Stars, galaxies and the universe: The Sun, and what starlight tells us about stars
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 22: Stars, galaxies and the universe Part 2 of 6The Sun, and what starlight tells us about stars
The Sun is the one star we can study in detail, and it is the key to all the others. This part starts there, then reads the colour and spectrum of starlight for a star's temperature and chemistry, and ends with the chart that sorted the stars into families and showed that they have life histories.
2.1 The Sun shows how long a star can shine, and neutrinos from its core show that fusion is real
Module 9 showed why the Sun is steady: gravity and gas pressure balance at every depth, and a core that ran too hot would swell, cool and slow down. Here the questions are how long that can last, and how we know what happens in a core that no one can see.
The fuel is hydrogen, fused to helium at about 15 million K. Each kilogram fused turns 0.7 per cent of its mass into energy by E = mc squared (node 'Mass-energy equivalence'). Only the core, roughly a tenth of the Sun's mass, is hot enough to fuse. That sets the lifetime, as the table shows: about ten billion years on the main sequence, and at 4.6 billion years old the Sun is near the middle.
The light we see left the core long ago: its energy takes tens of thousands of years or more to work outwards (module 21), so it carries no recent news. Neutrinos do. They are made in the fusion reactions, hardly interact with matter, and cross the Sun in about two seconds. About 65 billion pass through each square centimetre of your body every second. Detectors from the 1960s onward caught them, but at only a third to a half of the expected rate, a puzzle that lasted three decades.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Hydrogen in the core | About 10 per cent of 2 x 10^30 kg x 0.7 (the share that is hydrogen) | 1.4 x 10^29 kg (calculated) |
| Mass turned to energy | 1.4 x 10^29 kg x 0.007 | 9.8 x 10^26 kg (calculated) |
| Energy released | 9.8 x 10^26 kg x (3 x 10^8 m/s)^2 | 8.8 x 10^43 J (calculated) |
| Time at 3.8 x 10^26 W | 8.8 x 10^43 J / 3.8 x 10^26 W | 2.3 x 10^17 s, about 7 billion years (calculated) |
| Check | Accepted lifetime on the main sequence | About 10 billion years |
The rough working lands within a factor of 1.5 of the accepted figure. The fuel is no limit for a long time: the Sun has used about half of its core hydrogen.
Source: Calculated from standard values, Arithmetic shown in the table; constants recalled and listed in the sources- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 29, 'The Universe'
- Standard reference values recalled and not re-fetched in this session; check before reuse · Speed of light 299,792 km/s; light-year 9.461 x 10^12 km; parsec 3.086 x 10^13 km = 3.262 light-years; Proxima Centauri parallax 0.768 arcsec, 4.25 ly; Sirius 8.6 ly; Betelgeuse roughly 550 ly and Rigel roughly 860 ly; Barnard's Star proper motion 10.3 arcsec a year; Hipparcos 1989 to 1993; Gaia launched 2013, more than a billion parallaxes; Pogson 1856 scale; Wien constant 2.898 x 10^-3 m K; Sun L 3.83 x 10^26 W, M 1.989 x 10^30 kg, T 5,772 K, age 4.6 billion years; solar neutrino flux about 6.5 x 10^10 per cm2 per s; Super-Kamiokande 1998, SNO 2001 and 2002, 2015 Nobel Prize to Kajita and McDonald; Harvard spectral classes and temperatures; main-sequence L proportional to M^3.5; Sirius B radius 0.0084 solar and 25,000 K; white dwarf of about 0.6 solar masses; Eddington's objection at the Royal Astronomical Society, 1935; Crab supernova 1054 CE and Crab pulsar period 33 ms; Cygnus X-1 1971; photon sphere at 1.5 times the critical radius; Zwicky 1933; Sun's galactic speed 230 km/s; Milky Way 100,000 ly across and forming one or two solar masses of stars a year; V1 period 31.4 days on a 1923 plate from the 2.5 m Hooker telescope; Hubble's 1924 result presented in January 1925; 21 cm line at 1,420 MHz; COBE 1989 and the 2006 Nobel Prize to Mather and Smoot; recombination at about 3,000 K and 380,000 years; Einstein's cosmological constant 1917; Lemaitre 1927; Hoyle's 1949 radio talk; Slipher's redshifts from 1912; supernovae of 1998 about a fifth fainter at z near 0.5; JWST launched December 2021 with a 6.5 m mirror; SN 1987A about two dozen neutrinos; 51 Pegasi b 1995 and the 2019 Nobel Prize; Kepler 2009; TESS 2018; planetary masses, radii and orbital speeds; Drake equation 1961; Bullet Cluster 2006; Milky Way centre stars at several thousand km/s; accretion efficiency of about 10 per cent; observable universe about 93 billion ly across
2.2 A star's colour gives its temperature, and its spectrum gives both temperature and chemistry, as Saha and Payne showed
An iron bar glows dull red, then orange, then white as it heats, and stars follow the same rule. By Wien's law (module 5, node 'Blackbody radiation') the peak wavelength is 0.0029 metre-kelvin divided by the temperature. The Sun, at 5,800 K, peaks at 500 nm, green-yellow. Betelgeuse, at about 3,500 K, peaks at 830 nm, in the infrared, so its visible light is weighted to the red. Sirius, at 9,900 K, peaks at 290 nm in the ultraviolet and looks blue-white. Astronomers sort stars by the lines in their spectra into classes O, B, A, F, G, K and M, from hottest to coolest.
Module 8 introduced Meghnad Saha's equation of 1920, which links the ionisation of a gas to its temperature, and Cecilia Payne's use of it in 1925 to show that stars are mostly hydrogen and helium. The step that had misled astronomers before them is worth seeing. The strength of a line is not simply the amount of the element. The visible Balmer lines of hydrogen are absorbed only by atoms already raised to level 2. In a cool star almost no atoms are raised that far; in a very hot one, most hydrogen has lost its electron and absorbs nothing. So the lines peak near 10,000 K, in A stars, although the Sun has as much hydrogen.
Correct every line for this and the composition falls out. The Sun is about three quarters hydrogen and a quarter helium by mass, with under 2 per cent of everything else, very unlike the rocky Earth. Established opinion resisted at first, and Payne was persuaded to call her result probably unreal, but other work confirmed it within a few years.
| Class | Surface temperature (K) | Colour | Example and what dominates the spectrum |
|---|---|---|---|
| O | Above 30,000 | Blue | Rare, very luminous; ionised helium |
| B | 10,000 to 30,000 | Blue-white | Rigel; neutral helium |
| A | 7,500 to 10,000 | White | Sirius and Vega; strongest hydrogen lines |
| F | 6,000 to 7,500 | Yellow-white | Hydrogen weakening; ionised calcium |
| G | 5,200 to 6,000 | Yellow | The Sun; ionised calcium, many metals |
| K | 3,700 to 5,200 | Orange | Metal lines; first molecules |
| M | 2,400 to 3,700 | Red | Betelgeuse and most stars; molecules such as titanium oxide |
The order of letters is an accident of history: stars were first lettered by hydrogen line strength and later reordered by temperature. Most stars, by number, are the faint, cool class M.
Source: Britannica, Meghnad N. Saha, https://www.britannica.com/biography/Meghnad-N-Saha (thermal ionisation equation, 1920; professor at Allahabad from 1923; Calcutta Institute of Nuclear Physics); Standard reference values recalled and not re-fetched in this session; check before reuse, Speed of light 299,792 km/s; light-year 9.461 x 10^12 km; parsec 3.086 x 10^13 km = 3.262 light-years; Proxima Centauri parallax 0.768 arcsec, 4.25 ly; Sirius 8.6 ly; Betelgeuse roughly 550 ly and Rigel roughly 860 ly; Barnard's Star proper motion 10.3 arcsec a year; Hipparcos 1989 to 1993; Gaia launched 2013, more than a billion parallaxes; Pogson 1856 scale; Wien constant 2.898 x 10^-3 m K; Sun L 3.83 x 10^26 W, M 1.989 x 10^30 kg, T 5,772 K, age 4.6 billion years; solar neutrino flux about 6.5 x 10^10 per cm2 per s; Super-Kamiokande 1998, SNO 2001 and 2002, 2015 Nobel Prize to Kajita and McDonald; Harvard spectral classes and temperatures; main-sequence L proportional to M^3.5; Sirius B radius 0.0084 solar and 25,000 K; white dwarf of about 0.6 solar masses; Eddington's objection at the Royal Astronomical Society, 1935; Crab supernova 1054 CE and Crab pulsar period 33 ms; Cygnus X-1 1971; photon sphere at 1.5 times the critical radius; Zwicky 1933; Sun's galactic speed 230 km/s; Milky Way 100,000 ly across and forming one or two solar masses of stars a year; V1 period 31.4 days on a 1923 plate from the 2.5 m Hooker telescope; Hubble's 1924 result presented in January 1925; 21 cm line at 1,420 MHz; COBE 1989 and the 2006 Nobel Prize to Mather and Smoot; recombination at about 3,000 K and 380,000 years; Einstein's cosmological constant 1917; Lemaitre 1927; Hoyle's 1949 radio talk; Slipher's redshifts from 1912; supernovae of 1998 about a fifth fainter at z near 0.5; JWST launched December 2021 with a 6.5 m mirror; SN 1987A about two dozen neutrinos; 51 Pegasi b 1995 and the 2019 Nobel Prize; Kepler 2009; TESS 2018; planetary masses, radii and orbital speeds; Drake equation 1961; Bullet Cluster 2006; Milky Way centre stars at several thousand km/s; accretion efficiency of about 10 per cent; observable universe about 93 billion ly across- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 29, 'The Universe'
- Britannica, Meghnad N. Saha · web
2.3 The Hertzsprung-Russell diagram sorts stars by power and temperature, and shows that mass decides a star's life
One rule for glowing surfaces does much of the work here: power equals area times temperature to the fourth power (the Stefan-Boltzmann law, module 5). So a cool star can be powerful only if it is huge, and a hot star that is faint must be tiny. Plot every star by its true power against its surface temperature, as Ejnar Hertzsprung and Henry Norris Russell did in the 1910s, and the points fall into groups that the rule explains. About nine in ten lie on a diagonal band, the main sequence, running from hot and powerful to cool and faint. Above it sit the red giants and supergiants, cool but powerful, and so enormous. Below it sit the white dwarfs, hot but faint, and so about the size of the Earth. The table gives the numbers.
What decides where a star sits on the main sequence is its mass, which can be weighed in a pair of stars that orbit each other, using Kepler's third law (module 4). The Sun's mass is the unit. A star of 10 Suns is about 3,000 times as powerful, since power rises roughly as mass to the power 3.5. It burns its fuel faster than it has it: lifetime is fuel divided by power, so it falls as mass to the power minus 2.5. A 10-Sun star lasts about 30 million years. A half-Sun star lasts more than 50 billion, and a tenth-Sun red dwarf trillions, longer than the universe has existed. The diagram also gives distances: a star's class tells its true power, and comparing that with how bright it looks gives the distance, a method called spectroscopic parallax.
| Star | Radius (Suns) | Temperature (K) | Power = radius^2 x (T / 5,800)^4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Sun | 1 | 5,800 | 1 (the unit) |
| Sirius A | 1.7 | 9,900 | 2.9 x 8.5 = 25 Suns (calculated) |
| A red giant | 100 | 3,500 | 10,000 x 0.13 = 1,300 Suns (calculated) |
| Sirius B, a white dwarf | 0.0084 | 25,000 | 0.00007 x 345 = 0.024 Sun (calculated) |
The red giant is cooler than the Sun but 1,300 times more powerful, because its area is 10,000 times larger. Sirius B is hotter yet 40 times fainter, because its area is 14,000 times smaller.
Source: Calculated from standard values, Arithmetic shown in the table; constants recalled and listed in the sources- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 29, 'The Universe'
See it in the table
He HeliumH2 HydrogenCheck your understanding
Why do neutrinos, rather than sunlight, show what the Sun's core is doing now?
Neutrinos hardly interact, so they leave the core almost at once. The energy that becomes sunlight is absorbed and re-emitted on its way out for a very long time, so sunlight reports the core's past.Why do hydrogen lines peak in A stars at about 10,000 K, although every star has similar hydrogen?
Saha's equation sets the ionisation, the Boltzmann factor sets excitation. Together they favour about 10,000 K for the visible hydrogen lines.A star is cool but extremely powerful. What does the Stefan-Boltzmann law say about its size?
Power goes as area times temperature to the fourth power. With a low temperature, only a very large area can supply a lot of power.