Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Evolution and the diversity of life: Chance, migration and the splitting of species

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 15: Evolution and the diversity of life Part 4 of 6

Chance, migration and the splitting of species

Selection is not the only thing that changes a population, and it does not make new species by itself. Chance acts strongly in small groups, migrants carry alleles between populations, and separation lets populations drift apart until they can no longer interbreed. This part follows that road from one gene pool to many species, and ends in India's richest regions.

4.1 Genetic drift is chance acting on small populations, and gene flow moves alleles between them

Imagine a pot holding 10 red and 10 blue marbles. Draw 20 marbles with replacement, as a population does when parents leave offspring, and you will not get exactly 10 of each. By chance one colour may now be 13. Repeat from that new mix, and the share wanders. Eventually one colour may be all that is left. This wander is genetic drift. It has no direction and does not favour the better suited. It matters when the group is small, because the size of the random swing in an allele's share shrinks as the population grows.

The table gives the size of the typical swing per generation, using the standard rule that its spread is the square root of p x (1 - p) divided by twice the number of individuals. Two cases show drift at work. In a bottleneck, a population is cut to a few survivors, and the survivors' alleles are a random sample of the original. In a founder effect, a few individuals start a new colony and carry only some of the alleles. The Asiatic lion lives wild only in Gujarat, in and around Gir. It fell to a very small number early in the 1900s, was protected, and numbered 891 in the census of May 2025, with 507 of them outside Gir's boundaries. Studies have found low genetic variation in these lions, the mark of a bottleneck and one reason conservationists argue for a second population elsewhere.

Gene flow is the movement of alleles between populations by migrants, pollen or seeds. It works against divergence. Populations that exchange even one breeding migrant per generation, on average, stay genetically similar, however small they are, because the migrant resets the random drift. Gene flow can also bring a new allele into a population, and so it too causes evolution.

Data Worked estimate: the size of drift at an allele frequency of one half
Population size (breeding individuals)Copies of the gene (2 x N)Typical swing in one generation (calculated)Share of variation lost per generation, 1 / 2N (calculated)
1020about 0.11, or 11 points5 per cent
100200about 0.035, or 3.5 points0.5 per cent
1,0002,000about 0.011, or 1 point0.05 per cent

Swing = square root of (0.5 x 0.5 / 2N). A swing of 11 points per generation means an allele at 50 per cent can reach 0 or 100 per cent within a few dozen generations, with no selection at all.

Source: Rounded reference values used for estimates, uranium-238 half-life 4.47 billion years; mutation rate 1.2 x 10^-8 per base per generation and about 1.2 per cent difference between human and chimpanzee genomes; generation time 25 years; bacterial doubling 20 to 30 minutes; hydrostatic pressure 9.8 kPa per metre of water; atmospheric pressure 101 kPa; standard values quoted as round numbers for paper estimates, not re-fetched
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 17, 'The Evolution of Life'
  • Down To Earth, Asiatic lion population in Gujarat rises from 674 to 891 in 5 years (May 2025) · web
  • Rounded reference values used for estimates · mutation rate 1.2 x 10^-8 per base per generation and about 1.2 per cent difference between human and chimpanzee genomes; generation time 25 years; bacterial doubling 20 to 30 minutes; hydrostatic pressure 9.8 kPa per metre of water; atmospheric pressure 101 kPa; water density 1,000 kg per cubic metre; standard round numbers for paper estimates. Values marked (calculated) were worked from these and checked by the reviewer

4.2 A species is a group that interbreeds, and barriers keep species apart

A species, in the most widely used definition from Ernst Mayr in the 1940s, is a group of natural populations that breed with each other and produce fertile offspring, and are reproductively isolated from other such groups. The definition works well for animals, and less well for bacteria, which reproduce without sex, and for fossils, whose breeding we cannot test. Nature has fuzzy edges: wolves, coyotes and dogs hybridise, and many plants cross freely.

Barriers are grouped by when they act. Prezygotic barriers stop a fertilised egg forming at all. Female fireflies answer only the flash code of their own species; two frogs in one Western Ghats stream may call at different pitches; two plants may flower in different months; a flower's shape may admit only one kind of bee; or sperm may fail to fuse with a foreign egg. Postzygotic barriers act afterwards: the hybrid dies young, or lives but is sterile. A mule, from a horse with 64 chromosomes and a donkey with 62, has 63. Its unmatched chromosomes cannot pair properly in meiosis (see the module on the cell), so a mule is healthy but almost always sterile.

Each barrier is a kind of divergence that has gone far enough to matter. Barriers can be tested. Two populations that look alike but never mate in the wild count as separate species, and populations that mate freely do not, whatever their shapes. Over time, populations that do not exchange genes collect different mutations and different adaptations, and the barriers are a side effect. That is how one species becomes two.

  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 17, 'The Evolution of Life'
  • Standard histories of evolutionary biology, as summarised by Encyclopaedia Britannica and the Natural History Museum · Lamarck (1809), Lyell (1830 to 1833), Malthus (1798), the Beagle voyage (1831 to 1836), Wallace's Ternate essay (February 1858), Fisher, Haldane and Wright (1920s to 1930s), Pasteur's flask experiments (1860s), Miller (1953), Steno (1669), William Smith (about 1800 to 1815), ALH84001 (collected 1984, claim 1996); standard dates recalled, not re-fetched

4.3 Isolation splits species, adaptive radiation fills empty niches, and India's hotspots show the result

Speciation needs two things: populations that stop exchanging genes, and time to diverge. The commonest route is allopatric speciation, meaning in different places. In the Western Ghats the Palghat Gap, a low break in the hills, splits the cool hilltop forests in two. Songbirds called shortwings live on both sides, and their DNA shows that the northern and southern birds split about 4.3 million years ago. They are now separate species of the genus Sholicola, named in 2017. The gap kept them apart while each side changed.

Sympatric speciation occurs in the same place and is rarer in animals. In plants it can be sudden, when a cell division goes wrong and the chromosome number is doubled in a hybrid. Bread wheat has 42 chromosomes, six sets of seven, from three wild grasses with two sets each. Two of them crossed less than a million years ago to give wild emmer, with four sets, and emmer crossed with a goat grass only 8,000 to 10,000 years ago, in early farmers' fields. Such a plant is at once reproductively isolated from its parents.

When a group meets a wide range of unoccupied ways of life, as on a new island or after a mass extinction, it may split into many species in a short time. This is adaptive radiation, and it explains how a single early mammal group produced bats, whales, monkeys and horses after the dinosaurs. A new feature can set off a radiation as well, as flight did for insects and flowers did for bees, because it opens ways of life that nothing else was using. The cost is that a lineage that specialises very narrowly may be lost if its habitat changes.

See it in the table

Wh Wheat

Check your understanding

Which population shows the strongest random swings in allele frequency?

The random swing is proportional to one over the square root of twice the population size, so it is greatest in the smallest group.

A mule has 63 chromosomes. Why is it usually sterile?

Horse and donkey chromosomes do not form pairs in the hybrid, so eggs and sperm cannot be made with a balanced set.

Shortwings north and south of the Palghat Gap stopped exchanging genes and are now separate species. This is

A geographic gap broke gene flow, and the two populations diverged for about 4 million years until they became distinct species.
← Part 3: The evidence: change we can watch and change the rocks recordMark read · Part 5: Humans, the tree of life and the edge of life →