Ship propulsion: Science and limits
Why only 30% of the fuel actually pushes the ship
A ship burns fuel oil or LNG in a large piston engine that turns a propeller; about half the fuel energy becomes shaft work and roughly 60% of that becomes thrust, so about 30% ends up pushing the hull. Sails and rotors use wind directly; naval reactors use fission.
The conversion, step by step
Combustion and expansion in a slow-speed two-stroke engineChemical (heavy fuel oil, marine diesel or LNG) → Shaft work · about 51-54% (calculated from WinGD X92 fuel use of 156-166 g/kWh at 65-100% load and the 42.7 MJ/kg reference heating value)142Propeller
Shaft work → Thrust power · about 52-67% in open water; about 55-60% behind the hull for standard propeller series in a bulk carrier case study4Hull
Thrust power → Motion against water friction, waves and air drag · all thrust work is lost to resistance; this sets the fuel needed per tonne-km1End to end (calculated)
Chemical (fuel) → Thrust power · about 30% (0.51 engine x 0.98 shaft line, an assumed typical value, x 0.59 propeller behind hull)144
The science
Large ships use slow-speed two-stroke diesels, several storeys tall, coupled straight to the propeller. They are efficient because they compress air very hard and big, slow cylinders lose little heat; a turbocharger reuses exhaust energy. Dual-fuel engines burn LNG injected at high pressure (Diesel cycle) or premixed with air (Otto cycle) (which lets some methane escape unburned: 6.4% on average in low-pressure four-strokes, see methods). A large, slow propeller wastes less energy in the wake. Power rises roughly with the cube of speed, so slow steaming is the cheapest saving. Rotor sails use the Magnus effect: a spinning cylinder in wind feels a sideways force usable as thrust.
Limits set by science
| Limit | Value | Why it exists | Best today |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carnot limit on the engine | about 85% (calculated, illustrative)214 | 1 - Tc/Th with an assumed peak gas temperature of 2,000 K and seawater at 300 K: 1 - 300/2,000 = 0.85. Real engines fall far short because heat is added over a range of temperatures, walls are cooled and exhaust leaves hot. | about 51-54% (calculated); in gas mode the Diesel-cycle Everllence G95ME-GI beats the Otto-cycle WinGD X92DF by up to 2.9 points at 75% load |
| Propeller (actuator disc) limit | 2 / (1 + wake speed / ship speed)4 | The faster the propeller throws water back relative to the ship, the more energy is wasted; bigger, slower propellers get closer but are limited by draught. | open-water efficiency about 0.67 for Wageningen B and MAU series |
| Wind-assist thrust | two 35 m x 5 m rotors gave peak thrust equal to 7 MW of propeller power (test)67 | Sail force grows with wind speed squared and sail area, but depends on route and weather, so savings are voyage averages. | 25% average saving projected by Norsepower for one North Sea ship; up to 6% on a Vale ore carrier with five Anemoi rotors (company figures) |
Sources
- Fourth IMO GHG Study 2020: Executive Summary International Maritime Organization, 2020
- Comparative analysis of the heat balance results of the selected Tier III-compliant gas-fuelled two-stroke main engines (Korlak), Combustion Engines 193(2) Polish Scientific Society of Combustion Engines, 2023
- Design of propeller series optimizing fuel consumption and propeller efficiency (Tadros, Ventura and Guedes Soares), Journal of Marine Science and Engineering 9, 1226 MDPI, 2021
- Norsepower highlights Rotor Sail results at The Motorship Propulsion and Future Fuels webinar Norsepower, 2021
- Anemoi installs rotor sails on Vale's very large ore carrier Ship Technology, 2024
- X92 IMO Tier II/Tier III engine data WinGD, 2026