Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

The human body as a system: control, care and defence: Defence and renewal: immunity, vaccines and the next generation

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 16: The human body as a system: control, care and defence Part 6 of 6

Defence and renewal: immunity, vaccines and the next generation

The body meets microbes that could use it as food every day. This part separates the quick, general defences from the slow, specific ones that learn, explains vaccines as a principle with its history from Jenner to polio-free India, and ends with how one cell becomes a person.

6.1 Innate defences act within minutes, on anything foreign, and keep no memory

A thorn scratch turns red, warm and swollen within an hour: the innate immune system, present from birth, at work. The germ theory of disease (node 'Germ theory of disease') underlies it: Semmelweis cut deaths on a Vienna maternity ward in 1847 by having students wash their hands, John Snow traced a London cholera outbreak to a water pump in 1854, and Pasteur and Robert Koch showed in the 1860s to 1880s that particular microbes cause particular diseases. A pathogen can be a bacterium, a virus (Module 15), a fungus or a parasite.

The first line is barrier. Skin is dry, tough and slightly acidic. Mucus traps microbes in the airways and cilia sweep it out. Tears carry lysozyme, which splits bacterial walls, and stomach acid kills many swallowed microbes.

The second line works inside tissues. Phagocytes, such as neutrophils and macrophages, engulf microbes; Elie Metchnikoff saw this in 1882 in starfish larvae and shared the 1908 Nobel Prize. They recognise molecular patterns common to many microbes, using receptors found by Bruce Beutler and Jules Hoffmann (Nobel Prize 2011). Damaged tissue releases histamine, which widens vessels (redness, heat) and makes them leak (swelling), letting more defenders in. Natural killer cells destroy infected-looking cells, interferons warn neighbours, and complement proteins punch holes in microbes. Fever is the hypothalamus raising its set point (Part 1).

All this is quick but not specific, and it has no memory.

Value chain The layers of defence
  • Defence of the body
    • Innate (from birth, fast, general)
      • Barriers skin, mucus and cilia, tears, stomach acid
      • Cells and proteins phagocytes, natural killer cells, interferons, complement
      • Inflammation and fever
    • Acquired (learned, slower, specific, with memory)
      • B cells become antibody factories
      • T cells helper T cells coordinate; cytotoxic T cells kill infected cells
      • Memory cells faster response on the second meeting
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 20, 'Human Biology II: Care and Maintenance'
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 20, 'Human Biology II: Care and Maintenance'
  • Standard histories of physiology and immunology, as summarised in Encyclopaedia Britannica (Edward Jenner; Louis Pasteur; Emil von Behring; Frank Macfarlane Burnet; Frederick Banting; William Bayliss and Ernest Starling; Otto Loewi; Marcello Malpighi; Stephen Hales) · dates and findings recalled from these histories and not re-fetched in this session: Jenner's first vaccination in May 1796 and publication in 1798; Behring and Kitasato 1890; Pasteur's anthrax vaccine 1881; Bayliss and Starling 1902; Banting and Best 1921 to 1922; Loewi 1921; Malpighi 1661; Hales 1733; sliding filament papers 1954; Pert and Snyder 1973; Hughes and Kosterlitz 1975
  • Weizmann Institute of Science, Germs, Humans and Numbers (28 January 2016), on Sender, Fuchs and Milo · web

6.2 Acquired immunity learns the shape of a germ, multiplies the right cells and remembers

Survivors of smallpox or measles were rarely struck twice, as the node 'Acquired immunity and antibodies' recounts. The key fact is that immune cells recognise shapes. An antigen is any molecular shape, on a microbe or a toxin, that the immune system can respond to.

White cells called lymphocytes carry it out. B cells mature in bone marrow and T cells in the thymus. Each lymphocyte carries receptors of one shape, produced by shuffling segments of its own genes (Susumu Tonegawa, Nobel Prize 1987), giving billions of different lymphocytes. When an antigen meets the cell whose receptor fits, that cell is chosen and multiplies into a clone. This is clonal selection, proposed by Macfarlane Burnet in the late 1950s, and he shared the 1960 Nobel Prize for the related discovery of tolerance. Some of the clone become plasma cells, which release thousands of antibodies a second, and others long-lived memory cells.

An antibody is a Y-shaped protein of four chains with two identical grips at the arm tips. It does not kill. It blocks a microbe or toxin from entering cells, clumps microbes, and marks them for phagocytes and complement. In 1890 Emil von Behring and Kitasato Shibasaburo showed that serum from an animal immunised against diphtheria toxin protected another animal.

T cells are of two main kinds. Helper T cells coordinate the response by chemical signals. Cytotoxic T cells recognise infected cells that show fragments of the virus on their surface and destroy them. Training in the thymus removes T cells that react to the body itself.

Failures show the design. Allergy is a response to a harmless antigen, autoimmune disease a response to the body's own tissue, and HIV, identified in 1983, infects helper T cells and weakens the whole response. Transplanted organs are rejected when their surface markers differ.

Data Worked estimate: a race between a germ and a lymphocyte clone
QuantityFirst meeting (primary response)Second meeting (memory)
Matching cells at the start1 (calculated)10,000 (calculated)
Doublings to reach 1 million20 (2^20 is about 1 million) (calculated)6.6 (1,000,000 / 10,000 = 100 = 2^6.6) (calculated)
Time at 6 hours per doubling (assumed)120 hours, 5 days (calculated)40 hours, 1.7 days (calculated)
Doublings a germ could manage meanwhile (30 minutes each)240 (calculated)80 (calculated)

The 6-hour doubling time and the memory pool of 10,000 cells are round assumptions for illustration. A germ cannot double 240 times, because it runs out of food and meets the innate defences, but the table shows why the first days of an infection are fought by innate defences and why memory shortens the wait.

Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 20, 'Human Biology II: Care and Maintenance'; Standard histories of physiology and immunology, as summarised in Encyclopaedia Britannica (Edward Jenner; Louis Pasteur; Emil von Behring; Frank Macfarlane Burnet; Frederick Banting; William Bayliss and Ernest Starling; Otto Loewi; Marcello Malpighi; Stephen Hales), dates and findings recalled from these histories and not re-fetched in this session: Jenner's first vaccination in May 1796 and publication in 1798; Behring and Kitasato 1890; Pasteur's anthrax vaccine 1881; Bayliss and Starling 1902; Banting and Best 1921 to 1922; Loewi 1921; Malpighi 1661; Hales 1733; sliding filament papers 1954; Pert and Snyder 1973; Hughes and Kosterlitz 1975
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 20, 'Human Biology II: Care and Maintenance'
  • Standard histories of physiology and immunology, as summarised in Encyclopaedia Britannica (Edward Jenner; Louis Pasteur; Emil von Behring; Frank Macfarlane Burnet; Frederick Banting; William Bayliss and Ernest Starling; Otto Loewi; Marcello Malpighi; Stephen Hales) · dates and findings recalled from these histories and not re-fetched in this session: Jenner's first vaccination in May 1796 and publication in 1798; Behring and Kitasato 1890; Pasteur's anthrax vaccine 1881; Bayliss and Starling 1902; Banting and Best 1921 to 1922; Loewi 1921; Malpighi 1661; Hales 1733; sliding filament papers 1954; Pert and Snyder 1973; Hughes and Kosterlitz 1975
  • Nobel Prize site (nobelprize.org), Physiology or Medicine laureates 1904, 1908, 1923, 1930, 1936, 1960, 1963, 1971, 1972, 1987, 1990, 1991, 2003, 2004, 2008, 2010 and 2011 · years and findings recalled from these laureate pages and not re-fetched in this session (the site refused automated fetches)
  • Nobel Prize site (nobelprize.org), The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1960, summary · Burnet and Medawar, for discovery of acquired immunological tolerance

6.3 Vaccines train the memory without the disease: the history runs from Jenner to polio-free India

A vaccine shows the immune system an antigen without the disease. The antigen can be a killed germ, a live but weakened one, a purified protein or a piece of genetic instruction that makes the body build one protein. The response lays down memory cells, so a later meeting takes the quicker second path of the previous section.

Edward Jenner, a country doctor in Gloucestershire, heard that milkmaids who had caught cowpox, a mild disease, did not catch smallpox. In May 1796 he put matter from a dairymaid's cowpox sore into a scratch on the arm of an eight-year-old boy, James Phipps. Later he exposed the boy to smallpox, and the boy did not fall ill. Jenner published in 1798; vaccine comes from vacca, Latin for cow. Pasteur extended the method to anthrax in 1881. Inoculation with smallpox matter itself had long been practised in India, China and Turkey, at real risk.

The WHO's intensified campaign against smallpox began in 1967. A global commission certified the disease eradicated on 9 December 1979, and the 33rd World Health Assembly declared it on 8 May 1980. It remains the only human disease eradicated. That was possible because only humans catch it, cases show a visible rash, there are no healthy carriers, and the vaccine is stable. Polio is caused by a virus that damages nerve cells. On 27 March 2014 WHO certified its South-East Asia Region, including India, as free of wild poliovirus. The region held a quarter of the world's people.

The mathematics of spread explains why high coverage matters. R0 is the number of people one case infects in a fully susceptible population. If a fraction p is immune, each case infects R0 x (1 minus p), and spread fades when that falls below 1, so p must exceed 1 minus 1/R0.

Data Worked estimate: the share of a population that must be immune to stop spread
R0 (illustrative)1 minus 1/R0Share that must be immune
21 minus 0.550 per cent (calculated)
41 minus 0.2575 per cent (calculated)
61 minus 0.16783 per cent (calculated)
151 minus 0.06793 per cent (calculated)

These values are arithmetic on assumed R0, not claims about particular diseases; published R0 for a highly infectious childhood disease such as measles is commonly quoted in a range of about 12 to 18. The formula assumes random mixing and perfect protection, so real thresholds are higher.

Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 20, 'Human Biology II: Care and Maintenance'

6.4 Reproduction and development turn one cell into a person, steered by hormones

Gametes are made by meiosis (Module 14) with 23 chromosomes each. Testes make sperm continuously, near a thousand a second. A girl is born with 1 to 2 million immature eggs, of which only about 400 are ever released. The egg, about 0.1 millimetre across, is the body's largest cell.

Hormone loops run the system (Part 1). The hypothalamus releases GnRH, which makes the pituitary release FSH and LH; these drive the gonads to make oestrogen, progesterone and testosterone, which feed back on the pituitary. In the monthly cycle of about 28 days, an egg-containing follicle grows and oestrogen rises. A surge of LH, a rare positive feedback, triggers ovulation near day 14.

Fertilisation usually happens in the oviduct. One sperm fuses with the egg, and the zygote begins dividing as it travels to the womb. By about day 5 it is a hollow ball, the blastocyst, which implants in the womb lining in days 6 to 10. The placenta forms there. It lets oxygen, nutrients and wastes diffuse between maternal and foetal blood without the bloods mixing; foetal haemoglobin binds oxygen more tightly than adult haemoglobin, so oxygen passes to the baby.

In weeks 3 to 8 three embryonic layers form the organs: the outer layer the skin and nervous system, the middle one muscle, bone and blood, the inner one the gut lining. Body-plan genes shared by flies and people (Module 15) mark where each part goes. The heart beats by about week 5, and pregnancy lasts about 38 weeks from fertilisation. Labour is driven by positive feedback: stretching releases oxytocin, which strengthens contractions and so more stretch. The first birth after in vitro fertilisation came in 1978, and Robert Edwards won the 2010 Nobel Prize.

Data Worked estimate: how many cell divisions make a baby?
StepWorkingResult
Mass of a newborntypical3 kg
Cells per kilogram (adult: 37 trillion in 70 kg, Part 1)37 x 10^12 / 70about 5 x 10^11 per kg (calculated)
Cells in a newborn3 x 5 x 10^11about 1.6 x 10^12 (calculated)
Doublings from one celllog2(1.6 x 10^12) is about 40.5about 40 rounds (calculated)
Average time per doubling over 266 days266 / 40about 6.6 days (calculated)

This ignores cells that die and treats all cells alike. Early divisions are far faster than the average and later ones slower; the number of rounds is what the estimate fixes. Module 13 found about 45 doublings for a whole adult.

Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 19, 'Human Biology I: Control and Development'
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 19, 'Human Biology I: Control and Development'
  • Nobel Prize site (nobelprize.org), Physiology or Medicine laureates 1904, 1908, 1923, 1930, 1936, 1960, 1963, 1971, 1972, 1987, 1990, 1991, 2003, 2004, 2008, 2010 and 2011 · years and findings recalled from these laureate pages and not re-fetched in this session (the site refused automated fetches)

See it in the table

H₂O WaterEg EggsO2 OxygenVit Vitamins

Check your understanding

Which statement about innate immunity is correct?

Innate defences are present from birth and act on anything foreign within minutes. They do not learn, which is the job of the acquired system.

A vaccine works mainly by

The antigen triggers clonal selection, leaving memory cells. A later infection meets a quicker response.

If a disease has R0 of 4, the share that must be immune to stop its spread is above

The threshold is 1 minus 1/R0 = 1 minus 0.25 = 0.75.
← Part 5: Fuel, matter and waste: what goes in, what is used and what leavesMark read · Wrap-up →