Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Mineral nutrition of plants: Discovery

The story

How the idea was found and came to be accepted

In the early nineteenth century the leading view, the humus theory, held that plants lived on soluble extracts of humus, the rotted organic matter in soil [1]. Albrecht Thaer was one of its best-known advocates [1]. Carl Sprengel, whom Thaer had mentored, published an article refuting it in 1826; in 1828 he wrote that a plant needing many substances will not grow if any one is missing [1]. Justus von Liebig turned to agricultural chemistry in 1840 and his book that year made the mineral theory widely known [1, 2]. Liebig was not right on everything: he argued for years that crops drew nitrogen mainly from ammonia in the air, and his first chemical manures, begun in 1845, proved inefficient [2]. In England, John Bennet Lawes and his colleagues tested the ideas in field experiments at Rothamsted from 1843, and a long dispute with Liebig over nitrogen followed [3]. Historians now credit Sprengel as the true founder of the theory [1].

as of 2026-11-12

People

The people behind it, their years and what each contributed

NameYearsContribution
Carl Sprengel1787 to 1859Refuted the humus theory in 1826 and stated the law of the minimum in 1828 [1]
Justus von Liebig1803 to 1873Spread the mineral theory through his 1840 book and popularised the law of the minimum [1, 2]
John Bennet Lawes1814 to 1900Founded the Rothamsted field experiments that tested fertilisers against manure from 1843 [3, 4]
Albrecht Thaer1752 to 1828Leading advocate of the older humus theory [1]

as of 2026-11-12

Milestones

The key moments, year by year

YearEvent
1826Sprengel publishes an article refuting the humus theory [1]
1828Sprengel states the law of the minimum in an article on soil chemistry and plant nutrition [1]
1840Liebig publishes his book on organic chemistry applied to agriculture and physiology [1, 2]
1842Lawes is granted a patent for making superphosphate fertiliser [3]
1843The Broadbalk winter wheat experiment is first sown at Rothamsted [3]
2021World farming uses 195 million tonnes of mineral fertiliser nutrients [5]

as of 2026-11-12

Sources

  1. On the Origin of the Theory of Mineral Nutrition of Plants and the Law of the Minimum Soil Science Society of America Journal, by R. R. van der Ploeg, W. Böhm and M. B. Kirkham (copy hosted by Mississippi State University), 1999, vol. 63, pp. 1055 to 1062; DOI 10.2136/sssaj1999.6351055x (publisher page not reachable, copy read)
  2. Justus von Liebig: Developments in agricultural, animal, and food chemistry Encyclopaedia Britannica
  3. Visual history of Rothamsted Rothamsted Research
  4. A look back at 175 years of agricultural experiment at Rothamsted Chemistry World (Royal Society of Chemistry)
  5. Inorganic fertilizers 2000-2021 (FAOSTAT Analytical Brief Series No. 68) Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, 2023