Ecology: populations, interactions and energy flow: Interactions and change: predators, partners, webs and succession
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 17: Ecology: populations, interactions and energy flow Part 3 of 6Interactions and change: predators, partners, webs and succession
Species affect each other in six main ways, and the effects ripple through communities. This part follows a predator and prey cycle, sorts partners from parasites, looks at food webs and diversity, and watches a community rebuild after a disturbance.
3.1 Predators and prey rise and fall together, but the hare cycle shows that causes are tangled
A predator eats another animal, its prey. Each helps shape the other. More prey feeds more predators; more predators cut the prey; fewer prey starve the predators; and the prey recover. The result can be a regular cycle with the predator peak lagging the prey peak by a year or two.
The classic case is the snowshoe hare and the Canada lynx in northern Canada. The Hudson's Bay Company bought fur for centuries and kept records of the pelts. Their numbers rise and fall with a period of about ten years, and the lynx peak follows the hare peak. Early ecologists took it for a two-species story. Charles Krebs and colleagues tested it in the Yukon with field experiments over many years. Adding food roughly tripled hare density but did not stop the decline. Fencing out mammal predators roughly doubled it. Doing both gave an eleven-fold increase. The cycle is therefore driven by food and predation together, and many predators beyond lynx take part, from coyotes to great horned owls.
Predation also shapes the plants. When a top predator is removed, the herbivores can multiply and strip vegetation. Prey evolve speed, camouflage, spines and toxins; predators evolve counters.
| Phase | What happens | Experimental evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Increase | Hares breed fast; food and cover are plentiful | Feeding hares lifts their density |
| Peak | Hares overbrowse; predators multiply, with a lag | Combined food and predator control gave an 11-fold higher density |
| Decline | Predators kill many hares; stressed hares breed less | Extra food did not stop the fall |
| Low | Predators still numerous, hares scarce, plants recover | Excluding predators doubled density |
The cycle is about ten years long, with a low phase of two to five years.
Source: Krebs and colleagues, Using experimentation to understand the 10-year snowshoe hare cycle in the boreal forest of North America (Kluane, Yukon), https://www.zoology.ubc.ca/~krebs/papers/314.pdf (ten-year cycle; extra food roughly tripled hare density but did not stop the decline; excluding mammal predators doubled it; both together gave an eleven-fold increase)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 21, 'Ecology' (species interactions: predation)
- Krebs and colleagues, Using experimentation to understand the 10-year snowshoe hare cycle in the boreal forest of North America (Kluane, Yukon) · web
- Standard histories of ecology (Encyclopaedia Britannica and the original papers named in the text) · Haeckel (1866), Tansley (1935), Liebig (1840), Shelford (1913), Connell on intermediate disturbance (Science, 1978), Carson (1962), Elton (1958), Williamson and Fitter on the tens rule (1996), the Hudson's Bay Company pelt records, Surtsey (formed 1963; UNESCO World Heritage listing https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1267, which could not be opened in this check), and Rockstrom and colleagues (Nature, 2009), Steffen and colleagues (Science, 2015), Richardson and colleagues (Science Advances, 2023): standard dates, not re-fetched in this check
3.2 Symbiosis ranges from partnership to parasitism, and the effects on each side decide which it is
Symbiosis means living together in close contact over a long time. Ecologists sort it by what each partner gains or loses. In mutualism both gain. In commensalism one gains and the other is not affected. In parasitism one gains and the host is harmed.
A banyan or peepal fig, a keystone food for birds, bats and monkeys across India, depends on a tiny wasp that enters the fig to pollinate it. The wasp lays eggs in some flowers, and its larvae eat some seeds, but the fig gets pollinated. Each Ficus species typically has its own wasp, so losing one wasp can doom one fig and the animals that feed on it. The module 'Evolution and the diversity of life' met three other mutualisms: Rhizobium in the roots of pulses, the mycorrhizal fungi of most land plants, and lichens. Their ecological weight is large, because they set how much nitrogen and phosphorus enters whole plant communities.
Cattle egrets walk beside buffalo and eat the insects the animals disturb: that is commensalism. Orchids sit on tree branches for light, without harming the tree.
Parasites live on or in a host and take its food: leeches, liver flukes, the malaria parasite and the leafless dodder vine on hedges. Parasitoids go further and kill their host in the end. Tiny Trichogramma wasps lay their eggs inside the eggs of moth pests, and Indian farmers release them on cards to protect sugarcane and rice.
| Interaction | Effect on A | Effect on B | Indian example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Competition | Harmed | Harmed | Lantana and native shrubs for light |
| Predation | Gains | Killed | Tiger and chital |
| Parasitism | Gains | Harmed | Liver fluke and cattle |
| Mutualism | Gains | Gains | Fig and fig wasp; Rhizobium and pulses |
| Commensalism | Gains | Unaffected | Cattle egret and buffalo |
| Amensalism | Unaffected | Harmed | Walnut roots releasing chemicals that slow neighbours |
Signs are the effect on population growth of each side.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 21, 'Ecology' (symbiosis)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 21, 'Ecology' (species interactions: symbiosis)
3.3 Food webs tie a community together, a few keystone species hold it up, and diversity steadies it
A food chain is a line: grass, chital, tiger. A food web is the truer picture, because most animals eat several foods and have several enemies. The tiger also eats sambar and wild pig; the wild pig eats roots, fruit, insects and carrion. Decomposers such as fungi and bacteria, and detritivores such as dung beetles and termites, feed on the dead and dung from every level.
Some species matter far more than their numbers suggest. From 1963 Robert Paine kept a stretch of shore at Mukkaw Bay, Washington, clear of one starfish, Pisaster. Without it, mussels spread across the rock, and within a year the number of species there fell from fifteen to eight (published 1966). The starfish was a keystone species.
A diverse community is steadier, for the same reason that a fund with many holdings swings less than one stock. David Tilman's team at Cedar Creek, Minnesota, had measured hundreds of grassland plots for years when the 1988 drought struck. Species-rich plots lost far less of their plant mass, and across the years their total mass was steadier, because some species thrived while others failed (Tilman and Downing, Nature, 1994). Ecologists call this the insurance effect of diversity. It also protects against disease and pests, which spread more slowly through a mix than a monoculture.
- Tiger top predator
- Chital herbivore that grazes
- Grasses and herbs
- Fallen fruits and leaves
- Sambar herbivore that browses
- Leaves of shrubs and trees
- Wild pig omnivore
- Roots, fruit and insects
- Carrion
- Chital herbivore that grazes
Dead material and dung from every level feed decomposers and detritivores, which return nutrients to the soil.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 21, 'Ecology' (food chains and food webs)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 21, 'Ecology' (food webs; Science and Society: biodiversity)
- Standard histories of ecology (Encyclopaedia Britannica and the original papers named in the text) · Haeckel (1866), Tansley (1935), Liebig (1840), Shelford (1913), Connell on intermediate disturbance (Science, 1978), Carson (1962), Elton (1958), Williamson and Fitter on the tens rule (1996), the Hudson's Bay Company pelt records, Surtsey (formed 1963; UNESCO World Heritage listing https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1267, which could not be opened in this check), and Rockstrom and colleagues (Nature, 2009), Steffen and colleagues (Science, 2015), Richardson and colleagues (Science Advances, 2023): standard dates, not re-fetched in this check
- Nature Education Knowledge Project, Keystone species (Scitable), on Paine, Food web complexity and species diversity, American Naturalist 100 (1966) · web
- Tilman, The ecological consequences of changes in biodiversity, Ecology 80 (1999), Robert H. MacArthur Award lecture, on Tilman and Downing, Biodiversity and stability in grasslands, Nature 367 (1994) · web
3.4 Communities rebuild after a disturbance through succession, and moderate disturbance keeps diversity high
After a fire, a landslide or a farm is abandoned, the ground does not stay bare. A sequence of communities replaces one another, called ecological succession. Where soil is already present and some seeds and roots remain, as after a field is left fallow, it is secondary succession and takes decades. Where the ground is bare rock, new lava or land left by a retreating glacier, it is primary succession and takes far longer, because soil must first be built.
Pioneers come first: lichens, mosses, grasses and fast-growing weeds with light seeds spread far. They hold soil and add organic matter, and their shade and litter suit the slower shrubs and trees that replace them. Surtsey, an island that rose from the sea off Iceland in 1963, has been kept almost free of visitors so that scientists can watch life arrive. Seeds came on the sea and on birds within a couple of years, and once gulls began to nest, their droppings fed a much faster spread of plants. The final, stable community is a climax, though ecologists now see it as a moving target and not a fixed end.
In north-east India, jhum farmers clear a patch of hillside, grow crops for a year or two and move on. The fallow forest recovers by succession. Disturbance is natural too: fires help maintain savanna grasses by killing tree seedlings. In 1978 Joseph Connell argued that diversity is highest at intermediate disturbance, since frequent disturbance leaves only pioneers and rare disturbance lets a few dominant species take over. A warming climate is now a slow disturbance everywhere at once, pushing species ranges uphill and poleward, which helps only those that can move.
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 21, 'Ecology' (change in an ecosystem; ecologically sustainable development)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, Ecological succession · web
- Standard histories of ecology (Encyclopaedia Britannica and the original papers named in the text) · Haeckel (1866), Tansley (1935), Liebig (1840), Shelford (1913), Connell on intermediate disturbance (Science, 1978), Carson (1962), Elton (1958), Williamson and Fitter on the tens rule (1996), the Hudson's Bay Company pelt records, Surtsey (formed 1963; UNESCO World Heritage listing https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1267, which could not be opened in this check), and Rockstrom and colleagues (Nature, 2009), Steffen and colleagues (Science, 2015), Richardson and colleagues (Science Advances, 2023): standard dates, not re-fetched in this check
See it in the table
Ri RiceEg EggsPls PulsesCheck your understanding
In the Yukon experiments, extra food for hares alone tripled their density but did not stop the cycle's decline. What does that show?
If food were the only cause, feeding would have prevented the fall. Because the decline went ahead, and fencing out predators had a separate effect, both factors act.A fig and its wasp both benefit. A cattle egret benefits from buffalo, which are unaffected. A liver fluke benefits and the cow it lives in is harmed. Which is the correct order?
Both gain: mutualism. One gains, the other is unaffected: commensalism. One gains and the host is harmed: parasitism.Why is a 'keystone species' not necessarily the most abundant?
Paine's starfish was not common, but removing it halved the number of species. Importance depends on role, not count.