Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

How science knows: observation, models, measurement and testing: Limits of science, and science with technology and society

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 1: How science knows: observation, models, measurement and testing Part 6 of 6

Limits of science, and science with technology and society

Science is powerful because it is narrow: it answers questions that nature can answer by test. This part marks where its reach stops, how it relates to art and religion, how it feeds technology and is fed by it, and how a reader can weigh a scientific claim when making a decision.

6.1 Science answers testable questions about nature and is silent on the rest

Ask whether a bridge of a given design will carry a 40-tonne truck, and science and engineering can answer. Ask whether the bridge is beautiful, or whether the truck owner ought to be allowed to use it at night, and a different kind of answer is needed. Science has limits, and knowing them is part of understanding it.

The first limit is about testability. Science deals with claims that observation could in principle support or contradict. Questions about purpose, meaning, morals or whether something outside nature exists lie beyond its method, because no measurement could settle them. A scientist may have strong views on such matters, but those views are not scientific results. Likewise science can tell you the effect of a policy, such as how many tonnes of carbon dioxide a coal plant emits, and cannot say how much a society should value its future. That depends on values.

The second limit is that scientific answers are provisional. They rest on current instruments and ideas, and may be refined. This is the strength of the method, not a weakness. It also means that science seldom delivers certainty on complex systems such as the climate or a human body. It delivers best estimates with stated ranges, and a decision-maker must act on those.

The third limit is practical. Some things cannot be observed directly or repeated: the early Earth, extinct species, events in the first seconds of the universe. Here science reasons from present traces, such as rocks, fossils and the cosmic microwave background, and tests its ideas on what those traces should look like. This is weaker than a controlled experiment but still stronger than a story.

6.2 Science, art and religion ask different questions and share some habits

Watch the sky over the Arabian Sea at dusk. A physicist asks why it turns orange and red. A painter asks how to put that glow on canvas. A worshipper on the shore may ask what the daily return of light means. Each question is real, and an answer to one does not settle the others.

Science and art share more than is usually admitted. Both depend on imagination, on noticing patterns and on a sense of what is elegant. A good equation and a good raga can each reward the person who understands its structure. Both are also cumulative: each generation works with what earlier ones made. The difference is in what counts as success. A scientific idea must in the end match nature, whoever finds it beautiful. A work of art succeeds if it moves, enlightens or delights people, and nature does not grade it.

Religion deals with questions of ultimate meaning, purpose, conduct and the sacred, which lie outside the testing that science does. Many scientists, in India and elsewhere, are people of faith, and many are not. Conflict has arisen where a religious tradition has made claims about the physical world that evidence contradicts. The trial of Galileo in 1633 over the Sun-centred system, and the long arguments over the age of the Earth and evolution, are known examples. The conflicts were fought between particular institutions and particular findings. They were not conflicts between science and every form of belief, and in 1992 Pope John Paul II accepted that Galileo's judges had been wrong.

The workable position is mutual respect for each domain. Science should not claim to settle questions of meaning, and no tradition can overrule a well-tested finding about the physical world. Each has the right to be heard on matters inside its own domain.

6.3 Technology applies science, feeds science, and leaves choices to society

The phone in your pocket is a stack of science: quantum physics in its chips, electromagnetic waves in its radio, chemistry in its battery, and mathematics in its software. Technology is the practical use of knowledge to make tools and systems. It differs from science in aim. Science seeks understanding, technology seeks a working solution. The engineering module What engineers do explains why engineering is not simply applied science, and why many devices worked long before anyone could explain them.

The traffic runs both ways. Steam engines were working in mines decades before the laws of thermodynamics were written, and the study of why engines have limited efficiency produced a whole science. The telescope and the microscope were invented by lens-makers, and then opened new worlds. On 23 August 2023 India's Chandrayaan-3 lander touched down in the Moon's south polar region, about 600 km from the pole. That success came from engineering built on centuries of mechanics, and its rover sent back measurements of sulphur in the lunar soil that feed science in turn. In general, new tools produce new questions, and new questions demand new tools.

Technology also raises choices that science cannot make. Burning coal and oil powered the growth of modern economies and lifted carbon dioxide in the air from about 280 parts per million before industry to a record 422.8 in 2024. Antibiotics saved millions of lives and, as they are overused, breed resistant bacteria. Science can measure these effects and say what follows from each choice. Deciding what to do needs ethics, economics and politics, and the voters and investors who bear the consequences.

Data Science, technology and society: who asks what
RoleMain questionTypical outputExample
ScienceWhy does this happen?Explanations and lawsHow a lithium-ion cell stores charge
TechnologyWhat will work?Devices and systemsA battery pack for an electric bus
SocietyWhat should we do, and who decides?Rules, prices, prioritiesSubsidy and standards for batteries

Each feeds the other two. Weak links in any one slow the whole.

Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 1, 'About Science'

See it in the table

CO2 Carbon dioxide

Check your understanding

Which question is within the reach of science?

Only the oxygen question can be settled by measurement. The others turn on faith, values or taste.

Which is the best description of the relation between science and technology?

Steam engines preceded thermodynamics, and then thermodynamics improved engines. Lenses led to astronomy and biology. The links run both ways.

A report says a supplement 'boosts memory', based on a company survey of 20 happy customers. What is the main weakness?

Without a comparison group, and with customers who chose to reply, any benefit cannot be separated from expectation or chance. Supplements can be tested by a blinded trial.
← Part 5: Uncertainty: how sure can a measurement beMark read · Wrap-up →