Stars, galaxies and the universe: The life and death of stars
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 22: Stars, galaxies and the universe Part 3 of 6The life and death of stars
Stars are born, live on a fuel supply and die, and how they die depends almost entirely on their mass. This part follows the story from a cold cloud to a white dwarf, a neutron star or a black hole, and shows where the atoms of our bodies were made. An Indian physicist's calculation, the limit that Chandrasekhar worked out, sits at its centre.
3.1 A cold cloud collapses, ignites and settles onto the main sequence, where a star spends most of its life
Look at the Orion Nebula with binoculars and you see a glowing cloud, a nursery. Space between the stars is not empty: it holds thin gas, mostly hydrogen, and dust. Where the gas is dense and cold, a cloud of thousands of Suns' mass can start to fall inwards under its own gravity (module 4). Parts of the cloud collapse separately, each making a star. As a clump shrinks, it spins faster and flattens, the same process that made the solar system's disc (module 21). Falling gas heats, as a bicycle pump warms when compressed.
While it is still contracting, the young object, a protostar, shines on that heat. When its core reaches about 10 million K, hydrogen fusion starts (module 9) and the heat made matches the loss from the surface. Contraction stops, and the star joins the main sequence. A clump below about 8 per cent of the Sun's mass never gets hot enough and fades as a brown dwarf. Stars much above 100 to 200 Suns are not seen, because the light of such a star drives its outer layers away.
Main-sequence stars differ mainly in mass. Heavier stars have hotter cores, which fuse faster, so they are bluer and shorter-lived (see the lifetimes in Part 2). The Sun's 10 billion years is long; a tenth of it is more than all human history. Most stars are small and cool.
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 29, 'The Universe'
3.2 When the core's hydrogen runs out, a Sun-like star swells into a red giant and ends as a white dwarf, and Chandrasekhar found a limit to that ending
When the core hydrogen is spent, fusion at the centre stops. With less outward pressure, the core shrinks and heats, and hydrogen in a shell around it begins to fuse faster. The outer layers swell and cool: the star becomes a red giant. The Sun will reach that stage in about 5 billion years, with a radius of roughly 100 to 200 times today's, engulfing Mercury and probably Venus. Long before, within a billion years or two, its slow brightening will have boiled away Earth's oceans. Later the core fuses helium into carbon and oxygen. Finally the star puffs off its outer layers as a glowing shell, which 18th-century observers called a planetary nebula because in small telescopes it showed a disc like a planet's. Left behind is the hot core: a white dwarf.
A white dwarf packs about 0.6 of the Sun's mass into a ball the size of the Earth, so a cubic centimetre of it holds about a tonne (calculated). It does not collapse further because of quantum mechanics. Electrons cannot be packed into the same state (module 8, Pauli exclusion), and squeezing them leaves a pressure that does not depend on temperature. In 1930, on the long voyage from India to England, the 19-year-old Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar worked out what happens when a white dwarf is heavy. The electrons are pressed so hard that they move near the speed of light, and the pressure no longer rises fast enough. Above about 1.4 Suns, no white dwarf can exist. The Chandrasekhar limit was disputed by some leading figures for years. He shared the 1983 Nobel Prize in Physics.
White dwarfs cool for ever, since they cannot fuse. If one in a close pair pulls gas from its partner, hydrogen builds up on its surface and flashes in a nova, which can repeat. If it gains enough to reach the limit, it explodes as a Type Ia supernova, which is why those explosions have a nearly standard power.
Hydrogen to helium in the core for about 10 billion years
2 Red giantHydrogen shell burning, then helium to carbon and oxygen; radius 100 or more Suns
3 Planetary nebulaOuter layers blown off, over some tens of thousands of years
Outputs White dwarfEarth-sized, about 0.6 Sun, cooling for ever; atoms recycled to spaceA star of less than about 8 Suns follows this path. A heavier star ends differently, as the next section shows.
Source: NobelPrize.org, The 1983 Nobel Prize in Physics, speed read, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1983/speedread/ (calculations on a sea voyage from India to England in 1930; stars of more than 1.4 solar masses; 1983 prize shared with William Fowler); Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 29, 'The Universe'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 29, 'The Universe'
- NobelPrize.org, The 1983 Nobel Prize in Physics, speed read · web
3.3 A star of more than about 8 Suns ends in a supernova, which makes and scatters the heavy elements
A heavy star fuses beyond helium. Its core becomes layered, with carbon, neon, oxygen and silicon burning in turn at ever higher temperatures. Each stage is shorter than the last: for a 20-Sun star, hydrogen lasts some ten million years and silicon a matter of days. The chain stops at iron. Module 9 showed that the iron group has the most tightly bound nuclei, so a fusion step beyond it is a net cost and cannot supply the pressure the core needs.
The iron core, about as wide as the Earth, then has nothing to hold it up. In well under a second it falls in on itself and ends as a ball some 20 km across. The outer layers crash onto that hard, dense core and are driven out, helped by a flood of neutrinos, in a supernova that for weeks outshines billions of Suns. In 1987 detectors on Earth caught about two dozen of those neutrinos from a supernova in the Large Magellanic Cloud, confirming the physics.
Supernovae matter beyond the show. Almost every element heavier than helium was made in stars or in the explosions and mergers of dying ones: the carbon in your cells, the oxygen in your blood, the calcium in bones, the iron in haemoglobin. Module 9 traced gold and uranium to neutron star mergers and similar events. The solar system's heavy elements came from earlier generations of stars (module 21). The Crab Nebula is the debris of a star seen to explode in 1054 CE, recorded by astronomers in China and elsewhere.
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 29, 'The Universe'
3.4 A collapsed core becomes a neutron star, seen as a pulsar by Bell Burnell in 1967, or a black hole
If the collapsing core is heavier than the Chandrasekhar limit but under roughly 2 to 3 Suns, the electrons are pushed into the protons, making neutrons. The result is a neutron star: 1.4 Suns packed into a ball about 12 km in radius. Its density, about 4 x 10^17 kg per cubic metre, matches that inside an atomic nucleus (module 9), and the table works it out. The escape speed is more than half the speed of light.
As the core shrinks it spins faster, by conservation of angular momentum (module 3), and its magnetic field is squeezed and strengthened. Beams of radio waves stream from its magnetic poles, and if a beam crosses Earth once per turn we receive a sharp pulse each rotation. In 1967 Jocelyn Bell, a research student in Cambridge, noticed such pulses on a chart record, one every 1.337 seconds. They proved to come from a spinning neutron star, and the name pulsar was coined. The 1974 Nobel Prize in Physics for the discovery went to her supervisor, Antony Hewish, and to Martin Ryle, and not to her. The Crab pulsar spins 30 times a second.
If the core is heavier still, nothing known stops the collapse, and a black hole forms. Module 4 gave its critical radius, 2GM/c^2, about 3 km for each Sun's mass. That sphere is the event horizon: from inside it, not even light gets out. At 1.5 times that radius lies the photon sphere, where light can circle the hole in an unstable orbit, and at the centre theory predicts a singularity of unlimited density, a sign that general relativity has reached its limit. Black holes are found by their effects. The first strong case, the X-ray source Cygnus X-1 in 1971, is a star circling an unseen partner, and stars near our Galaxy's centre orbit a hidden mass of about 4 million Suns, the black hole Sagittarius A*, whose shadow the Event Horizon Telescope imaged in 2022, three years after that of M87 (module 4).
| Quantity | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Mass | 1.4 x 1.99 x 10^30 kg | 2.8 x 10^30 kg (calculated) |
| Volume at radius 12 km | (4/3) x pi x (1.2 x 10^4 m)^3 | 7.2 x 10^12 m^3 (calculated) |
| Density | 2.8 x 10^30 kg / 7.2 x 10^12 m^3 | 3.9 x 10^17 kg per m^3 (calculated) |
| A sugar cube (1 cm^3) | 3.9 x 10^17 kg per m^3 x 10^-6 m^3 | 3.9 x 10^11 kg, about 390 million tonnes (calculated) |
| Escape speed | square root of (2 x 6.67 x 10^-11 m^3/kg/s^2 x 2.8 x 10^30 kg / 1.2 x 10^4 m) | 1.8 x 10^8 m/s, 0.59 of light speed (calculated) |
| Spin-up | Core of radius 10,000 km turning once in 10 hours (36,000 s) shrinks to 12 km; period goes as radius squared | 36,000 s x (12 / 10,000)^2 = 0.052 s (calculated) |
| Event horizon of Sagittarius A* | 2 x 6.67 x 10^-11 x (4 x 10^6 x 1.99 x 10^30 kg) / (3.0 x 10^8 m/s)^2 | 1.2 x 10^10 m, 12 million km, a fifth of Mercury's 58 million km orbit (calculated) |
The spin-up line is a simple model with a uniform sphere. It gives a pulsar period within a factor of two of the Crab pulsar's 0.033 s, from nothing but conservation of angular momentum. A black hole of 4 million Suns would fit well inside Mercury's orbit.
Source: NRAO, Tick tock, pulsating star, https://public.nrao.edu/tick-tock-pulsating-star/ (6 August 1967 Bell Burnell noticed 'scruff' on the chart; a flash every 1.33730 seconds; the 1974 Nobel Prize to her adviser Hewish); ESO, Astronomers reveal first image of the black hole at the heart of our galaxy (eso2208, 12 May 2022), https://eso.org/public/news/eso2208 (Sagittarius A* about 27,000 light-years away and four million times the Sun's mass; follows the 2019 image of M87*); Calculated from standard values, Arithmetic shown in the table; constants recalled and listed in the sources- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 29, 'The Universe'
- Britannica, Jocelyn Bell Burnell · web
- ESO, Astronomers reveal first image of the black hole at the heart of our galaxy (eso2208, 12 May 2022) · web
- NRAO, Tick tock, pulsating star · web
See it in the table
U UraniumSi SiliconAu GoldHg MercuryHe HeliumPls PulsesH2 HydrogenO2 OxygenCheck your understanding
What stops the collapse of a white dwarf?
Electron degeneracy pressure comes from the exclusion principle and does not depend on temperature. Above 1.4 Suns it can no longer hold the star up.Why does a supernova follow the fusion of iron in a massive star?
Iron is the most tightly bound nucleus. Fusing it takes energy in rather than giving it out, so the core's pressure fails and it collapses.Why does the pulse of a pulsar repeat so regularly?
The core spun faster as it shrank, with angular momentum conserved. A beam from its magnetic poles crosses Earth once each turn, so the pulses keep the rotation's steady time.