# Evolution and the diversity of life: Natural selection: Darwin, Wallace and the logic of adaptation

Source page: https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/p2/

[All courses](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/) / [Understanding Science](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/) / [Module 15: Evolution and the diversity of life](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/) Part 2 of 6

## Natural selection: Darwin, Wallace and the logic of adaptation

Species change over time, and the cause is a process that follows from three plain facts about living things. Two men found it independently in the 1850s. This part sets out the history, the logic, a short calculation of how fast selection works, and the limits of adaptation.

### 2.1 Darwin and Wallace each found natural selection, and the 1858 joint paper made it public

In February 1858 Alfred Russel Wallace, collecting birds and insects in the Malay Archipelago and recovering from fever on the island of Ternate, wrote an essay on how species change and posted it to Charles Darwin. Darwin had reached the same idea twenty years earlier and had been piling up evidence without publishing. His friends arranged for Wallace's essay and extracts of Darwin's earlier writing to be read together at the Linnean Society of London on 1 July 1858. Darwin then wrote On the Origin of Species at speed. It appeared on 24 November 1859, and booksellers took nearly all of the 1,250 copies printed.

Both men were travellers. Darwin sailed on HMS Beagle from 1831 to 1836, dug up fossils of giant extinct mammals in South America that resembled living ones, and found that Galapagos mockingbirds differed from island to island. Wallace worked first in the Amazon and then in the islands between Asia and Australia. Both read Thomas Malthus, who argued in 1798 that populations can grow faster than food, so many must die young. Both used the geology of Charles Lyell, who argued in 1830 to 1833 that slow everyday processes, given vast time, shape the Earth. That gave evolution the time it needed.

The rival idea, from Jean-Baptiste Lamarck in 1809, was that animals change through use and disuse during life and pass those changes on. August Weismann tested it, describing the work in 1888: he cut the tails off 901 mice over five generations, and every new litter grew normal tails. Changes to the body do not reach eggs and sperm (see the module on genes). The node 'Evolution by natural selection' covers both men.
 Common misreading

#### Effort during life is not inherited

A common picture is that species change because individuals strive, so a farmer's hard hands or a snake's unused legs would be passed on. Weismann's mice show why this fails. What passes to offspring is the DNA in eggs and sperm, and a lifetime of use or injury does not rewrite it. Species change because inherited variants that happen to suit the setting leave more descendants, and the others leave fewer.

- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 17, 'The Evolution of Life'
- [University of Otago Library, Darwin exhibition, cabinet 8](https://www.otago.ac.nz/library/exhibitions/darwin/cabinet8.html (joint reading at the Linnean Society on 1 July 1858; Origin of Species published 24 November 1859; of 1,250 first edition copies, some 1,170 sold at once to the book trade; fetched 2026)) · web
- [Embryo Project Encyclopedia (Arizona State University), August Friedrich Leopold Weismann (1834 to 1914)](https://embryo.asu.edu/pages/august-friedrich-leopold-weismann-1834-1914 (Weismann cut off the tails of 901 mice and their offspring for five generations, and the descendants still grew normal tails; described in an 1888 lecture; fetched 2026)) · web
- Standard histories of evolutionary biology, as summarised by Encyclopaedia Britannica and the Natural History Museum · Lamarck (1809), Lyell (1830 to 1833), Malthus (1798), the Beagle voyage (1831 to 1836), Wallace's Ternate essay (February 1858), Fisher, Haldane and Wright (1920s to 1930s), Pasteur's flask experiments (1860s), Miller (1953), Steno (1669), William Smith (about 1800 to 1815), ALH84001 (collected 1984, claim 1996); standard dates recalled, not re-fetched

### 2.2 Natural selection follows from variation, inheritance and unequal survival, and it acts on populations

The argument has three steps that anyone can check. Individuals in a population differ from each other. Some differences are inherited. And more young are produced than can survive, so inherited differences that help survival or breeding become more common in the next generation. Nothing else is needed. The idea is sometimes called survival of the fittest, but fitness here means the number of offspring that themselves breed, not strength.

Variation comes from mutation, which makes new alleles, and from sexual reproduction, which shuffles alleles into new combinations each generation (see the module on genes). Selection acts on the phenotype, the traits that can be seen or measured, because it is the whole animal that lives or dies. But it changes the genotype, as the alleles of survivors are the ones passed on. Individuals do not evolve. A population does, because its allele frequencies shift from one generation to the next. That is the modern definition of evolution.

How fast can it work? Suppose an allele gives a small edge: each carrier leaves 10 per cent more offspring than other animals. Start it in 1 per cent of a population, with one generation a year. A short calculation, using the rule that its share grows by a factor of (1 + s)/(1 + s x share), gives the table below. Even a modest edge takes over in about a century. Larger edges take over in decades. Such calculations were made in the 1920s and 1930s by Fisher, Haldane and Wright, who joined Darwin's idea to Mendel's genetics.

Data Worked estimate: years for a helpful allele to spread, starting at 1 per cent (calculated)

| Edge per carrier (s) | Generations to reach 50 per cent | Generations to reach 99 per cent |
|---|---|---|
| 0.05 (5 per cent more offspring) | 95 | 189 |
| 0.10 (10 per cent) | 49 | 97 |
| 0.20 (20 per cent) | 26 | 51 |

Calculated for a single allele in a population that breeds in separate generations, using new share = share x (1 + s) / (1 + s x share). Selection slows as the allele becomes common, because there is less left to replace.
 Source: Rounded reference values used for estimates, uranium-238 half-life 4.47 billion years; mutation rate 1.2 x 10^-8 per base per generation and about 1.2 per cent difference between human and chimpanzee genomes; generation time 25 years; bacterial doubling 20 to 30 minutes; hydrostatic pressure 9.8 kPa per metre of water; atmospheric pressure 101 kPa; standard values quoted as round numbers for paper estimates, not re-fetched

- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 17, 'The Evolution of Life'
- Standard histories of evolutionary biology, as summarised by Encyclopaedia Britannica and the Natural History Museum · Lamarck (1809), Lyell (1830 to 1833), Malthus (1798), the Beagle voyage (1831 to 1836), Wallace's Ternate essay (February 1858), Fisher, Haldane and Wright (1920s to 1930s), Pasteur's flask experiments (1860s), Miller (1953), Steno (1669), William Smith (about 1800 to 1815), ALH84001 (collected 1984, claim 1996); standard dates recalled, not re-fetched
- Rounded reference values used for estimates · mutation rate 1.2 x 10^-8 per base per generation and about 1.2 per cent difference between human and chimpanzee genomes; generation time 25 years; bacterial doubling 20 to 30 minutes; hydrostatic pressure 9.8 kPa per metre of water; atmospheric pressure 101 kPa; water density 1,000 kg per cubic metre; standard round numbers for paper estimates. Values marked (calculated) were worked from these and checked by the reviewer

### 2.3 Adaptation is a compromise, and sexual selection, parental care and body size show the trade-offs

An adaptation is an inherited trait that raises the number of surviving offspring in a given setting, and every adaptation has a cost. Male long-tailed widowbirds of the Kenyan grasslands grow tails so long that flying is harder. In a field test, Malte Andersson cut some males' tails short and glued the clipped feathers onto others. The males with lengthened tails gained the most new nests. Darwin called this sexual selection: traits that win mates, through female choice or contests between males, can spread even when they harm survival, as long as the gain in offspring outweighs the loss.

Care for young is another trade. A female king cobra builds a nest of leaves and guards her eggs, while a mackerel scatters thousands of eggs and leaves them. Guarding costs food and future breeding; scattering wastes most eggs. Which pays depends on how likely young are to survive in that place.

Body size trades heat. A warm-blooded animal makes heat through its bulk and loses it through its skin, and the module on the cell showed that surface grows more slowly than volume. So within a group, animals in colder places tend to be bigger and more compact, a pattern called Bergmann's rule: the tigers of the Russian Far East are among the largest cats alive. Thin, blood-filled ears shed heat, which is one reason the African savanna elephant, living in open heat, has much larger ears than the Asian elephant of shaded forests.
 Worked example

#### Skin per kilogram: a mouse against an elephant

Treat each animal as a ball of water, 1,000 kg per cubic metre. For a ball, skin area per kilogram is 3 / (radius x density). A 20 g mouse fills 20 cubic centimetres, a ball of radius about 1.7 cm, so it has about 0.18 square metres of skin per kilogram (calculated). A 4,000 kg elephant is a ball of radius about 0.98 m, with about 0.003 square metres per kilogram (calculated). The mouse has some 58 times more skin per kilogram (calculated, the cube root of 200,000), so for its weight it must burn food far faster to stay warm.

- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 17, 'The Evolution of Life'
- [Stanford Birds, essay on sexual selection, describing Andersson (Nature, 1982)](https://web.stanford.edu/group/stanfordbirds/text/essays/Sexual_Selection.html (long-tailed widowbirds in Kenya; tails cut and the feathers glued to other males; males with lengthened tails acquired the most new nests; fetched 2026)) · web
- Rounded reference values used for estimates · mutation rate 1.2 x 10^-8 per base per generation and about 1.2 per cent difference between human and chimpanzee genomes; generation time 25 years; bacterial doubling 20 to 30 minutes; hydrostatic pressure 9.8 kPa per metre of water; atmospheric pressure 101 kPa; water density 1,000 kg per cubic metre; standard round numbers for paper estimates. Values marked (calculated) were worked from these and checked by the reviewer

### See it in the table
[H₂O Water](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/water/)[Eg Eggs](https://www.materialinsights.org/commodities/eggs/)

### Check your understanding

Weismann cut the tails off mice for five generations, and every litter still grew normal tails. What did this show?
 The cuts changed the parents' bodies but not the DNA in their eggs and sperm, so Lamarck's inheritance of acquired change failed the test.

A helpful allele gives carriers an edge of 10 per cent and starts at 1 per cent. Roughly how long to reach half the population, at one generation a year?
 The table gives 49 generations for s = 0.10, so about 50 years if there is one generation a year.

Why do larger warm-blooded animals tend to keep heat better than small ones of the same shape?
 Surface grows with the square of size and volume with the cube, so a 4,000 kg elephant has about 58 times less skin per kilogram than a 20 g mouse.

[← Part 1: Deep time: how life began and how the past is read](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/p1/)[Mark read · Part 3: The evidence: change we can watch and change the rocks record →](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/p3/)

## Other sections

- [Module overview](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/index.md)
- [Deep time: how life began and how the past is read](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/p1/index.md)
- [The evidence: change we can watch and change the rocks record](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/p3/index.md)
- [Chance, migration and the splitting of species](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/p4/index.md)
- [Humans, the tree of life and the edge of life](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/p5/index.md)
- [A tour of living diversity](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/p6/index.md)
- [Key terms, quiz and sources](https://www.materialinsights.org/learn/science/evolution-and-diversity/review/index.md)
