How science knows: observation, models, measurement and testing: What science is and where it came from
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 1: How science knows: observation, models, measurement and testing Part 1 of 6What science is and where it came from
Science is a way of finding out how the natural world works by testing ideas against it. It grew in many places over thousands of years, it is split into fields for convenience only, and it leans on mathematics to turn patterns into predictions. This part sets out the shape of the whole course.
1.1 Science is a habit of testing ideas, and many cultures built it
Every farmer who has watched the first monsoon clouds and decided when to sow is already doing a small piece of science. She notices a pattern, makes a guess about what comes next, and finds out whether the guess was right. What changed over the centuries is how carefully and how publicly this is done.
Early astronomers in Babylon, Egypt, China and India kept long records of the Moon, planets and eclipses. Indian mathematicians developed place-value numerals with a zero, which made large calculations possible. Aryabhata, writing around 499 CE, explained eclipses as shadows and argued that the Earth turns on its axis. Greek thinkers added the habit of argument from first principles. About 240 BCE Eratosthenes compared the noon shadow at two Egyptian towns and worked out the size of the Earth. Ibn al-Haytham, around 1020, ran controlled experiments on light in a darkened room and insisted that a claim about vision be settled by trial, not by authority.
The big shift in Europe came between 1543 and 1687. Copernicus placed the Sun at the centre, Galileo used a telescope and rolling balls to test ideas, and Newton joined motion on Earth and in the sky into one set of laws. The printing press had already let a result in one city be checked in another. The underlying change was from asking who said it to asking what happens when we look.
Why must it work this way? Because nature does not care who is speaking. A claim about falling stones, disease or monsoons is either borne out by the world or it is not. Any method that lets the world answer, and lets others repeat the question, will slowly climb towards better answers.
A number shows how far a clever observation can reach. At noon on the longest day, the Sun was overhead in Syene but cast a shadow of 7.2 degrees in Alexandria. That angle is one fiftieth of a full circle. The towns were about 800 km apart, so the Earth's circumference is about 50 times 800 km, or 40,000 km (calculated). The modern value round the equator is 40,075 km.
| Date | Who | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| About 240 BCE | Eratosthenes | Earth's size from two shadows and a distance |
| About 499 CE | Aryabhata | Eclipses explained by shadows; a spinning Earth proposed |
| About 1020 | Ibn al-Haytham | Experiments on light used to settle questions about sight |
| 1543 | Copernicus | A Sun-centred system argued in print |
| 1600s | Galileo, Newton | Measured experiments plus mathematics; one law for Earth and sky |
| 2015 | LIGO teams | Gravitational waves detected, a century after being predicted |
Dates are approximate for the early entries.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 1, 'About Science'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 1, 'About Science'
1.2 Five natural sciences describe one world at different scales
Think of an April heatwave over the plains of north India. The Sun stands high, so each square metre of ground takes in more energy. Dry air sinks and sits over the plains for days. Ozone forms faster in hot sunlight and fouls the air. Wheat grains shrivel if the heat arrives before harvest, and people working outdoors struggle to shed body heat. Astronomy, Earth science, chemistry and biology each own a piece of that one event.
The usual split is into five natural sciences. Physics studies matter, energy, motion and forces, and the basic rules that other fields rest on. Chemistry studies which substances exist, how atoms join, and how one substance turns into another. Biology studies living things, from a single cell to a forest. Earth science studies the planet: its rocks, oceans, air and ice. Astronomy studies everything beyond: the Moon, planets, stars and galaxies.
These boundaries are conveniences for teaching and for organising careers. Biochemistry, geophysics and astrophysics exist because real questions ignore them. The same atoms are in a crystal, a cell and a star. The same energy rules govern a car engine, a muscle and a volcano. The scale ranges from a nucleus, about 10^-15 m across, to the visible universe, about 10^26 m, a spread of forty-one powers of ten.
Beneath the many fields sits a short list of big ideas: energy is conserved, matter is made of atoms, forces act through fields, and living things evolve by natural selection. They return in module after module, so a new topic is usually a fresh use of something already met. The 131 ideas in the site's Science table can be read the same way, as branches growing from a few trunks.
- Natural science testing ideas about the physical and living world
- Physics motion, energy, waves, electricity, atoms and nuclei: modules 2 to 9
- Chemistry matter, bonding, reactions, carbon compounds: modules 8 to 12
- Biology cells, genes, evolution, the body, ecology: modules 13 to 17
- Earth science plate tectonics, surface, weather and climate: modules 18 to 20
- Astronomy the solar system, stars, galaxies: modules 21 and 22
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 1, 'About Science'
1.3 Mathematics turns a pattern into a prediction
A shared auto-rickshaw fare in a city rises with distance. If 2 km costs Rs 40, a hail-and-ride of 6 km costs about Rs 120. Double the distance, double the fare. That is a direct proportion, and it is the simplest kind of equation: fare = rate x distance. Once you have written it, you can answer questions you have never tried.
That is the real job of mathematics in science. It does not prove that nature behaves a certain way. It records a pattern exactly enough to be tested, and it lets you carry a result to new cases. Pure mathematics is about what follows from definitions. Science asks whether nature obeys the rule. When the two agree to many decimal places, as with the orbits of planets, the agreement is a strong sign that the rule is right.
Three shapes of relationship appear in nearly every module. In a direct proportion one quantity grows in step with another, as the stretch of a spring grows with the load hung on it, until the spring is overloaded. In an inverse proportion one falls as the other rises, as the time for a 120 km trip falls as the speed rises. In an inverse square law a quantity drops with the square of the distance. The third is not arbitrary. Light from a lamp spreads over the surface of a sphere, whose area is 4 times pi times the radius squared. Triple the distance and the same light covers nine times the area, so each square centimetre gets a ninth as much.
A formula can also be read like a sentence. Take fare = rate x distance. If fuel prices push the rate up by a tenth, every trip costs a tenth more, whatever its length. Halve the distance as well and the fare falls to 1.1 x 0.5 = 55% of the old one (calculated). No algebra is needed once you see what each symbol stands for.
The table below works all three on paper, with a check for each. The module on estimation in the engineering course, Thinking in estimates, shows the same habits applied to design.
| Case | Relationship | Working | Check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spring balance, 2 kg gives 1 cm | Direct proportion | 5 kg / 2 kg x 1 cm = 2.5 cm | Within the spring's elastic range |
| 120 km trip, 60 then 80 km/h | Inverse proportion | 120 / 60 = 2 h; 120 / 80 = 1.5 h | Faster by one third, 25% less time |
| Lamp gives 100 lux at 1 m; at 3 m? | Inverse square | 100 / 3^2 = 100 / 9 = about 11 lux | Three times as far, nine times as dim |
Lux measures how brightly a surface is lit.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 1, 'About Science'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 1, 'About Science'
See it in the table
Wh WheatRi RiceCheck your understanding
Eratosthenes found the size of the Earth from two shadows and a distance. What made the result testable by others?
A claim built on repeatable measurements and open reasoning can be checked by anyone. Authority and tradition cannot be checked in the same way, and telescopes were not yet invented.A lamp lights a page at 50 lux from 1 m. About how bright is it at 2 m?
Light follows an inverse square law. Doubling the distance spreads the light over four times the area, so the brightness is a quarter: 50 / 4 = 12.5 lux.Which statement best describes how mathematics is used in science?
Mathematics states a pattern precisely. Only comparison with nature can show whether the pattern holds, and every field of science uses it.