Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Atoms, the periodic table and the quantum idea: Size, emptiness and models: putting numbers on the atom

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 8: Atoms, the periodic table and the quantum idea Part 6 of 6

Size, emptiness and models: putting numbers on the atom

With the structure in hand, this part turns to scale. It estimates how wide an atom is, how little of it is occupied, why solid things do not pass through each other, how the models of the atom fit together, and how many atoms there are in a person and how old they are.

6.1 An atom is about a tenth of a nanometre across, so a hair is hundreds of thousands of atoms wide

The neighbouring atoms in a solid sit about 0.25 nanometres apart. A nanometre is a billionth of a metre. The simplest check on this is the iron estimate in the engineering module 'Matter at the atomic scale', which found 0.23 nm from density and atomic mass. For a feel of the scale, take a human hair, about 70 micrometres across. Divide by 0.25 nm and the hair is 280,000 atoms wide.

This explains why no ordinary microscope shows atoms. Visible light has a wavelength of about 500 nm, about 2,000 atoms. A microscope cannot resolve detail much finer than the wavelength it uses (the node 'Diffraction limit of resolution'). Atoms are therefore far below its reach, whatever the lenses. The waves of fast electrons are far shorter, a few picometres, so electron microscopes can resolve atoms. Since the 1980s a third route has needed no lens. In a scanning tunnelling microscope a metal point, ending in a single atom, hovers a fraction of a nanometre above a surface, and a tiny current leaks across the gap (node 'Quantum tunnelling'). The current changes steeply with the gap, so mapping it point by point gives a relief map of the electron clouds.

The Bohr radius, 5.29 x 10^-11 m, gives hydrogen a diameter of about 0.1 nm, in line with the spacing above. Bigger atoms are not much bigger: caesium, among the largest, has a radius of only about 0.3 nm, though it has 55 electrons. Each added proton pulls the shells inward, which offsets the growth from new shells.

Surfaces are crowded too. One layer of atoms 0.25 nm apart on a square centimetre of polished steel holds (10^-2 m / 0.25 x 10^-9 m) squared = 1.6 x 10^15 atoms (calculated), and a catalyst or a solar cell works through layers like that.

Data Worked estimates: counting and comparing atoms (calculated)
QuestionWorkingResult
Atoms across a hair70 x 10^-6 m / 0.25 x 10^-9 m2.8 x 10^5
Atoms in the thickness of paper0.1 x 10^-3 m / 0.25 x 10^-9 m4 x 10^5
Atoms across one wavelength of green light500 x 10^-9 m / 0.25 x 10^-9 m2,000, too fine for an optical microscope
Atoms in one layer on 1 cm^2 of surface(1 x 10^-2 m / 0.25 x 10^-9 m)^2 = (4 x 10^7)^21.6 x 10^15
Electron wavelength at 100 kVabout 0.0037 nm (waves module); 0.25 nm / 0.0037 nm = 68About 70 times smaller than the atom spacing, enough to resolve it

The atom spacing 0.25 nm is typical of solids. A line of atoms is not a perfect row, so counts across a hair are order-of-magnitude values.

Source: NIST, Fundamental Physical Constants, 2022 CODATA values, https://www.physics.nist.gov/cuu/pdf/wall_2022.pdf (Bohr radius 5.29177 x 10^-11 m; atomic mass constant 1.66054 x 10^-27 kg; h = 6.62607015 x 10^-34 J s exact; Rydberg constant 1.09737 x 10^7 per m; electron mass 9.10938 x 10^-31 kg; proton mass 1.67262 x 10^-27 kg); Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 9, 'Atoms and the Periodic Table'

6.2 Nearly all the mass sits in a nucleus about twenty thousand times narrower than the atom, so matter is mostly empty and still solid

The gold nucleus has a radius of about 7 x 10^-15 m, found from the rule of thumb r = 1.2 femtometres x A^(1/3), with A = 197. The atom's radius is 1.4 x 10^-10 m. The ratio is 20,000. For a feel, picture a cricket ball, 7 cm across, as the nucleus. The atom would then reach out 700 m in every direction, with the electron cloud spread thinly through all that space. By volume the nucleus fills about one part in 10^13 of the atom (20,000 cubed is 8 x 10^12).

That nucleus holds almost all the mass. In carbon-12 the six electrons weigh 5.5 x 10^-30 kg of the atom's 1.99 x 10^-26 kg, which is 0.027 per cent. So the nucleus is extremely dense. A nucleus has a mass of one nucleon, 1.67 x 10^-27 kg, in every 7.2 x 10^-45 m^3 (the volume of a sphere of radius 1.2 fm), giving about 2.3 x 10^17 kg per cubic metre. A teaspoon of material that dense, 5 cm^3, would weigh 1.15 x 10^12 kg, a billion tonnes, the mass of a cube of rock about 750 m on a side. Neutron stars, the collapsed cores of large stars, are built from material of this density.

If atoms are nearly empty, why does a coin lie on a table instead of sinking through it? The nuclei of the two never come near each other. What matters is the electron cloud. Electrons in the coin and in the table repel one another, and the Pauli rule forbids two of them from sharing a state. To push the atoms closer, electrons must be moved into higher levels, and that costs energy. The table pushes back with that cost. The emptiness is not nothing either: it is filled with electron waves and electric fields.

Data Worked estimates: the emptiness and density of an atom (calculated)
QuantityWorkingResult
Size ratio, gold atom to nucleus1.4 x 10^-10 m / 7.0 x 10^-15 m20,000
Volume ratio20,000 cubed8 x 10^12
If the nucleus were a 7 cm cricket ball3.5 cm x 20,000atom radius 700 m
Electron share of carbon-12's mass6 x 9.109 x 10^-31 / 1.993 x 10^-260.027%
Nuclear density1.67 x 10^-27 kg / (4/3 x 3.1416 x (1.2 x 10^-15)^3 m^3)2.3 x 10^17 kg/m^3
Mass of 5 cm^3 at that density5 x 10^-6 m^3 x 2.3 x 10^171.15 x 10^12 kg, about a billion tonnes
Equivalent cube of rock (2,700 kg/m^3)(1.15 x 10^12 / 2,700)^(1/3)about 750 m on a side

The nuclear radius rule r = 1.2 fm x A^(1/3) is an average fit to measurements, accurate to ten or twenty per cent for most nuclei.

Source: American Physical Society, APS News, May 1911: Rutherford and the Discovery of the Atomic Nucleus (2006), https://aps.org/publications/apsnews/200605/history.cfm (hard dense core; nucleus about 1/100,000 of the atom; plum pudding could not give backward scattering); NIST, Fundamental Physical Constants, 2022 CODATA values, https://www.physics.nist.gov/cuu/pdf/wall_2022.pdf (Bohr radius 5.29177 x 10^-11 m; atomic mass constant 1.66054 x 10^-27 kg; h = 6.62607015 x 10^-34 J s exact; Rydberg constant 1.09737 x 10^7 per m; electron mass 9.10938 x 10^-31 kg; proton mass 1.67262 x 10^-27 kg)

6.3 Each model of the atom answers some questions and fails others, and a good model is a tool to be matched to the question

Atomic models come in a sequence, and each one grew from an experiment that the one before could not explain. Dalton in 1808 pictured solid balls, one kind for each element, which explained why compounds have fixed ratios (node 'Atomic theory'). Thomson in 1897 added electrons. Rutherford in 1911 put the charge into a tiny nucleus. Bohr in 1913 gave the electrons steps of energy. The orbital picture of 1925 and 1926 made the electrons waves, and it is the one in use today.

A model ship is a physical model: the real thing at another scale. An atom cannot have one, because it has no colour and no sharp surface, so every model of it is a conceptual model, a set of rules for predicting what it does. Think of two records of one cricket match, the scorecard and the ball-by-ball video. The scorecard lists runs, wickets and overs and says nothing of how anyone batted, which suits the question of who won and fails if you want to coach a cover drive. The shell diagram of rings and dots is a scorecard of that kind.

The practical rule is to pick the simplest model that answers the question. Use the shell picture to count outer electrons and predict bonds. Use Bohr's levels to work out hydrogen's colours. Use orbitals for the shapes of molecules. Use the Rutherford picture for scattering. The mistake is to treat any one of them as what an atom looks like.

Data The ladder of atomic models
ModelYearEvidence behind itWhat it does wellWhere it fails
Dalton's solid atom1808Fixed mass ratios in compoundsCounting atoms in reactionsHas no parts; no electrons
Thomson's plum pudding1897Electrons are in all atomsNeutral atom with light charges insideCannot produce large-angle scattering
Rutherford's nuclear atom1911Alpha particles bounced backSize and mass of the nucleusCannot explain line spectra or stability
Bohr's levels1913Hydrogen's lines and Planck's quantumHydrogen colours and sizeFails for atoms with several electrons
Orbitals (quantum model)1925 to 1926Electron waves, spectra, ionisation energiesPeriodic table, bonds, spectraHard to picture; needs mathematics
Source: American Physical Society, APS News, May 1911: Rutherford and the Discovery of the Atomic Nucleus (2006), https://aps.org/publications/apsnews/200605/history.cfm (hard dense core; nucleus about 1/100,000 of the atom; plum pudding could not give backward scattering); Encyclopedia.com, Thomson, Joseph John (Complete Dictionary of Scientific Biography), https://encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/thomson-joseph-john (1897: cathode rays as subatomic charged particles, called corpuscles, later electrons; plum pudding atom); Nobel Prize in Physics 1922, summary, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1922/summary/ (Bohr: services in the investigation of the structure of atoms and of the radiation emanating from them); Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 9, 'Atoms and the Periodic Table'

6.4 A person holds about seven thousand trillion trillion atoms, and most of the hydrogen among them is as old as the universe

The estimate that closes the module uses everything above. Take a 70 kg adult. By mass the body is roughly 65 per cent oxygen, 18 per cent carbon, 10 per cent hydrogen and 3 per cent nitrogen, which together make up about 96 per cent, and many trace elements make up the rest. Convert each mass to moles by dividing by the atomic mass, then multiply by 6.022 x 10^23 atoms per mole.

The sum comes to about 7 x 10^27 atoms. Hydrogen is only 10 per cent by mass, but each hydrogen atom is light, so there are many of them: about 63 per cent of the atoms are hydrogen. Water and carbon compounds, which make up most of the body, are rich in hydrogen.

Now ask where they came from. The hydrogen atoms in a person are older than any star. Almost all the matter made in the first few minutes after the Big Bang, about 13.8 billion years ago by the Planck satellite's 2013 measurement, was hydrogen and helium, with helium about a quarter of the mass. So the proton at the centre of most hydrogen atoms in your body, and in the sea, is billions of years old. Carbon, oxygen and nitrogen were made later, inside stars by fusion, and spread when those stars died. The module 'The nucleus' gives fusion and 'Stars, galaxies and the universe' the story of the stars.

The module 'The nucleus' goes inside the nucleus, and 'Matter and bonding' shows how electrons join atoms into everything else.

Data Worked estimate: atoms in a 70 kg person (calculated)
ElementMass (kg)Atomic massMolesAtoms (x 10^27)Share of atoms
Oxygen45.516.02,8401.7126%
Carbon12.612.01,0500.6310%
Hydrogen7.01.0086,9404.1863%
Nitrogen2.114.01500.091.4%
Total of these four67.210,9806.6about 100%

Moles = mass in grams / atomic mass; atoms = moles x 6.022 x 10^23. The other 4 per cent of body mass, mostly calcium and phosphorus with heavier atoms, adds roughly 1 per cent to the count, so the total is about 6.7 x 10^27, which rounds to 7 x 10^27.

Source: Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Primordial nucleosynthesis, https://aether.lbl.gov/www/science/bbndetails.html (about 25 per cent by mass of the matter in the universe is helium nuclei; the rest is mostly hydrogen); NIST, Periodic Table of the Elements (2024), https://www.nist.gov/document/periodic-table-2024 (first ionization energies in eV: H 13.5984, He 24.5874, Li 5.3917, Ne 21.5645, Na 5.1391, Ar 15.7596, K 4.3407; atomic weights Cu 63.546, B 10.81); NASA JPL, Planck mission brings universe into sharp focus (21 March 2013), https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/planck-mission-brings-universe-into-sharp-focus/ (the universe is 13.8 billion years old, 100 million years older than previous estimates)

See it in the table

H₂O WaterSt SteelAu GoldCs CaesiumHe HeliumH2 HydrogenO2 Oxygen

Check your understanding

A hair is 70 micrometres wide and atoms are 0.25 nm apart. About how many atoms span a hair?

70 x 10^-6 m divided by 0.25 x 10^-9 m is 2.8 x 10^5, or 280,000.

A nucleus is about 20,000 times narrower than its atom. If the nucleus were 1 cm wide, about how wide would the atom be?

Scaling the width by 20,000 gives 1 cm x 20,000 = 200,000 cm = 200 m.

Why does a coin not sink into a table, if both are mostly empty space?

The nuclei never come near each other. The push-back comes from the electron clouds.
← Part 5: The quantum idea: why atoms have shells and the table has columnsMark read · Wrap-up →