Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Statics of arches and the line of thrust: Discovery

The story

How the idea was found and came to be accepted

Builders raised arches, vaults and domes for thousands of years by rules of thumb. The first theory came from Robert Hooke, who told the Royal Society in 1671 that he had solved the shape of the ideal arch and in 1675 printed the answer as a Latin anagram; his executor revealed it in 1705: as hangs the flexible line, so, inverted, stands the rigid arch [3]. Mathematicians found the equation of the hanging chain in 1691 [3]. In France, Philippe de La Hire treated an arch with the forces on a weightless cord in his mechanics of 1695 [4]. In 1743 Pope Benedict XIV called Giovanni Poleni to Rome to deal with the problem of the dome of St Peter's [5]. Poleni divided the dome into slices, hung weights in proportion to each slice on a chain, found that the chain's curve fitted inside the shell, and judged the dome safe [2]; iron rings were fitted to it by 1748 [5]. Henry Moseley gave the line of thrust a rigorous form in 1833 [2], and Jacques Heyman's rules of 1966 made it the basis of modern masonry analysis [2].

as of 2026-11-10

People

The people behind it, their years and what each contributed

NameYearsContribution
Robert Hooke1635 to 1703Found that an inverted hanging chain gives the shape of an arch, published as an anagram in 1675 [2, 3]
Philippe de La Hire1640 to 1718Brought masonry arches into the theory of mechanics [4, 6]
Giovanni Poleni1683 to 1761First applied the hanging-chain rule to a real building, the dome of St Peter's [2, 5]

as of 2026-11-10. Source 4 gives La Hire's death as 1719; the full date in source 6, 21 April 1718, is used.

Milestones

The key moments, year by year

YearEvent
1671Hooke tells the Royal Society he has solved the shape of the ideal arch [3]
1675Hooke publishes the rule as a Latin anagram [1, 3]
1695La Hire's Traité de mécanique treats arches with the forces on a cord [4]
1748Poleni's study of the dome of St Peter's; iron rings fitted by this year [2, 5]
1833Moseley first states the line of thrust rigorously [2]
1966Heyman's three assumptions found modern limit analysis of masonry [2]

as of 2026-11-10

Sources

  1. As Hangs the Flexible Line: Equilibrium of Masonry Arches Nexus Network Journal, vol. 8 no. 2 (Block, DeJong and Ochsendorf), Springer, 2006, abstract
  2. Equilibrium Systems: Studies in Masonry Structure Massachusetts Institute of Technology (Philippe Block, SMArchS thesis), 2005
  3. Catenary Wikipedia
  4. El análisis gráfico de equilibrio de arcos, bóvedas y edificios. Un esquema de su desarrollo histórico Revista de Historia de la Construcción (Santiago Huerta), on the Universidad Politécnica de Madrid archive, 2024
  5. Giovanni Poleni MacTutor History of Mathematics, University of St Andrews
  6. Philippe de La Hire Structurae