Evolution and the diversity of life: The evidence: change we can watch and change the rocks record
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 15: Evolution and the diversity of life Part 3 of 6The evidence: change we can watch and change the rocks record
A theory earns trust by predictions that could fail. Evolution has been tested for more than 160 years by moths, birds, bacteria, fossils, anatomy, maps and DNA, which approach the question from different sides and agree. This part covers the evidence that can be watched in a lifetime and the evidence that was left behind.
3.1 Selection can be watched within a lifetime in moths, finches, bacteria and crops
In 1848 a black form of the peppered moth was recorded near Manchester, where the speckled pale form had been the norm. As coal smoke killed pale lichens and blackened bark, the black form became the usual one in industrial districts by the end of the century. After the Clean Air Act of 1956 and later laws, it fell fast, especially since about 1970. Between 2001 and 2007 Michael Majerus released 4,864 moths in a Cambridgeshire garden: birds took black moths more often on the cleaner trees, and the black share nearby fell from 12 per cent in 2001 to 1 per cent in 2007. The black form was later traced to a stretch of mobile DNA inserted in a gene called cortex. In the simple model of Part 2, a rise from rare to common in about 50 generations needs an edge of roughly 20 per cent (calculated).
Peter and Rosemary Grant studied the medium ground finch on the small Galapagos island of Daphne Major from 1973. The 1977 drought left mostly large, hard seeds, and the population fell from about 1,400 birds to a few hundred, with small-beaked birds dying most. Before the drought the average adult beak was 9.2 mm deep. The chicks raised afterwards averaged 9.7 mm, about 5 per cent deeper (calculated), because beak depth is inherited. After the rains of 1982 to 1983 brought back small soft seeds, selection ran the other way.
Bacteria are fastest. A dense culture holds about a billion cells per millilitre. If a given resistance mutation arises in about one cell in a billion, each millilitre typically holds one resistant cell before any drug is added. The drug removes the rest, and the survivor's line, doubling every half hour, grows about a millionfold in ten hours (calculated, table). In 2019 resistant bacterial infections directly caused about 1.27 million deaths worldwide and were associated with about 4.95 million, according to a Lancet study; South Asia's direct rate, 22 per 100,000 people, was among the highest. Penicillin is a case of 'Antibiosis', one microbe's chemicals turned against others.
Selection by people works the same way, and Darwin used it as his model. From one coastal plant of the mustard family, wild cabbage, farmers choosing for leaves, buds, stems or flower heads produced cabbage, kale, Brussels sprouts, kohlrabi, cauliflower and broccoli.
| Step | Number | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Cells in 1 mL of culture | 1,000,000,000 (10^9) | a dense culture |
| Chance that one cell carries a given resistance mutation | 1 in 10^9 | a typical rate for one particular change |
| Resistant cells in 1 mL before the drug | about 1 (calculated) | 10^9 x 10^-9 |
| Doublings in 10 hours at 30 minutes each | 20 (calculated) | 10 hours x 2 per hour |
| Descendants of one survivor | 2^20 = 1,048,576, about a million (calculated) | one cell grows to a million |
Real resistance has many causes, and fitness costs slow some resistant strains. The estimate shows only why a rare cell can matter.
Source: Rounded reference values used for estimates, uranium-238 half-life 4.47 billion years; mutation rate 1.2 x 10^-8 per base per generation and about 1.2 per cent difference between human and chimpanzee genomes; generation time 25 years; bacterial doubling 20 to 30 minutes; hydrostatic pressure 9.8 kPa per metre of water; atmospheric pressure 101 kPa; standard values quoted as round numbers for paper estimates, not re-fetched- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 17, 'The Evolution of Life'
- Cook, Grant, Saccheri and Mallet, Selective bird predation on the peppered moth: the last experiment of Michael Majerus, Biology Letters (2012) · web
- Grant and Grant, Science 313 (2006) 224, and The Open University, OpenLearn, Migration, section 3.4 · web
- University of Oxford, An estimated 1.2 million people died in 2019 from antibiotic-resistant bacterial infections (20 January 2022), reporting Murray and colleagues, Lancet (2022) · web
- Rounded reference values used for estimates · mutation rate 1.2 x 10^-8 per base per generation and about 1.2 per cent difference between human and chimpanzee genomes; generation time 25 years; bacterial doubling 20 to 30 minutes; hydrostatic pressure 9.8 kPa per metre of water; atmospheric pressure 101 kPa; water density 1,000 kg per cubic metre; standard round numbers for paper estimates. Values marked (calculated) were worked from these and checked by the reviewer
3.2 Fossils and body plans record descent with modification
If species descend from earlier ones, rocks of the right age should hold forms in between, and bodies should carry marks of shared ancestry. Both tests have been passed.
Fossils first. A team seeking the step from fish to four-legged animals chose to search rocks about 375 million years old, the age the record pointed to, in Arctic Canada. In 2004 they found Tiktaalik, a fish with a flat head, a neck and fins holding wrist-like bones. Whales are partly an Indian story. Indohyus, a fox-sized hoofed mammal about 48 million years old from Kashmir, shares ear and skull features otherwise found only in whales, and has heavy bones like those of wading animals. From the Harudi rocks of Kutch in Gujarat, Sunil Bajpai and Hans Thewissen in 2000 described Kutchicetus minimus, the smallest Eocene whale known, with a back about as flexible as an otter's. With finds from Pakistan, these trace the move from land to sea in rocks of the right order.
Then anatomy. Almost every mammal, from a mouse to a giraffe, has seven bones in its neck; the giraffe's are just very long. That fits inheritance of the count from one ancestor, and makes little sense if each neck were designed afresh. Such inherited matches are homologies. Look-alikes with separate origins, such as the wings of birds and insects, are analogies, produced by convergent evolution. Bodies also keep leftovers: goose bumps are the muscles that once raised a coat of fur, still working in an animal that has almost none.
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 17, 'The Evolution of Life'
- ScienceDaily, Research suggests whales had small deer-like ancestor (20 December 2007), reporting Thewissen and colleagues, Nature (2007) · web
- Bajpai and Thewissen, A new, diminutive Eocene whale from Kachchh (Gujarat, India), Current Science 79 (2000) 1478 · web
3.3 Maps and molecules agree with the fossils, and a molecular clock needs calibrating
Biogeography, the study of where species live, gives the third line of evidence. Narcondam Island in the Andaman Sea has a hornbill found nowhere else, and its relatives live on the nearby South-East Asian mainland, not on distant islands with a similar climate, as descent from colonists predicts. Drifting continents leave marks too. The purple frog of the Western Ghats, which spends most of the year underground, was described only in 2003. Its nearest living relatives are frogs of the Seychelles, and the two lines split about 130 million years ago, when India, the Seychelles and Madagascar were parts of one southern landmass. Wallace drew a line across the Malay Archipelago where animals change abruptly from Asian to Australian types, along a deep strait that few could cross.
DNA gives the fourth line. All known life uses the same genetic code, and the more closely two species are related by fossils and anatomy, the more similar their DNA. Mutations build up slowly and, over long spans, at roughly constant rates, so the number of differences works as a molecular clock. Even errors are shared. Humans, apes and monkeys cannot make their own vitamin C, because they carry the same broken copy of the gene for the last enzyme, with the same fault in the same place. Such a shared error is most simply explained by inheritance from one ancestor in which it first happened. Humans and chimpanzees differ at about 1.2 per cent of positions in their genomes.
| Step | Value | Working |
|---|---|---|
| Mutation rate per base per generation | 1.2 x 10^-8 | measured by sequencing parents and children |
| Generation time | 25 years | assumed |
| Rate per base per year | 4.8 x 10^-10 (calculated) | 1.2 x 10^-8 / 25 |
| Difference between the two genomes | 1.2 per cent = 0.012 | observed |
| Both lineages gain changes, so time = difference / (2 x rate) | 0.012 / (2 x 4.8 x 10^-10) | about 12.5 million years (calculated) |
| Date from fossils and calibrated analyses | about 6 to 8 million years | for comparison |
The paper estimate is roughly double the usual date. Part of the gap is that the two lineages' gene copies already differed before the species split, and mutation rates probably fell in apes over time. This is why molecular clocks are calibrated with dated fossils.
Source: Rounded reference values used for estimates, uranium-238 half-life 4.47 billion years; mutation rate 1.2 x 10^-8 per base per generation and about 1.2 per cent difference between human and chimpanzee genomes; generation time 25 years; bacterial doubling 20 to 30 minutes; hydrostatic pressure 9.8 kPa per metre of water; atmospheric pressure 101 kPa; standard values quoted as round numbers for paper estimates, not re-fetched- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 17, 'The Evolution of Life'
- Scientific American, Scientists discover new frog family, reporting Biju and Bossuyt, Nature (2003) · web
- Rounded reference values used for estimates · mutation rate 1.2 x 10^-8 per base per generation and about 1.2 per cent difference between human and chimpanzee genomes; generation time 25 years; bacterial doubling 20 to 30 minutes; hydrostatic pressure 9.8 kPa per metre of water; atmospheric pressure 101 kPa; water density 1,000 kg per cubic metre; standard round numbers for paper estimates. Values marked (calculated) were worked from these and checked by the reviewer
See it in the table
Gly HerbicidesCheck your understanding
Why did dark peppered moths rise in industrial Britain and then fall after clean air laws?
Dark forms were hidden on sooty bark and pale forms on clean bark, so differential predation changed the frequencies both ways.A drug is applied to a culture that already holds one resistant cell in every millilitre. What happens?
Resistance existed by chance before the drug. The drug removes competitors, so the survivor's descendants fill the space.The paper molecular clock gave about 12 million years for the human and chimpanzee split, against 6 to 8 million years from fossils. What is the lesson?
The clock depends on assumed rates and ignores earlier divergence of gene copies, so it must be calibrated against independently dated evidence.