Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Genes: DNA, inheritance and DNA technology: Inheritance: Mendel, chromosomes and meiosis

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 14: Genes: DNA, inheritance and DNA technology Part 1 of 6

Inheritance: Mendel, chromosomes and meiosis

Children resemble their parents but are never copies. Before anyone knew what a gene was, a monk counting peas found that inheritance follows rules of chance, and later workers found where the units sit and how they are shuffled. This part starts from the pattern, because the molecule makes sense only once you know what it has to explain.

1.1 Mendel's peas in 1865 showed that heredity comes in countable units that do not blend

Look at a family and it seems that a child is a blend of its parents, like paint mixed in a bucket. For most of history that was the working theory. Gregor Mendel, an Augustinian friar in Brno, tested it with garden peas. Peas were a good choice: they fertilise themselves, he could cross them by hand, and several traits come in two clear forms, such as round or wrinkled seeds.

He first made lines that always bred true. Crossing a round line with a wrinkled one gave only round seeds in the first generation. Nothing was blended. Letting those plants fertilise themselves, the wrinkled form came back in the next generation, at about one plant in four. In his count, 5,474 seeds were round and 1,850 wrinkled, a ratio of 2.96 to 1 (calculated). Across seven traits and about 28,000 plants he saw the same 3 to 1.

His explanation was that each plant carries two copies of a hereditary factor for each trait, now called alleles of a gene, and passes on one, chosen at random, in each pollen grain or egg. If one allele is dominant, it hides the other in a plant with one of each. The hidden recessive allele is not lost. It is passed on and shows again when two copies meet. This is the law of segregation. Tracking two traits together, he found they were sorted independently, giving 9: 3: 3: 1, the law of independent assortment, which holds when the genes are on different chromosomes.

He read the work to Brno's Natural History Society on 8 February and 8 March 1865, and it was printed in 1866. It was ignored until 1900, when three botanists, de Vries, Correns and Tschermak, found the same ratios and then found his paper. The node 'Mendelian inheritance' gives the longer story.

Data Worked estimate: a cross of two purple-flowered pea plants that each carry one white allele (Pp x Pp)
Egg \ pollenP (half the pollen)p (half the pollen)
P (half the eggs)PP, purple, 1 in 4Pp, purple, 1 in 4
p (half the eggs)pP, purple, 1 in 4pp, white, 1 in 4

Three boxes in four give purple flowers, so the expected ratio is 3: 1. Mendel's own flower-colour count was 705 purple to 224 white, 705 / 224 = 3.15: 1 (calculated). For 80 plants expect 80 x 3/4 = 60 purple and 20 white (calculated), but chance alone gives a spread of about plus or minus 4 plants (square root of 80 x 0.75 x 0.25 = 3.9 plants, calculated), so 55 purple and 25 white would not be a surprise. A test cross of Pp with pp gives 1: 1 and reveals a hidden allele.

Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 16, 'Genetics'
Data Worked estimate: two parents who each carry one copy of the same recessive allele; chance that at least one child shows the trait
ChildrenChance none shows itChance at least one shows it
13/4 = 75%25%
2(3/4)^2 = 56%44%
3(3/4)^3 = 42%58%
4(3/4)^4 = 32%68%

Each child is a fresh draw, like a new toss of a coin; earlier children do not change the odds. This is the principle behind genetic counselling, not advice about any real condition.

Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 16, 'Genetics'
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 16, 'Genetics'

1.2 Most traits do not follow simple ratios, because genes interact, share chromosomes and meet the environment

In incomplete dominance the heterozygote sits between its parents: crossing red and white four o'clock plants (Mirabilis jalapa) gives pink flowers, and the next generation shows 1 red: 2 pink: 1 white. In codominance both alleles show at once. The human ABO blood groups have three alleles, A, B and O. A and B are both expressed, so a person with one of each has group AB. A parent with group AB and one with group O can have only A or B children, in equal shares, because every child gets O from one side and either A or B from the other.

Most everyday traits are polygenic, set by many genes of small effect. Height, blood pressure and the milk yield of a cow vary smoothly in a bell-shaped curve because many genes add together, with diet and illness on top. A single gene can also affect several traits, which is called pleiotropy. The allele that makes some cats pure white often makes them deaf as well, because the same pigment cells are needed in the inner ear.

Genes on the same chromosome tend to travel together, so they break Mendel's second law. They are separated only by crossing over, and the nearer two genes lie, the more rarely this happens.

Genes on the X chromosome show sex-linked patterns. A male carries a single X, paired with a Y, so a recessive allele on his X always shows. Red-green colour blindness is the standard case. A mother who carries it passes the allele to half her sons. About 8 men in 100 of European descent are affected but only about 0.6 women in 100 (0.08 x 0.08 = 0.0064, calculated), because a woman needs two copies. The environment matters too: a Siamese cat has dark ears and paws because its pigment enzyme works only in the cooler parts of the body.

  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 16, 'Genetics'

1.3 Chromosomes carry the genes, and meiosis shuffles them, so each egg and sperm is one of millions of possibilities

Mendel's factors were abstract until 1902 to 1903, when Sutton and Boveri saw that chromosomes behave the same way: they come in pairs, one from each parent, and the pairs separate when eggs and sperm are made. In 1910 Thomas Morgan found a white-eyed male fruit fly and showed that the eye colour went with the sex chromosome. That tied a named gene to a named chromosome.

Human body cells have 46 chromosomes in 23 pairs: 22 pairs of autosomes and one pair of sex chromosomes, XX in females and XY in males. Module 13 (The cell) explained mitosis, which keeps the number at 46. Eggs and sperm need 23, so they are made by meiosis, in which the DNA is copied once and the cell divides twice. Four steps matter. First, the chromosomes in each pair line up side by side. Second, they swap matching stretches, called crossing over, so that each chromosome becomes a patchwork of the mother's and father's DNA. Third, the pairs line up and separate at random, so each cell gets one chromosome from each pair, in any mix. Fourth, the second division splits the copies, giving four haploid cells. Fertilisation restores 46.

The randomness is large. With 23 pairs there are 2 to the power 23, or 8.4 million (calculated), ways to choose a set, before any crossing over. A couple can therefore make about 8.4 million x 8.4 million = 70 trillion (calculated) different children by this alone. Except for identical twins, siblings differ for this reason.

Meiosis can fail. If a pair does not separate, an egg or sperm has an extra or missing chromosome. Three copies of chromosome 21 cause Down syndrome, and the chance rises as mothers get older.

Data Worked estimate: how many different eggs or sperm one person can make from chromosome choice alone
Chromosome pairs nCombinations 2^nMeaning
24a toy case
532a small genome
101,024maize has 10 pairs
238,388,608 (calculated)a human, before crossing over
23 + 23 (two parents)2^46 = 70,368,744,177,664 (calculated)about 70 trillion distinct children

Crossing over adds far more, so these are lower bounds. Each pair is an independent coin toss, which is Mendel's second law at the scale of whole chromosomes.

Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 16, 'Genetics'
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 16, 'Genetics'
  • Standard histories of genetics, as summarised in Encyclopaedia Britannica (Gregor Mendel; Rosalind Franklin; Francis Crick; James Watson; DNA; Meselson-Stahl) and the Nobel Prize site (Physiology or Medicine 1962, 1968, 1978 and 1980; Chemistry 1993) · dates and findings for Mendel (read 1865, published 1866, rediscovered 1900), Sutton and Boveri (1902 to 1903), Morgan (1910), Griffith (1928), Avery, MacLeod and McCarty (1944), Hershey and Chase (1952), Chargaff, Franklin and Gosling (Photo 51, 1952), Watson and Crick (Nature, 25 April 1953), Meselson and Stahl (1958), Crick and others (1961), Nirenberg and Matthaei (1961), Jacob and Monod (1961), Luria and Delbruck (1943), Cohen and Boyer (1973), Sanger (1977), Mullis (1983). Checked in November 2026: Mendel read 8 February and 8 March 1865, printed 1866 (Villanova Mendel text); Photo 51 taken May 1952 and published in Nature on 25 April 1953 beside Watson and Crick (King's College London); Meselson and Stahl at Caltech, PNAS 44 (1958) (Arizona State University Embryo Project); Mullis developed PCR in 1983 at Cetus, Nobel 1993 (Britannica)

See it in the table

Eg Eggs

Check your understanding

In a cross of two purple-flowered pea plants that each carry a white allele (Pp x Pp), about how many of 800 plants do you expect to have white flowers?

Only the pp combination is white, and that is one of four equally likely pairings, so 800 / 4 = about 200 plants.

A scientist says a trait is recessive, so it must be rare. What is wrong with this?

Blood group O is recessive and widespread. Frequency depends on population history and chance, while dominance only describes expression.

Why can siblings who are not identical twins differ so much?

Random pairing of 23 chromosome pairs alone gives 8.4 million possible eggs or sperm, and crossing over adds more.
← Module contentsMark read · Part 2: DNA: the molecule, its shape and its copying →