Aviation propulsion: Science and limits
Why bigger, slower fans are the secret to efficiency
A jet engine burns kerosene or sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) in compressed air and turns the heat into a fast jet and a spinning fan. The best engines turn about 40% of the fuel's energy into thrust power.
The conversion, step by step
Combustion in the coreChemical (jet fuel) → Heat in compressed air · near complete1Thermodynamic cycle (compressor, combustor, turbine)
Heat → Kinetic energy of the jet and shaft power to the fan · over 50%, up to about 55% at cruise in the best engines (about 30% fifty years ago)1Propulsion (fan and jet push air backwards)
Kinetic energy of the air streams → Thrust power (thrust x flight speed) · 70-80% for turbofans in service1Whole engine (product of the above)
Chemical (jet fuel) → Thrust power · about 40% today1Aircraft (thrust works against drag)
Thrust power → Passenger-kilometres · about 1.2 MJ of fuel per passenger-km, world average 2019 (calculated from ICCT's 90 g CO2 per passenger-km at 3.16 kg CO2 and 43 MJ per kg of fuel)2
The science
A turbofan runs the Brayton cycle: a compressor squeezes air, fuel burns in it, and turbines drive the compressor and a large front fan. Thermal efficiency rises with pressure ratio and turbine temperature. Propulsive efficiency rises when a large mass of air is accelerated gently, since energy left in the wake is wasted; so bypass ratios have grown from about 2:1 seventy years ago to about 11:1. Turboprops and helicopter turboshafts drive a propeller or rotor through a gearbox; turboprops are about 10% more propulsively efficient but slower, and a hovering helicopter spends power just staying up.
Limits set by science
| Limit | Value | Why it exists | Best today |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carnot limit on the core | about 88% (calculated, illustrative)1 | 1 - Tc/Th with Th = 1,800 K (assumed turbine inlet gas temperature; hot parts must survive 2,200-3,000 F, about 1,480-1,920 K) and Tc = 217 K (air at 11 km): 1 - 217/1,800 = 0.88. A loss-free Brayton cycle gives somewhat above 80%; practical cores about 65-70%. | up to about 55% at cruise |
| Propulsive efficiency | 2 / (1 + jet speed / flight speed); 90-95% judged possible1 | Thrust needs a jet faster than the aircraft; the faster the jet, the more energy is left in the wake. Bigger, slower fans get closer but add weight, drag and noise. | 70-80% at cruise |
| Materials (turbine inlet temperature) | hot-section parts need long life at 2,200-3,000 F (about 1,480-1,920 K); CMCs now rated 2,200-2,400 F16 | Superalloy blades survive only because 20-30% of core airflow cools the hot section, at a cost in efficiency. | CMC parts approaching 2,400 F (about 1,590 K) in the CFM LEAP |
| Overall engine efficiency headroom | 30-35% better than today's best engines judged achievable1 | Overall efficiency has improved about 7% per decade since 1970 through many small steps. | about 40% overall |
Sources
- Commercial Aircraft Propulsion and Energy Systems Research, chapter 2: Aircraft-Propulsion Integration and gas turbine engines National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, 2016
- CO2 emissions from commercial aviation: 2013, 2018, and 2019 ICCT, 2020
- French connection: Air France-KLM will use fuel-efficient LEAP engines GE Aerospace, 2022