Thinking in estimates: units, scaling and educated guessing: Key terms, quiz and sources
All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 2: Thinking in estimates: units, scaling and educated guessing Wrap-upThinking in estimates: units, scaling and educated guessing: review
Key terms
- Order of magnitude
- The nearest power of ten to a quantity; two numbers within the same power of ten are said to be of the same order.
- Estimate
- A rough answer built from stated round-number assumptions and open to checking and correction.
- Fermi estimate
- A rough figure for a large unknown, obtained by multiplying several smaller quantities that can be guessed.
- Unit
- A chosen scale for measuring a quantity, such as the metre, the foot or the kilowatt-hour.
- Dimension
- The kind of quantity underneath a unit, written with letters such as M for mass, L for length and T for time.
- Conversion factor
- A fraction equal to one, such as 1 hour over 3,600 seconds, used to change units by cancelling.
- Dimensional analysis
- Working out how a quantity can depend on others by requiring that both sides of a formula have the same dimensions.
- Pure number
- A quantity with no dimensions, such as an efficiency or a ratio of two lengths, which is the same in any unit system.
- Easy case
- A simple or extreme setting of the inputs, where the answer is obvious, used to test a formula.
- Lumping
- Replacing a complicated shape or distribution by a simple one of the same overall size.
- Significant figures
- The digits of a number that are justified by how well it is known; extra digits claim a precision that does not exist.
- Taking out the big part
- Computing the dominant effect first and then adjusting for small corrections close to one.
- Analogy
- Using the structure of a familiar system, such as water in pipes, to reason about an unfamiliar one.
- Scaling law
- A rule stating how a quantity changes when size changes, usually as a power of length.
- Surface-to-volume ratio
- Surface area divided by volume; it falls as an object gets bigger, which governs heat loss and cooling.
- Safety factor
- The multiple by which a part is made stronger than its expected load, to cover what is unknown.
- Standing loss
- The heat a hot storage tank loses each day while nothing is drawn from it.
Try it in the table
- Open 'Solar PV module' in the Products table. Take a module's rated watts and its area from any maker's sheet, divide, and compare the result with the 200 W per m2 used in part 3. Then change the roof allowance and see how the roof area for 2 kW moves.
- Under 'CNG, LPG and biogas distribution', note how many households your state or city is said to serve. Redo the LPG estimate with your own state's count and a refill rate you ask a neighbour about, and compare it with a published figure.
- Look at 'Steel-frame skyscraper' and 'Reinforced concrete'. Pick a tower you know, find its height, and work out what compressive strength a uniform column of that height would need if it carried only its own weight with a margin of 3.
- Open 'Centrifugal water pump' and redo the module 1 tank estimate for your own building: floors, litres a day, minutes to fill. Compare your shaft power with the motor ratings on a maker's sheet, being careful with horsepower against watts.
- Under 'Motorcycle and scooter' and 'Lithium-ion battery', repeat the running-cost estimate with your own city's petrol price and your local electricity tariff. At what electricity price would the two scooters cost the same per kilometre?
- Open 'Mineral wool insulation' and 'Solar heat collectors'. Estimate the heat leak of a 100-litre solar water tank at 45 K above room temperature for two foam thicknesses, and check it against the 100-litre limits in the BEE star table.
Final quiz
Why do engineers estimate before running a detailed calculation?
The rough answer guides the work and guards against large errors, such as unit slips, in the detailed one.A formula for the power of a pump is proposed as flow in kg/s multiplied by height in metres. What does a dimensions check show?
Power needs M x L2 / T3 but the proposal gives M x L / T. The missing L / T2 is gravity.Which of these is a pure number?
An efficiency is a ratio of two quantities with the same dimensions, so it has no unit.Dimensional analysis gives the speed of a jet from a tank as C x the square root of (g x h). What does it not tell you?
The method fixes the powers but cannot give pure numbers; they come from an experiment or a further argument.A rooftop solar module of 20 per cent efficiency is rated at 1,000 W per m2 of sunshine. How much module area gives 1 kW?
Each square metre gives 200 W, so 1,000 W needs 5 m2 of module. About twice the area of roof is needed for gaps and walkways.A structure is scaled up three times in every direction. By what factor does the stress from its own weight rise?
Weight grows as the cube (27) and cross-section as the square (9), so stress grows by 27 / 9 = 3.The 200-litre heater estimate, at 1.76 kWh a day, was well above the 2023 to 2025 5-star limit of 0.984 kWh. How should this miss be read?
The estimate assumed the same foam as the small tank. The label implies about 55 mm instead of 30 mm.An estimate says electric running cost is ₹0.24 per km against ₹2.3 for petrol. Which input error would be needed to reverse the ordering?
The ratio is about 10, so only a combined error of that size would reverse it, which careful estimating does not usually produce.Sources for this module
- Mahajan, Street-Fighting Mathematics (MIT Press, 2010) · Preface; ch. 1, 'Dimensions'; ch. 2, 'Easy cases'; ch. 3, 'Lumping'; ch. 4, 'Pictorial proofs'; ch. 5, 'Taking out the big part'; ch. 6, 'Analogy'
- Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 2, 'Elements of Engineering Analysis' (SI units, conversions, significant figures, need-know-how-solve method, spreadsheet analysis)
- Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, vol. I (Caltech online edition) · further reading: ch. 5, 'Time and Distance', https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_05.html
- Construction World, 'India's LPG Q1 sales rise 4.7% as customer base grows to 326.8 million' (reporting PPAC data, 23 August 2024) · 326.8 million active domestic LPG customers of the public-sector oil marketing companies (first quarter of 2024-25), https://www.constructionworld.in/amp/energy-infrastructure/oil-and-gas/indias-lpg-q1-sales-rise-4.7-as-customer-base-grows-to-326.8-million/61155
- Inshorts, 'How much LPG did India produce and consume in last 5 financial years' (reporting PPAC data, 21 March 2026) · LPG consumption 31.3 million tonnes in 2024-25, https://inshorts.com/en/news/how-much-lpg-did-india-produce-and-consume-in-last-5-financial-years--1774093334297
- Central Public Health and Environmental Engineering Organisation (CPHEEO), Manual on Water Supply and Treatment (Ministry of Urban Development, 1999), clause 2.2.8.3, as reproduced by the National Capital Region Planning Board · minimum residual pressure at the ferrule: 7 m for one storey, 12 m for two, 17 m for three, https://www.ncrpb.nic.in/NCRBP%20ADB-TA%207055/repository/pdf/clause/Clause.2.2.8.3e.pdf
- Ministry of New and Renewable Energy, FAQ on grid-connected rooftop solar (28 April 2022, published by PIB) · about 10 to 12 square metres of shadow-free area per kWp; 4 to 5.5 units a day per kWp on a clear sunny day, https://static.pib.gov.in/WriteReadData/specificdocs/documents/2022/apr/doc202242850101.pdf
- Bridgeway Power, 'Solar panel generation in India per kW' (2025) · about 4 units a day and 1,300 to 1,600 units a year per kW on average, https://bridgewaypower.in/blog/solar-panel-generation-india-per-kw-units
- Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat, Skyscraper Center entry for Burj Khalifa · architectural height 828 m, completed 2010, steel over concrete, https://www.skyscrapercenter.com/building/burj-khalifa/3
- Novak, 'A tall adventure: the Burj Khalifa, the world's tallest structure', Building Safety Journal (International Code Council, 8 August 2023) · wall concrete C60 to C80 cube strength; telescopic structural steel spire of over 200 m, https://www.iccsafe.org/building-safety-journal/bsj-technical/a-tall-adventure-the-burj-khalifa-the-worlds-tallest-structure/
- Bureau of Energy Efficiency, note on star labelling of storage water heaters (star rating plan valid 1 January 2023 to 31 December 2025) · Table 3.4 standing loss limits in kWh per 24 hours per 45 degrees C, https://beeindia.gov.in/sites/default/files/GeyserNote.pdf
- Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 2082:1993 Stationary Storage Type Electric Water Heaters: Specification · clause 16.1, standing loss per 24 hours scaled to a 45 K difference between mean water temperature and ambient, https://law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/S05/is.2082.1993.pdf
- VSC Times, 'BEE star ratings for water heaters (geysers)' (2026, secondary report of the BEE table) · 5-star limits 0.423 kWh (25 L) and 0.890 kWh (200 L) per 24 hours per 45 degrees C, table valid 1 July 2026 to 31 December 2027, https://vsctimes.com/bee-star-ratings-for-water-heaters-geysers/
- Ather Energy, Rizta specifications page · installed battery 2.7, 2.9 or 3.5 kWh; IDC range 123 and 161 km; TrueRange 100 and 125 km; kerb weight 125 kg, https://www.atherenergy.com/rizta/specifications
- Autocar India, 'Ather scooters get new battery packs, LFP cells on Rizta' (16 July 2026) · Rizta 2.7 kWh (LFP) or 2.9 kWh (NMC) for 123 km IDC; 3.5 kWh for 161 km IDC, https://www.autocarindia.com/bike-news/ather-scooters-get-new-battery-packs-lfp-cells-on-rizta-440234
- HDFC Sky, 'Petrol, diesel prices today, November 11, 2026' (from Goodreturns) · petrol Rs 102 to Rs 112 a litre in Delhi, Mumbai, Bengaluru and Chennai, https://hdfcsky.com/news/petrol-diesel-prices-today-november-11-2026-check-latest-rates-in-delhi-mumbai-kolkata-chennai-bengaluru-hyderabad
- Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 456:2000 Plain and Reinforced Concrete: Code of Practice · grades of concrete designated by characteristic compressive strength in N/mm2; unit weight of reinforced concrete 25 kN/m3