5 of 5, because one company holds most of the market for lithography tools.

**Relationship pages**a checked page for a closely linked pair

- **The pair:** two nodes (for example aluminium and copper) and one or more relationships between them.
- **For each relationship:** its type (family and type, listed below), its direction, a strength label (Strong, Medium, Weak, Rising, Asymmetric, High in India, a criticality level, or a cost such as ₹0.9 per ₹100), a short title, which way it runs, why it holds, up to three key figures, the detail of where it holds or breaks, and its sources.
- **For the pair as a whole:** a summary; what investors learn and track; what policy makers learn and track; India's position; how the tie has changed over time; risks to it; the outlook for the next ten years.

**Products (coming next)**the planned schema

- **Identity:** a class of sellable goods at the level a buyer chooses, mapped to one or more HS trade headings; variants as child nodes when the make-up differs a lot.
- **Base or composite:** worked out from its links, not stored.
- **Links:** made from (materials, with amount per unit, role, share of the material's demand, recyclable); component of (other products, with quantity and shares by mass and by cost); energy to make and energy in use; made with and embodies (technologies); made by and used by (industries, with the industrial process written on the link).
- **Tabs:** overview; made of (tree, roll-up and flow diagram); how it is made; who uses it, by process; evolution; market; risks; sources.
- **Facts:** output, trade value and volume, unit price, mass per unit, lifetime, recycling rate, energy per unit.

**Interventions (being designed)**the planned schema

- **Family:** one of use less material, substitute, change route, circularity, energy efficiency, electrification and fuel switch, capture, product design, demand and business model, enablers.
- **Changes:** the exact links it alters, by how much and from which year.
- **Who and what:** technologies that enable it; industries that act; industries affected; preconditions (clean power, scrap supply, a recycling network, a standard).
- **Evidence:** deployments in India and elsewhere, with dates and sources.
- **Scores** (computed): impact, viability at market prices, scalability, plausibility and fairness to stakeholders.

#### Relationship types

Each relationship has a **family** and a **type**, a **direction** and, where it matters, numbers and a strength. Relationships between commodities, chemicals, energy and industries come from data (such as feedstock lists, input-output tables and price correlations) or from checked relationship pages. Relationships from a technology are written on the technology's own tabs as links: each link names the other node, its role (the type), a note saying exactly how the two connect and, where a source gives them, numbers. In Explore, each type is drawn under one of the filters named after "shown in Explore as".

**Physical flow**one is made from, runs on or is built with the other

- **Feedstock** commodity or chemical → chemical
A raw material that the other's production routes start from. *Example:* natural gas is a feedstock for ammonia. Shown in Explore as "Made from".
- **Direct input** material → industry
An input that an industry, or its enterprise types, depend on. *Example:* copper is a direct input to electrical equipment makers. Shown in Explore as "Industry uses".
- **Chain step** energy → energy
Energy or material passes from one to the other along the chain. *Example:* coal passes into electricity at a power station. Shown in Explore as "Energy flow".
- **Buys from** industry → industry
One industry buys from the other, from input-output cost shares (for India). *Example:* vehicle makers buy from metal products makers. Shown in Explore as "Buys from".
- **Material need** energy technology → commodity or chemical
Building or running the technology needs the material. *Example:* wind turbines need rare earths for their magnets. Shown in Explore as "Needs material".
- **Reagent** any → any
One is used up in processing the other without becoming part of it. *Example:* sulphuric acid is used up in leaching copper ore.
- **Scrap loop** any → any
Scrap from one goes back into making the other. *Example:* steel scrap goes back into steelmaking.
- **Precursor** chemical → chemical
One is the intermediate the other is made from. *Example:* ethylene is the precursor of polyethylene.
- **Power intensity** any → energy
Making one uses a lot of the other's electricity or energy. *Example:* aluminium smelting uses a great deal of electricity.
- **Fuel** energy → any
One is burned or used as fuel to make or run the other. *Example:* coal is burned to make cement.
- **Energy use** any → energy
One uses the other as its energy supply. *Example:* data centres run on electricity.
- **Embedded content** material → material or product
One is contained in the other's finished products. *Example:* tin is contained in the solder of electronics.
- **Crop nutrient** fertiliser → crop
One feeds the crops the other comes from. *Example:* potash feeds wheat.
- **Biofuel link** crop → biofuel
One is a crop or oil the biofuel is made from. *Example:* sugarcane is made into ethanol.
- **Energy carrier** energy → energy
One carries the other's energy to where it is used. *Example:* electricity carries the energy of wind to homes and factories.
- **Refined into** commodity → product of refining
One is refined into the other. *Example:* crude oil is refined into diesel.

**Cost and price**the price or cost of one moves the price or cost of the other

- **Prices move together** any ↔ any
Their prices are correlated, measured on monthly and yearly changes. *Example:* nickel and copper prices tend to move together. Shown in Explore as "Price link".
- **Price link** any → any
One's price feeds into the other's cost or revenue. *Example:* the natural gas price feeds into the cost of ammonia.
- **Cost pass-through** any → any
A change in one's price is passed on in the other's price. *Example:* a rise in crude oil is passed on in petrol prices.
- **Conversion spread** input ↔ output
The margin between the two is the profit of turning one into the other. *Example:* the gap between crude oil and refined products is the refiner's margin.

**Substitution**one can replace the other, or they compete for the same use

- **Substitute** any ↔ any
One can replace the other in some uses. *Example:* aluminium can replace copper in some power cables.
- **Competing route** any ↔ any
They are rival routes or technologies for the same product or service. *Example:* steel from blast furnaces and from scrap in electric arc furnaces.
- **Competitor** any ↔ any
They compete for the same customers or market. *Example:* palm oil and soybean oil compete for the same buyers.
- **Fuel switch** energy ↔ energy
Users can switch between the two as fuels. *Example:* power plants that can burn coal or natural gas.

**Joint production**they come out of the same mine, field, plant or process

- **By-product** any → any
One is recovered while producing the other. *Example:* cobalt is mostly recovered while mining copper and nickel.
- **Co-product** any ↔ any
Both come out of the same process in fixed proportions. *Example:* chlorine and caustic soda come out of brine electrolysis together.
- **Site integration** any ↔ any
They are made on the same integrated sites. *Example:* refineries and petrochemical crackers share sites.
- **Same geology** any ↔ any
They are found in the same kinds of deposit. *Example:* platinum and palladium occur in the same ore bodies.

**Shared risk**one disruption, chokepoint or customer hits both

- **Chokepoint** any → any
One depends on a chokepoint that the other controls or is exposed to. *Example:* chip making depends on gallium refined mostly in one country.
- **Shared chokepoint** any ↔ any
One route, mine or plant outage cuts the supply of both. *Example:* crude oil and LNG both pass through the Strait of Hormuz.
- **Shared customer** any ↔ any
They sell to the same customer industry, so its swings hit both. *Example:* steel and rubber both depend on car makers.

**Policy**the same rules, taxes or trade measures act on both

- **Policy overlap** any ↔ any
The same policies, standards or trade measures act on both. *Example:* the EU carbon border tax covers both steel and aluminium.
- **Regulated use** any → any
Rules restrict how one is used in the other. *Example:* mercury rules restrict its use in chlor-alkali plants.

**Transition**the energy transition moves demand from one to the other, or ties them together

- **Demand driver** any → any
Growth of one drives demand for the other. *Example:* electric vehicles drive demand for lithium.
- **Transition shift** any → any
The transition moves demand from one to the other. *Example:* electricity demand moves from coal power to solar.
- **Load growth** any → energy
One adds electricity demand that the other must supply. *Example:* data centres add load to the grid.
- **Balancing pair** any ↔ any
One balances or firms the other's variable supply. *Example:* batteries balance solar power through the evening.

**Geography and ownership**they are made in the same countries or by the same companies

- **Country overlap** any ↔ any
The same few countries dominate both. *Example:* China leads both rare earth and graphite processing.
- **Same companies** any ↔ any
The same companies produce or control both. *Example:* the large oil companies produce both oil and gas.

**Technology lineage**how technologies descend from, combine with and replace each other

Written on the technology's Evolution tab. Shown in Explore as "Technology lineage".

- **Builds on** technology → technology
Uses the other as a part or a foundation. *Example:* a turbine builds on the bearing.
- **Evolved from (predecessor and successor)** technology → technology
Grew out of the other, its predecessor; seen from the other side, a successor. *Example:* the transistor evolved from the vacuum tube.
- **Enables** technology → technology
Made the other possible or practical. *Example:* the laser enabled optical fibre communication.
- **Substitutes** technology ↔ technology
Does the same job as the other and can replace it. *Example:* LED lighting substitutes for fluorescent lamps.
- **Complements** technology ↔ technology
Used together, each makes the other more useful. *Example:* shipping containers and container cranes.
- **Converges into** technology → technology
Merged with others into the other one. *Example:* the phone, camera and computer converged into the smartphone.

**Science basis**the science a technology rests on and the limits it sets

Written on the technology's Science tab and shown on the science node's Technologies tab. Shown in Explore as "Science basis".

- **Relies on principle** technology → science
Works because of this principle or discovery. *Example:* the electric generator relies on electromagnetic induction.
- **Limited by** technology → science
A physical limit from this science caps how good the technology can get. *Example:* a rocket is limited by the rocket equation; a heat engine by the second law of thermodynamics.

**Material needs**the commodities and chemicals a technology needs, processes, recovers, makes or emits

Written on the technology's Materials tab, each with an amount per unit, the share of the material's world demand and a criticality rating (high, medium or low) where known. Shown in Explore as "Needs material" or "Material output".

- **Requires material** technology → commodity
Needs the commodity to be built or run, in an amount per unit. *Example:* a lithium-ion battery requires lithium, nickel and cobalt.
- **Processes material** technology → commodity
Turns the commodity into something else. *Example:* a blast furnace processes iron ore.
- **Recovers material** technology → commodity
Gets the commodity back from waste or scrap. *Example:* battery recycling recovers cobalt.
- **Uses chemical** technology → chemical
Uses the chemical while it runs (a reagent, catalyst, coolant or fuel). *Example:* froth flotation uses frothing reagents.
- **Made of chemical** technology → chemical
Built partly from the chemical (a polymer, a resin, an electrolyte). *Example:* a wind turbine blade is made of epoxy resin.
- **Produces chemical** technology → chemical
Makes the chemical as its product. *Example:* the Haber-Bosch process produces ammonia.
- **Emits chemical** technology → chemical
Gives off the chemical as a pollutant or waste. *Example:* coal combustion emits sulphur dioxide.

**Energy role**what a technology does with energy

Written on the technology's Energy footprint tab. Shown in Explore as "Energy role".

- **Consumes** technology → energy
Runs on this form or carrier of energy. *Example:* a heat pump consumes electricity.
- **Embodies** technology → energy
This energy is used to make the technology (its embodied energy). *Example:* solar panels embody the electricity used to purify their silicon.
- **Converts** technology → energy
Turns this energy into another form. *Example:* a wind turbine converts wind into electricity.
- **Stores** technology → energy
Holds this energy for later. *Example:* a battery stores electricity.
- **Wastes** technology → energy
Loses part of its energy in this form. *Example:* an engine wastes heat in its exhaust.
- **Recovers** technology → energy
Captures energy that would otherwise be lost. *Example:* a heat exchanger recovers waste heat.

**Industry use**which industries and kinds of firm use, make or were changed by a technology

Written on the technology's Industries tab. Shown in Explore as "Industry use".

- **Used by** technology → industry or enterprise type
The industry or kind of firm uses the technology in its work. *Example:* photolithography is used by semiconductor makers.
- **Made by** technology → industry or enterprise type
The industry or kind of firm makes the technology. *Example:* gas turbines are made by electrical equipment makers.
- **Transforms** technology → industry or enterprise type
The technology changed how the industry works. *Example:* the shipping container transformed ports and logistics.
- **Created** technology → industry or enterprise type
The technology gave rise to the industry or kind of firm. *Example:* the internet created e-commerce.

**Structure links**how the pyramid holds together

These come from the industry pages rather than from a relationship family.

- **Part of** enterprise type → industry
The enterprise type belongs to the industry. *Example:* contract foundries are part of semiconductors. Shown in Explore as "Part of".
- **Depends on** enterprise type → commodity, chemical, energy or industry
What a kind of firm needs to work, from its profile. *Example:* cold-chain operators depend on electricity and refrigerants. Shown in Explore as "Depends on".

**Product and sustainability links (planned)**added with products and interventions

- **Made from** product → commodity or chemical
The material in one unit, by mass and by cost where known. *Example:* a tyre is made from natural and synthetic rubber, carbon black and steel cord.
- **Component of** product → product
One product is a part of another. *Example:* a battery pack is a component of an electric car.
- **Energy to make** product → energy
Energy used to make one unit. *Example:* electricity used to make a PV module.
- **Energy in use** product → energy
Energy it uses each year in service. *Example:* a car's petrol or electricity use.
- **Made with** product → technology
The technology used to make it. *Example:* flat glass is made with the float glass process.
- **Embodies** product → technology
The technology inside it. *Example:* a smartphone embodies the transistor and satellite navigation.
- **Made by** product → industry
The industry that makes it, with its share of output. *Example:* tyres are made by tyre makers.
- **Used by** product → industry
The industry that uses it, written with the industrial process. *Example:* steel plate is used by shipbuilding in hull construction.
- **Recovered as** product → commodity or chemical
What it becomes at end of life, with a recovery rate. *Example:* a scrapped car is recovered as steel scrap.
