# Heat and thermodynamics: engines, heat pumps and their limits: Waste heat, cogeneration and judging a heat claim

Source page: https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/heat-and-thermodynamics/p5/

[All courses](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/) / [Understanding Engineering](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/) / [Module 6: Heat and thermodynamics: engines, heat pumps and their limits](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/heat-and-thermodynamics/) Part 5 of 5

## Waste heat, cogeneration and judging a heat claim

Most heat machines throw away more energy than they use, and that waste is a design problem, a cost and sometimes an opportunity. This part grades waste heat by temperature, works out what a simple recovery device saves, shows why generating power and heat together can use fuel far better than separate plants, and ends by giving the reader a short checklist for testing claims about heat engines and pumps.

### 5.1 Waste heat comes in grades, and its temperature decides what can be done with it

A coal plant rejects about 4.8 GJ per megawatt hour at the condenser, and a combined cycle still sends a third of its fuel there. Waste heat is everywhere, but it is not all alike. Heat at 600 °C in the exhaust of a gas turbine can raise steam. Heat at 150 °C in a boiler's flue gas can warm feed water or air. Heat at 35 °C in condenser water can do little except dry a few grains or warm a nursery. The Carnot formula quantifies it: a joule at 600 °C can in principle yield 65 per cent work against 300 K, a joule at 150 °C 29 per cent, and a joule at 35 °C only 3 per cent. Quantity of heat is not the same as quality of heat. The course Understanding Energy treats this idea as exergy in its module 'The laws of energy: conservation, entropy and efficiency'.

The cheapest recovery device is a heat exchanger that moves heat from one stream to another through a metal wall, such as the economiser in a boiler, which warms the incoming water with the leaving flue gas. Because heat flow = conductivity x area x temperature difference / thickness (section 1.2), a small temperature gap needs a large area, and area is steel. The trade-off is always capital cost against fuel saved. And there is a floor: flue gas from sulphur-bearing coal cooled below about 130 °C drops sulphuric acid on cold metal, so economisers stop there.

The table sizes a typical industrial case. A 6 MW coal-fired boiler sends about 3 kg/s of flue gas out at 220 °C; cooling it to 140 °C recovers about 4 per cent of the fuel.

Data Worked estimate 10: an economiser on a 6 MW industrial boiler

| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Flue gas flow (assumed) | about 7.5 kg of gas per kg of coal x 0.4 kg/s of coal | 3 kg/s |
| Heat recovered, 220 °C down to 140 °C | 3 kg/s x 1.1 kJ/kg K x 80 K | 264 kW |
| Share of the fuel | 264 kW / 6,000 kW | 4.4% |
| Heat in a year of 6,000 hours | 264 kW x 6,000 h | 1,584 MWh, 5.7 TJ |
| Coal saved, boiler 85%, 15 MJ/kg | 5,700,000 MJ / (15 x 0.85) | about 447 tonnes |
| Value at an assumed Rs 7,000 per tonne | 447 x 7,000 | about Rs 31 lakh a year |

Results calculated; flow, hours, price and the 1.1 kJ/kg K for flue gas are assumed round values. Check: the shop-floor rule of about one point of boiler efficiency for each 20 K of stack temperature gives 4 per cent for 80 K. Savings must be set against the cost of the exchanger, the extra fan power to push gas through it, and the 130 °C acid floor.
 Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 7, 'Heat and Phase Transitions', section 7.1 ('Woodstoves': heat exchangers and specific heat)  Common misreading

#### 'Just use the waste heat to make more power'

Because waste heat is so abundant, start-up pitches often promise to turn it into power. Carnot reminds us that the cooler the heat, the smaller the yield, and the machine and heat exchangers cost money in proportion to their size, not their output. Low-grade heat is usually best used as heat, close by, where a use exists, such as drying, space heating or preheating, and not forced through an engine with a 5 per cent yield.

- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 7, 'Heat and Phase Transitions', sections 7.1 and 7.3 (heat exchangers; conduction)
- Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 4, 'Energy Conversion', section 4.5 (conservation of energy and the control boundary)
- Understanding Energy, course on this site · module 'Efficiency, waste heat and recovery' (further reading)

### 5.2 Cogeneration makes power and useful heat from one fuel supply, and saves about a fifth of the fuel

If condenser heat is nearly useless, the answer is to take the heat out of the turbine earlier, at a temperature where someone can use it. That is cogeneration, or combined heat and power. A back-pressure steam turbine, instead of expanding the steam down to a vacuum, lets it out at 2 or 3 bar and about 130 °C, and the exhaust steam goes to a process. The electricity per unit of fuel is lower than a power-only plant's, but the heat that would have been thrown away becomes a product.

India's sugar mills are the classic case. Crushing cane leaves a fibrous residue, bagasse, which the mill burns in a boiler. The steam runs a turbine for the mill's own power, and the exhaust steam boils the cane juice, which needs a great deal of heat. A mill that uses its steam twice in this way spends less fuel than one that burns separately for each task, and many sell surplus electricity to the grid. Other users of cogeneration are textile mills, paper mills, fertiliser plants and hospitals.

The saving can be counted with fuel ratios, as in the table. In this case cogeneration saves roughly a fifth of the fuel needed by separate production. And there is a tight condition: the heat cannot travel far, because steam pipes leak heat and cost money, so the user must be near and must need the heat for most of the year. A mismatch between when power and heat are wanted is the usual reason cogeneration projects fail to repay.

Data Worked estimate 11: fuel needed for 25 units of power and 55 units of heat

| Route | Working | Fuel used |
|---|---|---|
| Separate: power from a grid plant at 38% | 25 / 0.38 | 65.8 units |
| Separate: heat from a boiler at 90% | 55 / 0.90 | 61.1 units |
| Separate total | 65.8 + 61.1 | 126.9 units |
| Cogeneration at 80% total (25 power + 55 heat) | (25 + 55) / 0.80 | 100 units |
| Fuel saved | (126.9 - 100) / 126.9 | about 21% |
| Power-to-heat ratio of the cogenerator | 25 / 55 | 0.45, fixed by the turbine |

All inputs are round, assumed figures; results calculated. Check: the European definition of high-efficiency cogeneration asks for a primary energy saving of at least 10 per cent against separate production, and this case is well above it. The saving falls if the heat is wasted part of the year.
 Source: Directive 2012/27/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council on energy efficiency (Official Journal of the European Union, 2012), Annex II: high-efficiency cogeneration must give primary energy savings of at least 10 per cent against separate production of heat and power

- Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 4, 'Energy Conversion', section 4.5 (conservation of energy and the control boundary)
- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 8, 'Thermodynamics', section 8.2 ('Automobiles': heat engines)
- Directive 2012/27/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council on energy efficiency (Official Journal of the European Union, 2012) · Annex II: high-efficiency cogeneration must give primary energy savings of at least 10 per cent against separate production of heat and power

### 5.3 A short checklist lets you test any claim about a heat engine or heat pump

The module's ideas can now be turned into a quick test for the claims a founder or a brochure might make about a heat machine. The questions run in a fixed order, and most claims fail at one of the first three.

First, is it a heat machine at all, and where do its two temperatures sit? Write both in kelvin. Second, apply the Carnot bound: engine 1 - Tc/Th, pump Tc / (Th - Tc) for cooling or Th / (Th - Tc) for heating. A claim above the bound is impossible, whatever the design. Third, do the first-law audit: energy in must equal energy out. A machine is not producing energy if the claim leaves out the source of heat. Fourth, compare with the real machines of the same class: real engines reach about half to two-thirds of Carnot, and heat pumps and refrigerators about half to two-thirds of the ideal COP. A claim near the bound needs strong evidence. Fifth, ask about the heat exchangers and the parts that do not appear in the pitch: temperature gaps, area, fouling and the cost of the materials at the hot end. Sixth, ask what the claim means in money: fuel saved per year against cost installed.

The table applies the test to six claims. A measured result from an independent laboratory, with temperatures and the boundary of the test stated, is worth more than any calculation, as with an independent test report for an air conditioner. For the wider view of how efficiency, rebound and recovery work across the economy, the course Understanding Energy offers a module on efficiency and recovery.

Data Worked estimate 12: six claims against the second law

| Claim | Check | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Engine from 150 °C exhaust (423 K), cooling at 30 °C (303 K), 40% efficient | limit = 1 - 303/423 = 28% | Impossible |
| Heat pump for 60 °C water from 20 °C air, COP 4 | ideal = 333 / 40 = 8.3; real at half to two-thirds = 4 to 5.5 | Plausible, at the good end |
| Heat pump for 90 °C water from 10 °C air, COP 6 | ideal = 363 / 80 = 4.5 | Impossible |
| Air conditioner COP 12 at 35 °C outdoor, 24 °C indoor | ideal = 297 / 11 = 27, but refrigerant needs about 40 K lift, ideal 7 | Doubtful, above the practical limit |
| Gas turbine combined cycle at 62% | limit = 82%; verified record 64.18% under test conditions | Plausible at the best-in-class level |
| A machine using 1 kW of electricity to make 1.5 kW of electricity from room air | first law: 0.5 kW from nowhere | Impossible |

The verdicts are checks against the limits, not tests of any real product. Real values come from the makers' data and independent test reports.
 Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 8, 'Thermodynamics', sections 8.1 and 8.2 ('Air Conditioners'; 'Automobiles'); checks calculated  Worked example

#### Reading a claim as an engineer

A pitch says a unit turns 150 °C factory exhaust into electricity at 40 per cent efficiency. With 30 °C cooling water, the Carnot limit is 1 - 303/423 = 28 per cent. The claim is above the law, so either the number counts something else (perhaps the heat actually captured rather than the heat available) or it is wrong. A good question is: 40 per cent of what, and at which two temperatures?

- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 8, 'Thermodynamics', sections 8.1 and 8.2
- Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 4, 'Energy Conversion', section 4.5 (conservation of energy)
- Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, vol. I (Caltech online edition) · further reading: ch. 45, 'Illustrations of Thermodynamics', https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_45.html

### See it in the table
[H₂O Water](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/water/)[St Steel](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/steel/)[Su Sugar](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/sugar/)[H2SO4 Sulphuric acid](https://www.materialinsights.org/chemicals/sulphuric_acid/)[CHP Combined heat and power](https://www.materialinsights.org/technologies/e_chp/)[El Electricity](https://www.materialinsights.org/energy/electricity/)

### Check your understanding

Why is heat at 35 °C from a condenser a poor source for an engine?
 Quality, not quantity, matters. Between 308 K and 300 K the ideal yield is 1 - 300/308, about 2.6 per cent, so low-grade heat is best used as heat.

A cogeneration plant makes 25 units of power and 55 units of heat from 100 units of fuel. Separate plants at 38% and 90% would need
 Power takes 25/0.38 = 65.8 and heat 55/0.9 = 61.1, a total of 126.9 units, so cogeneration saves about 21 per cent. The saving depends on the heat actually being used.

A company claims a heat pump delivering 90 °C water from 10 °C air with COP 6. What is wrong?
 The ideal heating COP is Th / (Th - Tc) = 363 / 80 = 4.5. No machine can beat that, and real ones reach half to two-thirds of it.

[← Part 4: Refrigerators, air conditioners and heat pumps: moving heat uphill](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/heat-and-thermodynamics/p4/)[Mark read · Wrap-up →](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/heat-and-thermodynamics/review/)

## Other sections

- [Module overview](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/heat-and-thermodynamics/index.md)
- [Temperature, heat and the ways heat moves](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/heat-and-thermodynamics/p1/index.md)
- [The first and second laws: the audit and the limit](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/heat-and-thermodynamics/p2/index.md)
- [Real cycles: steam, petrol, diesel and gas turbine plants](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/heat-and-thermodynamics/p3/index.md)
- [Refrigerators, air conditioners and heat pumps: moving heat uphill](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/heat-and-thermodynamics/p4/index.md)
- [Key terms, quiz and sources](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/engineering/heat-and-thermodynamics/review/index.md)
