Aviation propulsion: Engineering methods
Turbofan, geared fan, open fan, propeller or rotor
All commercial aircraft engines share a gas-turbine core; they differ in how they turn core power into thrust: a directly driven fan, a geared fan, an unducted open fan, a propeller or a rotor.
Comparison
| Method | Efficiency | Scale | Economics | Limitations | Reliability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Direct-drive high-bypass turbofan (e.g. CFM LEAP)63 | 15% lower fuel use than the CFM56 it replaced (company claim) | single-aisle jets (A320neo, 737 MAX); more than 20 million engine flight hours by 2022 | the default for 150-240 seat aircraft | fan diameter limited by ground clearance and fan speed | mature; durability of hot-section parts in hot, sandy climates is the main issue |
| Geared turbofan (Pratt & Whitney GTF)7 | up to 20% fuel saving per trip on the A320neo family; up to 25% per seat on A220 and E2 (company claims) | 13,000 engines ordered, 2,730+ aircraft in service, 51 million hours (company figures) | lower fuel cost; durability problems have raised maintenance costs and grounded aircraft for inspections | gearbox heat and weight; hot-section durability | GTF Advantage upgrade promises longer time on wing (no figure given) |
| Large widebody turbofan and geared UltraFan (Rolls-Royce)89 | UltraFan 10% better than Trent XWB and 25% better than the first Trent (company claims for the demonstrator) | 25,000-110,000 lb thrust family | not yet in production | large fans add weight and drag for widebody installation | demonstrator ran to maximum power in 2023 |
| Open fan (CFM RISE)101 | target about 20% better than current engines (company target) | single-aisle successor, flight demonstration planned later this decade | unknown | noise, blade-off safety, cabin installation | 250+ critical tests and 300+ hours of wind tunnel tests so far |
| Turboprop (e.g. ATR with Pratt & Whitney Canada PW127XT)12171 | about 30% less fuel than a similar-size regional jet (ATR claim); ATR also quotes 69 g per seat-km without saying of what (probably CO2) | 30-78 seats; 1,900 ATR aircraft sold | lowest fuel cost per seat on short routes | slower, cabin noise | PW127XT claimed to stay on wing 40% longer, cutting engine maintenance cost by 20% (company claims) |
| Helicopter turboshaft (e.g. Safran Arriel)13 | much higher fuel per passenger-km than aircraft because power is needed just to hover | 21,500 Safran engines in service with 2,500 customers in 155 countries | justified where runways are absent (offshore, rescue, medical) | speed and range | gearbox and rotor fatigue drive inspection schedules |
Efficiency gains come mainly from bigger, slower fans (propulsive efficiency) and hotter, higher-pressure cores (thermal efficiency). Turboprops beat jets on fuel but not on speed; geared and open fans push the jet towards turboprop-like propulsive efficiency. ICCT finds that new-aircraft fuel burn improvement has stalled since 2020, with fewer than one new type certified per year and no new narrowbody planned before the mid-2030s. IATA reports fleet fuel efficiency stopped improving in 2024 and 2025 because of aircraft delivery shortages.
How each method works
Direct-drive high-bypass turbofan (e.g. CFM LEAP)A low-pressure turbine drives the fan on the same shaft, so fan and turbine speed are a compromise. LEAP added ceramic matrix composite parts and higher temperatures.
Geared turbofan (Pratt & Whitney GTF)A gearbox lets the fan turn slower and the turbine faster, each near its best speed, allowing a bigger fan and fewer turbine stages.
Large widebody turbofan and geared UltraFan (Rolls-Royce)Three-shaft Trent engines power long-haul jets; UltraFan adds a power gearbox of over 50 MW and a 140-inch carbon-titanium fan.
Open fan (CFM RISE)An unducted fan of very large diameter, with fixed guide vanes behind, gives a bypass ratio of about 60:1 against 11:1 today.
Turboprop (e.g. ATR with Pratt & Whitney Canada PW127XT)The gas turbine drives a propeller through a reduction gearbox; the propeller moves a large mass of air slowly, giving high propulsive efficiency at moderate cruise speeds.
Helicopter turboshaft (e.g. Safran Arriel)A small gas turbine sends shaft power through a main gearbox to the rotor, which must produce both lift and thrust.
Sources
- Commercial Aircraft Propulsion and Energy Systems Research, chapter 2: Aircraft-Propulsion Integration and gas turbine engines National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, 2016
- Fuel burn of new commercial jet aircraft: 1960 to 2024 ICCT, 2025
- French connection: Air France-KLM will use fuel-efficient LEAP engines GE Aerospace, 2022
- GTF engine: the most fuel-efficient engine for single-aisle aircraft Pratt & Whitney (RTX), 2026
- Rolls-Royce announces successful run of UltraFan technology demonstrator to maximum power Rolls-Royce, 2023
- UltraFan demonstrator fact sheet Rolls-Royce, 2023
- Shape of things to come: open fan technology championed at Airbus Summit 2025 GE Aerospace, 2025
- The most responsible regional aircraft by design ATR
- Safran Helicopter Engines: the world's leading manufacturer of helicopter engines Safran
- ATR powers its aircraft into a sustainable future with the new Pratt & Whitney Canada PW127XT engine ATR, 2021