Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Ecology: populations, interactions and energy flow: Energy flow: sunlight, trophic levels and the ten per cent rule

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 17: Ecology: populations, interactions and energy flow Part 4 of 6

Energy flow: sunlight, trophic levels and the ten per cent rule

Matter goes round an ecosystem, but energy goes through it once and leaves as heat. That one-way flow explains why food chains are short and tigers rare. This part follows sunlight from leaf to predator and does the sum.

4.1 Producers capture a small slice of sunlight, and every other feeding level lives on what they store

Sunlight in much of India delivers about 5 kilowatt-hours per square metre per day, or 5 x 3.6 MJ x 365 = about 6,570 megajoules per square metre a year (calculated). Green plants, algae and some bacteria are producers: by photosynthesis they turn light, water and carbon dioxide into sugar and oxygen. The node 'Photosynthesis' explains the chemistry, and the module 'The cell' shows the chloroplast.

Producers do not keep all they make. Gross primary production is the total sugar made. Plants burn part of it in their own respiration to run the cell. What remains is net primary production, the new plant tissue per year that is available to everything else. In a productive tropical stand this is about 0.5 per cent of the sunlight that falls, about 33 MJ per square metre per year, or at 17 MJ per kilogram roughly 2 kilograms of dry plant matter (calculated). Productivity differs widely: swamps, reefs and rainforests are high, deserts and tundra low. Most of the light is reflected, heats the leaves, evaporates water, or has a wavelength the leaf cannot use.

Each step along the feeding line is a trophic level. Producers are the first. Primary consumers (herbivores) eat the plants. Secondary consumers eat herbivores, and tertiary consumers eat those. Decomposers and detritivores, the fungi, bacteria, termites and dung beetles, feed on dead matter from all levels and return its minerals to the soil. In most ecosystems the bulk of plant production, such as fallen leaves and wood, passes to decomposers and not to grazers. Omnivores such as pigs and people feed at several levels.

Process flowchart From sunlight to a tiger's meal: one hectare of grassland and forest edge
Inputs Sunlight on 1 hectareabout 6.6 x 10^7 MJ a year (calculated) Process steps 1 Producers (grass, leaves)

net production about 0.5 per cent, near 330,000 MJ a year (calculated)

2 Primary consumers (chital, sambar)

about a tenth of the plant energy they eat becomes new animal tissue

3 Secondary consumer (tiger)

takes only part of the herbivore tissue; about a tenth of what it eats becomes tiger

4 Decomposers

get dead matter, dung and uneaten leaves from every level

Outputs Heat to the surroundingsabout 90 per cent or more lost at each step

Quantities are rounded estimates for a productive tropical stand.

Source: Rounded reference values used in the worked estimates, annual sunlight in much of India about 5 kWh per square metre a day; net primary production near 0.5 per cent of sunlight in a productive tropical stand; mass of the atmosphere 5.15 x 10^18 kg; molar masses 44 g/mol (CO2) and 29 g/mol (air); protein about 16 per cent nitrogen; meat about 6 MJ per kg; dry plant matter about 17 MJ per kg. Standard round figures for paper estimates
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 21, 'Ecology' (energy flow in ecosystems)
  • Rounded reference values used in the worked estimates · annual sunlight in much of India about 5 kWh per square metre a day; net primary production near 0.5 per cent of sunlight in a productive tropical stand; mass of the atmosphere 5.15 x 10^18 kg; molar masses 44 g/mol (CO2) and 29 g/mol (air); protein about 16 per cent nitrogen; meat about 6 MJ per kg; dry plant matter about 17 MJ per kg. Standard round figures for paper estimates

4.2 Only about a tenth of the energy passes up each step, because energy is always degraded as it is used

Ecologists split each step into three shares and multiply them. The first is the share of the food supply that actually gets eaten. The second is the share of the eaten food that is absorbed instead of leaving as dung. The third is the share of the absorbed energy that becomes new body, in growth and young, instead of being burned in respiration for warmth and movement. For a grasshopper on grass the three might be about a half, two-fifths and two-fifths: 0.5 x 0.4 x 0.4 = 8 per cent (calculated). The product is the transfer efficiency, and a figure near 10 per cent is a useful rule of thumb. Raymond Lindeman's 1942 study of Cedar Bog Lake in Minnesota was the first to measure such transfers through a whole ecosystem. Real values run from a few per cent to about 20 per cent: cold-blooded animals do better than warm-blooded ones, which spend most of their food energy staying warm.

This is the second law of thermodynamics at work. Energy is conserved, so none vanishes, but each time it is used it spreads out as low-grade heat that no animal can use again. The module 'Heat, temperature and the laws of thermodynamics' gives the principle, and the 'Understanding Energy' module 'The laws of energy: conservation, entropy and efficiency' applies it to engines and power plants.

The arithmetic of the rule explains the shape of ecosystems. After four transfers at 10 per cent, 0.1^4 = 0.0001 of the plant energy, or 0.01 per cent, remains (calculated). Food chains are therefore short, usually three to five links, and top predators such as tigers are always few.

Data Worked estimate: how much grass and land does one tiger need, at the very least?
StepWorkingResult
Sunlight per hectare5 kWh per m2 a day x 3.6 MJ per kWh x 365 days = 6,570 MJ per m2; x 10,000 m2 per hectareabout 6.6 x 10^7 MJ a year (calculated)
Plant production0.5 per cent of 6.6 x 10^7 MJabout 330,000 MJ a year per hectare (calculated)
Tiger's food5 kg of meat a day x 6 MJ per kg x 365 daysabout 11,000 MJ a year (calculated)
Plants the prey must eat to make that meatOne step at 10 per cent: 11,000 MJ x 10about 110,000 MJ a year (calculated)
If tigers take one quarter of all prey productionPrey must make 4 x 11,000 = 44,000 MJ of tissue, from 44,000 x 10 MJ of plantsabout 440,000 MJ a year of plants eaten by prey (calculated)
If prey eat one tenth of plant production330,000 MJ per hectare x 0.1 = 33,000 MJ per hectare; 440,000 MJ / 33,000 MJ per hectareabout 13 hectares (calculated)
Check against realityFemale tigers in prey-rich Indian reserves range over roughly 10 to 30 square km1,000 to 3,000 hectares

The energy sum gives a floor of about 13 hectares. Real ranges are about a hundred times bigger, because much plant growth is wood that herbivores cannot eat, prey is patchy, and a tiger succeeds in only a small share of its hunts. Energy sets the minimum; behaviour and habitat set the rest.

Source: Rounded reference values used in the worked estimates, annual sunlight in much of India about 5 kWh per square metre a day; net primary production near 0.5 per cent of sunlight in a productive tropical stand; mass of the atmosphere 5.15 x 10^18 kg; molar masses 44 g/mol (CO2) and 29 g/mol (air); protein about 16 per cent nitrogen; meat about 6 MJ per kg; dry plant matter about 17 MJ per kg. Standard round figures for paper estimates

4.3 Persistent poisons climb the food chain while energy drains away, so top predators carry the largest dose

Energy is used up as it moves along the chain, but some substances are not. A fat-soluble pollutant that is not broken down by the body stays in the animal's tissue. Each predator eats many prey over its life. If a predator eats 10 kilograms of prey to gain one kilogram, then it takes in the poison from 10 kilograms but keeps most of it in 1 kilogram. The concentration thus rises at each level, a process called biomagnification.

The insecticide DDT showed it. Rachel Carson's Silent Spring in 1962 collected evidence that DDT sprayed on land and water reached very high levels in fish-eating birds such as ospreys, eagles and pelicans, where it thinned eggshells so the eggs broke. Populations fell sharply and recovered after DDT was restricted in many countries. Mercury behaves the same way: it builds up in large predatory fish such as tuna and swordfish.

The lesson applies to any persistent chemical, from old pesticides to microplastics and their additives. Energy dilutes upward and persistent chemicals concentrate upward. So top predators give the earliest warning. The module 'The cell' explains why fat-soluble molecules lodge in membranes and stored fat, and the Understanding Chemicals module 'Soaps, detergents and agrochemicals' covers the pesticides themselves.

  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 21, 'Ecology' (energy flow in ecosystems)
  • Standard histories of ecology (Encyclopaedia Britannica and the original papers named in the text) · Haeckel (1866), Tansley (1935), Liebig (1840), Shelford (1913), Connell on intermediate disturbance (Science, 1978), Carson (1962), Elton (1958), Williamson and Fitter on the tens rule (1996), the Hudson's Bay Company pelt records, Surtsey (formed 1963; UNESCO World Heritage listing https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1267, which could not be opened in this check), and Rockstrom and colleagues (Nature, 2009), Steffen and colleagues (Science, 2015), Richardson and colleagues (Science Advances, 2023): standard dates, not re-fetched in this check

See it in the table

H₂O WaterHg MercurySu SugarEg EggsO2 OxygenCO2 Carbon dioxide

Check your understanding

A lake's algae make 50,000 MJ of new tissue per hectare a year. Cold-blooded grazers and fish pass on about 15 per cent at each step. How much energy reaches small fish that eat the grazers?

Two steps at 15 per cent: 50,000 x 0.15 = 7,500 MJ in the grazers, and 7,500 x 0.15 = about 1,100 MJ in the small fish. Cold-blooded animals waste less on warmth, so their efficiency can exceed 10 per cent.

Why are food chains rarely longer than five links?

After four transfers of about 10 per cent, 0.1^4 = 0.0001 of the plant energy, 0.01 per cent, is left, too little to feed a viable population.

The second law of thermodynamics is relevant to ecosystems because

Respiration and every other use turn useful chemical energy into heat that radiates away. Ecosystems need a constant supply of new energy from the Sun.
← Part 3: Interactions and change: predators, partners, webs and successionMark read · Part 5: Matter cycles: carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus and water →