# Cost, trade-offs and resources: why the best design is rarely the strongest: Whole-life cost and the price of money

Source page: https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p1/

[All courses](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/) / [Understanding Engineering](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/) / [Module 13: Cost, trade-offs and resources: why the best design is rarely the strongest](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/) Part 1 of 5

## Whole-life cost and the price of money

A price tag is one number on one day, but a machine is paid for over years. Engineers therefore compare designs by what they cost to own, not by what they cost to buy. This part builds three tools for that, life-cycle cost, discounting and levelised cost, each worked in rupees.

### 1.1 The cheapest thing to buy is often the dearest thing to own

Picture a farmer in Rajasthan choosing a 5 HP pump for a borewell. A diesel pump set costs about Rs 40,000. A solar pump of the same size, with its panels and controller, costs about Rs 3 to 3.5 lakh before any subsidy. Judged at the counter, diesel wins by a factor of eight. Life-cycle cost counts everything paid from purchase to scrap, less any resale value. For a pump, fuel is most of it.

Start with units. Fuel used is litres per hour times hours. Assume the engine burns about 1 litre an hour and runs 1,000 hours a year. As a check, a litre of diesel holds about 10 kWh of heat, and an engine turning 30 per cent of it into work gives 3 kWh, which runs a 3.7 kW pump for about 50 minutes (calculated). At Rs 95 a litre, the Delhi price in November 2026, fuel costs Rs 95,000 a year. Add Rs 5,000 of servicing and the diesel pump costs Rs 1 lakh a year to run. The solar pump burns nothing; allow Rs 2,000 a year for cleaning panels and small repairs.

Over ten years, before any discounting, the diesel pump costs Rs 40,000 + 10 x Rs 1 lakh = Rs 10.4 lakh (calculated) and the solar pump Rs 3.25 lakh + Rs 20,000 = Rs 3.45 lakh (calculated), about a third as much. The extra Rs 2.85 lakh paid at purchase is earned back by a saving of Rs 98,000 a year in about 2.9 years (calculated).

Why, then, do farmers still buy diesel? The first cost must be found in cash or credit, which a small farmer may lack. The solar pump works only while the sun shines, so water comes by day and less of it on cloudy days, while a diesel set pumps whenever it is started. And a diesel set can be carried to another field or sold, while panels fixed beside one well cannot. Life-cycle cost settles which design is cheaper, not which one the buyer can afford.

Data Worked estimate 1: ten years of pumping, diesel set against solar pump (5 HP, 1,000 hours a year)

| Item | Diesel pump set | Solar pump |
|---|---|---|
| Price on the day of purchase | Rs 40,000 (assumed) | Rs 325,000 (middle of the Rs 3 to 3.5 lakh range) |
| Fuel a year: 1,000 h x 1 litre per hour x Rs 95 per litre | Rs 95,000 (calculated) | none |
| Servicing a year | Rs 5,000 (assumed) | Rs 2,000 (assumed) |
| Running cost a year | Rs 100,000 (calculated) | Rs 2,000 |
| Total over ten years, not discounted | 40,000 + 10 x 100,000 = Rs 1,040,000 (calculated) | 325,000 + 10 x 2,000 = Rs 345,000 (calculated) |
| Payback of the extra first cost |  | 285,000 / 98,000 = 2.9 years (calculated) |

Fuel use, hours, servicing and the diesel set's price are round assumptions. The solar price is an indicative pre-subsidy range, not an official benchmark, since states set prices by tender. Diesel price for Delhi on 11 November 2026.
 Source: Diesel price: HDFC Sky (11 November 2026); solar pump price range: SolarSquare PM-KUSUM guide (September 2026), Rs 95.20 per litre in Delhi; about Rs 3 to 3.5 lakh for a 5 HP pump before subsidy  In the data

#### Who pays the first cost

Under the PM-KUSUM scheme, as summarised in September 2026, the central government pays 30 per cent of the benchmark or tendered cost of a standalone solar pump, the state at least 30 per cent and the farmer up to 40 per cent, of which about 10 per cent can be paid at once and the rest borrowed. On a Rs 3.25 lakh pump that leaves the farmer about Rs 1.3 lakh (calculated), with about Rs 32,500 (calculated) in cash on day one. The subsidy does not change the life-cycle sum for the country. It moves the first cost away from the person least able to carry it. There is no national price list, because each state sets prices by tender.

- Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Engineering Economics' (first cost against life-cycle cost; break-even point)
- HDFC Sky, Petrol and diesel prices today, 11 November 2026 (data from Goodreturns) · diesel Rs 95.20 per litre in Delhi, https://hdfcsky.com/news/petrol-diesel-prices-today-november-11-2026-check-latest-rates-in-delhi-mumbai-kolkata-chennai-bengaluru-hyderabad
- SolarSquare, PM-KUSUM Yojana for solar pumps: subsidy guide (4 September 2026) · indicative pre-subsidy prices and subsidy shares, https://www.solarsquare.in/blog/pm-kusum-yojana-for-solar-pumps-subsidy/

### 1.2 Discounting turns rupees at different dates into one comparable number

A rupee in ten years is worth less than a rupee today, and not only because of inflation: money today can be lent at interest or used to repay a loan. Suppose it can earn 10 per cent a year. Then Rs 100 today grows to Rs 259 in ten years, because 1.1 multiplied by itself ten times is 2.59. Run that backwards and Rs 100 promised in ten years is worth only 100 / 2.59 = Rs 38.6 now. That backward step is discounting, and the 10 per cent is the discount rate.

Net present value, NPV, adds up every future cash flow after discounting it, costs counted as negative; a positive NPV beats leaving the money at the discount rate. A stream of equal yearly amounts has a shortcut: multiply the yearly amount by the annuity factor, which for ten years at 10 per cent is 6.145. So the diesel pump's Rs 1 lakh a year of running cost has a present value of 100,000 x 6.145 = Rs 6.15 lakh (calculated).

At 10 per cent the diesel pump's present cost is about Rs 6.5 lakh and the solar pump's about Rs 3.4 lakh. Choosing solar has an NPV of about Rs 3.2 lakh: that is what the farmer gains, in today's money, by paying more now. At 20 per cent, a rate a farmer borrowing informally might face, the gap narrows to Rs 4.6 lakh against Rs 3.3 lakh. At about 32 per cent the two are equal (calculated). The rate at which the NPV of an extra investment falls to zero is its internal rate of return. A farmer whose only credit costs, say, 36 per cent a year is rational to keep the diesel set, though it burns three times as much money.

Two cautions. First, the choice of rate is a judgement and it decides the answer for long-lived assets: a high rate favours cheap-to-buy designs and a low rate favours durable ones, which is why cheap credit works as a technology policy. Second, discounting shrinks the far future to almost nothing. At 10 per cent, Re 1 of damage 50 years away is worth under one paisa today. So climate and dam-safety decisions use lower rates, or rules beyond discounting.

Data Worked estimate 2: present value of ten years of pumping at three discount rates

| Item | Diesel pump set | Solar pump |
|---|---|---|
| Paid on day one | Rs 40,000 | Rs 325,000 |
| Running cost a year | Rs 100,000 | Rs 2,000 |
| Present value at 10 per cent (annuity factor 6.145) | 40,000 + 100,000 x 6.145 = Rs 654,500 (calculated) | 325,000 + 2,000 x 6.145 = Rs 337,300 (calculated) |
| Present value at 20 per cent (annuity factor 4.192) | 40,000 + 100,000 x 4.192 = Rs 459,200 (calculated) | 325,000 + 2,000 x 4.192 = Rs 333,400 (calculated) |
| Present value at 30 per cent (annuity factor 3.092) | Rs 349,200 (calculated) | Rs 331,200 (calculated) |
| NPV of choosing solar: Rs 98,000 a year saved for Rs 285,000 extra |  | Rs 317,200 at 10 per cent; Rs 125,900 at 20 per cent; Rs 18,000 at 30 per cent (calculated) |

Annuity factor = (1 - 1 / (1 + r)^n) / r, here with n = 10 years. The NPV of choosing solar reaches zero at about 32 per cent (calculated), the internal rate of return of the extra Rs 285,000. Below that rate solar wins; above it diesel does.
 Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 5, 'Engineering Economics' (compound interest and present value); numbers from worked estimate 1

- Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Engineering Economics' (cost of money, compound interest, present value)

### 1.3 Levelised cost divides a plant's whole-life cost by all the energy it will ever deliver

A solar plant has a huge cost on day one and almost none afterwards, because sunshine is free. To compare it with a gas plant, cheap to build but with a fuel bill every year, engineers spread each plant's costs over every kilowatt-hour it will produce. The result is the levelised cost of energy, LCOE: the present value of all costs divided by the present value of all energy. It is the flat price per kWh at which the owner just earns the discount rate.

A simple version has three steps. Turn the capital cost into a yearly charge with the capital recovery factor, the reciprocal of the annuity factor; add the yearly upkeep; divide by the kWh produced in a year. Take a 1 MW plant in Rajasthan. Capacity factor, the share of the year it effectively runs at full output, is 22 per cent, so it yields 1 MW x 8,760 h x 0.22 = 1,927 MWh a year. Assume a capital cost of Rs 4.5 crore (a round assumption: India's regulator sets solar tariffs project by project and publishes no benchmark cost), upkeep of Rs 5 lakh a year, 25 years of life and a 10 per cent discount rate.

The recovery factor is 0.110, so the capital charge is Rs 49.6 lakh a year, and with upkeep the total is Rs 54.6 lakh. Divided by 1.93 million kWh, the LCOE is about Rs 2.83 per kWh (calculated). For comparison, IRENA puts India's 2025 solar LCOE at about US$0.035 per kWh, roughly Rs 3.1 (calculated at an assumed Rs 88 to the dollar), and a SECI auction in October 2025 for 2 GW of solar with 1 GW and 4 GWh of storage set a record low of Rs 2.86 per kWh. That tariff also pays for batteries, so the round number is in the right range, not exact.

The most useful lesson is the sensitivity row. About 91 per cent of the cost is capital, so the discount rate, not the sunshine or the panel price, moves the answer most: 7 per cent gives Rs 2.26 and 12 per cent gives Rs 3.24 (calculated). The method's limit is that a kilowatt-hour at noon is not worth the same as one at 8 pm. LCOE says nothing about when the energy comes, which is why storage and grid design matter (see the module on Electricity and magnetism).

Process flowchart How a levelised cost is built for a 1 MW solar plant Inputs **Capital cost**Rs 4.5 crore, 25 years, 10 per cent **Yearly upkeep**Rs 5 lakh **Sunshine**22 per cent capacity factor Process steps 1 **Annualise the capital**

multiply by the recovery factor, 0.110 → Rs 49.6 lakh a year (calculated)
 2 **Add upkeep**

Rs 49.6 + 5 = Rs 54.6 lakh a year
 3 **Count the energy**

1 MW x 8,760 h x 0.22 = 1.93 million kWh a year (calculated)
 4 **Divide**

Rs 54.6 lakh / 1.93 million kWh
 Outputs **Levelised cost**about Rs 2.83 per kWh (calculated; Rs 2.26 at 7 per cent, Rs 3.24 at 12 per cent)

Capital cost, upkeep and life are round assumptions for illustration, not a quotation; no CERC benchmark capital cost exists for solar. Degradation of output over the years would raise the result by a few per cent.
 Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 5, 'Engineering Economics' (compound interest and present value, on which the recovery factor rests)

Data Worked estimate 3: levelised cost of a 1 MW solar plant, and how the discount rate moves it

| Quantity (calculated) | 7 per cent | 10 per cent | 12 per cent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Capital recovery factor (25 years) | 0.0858 | 0.1102 | 0.1275 |
| Capital charge a year, on Rs 4.5 crore | Rs 38.6 lakh | Rs 49.6 lakh | Rs 57.4 lakh |
| Plus upkeep, Rs 5 lakh | Rs 43.6 lakh | Rs 54.6 lakh | Rs 62.4 lakh |
| Energy a year | 1.93 million kWh | 1.93 million kWh | 1.93 million kWh |
| Levelised cost per kWh | Rs 2.26 | Rs 2.83 | Rs 3.24 |

Global comparison: IRENA's 2025 averages are about US$0.044 per kWh for solar PV (India about US$0.035), US$0.033 for onshore wind and US$0.078 for offshore wind. More than 90 per cent of utility-scale renewable projects commissioned in 2025 produced power below the cost of the cheapest new fossil alternative.
 Source: IRENA, Renewable power generation costs in 2025 (July 2026), executive summary; figures as reported by PV Tech and Down To Earth, July 2026, global and India weighted-average LCOE in 2025  Worked example

#### A cheaper loan beats a cheaper module

Solar modules sold for about US$0.09 per watt at the end of 2025. For 1 MW of panels that is US$90,000, roughly Rs 79 lakh (calculated, at an assumed Rs 88 to the dollar), or 18 per cent of the Rs 4.5 crore plant. The rest is inverters, mounting, cabling, land, grid connection and finance. Halving the module price would cut capital by 9 per cent and the LCOE by about 8 per cent. Cutting the discount rate from 12 to 10 per cent lowers it from Rs 3.24 to Rs 2.83, or 13 per cent. Cheap credit is now worth more than cheaper panels.

- Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Engineering Economics' (compound interest and present value)
- [IRENA, Renewable power generation costs in 2025 (July 2026), executive summary; figures as reported by PV Tech and Down To Earth, July 2026](https://www.pv-tech.org/solar-pv-lcoe-ticks-marginally-upwards-2025-irena/ and https://www.downtoearth.org.in/energy/renewables-save-480-billion-in-fossil-fuel-costs-in-2025-as-price-advantage-widens-irena) · web
- pv magazine, India's solar-plus-storage tender sets record low INR 2.86 tariff (16 October 2025) · SECI auction of 2,000 MW solar with 1,000 MW / 4,000 MWh storage, https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/10/16/indias-solar-plus-storage-tender-sets-record-low-inr-2-86-tariff/

### See it in the table
[H₂O Water](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/water/)[El Electricity](https://www.materialinsights.org/energy/electricity/)

### Check your understanding

Why can a solar pump costing eight times as much as a diesel set be the cheaper choice?
 Over ten years the diesel set burns about Rs 9.5 lakh of fuel (calculated), far more than the Rs 2.85 lakh extra paid for the solar pump. Life matters too, but fuel is the larger part.

Rs 100 will be received in ten years and the discount rate is 10 per cent. What is it worth today?
 Divide by 1.1 ten times, that is by 2.59. The answer is Rs 38.6. A common slip is to subtract 10 per cent once for each year, which ignores compounding.

In the solar example about 91 per cent of the levelised cost is capital. What follows?
 When capital dominates, the yearly charge on it is set by the discount rate and the life, so a few points of interest move the cost per kWh more than most other inputs. Sunshine still matters, since it sets the kWh that the charge is spread over.

[← Module contents](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/)[Mark read · Part 2: Why things get cheaper: learning, scale and standards →](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p2/)

## Other sections

- [Module overview](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/index.md)
- [Why things get cheaper: learning, scale and standards](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p2/index.md)
- [Choosing a material under cost, weight and carbon](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p3/index.md)
- [Optimising, Pareto fronts and the price of margin](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p4/index.md)
- [Resources, recycling and designing for the conditions you have](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p5/index.md)
- [Key terms, quiz and sources](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/review/index.md)
