Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Atoms, the periodic table and the quantum idea: Are there atoms? Brownian motion, the electron and the nucleus

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 8: Atoms, the periodic table and the quantum idea Part 1 of 6

Are there atoms? Brownian motion, the electron and the nucleus

Chemists had worked with atoms for a century before most physicists agreed that they were real. This part follows the three pieces of evidence that closed the case between 1897 and 1911: a dancing speck in water, a particle lighter than any atom, and thin metal foils that turned a few projectiles back.

1.1 Specks in water jitter because unseen molecules hit them, and measuring the jitter settled the argument over atoms

Put a drop of diluted milk under a microscope and the tiny fat droplets never rest. They twitch and wander for hours. The botanist Robert Brown noticed the same dance in pollen grains in 1827, and found it in powdered rock too, so it was not life. For eighty years nobody could say what pushed the grains.

In 1905 Albert Einstein gave an answer that could be tested. Heat is the random motion of molecules. A speck about a micrometre wide has water molecules striking it from every side, roughly ten billion billion times a second. On average the pushes cancel, but at any instant one side wins by a little, so the speck takes a small step in a random direction. Einstein worked out that the typical sideways drift grows with the square root of the time, not with the time itself. His formula linked the wandering to the temperature, the thickness of the liquid, the size of the speck and the number of molecules in a mole. So a measurement under a microscope would give a count of molecules.

Jean Perrin in Paris did the measuring. He made specks of resin of uniform size, tracked them at fixed intervals and plotted where they went. He also let a column of such grains settle in water and counted how they thinned out with height, like air thinning with altitude. If liquids were smooth, the grains would simply have sunk to the bottom. The settling grains gave him about 6.8 x 10^23 molecules per mole, and his other methods gave values close to it. The modern value is 6.022 x 10^23, so he was within about 13 per cent (calculated). The results answered sceptics such as Ernst Mach and Wilhelm Ostwald, and Perrin won the 1926 physics Nobel Prize.

The table redoes the estimate for a 1 micrometre grain in water at 20 C. A step of about a micrometre a second is easy to see under a microscope.

Data Worked estimate: how far does a 1 micrometre grain wander in water at 293 K (20 C)? (calculated)
StepWorkingResult
Thermal energy kT1.381 x 10^-23 J/K x 293 K4.05 x 10^-21 J
Diffusion constant D = kT / (6 x pi x viscosity x radius)4.05 x 10^-21 J / (6 x 3.142 x 1.0 x 10^-3 Pa s x 0.5 x 10^-6 m) = 4.05 x 10^-21 / 9.42 x 10^-94.3 x 10^-13 m^2/s
Typical sideways step along one axis in 1 s (square root of 2Dt)square root of (2 x 4.3 x 10^-13 m^2/s x 1 s) = square root of 8.6 x 10^-13 m^29.3 x 10^-7 m = 0.93 micrometres
Typical sideways step in 60 ssquare root of 60 = 7.75, times the 1 s value7.2 micrometres, not 60 x 0.93 = 56
Reverse use: from a measured D to a molecule countk = 6 x pi x viscosity x radius x D / T, then N_A = R / k = 8.314 J/(mol K) / 1.381 x 10^-23 J/K6.02 x 10^23 per mole

Water viscosity 1.0 x 10^-3 Pa s at 20 C. A minute gives under eight times the distance of a second: the signature of a random walk. Perrin worked the last row backwards from his measured steps.

Source: American Institute of Physics, Einstein exhibit, Brownian motion, https://history.aip.org/exhibits/einstein/essay-brownian.htm (Einstein predicted irregular motion of suspended particles that could be seen under a microscope and used it to find the size of molecules; by 1908 molecules could no longer be called hypothetical); Nobel Prize, Jean Baptiste Perrin, Facts, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1926/perrin/facts (1926 prize for work on the discontinuous structure of matter and the discovery of sedimentation equilibrium; his work substantiated Einstein's theory that Brownian motion comes from collisions with molecules of the liquid); Encyclopedia.com, Perrin, Jean Baptiste (Complete Dictionary of Scientific Biography), https://encyclopedia.com/people/science-and-technology/physics-biographies/jean-baptiste-perrin (from gamboge suspensions in equilibrium, 'The result, 6.8 x 10^23, was extremely close to Avogadro's number'; results contrary to the expectations of Ostwald and Mach)

1.2 The electron was found in 1897 to be far lighter than any atom, so atoms have parts and most of their mass lies elsewhere

The module on electricity and magnetism told how J. J. Thomson at Cambridge bent cathode rays with electric and magnetic fields in 1897 and found one charge-to-mass ratio for every metal and gas he tried. For the atom, the size of that ratio is what counts. By modern values it is about 1,836 times the ratio for a hydrogen ion in electrolysis, and the charges are equal in size, so the particle is about 1,836 times lighter than the ion.

He concluded that the beam was made of one kind of particle, carried by every atom, with a mass of the order of a thousandth of the lightest atom. He called them corpuscles. We call them electrons. Millikan's oil drops, in the same module and the node 'The electron', later fixed the charge itself.

Until then an atom was the end of the road. Now it had parts, and an atom as a whole carries no net charge. So every atom must hold positive charge to balance its electrons. The electrons are so light that the positive part must carry nearly all the mass: a gold atom has 79 electrons, which together weigh about two hundredths of one per cent of the atom. Thomson pictured the electrons as dots in a ball of positive charge, which became known as the plum pudding model.

The pudding made a clear prediction: positive charge spread over a whole atom pulls weakly, so a fast charged projectile should pass through with only small nudges.

1.3 Alpha particles fired at thin metal foils sometimes bounced back, which showed that the positive charge and the mass sit in a tiny nucleus

Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden worked in Rutherford's laboratory at Manchester. Their alpha particles came from radium C, a short-lived product of radon gas. Alpha particles are helium nuclei, with two units of positive charge and about 7,300 times the mass of an electron. Each one that struck a screen coated with zinc sulphide made a tiny flash, and the flashes were counted by eye. Through thin metal foils nearly all the particles went straight or bent slightly, as the pudding model said. Then in 1909 they found that some came back off the face of the metal: from a platinum plate, about one in 8,000. Gold foil only about a thousand atoms thick also turned some through large angles.

Rutherford later called it as unlikely as a shell bouncing off tissue paper. The pudding cannot do it: an electron is thousands of times lighter than the alpha particle and cannot turn it, and a diffuse positive charge pulls too weakly. A big deflection needs a strong push, and a strong push needs the whole positive charge packed into a very small place, so that a particle can come very close to it.

In 1911 Rutherford published the nuclear atom. His calculation for a point-like positive charge predicted how many particles should appear at each angle. In 1913 Geiger and Marsden checked the pattern at many angles and it fitted. The size follows from energy. A head-on alpha particle slows as it climbs the electrical hill of the nucleus, and stops where the whole of its energy has become electrical energy. Everything it met up to that point lay outside the charge, so the nucleus is smaller than that distance.

The table works it out. The nucleus turns out to be tens of thousands of times narrower than the atom.

Data Worked estimate: how close can an alpha particle get to a gold nucleus? (calculated)
QuantityWorkingResult
Alpha energy (fastest alphas of the radium C deposit, from polonium-214, then called radium C')Decay energy 7.833 MeV x 210 / 214, since the recoiling nucleus keeps 4/214 of it = 7.69 MeV; 7.69 MeV x 1.602 x 10^-13 J per MeV1.23 x 10^-12 J
Electrical energy at distance dk x (2e) x (79e) / d = 8.99 x 10^9 N m^2/C^2 x 158 x (1.602 x 10^-19 C)^2 / d3.65 x 10^-26 J m / d
Closest approach, head-on (all motion energy turned to electrical energy)3.65 x 10^-26 J m / 1.23 x 10^-12 J3.0 x 10^-14 m (30 femtometres)
Radius of a gold atomabout 1.4 x 10^-10 m; 1.4 x 10^-10 m / 3.0 x 10^-14 mabout 4,700 times the closest approach
Radius of gold nucleus, from 1.2 fm x A^(1/3), A = 197197^(1/3) = 5.82; 1.2 fm x 5.827.0 x 10^-15 m; 1.4 x 10^-10 m / 7.0 x 10^-15 m = 20,000

The nucleus is smaller than the closest approach, so this method gives an upper bound on its size. Rutherford's own estimate was that the nucleus is about 1/100,000 of the atom. Slower alphas from radon (5.49 MeV) or polonium-218 (6.00 MeV) stop farther out, at about 41 and 38 femtometres (calculated the same way); the answer moves by tens of per cent, not by orders of magnitude.

Source: American Physical Society, APS News, May 1911: Rutherford and the Discovery of the Atomic Nucleus (2006), https://aps.org/publications/apsnews/200605/history.cfm (hard dense core; nucleus about 1/100,000 of the atom; plum pudding could not give backward scattering); Geiger and Marsden, On a diffuse reflection of the alpha-particles, Proceedings of the Royal Society A 82 (1909) 495, text at https://www.chemteam.info/Chem-History/GM-1909.html (source: radium C on a small plate; about 1 in 8000 of the incident alpha particles reflected, measured with a platinum reflector); American Institute of Physics, Rutherford exhibit, Alpha particles and the atom, https://history.aip.org/exhibits/rutherford/sections/alpha-particles-atom.html (source a glass tube of radium emanation, radon; results submitted May 1909; Rutherford's May 1911 paper; the 15-inch shell remark from a 1938 memoir); HyperPhysics (Georgia State University), History of the Rutherford experiment, https://hyperphysics.gsu.edu/hbase/nuclear/rutsca2.html (the most energetic alpha particles available to them, 7.7 MeV); NNDC (Brookhaven National Laboratory), Discovery of nuclides: A = 214, https://www.nndc.bnl.gov/discovery/abstracts/84/214.pdf (Fajans reported the alpha activity of 214Po in the decay of radium C and named it RaC'); CERN Indico, Ra-226 decay chain (workshop slides), https://indico.cern.ch/event/835006/contributions/3548764/attachments/1924479/3184497/Ra226Decays.pdf (decay energies: Rn-222 5.590 MeV, Po-218 6.115 MeV, Po-214 7.833 MeV); Live Science, The gold foil experiment: the Geiger-Marsden experiments explained, https://www.livescience.com/gold-foil-experiment-geiger-marsden (foil extremely thin, about 1,000 atoms in the path of an alpha particle)

See it in the table

H₂O WaterZn ZincAu GoldPt PlatinumHe HeliumH2 HydrogenEl Electricity

Check your understanding

A grain of pollen in water wanders about 1 micrometre in one second. About how far does it drift sideways in 100 seconds?

Random steps partly cancel, so the typical distance grows as the square root of the time: the square root of 100 is 10.

Why did Thomson's result mean that most of an atom's mass is not electrons?

The charge-to-mass ratio showed a very light particle. Since atoms are neutral and contain many such particles, nearly all the mass lies in the positive part.

What did the rare backward bounce of alpha particles show?

Only a strong electrical push from a concentrated charge can turn back a fast, heavy alpha particle. A diffuse pudding of charge could not.
← Module contentsMark read · Part 2: Inside the atom: protons, neutrons, isotopes and atomic mass →