Power-to-X: Science and limits
Where half the electricity disappears on the way to fuel
Power-to-X builds low-carbon hydrogen into molecules that are easier to store, ship or burn: ammonia (with nitrogen from air), methanol and methane (with CO2), and jet fuel or diesel (with CO2, via Fischer-Tropsch). Only about 40-60% of the electricity ends up in the fuel.
The conversion, step by step
ElectrolysisElectricity plus water → Hydrogen · 65-70% LHV for large commercial electrolysers1CO2 or N2 supply
Heat and electricity → Pure CO2 (from fermentation, flue gas or air) or N2 (air separation) · Air separation and compression for ammonia: about 500 kWh per tonne NH3. Air capture needs about 4-10 GJ of heat per tonne of CO214Synthesis
H2 plus CO2 or N2 → Ammonia, methanol or Fischer-Tropsch syncrude · H2 to ammonia 88%, to methanol 80%, to Fischer-Tropsch syncrude 57% (LHV); a jet-optimised refinery then gets about 75% kerosene1End to end
Electricity → Liquid or gaseous fuel · 40-60% (IEA); roughly half (ICCT)12
The science
These syntheses are catalytic reactions that give off heat, so once hydrogen exists the chemistry runs downhill. Haber-Bosch joins nitrogen and hydrogen over iron at high pressure (N2 + 3H2 → 2NH3). Methanol forms over copper (CO2 + 3H2 → CH3OH + H2O); the Sabatier reaction over nickel makes methane (CO2 + 4H2 → CH4 + 2H2O). For jet fuel, CO2 is first turned into carbon monoxide (reverse water-gas shift), then Fischer-Tropsch synthesis at about 200 C and 20-30 bar on cobalt or iron links CO and H2 into chains that a refinery sorts into kerosene, diesel and naphtha. In the carbon routes some hydrogen leaves as water, a loss no catalyst can avoid. Ammonia has no oxygen to remove, so it is the most efficient carrier, then methanol, with Fischer-Tropsch last.
Limits set by science
| Limit | Value | Why it exists | Best today |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ammonia energy ceiling | About 88% of hydrogen LHV kept in NH3 (calculated: 0.176 t H2 per t NH3)1 | Synthesis gives off heat, so ammonia holds less energy than the hydrogen in it. | IEA assumes 88%, close to the ceiling; air separation and compression add about 500 kWh/t |
| Carbon-route ceilings | About 88% for methanol, 83% for methane, 84% for Fischer-Tropsch fuel (calculated from heating values and 0.19, 0.5 and 0.43 t H2 per t of product)1 | Part of the hydrogen ends up in water, carrying its energy away as heat. | 80% H2-to-methanol and 57% H2-to-syncrude in IEA modelling; e-methane only at pilot scale (6 MW) |
| Air capture minimum | About 0.44 GJ per t CO2 (calculated from the free energy of separating 0.04% CO2 from air)4 | CO2 in air is so dilute that real sorbents need many times this, mostly as heat to release the CO2. | About 4-6 GJ of heat per t for solid sorbents (80-120 C) and 6-10 GJ for liquid solvents (about 900 C) |
| Grid carbon threshold | Below 160-190 g CO2-eq/kWh for e-methanol; below 95-140 g for e-methane and e-kerosene3 | Above these levels the e-fuel emits more over its life than the fossil fuel it replaces. | Only met with dedicated renewable or nuclear power |
Sources
- The Role of E-fuels in Decarbonising Transport (revised January 2024) International Energy Agency, 2024
- Current and future cost of e-kerosene in the United States and Europe International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT), 2022
- Global Hydrogen Review 2024: GHG emissions of hydrogen and its derivatives International Energy Agency, 2024
- Direct air capture of CO2: from insights into the current and emerging approaches to future opportunities (Zeeshan, Kidder, Pentzer, Getman, Gurkan), Frontiers in Sustainability 4 Frontiers, 2023