# Cost, trade-offs and resources: why the best design is rarely the strongest: Resources, recycling and designing for the conditions you have

Source page: https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p5/

[All courses](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/) / [Understanding Engineering](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/) / [Module 13: Cost, trade-offs and resources: why the best design is rarely the strongest](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/) Part 5 of 5

## Resources, recycling and designing for the conditions you have

Every design is made from what is available: materials, energy, skills and money. When one of these is short, the design bends around it. This last part looks at where resource limits really bite, how far recycling can ease them, and how designers in India have turned scarcity into products that cost a fraction of the usual price. It ends by drawing the course together.

### 5.1 Resource limits appear as concentration, price spikes and delay long before anything runs out

The earth holds far more lithium, copper or rare earths than any plausible need. What runs short is the ability to turn rock into purified material at the right place and time: mines take a decade to open, refineries are few, and governments can restrict exports. The risk is therefore in the supply chain more than in the ground.

The International Energy Agency's 2026 outlook on critical minerals gives the scale. Leaving out rare earths, the leading refining country held an average of 72 per cent of refined supply in 2025, up from 70 per cent in 2023, and Indonesia for nickel and China for other key minerals accounted for over three-quarters of the growth in refined supply over two years. The number of mineral tariff codes under Chinese export controls has tripled since 2023, and other producers, such as the Democratic Republic of the Congo for cobalt, have imposed export limits of their own. The agency projects that copper could face a supply shortfall of about 25 per cent by 2035 and lithium shortfalls through 2035. A country such as India, which imports most of the refined lithium, cobalt and rare-earth magnets it uses, feels these risks in the price of batteries and motors (see the Lithium-ion battery, Permanent magnet and Electric motor entries).

Designers respond in four ways. They substitute: lithium iron phosphate batteries use no nickel or cobalt, and BloombergNEF found them averaging US$81 per kWh against US$128 for nickel-manganese-cobalt packs in 2025. They use less: thinner walls, less copper per kW. They recycle (next section). And they diversify supply. Each has a cost: iron phosphate cells store less energy per kilogram, so a heavier pack gives the same range, and using less means closer tolerances.

Value chain Four responses to a scarce material, and what each costs

- **A material is scarce or concentrated**

  - **Substitute** e.g. iron phosphate for nickel and cobalt cells; gives up energy density
  - **Use less** thinner sections, less copper; gives up margin and needs tighter manufacture
  - **Recycle** recover from scrap; limited by what has been collected and by purity
  - **Diversify supply** new mines and refiners; takes years and money, and raises first cost

 Source: IEA, Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026, executive summary, https://www.iea.org/reports/global-critical-minerals-outlook-2026/executive-summary  Case

#### Aluminium and steel in one overhead line

Long-distance overhead conductors in India and elsewhere often combine strands of aluminium wrapped around a core of steel. Aluminium is abundant, light and carries current well, though it is weak. Steel is strong but a poor conductor. Giving each metal the job it does best saves copper, which is dearer and heavier for the same conductance, and lets towers stand farther apart. The design is a division of labour forced by a trade-off in resources.

- Hammack, The Things We Make (Sourcebooks, 2023) · ch. 4, 'Resources: From Mesopotamia to the Islamic Empire to Space'
- IEA, Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026 · executive summary, https://www.iea.org/reports/global-critical-minerals-outlook-2026/executive-summary
- BloombergNEF, Lithium-ion battery price survey (9 December 2025) · pack prices by chemistry, segment and region, 2025, https://about.bnef.com/insights/clean-transport/lithium-ion-battery-pack-prices-fall-to-108-per-kilowatt-hour-despite-rising-metal-prices-bloombergnef/

### 5.2 Recycling saves most where making the metal from ore takes the most energy, and it is capped by what has been collected

Recycling is worth most for materials that take a great deal of energy to make from ore. Aluminium is the extreme case, because smelting takes about 14 to 15 kWh of electricity per kg, while remelting scrap needs only a few per cent of that energy; the industry quotes savings of about 95 per cent. Steel sits in the middle. Worldsteel's 2024 data give 2.34 tonnes of CO2 per tonne for the blast furnace route and 0.69 for scrap melted in an electric arc furnace, so scrap cuts the carbon by about 70 per cent. For a beverage can made of aluminium, a thousand cans weigh about 13 kg, so primary metal carries about 196 kg CO2e and remelted metal about 7 kg.

The limits are as important as the savings. Scrap exists only after something has reached the end of its life. A steel bar in a building can stay in place for sixty years, so today's scrap reflects the demand of the 1960s, and growing demand cannot be met from scrap alone. Purity matters: copper contaminates steel and cannot be removed once melted, and mixed alloys degrade into lower grades. Products made of glued layers, composites or many materials are hard to separate. IEA estimates average recycling of key energy minerals at about 10 per cent today and close to 20 per cent by 2040, held back by collection and by processing capacity, with China holding over three-quarters of battery pre-treatment capacity.

Informal collectors in India already recover lead-acid batteries, aluminium and bottles at high rates, showing what collection can do and what it can cost in worker safety. The Aluminium can, Lead-acid battery and PET bottle entries are good places to look.

Data Worked estimate 10: carbon saved by recycling one tonne of steel and one thousand aluminium cans

| Product | From ore (primary) | From scrap (recycled) | Saving |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 tonne of crude steel | 2.34 t CO2 (blast furnace route) | 0.69 t CO2 (arc furnace on scrap) | 1.65 t CO2, about 70 per cent |
| 1,000 aluminium cans, about 13 kg of metal | 13 x 15.1 = about 196 kg CO2e | 13 x 0.52 = about 7 kg CO2e (understated) | about 189 kg CO2e, in practice somewhat less |

Can mass is a typical value for a 330 ml can. Aluminium recycled figure excludes the burden of the scrap and some melt loss.
 Source: worldsteel Sustainability Indicators 2025; IAI factsheet, route emissions and primary versus recycled aluminium  In the data

#### Fewer cans from ore

Per tonne of metal, primary aluminium from mine to cast house was 15.1 t CO2e in the IAI's global 2022 figure, against 0.52 for remelting alone. The two are not strictly comparable, because the remelting figure does not carry the scrap's earlier burden. The fair statement is that recycling saves a very large share of the energy, and that more recycling is limited by how much can be collected, not by the technology.

- Hammack, The Things We Make (Sourcebooks, 2023) · ch. 4, 'Resources: From Mesopotamia to the Islamic Empire to Space'
- worldsteel, Sustainability Indicators 2025 (data year 2024) · CO2 intensity of crude steel by route
- International Aluminium Institute, factsheet on recycling and greenhouse gas savings · primary aluminium 2022 and recycled aluminium emissions per tonne
- IEA, Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026 · executive summary, https://www.iea.org/reports/global-critical-minerals-outlook-2026/executive-summary

### 5.3 Frugal design begins from the user's constraints, so cost falls by a factor and not by a percentage

A frugal design is not a cheaper copy of a rich-world product. It starts from what the user has, needs and can do without. Two Indian designs show how.

The Jaipur foot was developed at SMS Medical College Hospital in Jaipur in the late 1960s, by the craftsman Ram Chandra Sharma working with doctors, for amputees who walked barefoot, squatted, sat cross-legged and worked in wet fields. A rigid Western foot did not suit them and cost far too much. The foot is built from cheap, locally available materials: high-density polyethylene, sponge rubber and wood. It is made by hand to fit, and the wearer is typically fitted on arrival and leaves the same day. Engineering For Change lists a suggested price of US$30; the maker, Bhagwan Mahaveer Viklang Sahayata Samiti, fits about 20,000 limbs a year and had distributed 513,806 by March 2016. The foot lasts roughly two to five years, so US$30 is US$6 to US$15 a year. What it gives up is uniformity: the same source records slow, laborious handwork, variable quality and high reject rates, and children need refitting every few months as they grow.

The Embrace infant warmer began in a Stanford course on design for extreme affordability, with field research in India. Conventional incubators cost up to US$20,000, need steady electricity and trained staff. Field research showed that the babies most at risk were born in villages with neither. The result is a sleeping bag with a pouch of wax-like phase-change material that holds 37 degrees Celsius as it melts and freezes, needing heat only to recharge the pouch between uses rather than a steady electricity supply, at a price of US$25 to US$100. The price is under 1 per cent of the incubator, with no alarms and no fine control, so it complements intensive care and does not replace it.

Data Worked estimate 11: how large is a frugal saving?

| Item | Jaipur foot | Embrace infant warmer |
|---|---|---|
| Price quoted | about US$30 (suggested retail) | US$25 to US$100 |
| Conventional price quoted | not given in the source | up to US$20,000 |
| Price ratio | not available | 20,000 / 100 = 200 to 20,000 / 25 = 800 times cheaper (calculated) |
| Cost per year of use | US$30 / 2 to 5 years = US$6 to US$15 (calculated) | not given |
| Power needed | none | none while in use; the pouch is reheated between uses |
| Main thing given up | uniform quality and volume | monitoring, alarms and control |

Ratios use the maker's and university's published prices; the warmer's is a target and a range quoted in 2011. Only the foot's price and lifespan come from one source.
 Source: Engineering For Change; Stanford GSB, prices, lifespan and design constraints

- Hammack, The Things We Make (Sourcebooks, 2023) · ch. 4, 'Resources: From Mesopotamia to the Islamic Empire to Space'
- Engineering For Change, Jaipur Foot solution page (updated December 2023) · cost, materials, fitting and numbers fitted, https://www.engineeringforchange.org/solutions/product/jaipur-foot/
- Stanford Graduate School of Business, Embracing a Way to Change the World (2011) · cost and design constraints of the Embrace infant warmer, https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/embracing-way-change-world

### 5.4 The course ends on one question: what is the bargain, and what does it assume?

Every number in this module leaned on an earlier one. The pipe optimum needed the friction law from Fluids, and the panel ranking needed bending stiffness from Structures and materials. The infant warmer and the diesel check needed latent heat and engine efficiency from Heat and thermodynamics. The solar plant's falling module price rests on the physics of Light, semiconductors and information, and its timing problem on the grid of Electricity and magnetism. Embodied carbon is the chemistry of Matter at the atomic scale, counted in kilograms of CO2. Each estimate followed Thinking in estimates: units first, then round numbers, then a check. And each margin and code from Design, failure and safety is a cost decision of the kind priced in Part 4.

This module added the currency. Every choice has a cost over its life, discounted to today. Prices fall through learning, scale and standards, each with a different limit. Materials trade cost, mass and carbon, and no one wins on all three. Margins and recycling have prices, and scarcity shapes designs as strongly as physics does. The best design is rarely the strongest because strength is one count among many, and strength beyond the need is waste.

To use all this on the site, take any technology in the Periodic Table of Technologies or any product in the Products table and ask six questions: what does it cost over its life, how does its cost fall with volume, which material or limit decides its form, what trade-off front does it sit on, what scarce input does it rely on, and who is it for and what do they have? Each has a short worked method here that you can redo on paper.

Data Six questions to ask of any technology, and the method for each

| Question | Method in this module | Try it on |
|---|---|---|
| What does it cost over its life? | Life-cycle cost, discounting and levelised cost (Part 1) | Solar PV module, Heavy-duty diesel engine |
| How does its cost fall with volume? | Learning rate, six-tenths rule, tooling spread (Part 2) | Lithium-ion battery, Shipping container |
| What decides its form? | Material index for the load, then price and carbon (Part 3) | Carbon fibre and composite parts, Aeroplane |
| What trade-off front does it sit on? | Optimum, Pareto front, robust choice (Part 4) | Centrifugal water pump, Passenger car |
| What scarce input does it rely on? | Concentration, substitution, recycling (Part 5) | Permanent magnet, Aluminium can |
| Who is it for and what do they have? | Frugal design from the user's constraints (Part 5) | Bicycle, Syringe |

 Source: Hammack, The Things We Make (Sourcebooks, 2023), ch. 4, 'Resources: From Mesopotamia to the Islamic Empire to Space'

- Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Engineering Economics'
- Hammack, The Things We Make (Sourcebooks, 2023) · ch. 4, 'Resources: From Mesopotamia to the Islamic Empire to Space'
- Hammack, The Things We Make (Sourcebooks, 2023) · ch. 2, 'Best: The Vitruvian Man, Kodachrome, and the Constant Search for Better'

### See it in the table
[Cu Copper](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/copper/)[Al Aluminium](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/aluminum/)[Ni Nickel](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/nickel/)[St Steel](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/steel/)[Mn Manganese](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/manganese/)[Li Lithium](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/lithium/)[Co Cobalt](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/cobalt/)[REE Rare earths](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/rare_earths/)[HDPE High-density polyethylene](https://www.materialinsights.org/chemicals/hdpe/)[LFP Lithium iron phosphate batteries](https://www.materialinsights.org/technologies/e_li_lfp/)[PbA Lead-acid batteries](https://www.materialinsights.org/technologies/e_lead_acid/)[El Electricity](https://www.materialinsights.org/energy/electricity/)

### Check your understanding

Why does the IEA stress refining concentration more than reserves?
 The ground holds enough, but a leading refiner held about 72 per cent of refined supply on average in 2025, and export controls have spread. The risk is in the chain.

Recycling steel in an arc furnace cuts carbon by about 70 per cent. Why can it not meet all steel demand?
 Long-lived products mean scrap reflects demand decades earlier, so growth needs ore-based steel. Copper and other impurities also limit the grades scrap can make.

What did the Embrace warmer design use to hold a baby at 37 degrees Celsius without a steady electricity supply?
 The wax-like material absorbs and releases latent heat at a fixed temperature, so it acts as a built-in thermostat that needs no electricity.

[← Part 4: Optimising, Pareto fronts and the price of margin](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p4/)[Mark read · Wrap-up →](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/review/)

## Other sections

- [Module overview](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/index.md)
- [Whole-life cost and the price of money](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p1/index.md)
- [Why things get cheaper: learning, scale and standards](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p2/index.md)
- [Choosing a material under cost, weight and carbon](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p3/index.md)
- [Optimising, Pareto fronts and the price of margin](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/p4/index.md)
- [Key terms, quiz and sources](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/cost-tradeoffs-resources/review/index.md)
