Other and primary batteries: What to track
Cycle-life proof for new cells, and rules for old ones
For emerging chemistries track cost and cycle-life data against lithium-ion and sodium-ion; for primary cells track EU collection and durability rules.
| Category | Attribute | Latest | Trend | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Techno-economic | LCOS trajectory | No published LCOS; zinc system USD 449/kWh installed (10 MW / 10 h, 2021) vs US lithium-ion 4 h LCOS USD 210-292/MWh (Lazard, Jul 2026)111 | → stable | US lithium-ion LCOS rose in 2026 on tariffs, a small opening for non-lithium chemistries, but global lithium-ion cell prices remain low. |
| Technical | Capacity fade and state of health | Zinc pouch cells often under 300 cycles, best about 750; potassium-ion full cells short of commercial needs; no commercial magnesium-ion data1314 | ↗ improving | Bankable warranties need third-party test data on full-size cells. |
| Supply chain | Critical mineral cost and geopolitical concentration | China about 86% of primary magnesium and 32% of zinc mining (calculated, 2025); battery-grade lithium carbonate USD 9,000/t (2025 US average, real)567 | ↕ volatile | Cheap lithium weakens the case for substitutes; magnesium is highly concentrated. |
| Market | Ancillary service market saturation | Not yet participating | → stable | Emerging chemistries will enter crowded short-duration markets. |
| Regulatory | Safety and environmental compliance | EU mercury limit 0.0005%; portable lead limit 0.01% from Aug 2024; battery passport for industrial batteries above 2 kWh from 18 Feb 20279 | → stable | Rules tighten for both primary and rechargeable cells. |
| Environmental | Lifecycle carbon payback period | No figure found in sources reviewed | → stable | For primary cells the relevant measure is embodied carbon per kWh delivered, which is high. |
| Regulatory | Portable battery collection rate (technology-specific) | EU target 63% by 2027, 73% by 203010 | ↗ improving | Determines how much primary-cell zinc, manganese and silver is recovered. |
| Market | Mercury-free button cells (technology-specific) | Some button-type batteries may still contain mercury (US, 2025)3 | ↗ improving | Indium substitutes in alkaline cells; full phase-out is a compliance marker. |
Sources
- 2022 Grid Energy Storage Technology Cost and Performance Assessment (PNNL-33283), Executive Summary p. vii Pacific Northwest National Laboratory for US Department of Energy, 2022
- Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Mercury US Geological Survey, 2026
- Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Lithium US Geological Survey, 2026
- Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Zinc US Geological Survey, 2026
- Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Magnesium Metal US Geological Survey, 2026
- SafeGuardS 115/23: EU issues new regulation on batteries and waste batteries (summary of Regulation (EU) 2023/1542) SGS, 2023
- Batteries and waste batteries: summary of Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 European Parliament Legislative Observatory, 2023
- Lazard's Levelized Cost of Energy+ (LCOE+), July 2026 (LCOS v11.0 key assumptions p. 38; LCOE v19.0 assumptions p. 28) Lazard, 2026
- Several concerns about aqueous zinc metal batteries: from components to unit cells (Li, Liang and Fang, EES Batteries, first published 22 Dec 2025) Royal Society of Chemistry, 2025
- 10 years development of potassium-ion batteries (Li, Wang, Wang, Lyu, Wang, Xia, Mao and Guo, Advanced Materials, article 2416717) Wiley / University of Adelaide repository, 2025