Thermochemical biomass conversion: Resources and labour
Why each tonne of fuel needs several tonnes of residue
Thermochemical plants need dry (or, for HTL, wet) biomass, hydrogen for upgrading oils, and high-temperature, pressure-rated equipment.
Natural resources
| Resource | How much | Why it is needed |
|---|---|---|
| Biomass feedstock | About 5.6-7.1 t of residue per t of Fischer-Tropsch distillate (calculated from 14-18% yield); about 1.3-1.5 t of dry wood per t of bio-oil (calculated from 65-75% yield)512 | Every tonne of product needs several tonnes of feedstock because part of the carbon leaves as gas, char or CO2. |
| Land | Median 58,000 ha per TWh a year for biomass grown for energy; about 130 ha per TWh a year from residues10 | Using residues avoids dedicating land to fuel; purpose-grown biomass needs large areas because plants capture sunlight thinly. |
| Hydrogen | Not quantified in the sources reviewed98 | Pyrolysis oils and HTL biocrude contain much oxygen, which must be removed with hydrogen to make stable transport fuel. |
| Capital equipment (gasifiers, gas cleaning, reactors) | USD 2,500-5,500/kW for IGCC; USD 4,560-5,560/kW for gasification-FT49 | Equipment must withstand high temperatures, pressures and corrosive tars and acids. |
Labour
| Phase | How much | Skills | Why it is needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Construction | Not quantified per MW in the sources reviewed; Fischer-Tropsch plants take about 5 years to build5 | Process plant construction, pressure vessels, gas cleaning systems | These are chemical plants rather than simple boilers. |
| Operation | Not quantified in the sources reviewed4 | Chemical engineers, process operators, catalyst and gas-safety specialists | Syngas contains toxic carbon monoxide and tars that must be controlled continuously. |
Sources
- Torrefaction and pyrolysis (European Industrial Bioenergy Initiative factsheet EIBI-4) ETIP Bioenergy
- IEA Bioenergy Update 29: Task 34 technology report on fast pyrolysis IEA Bioenergy
- Energy Technology Essentials ETE03: Biomass for Power Generation and CHP (2007 cost estimates) International Energy Agency (copy hosted by nachhaltigwirtschaften.at), 2007
- Progress in commercialisation of biojet / SAF (van Dyk, IEA Bioenergy workshop presentation) IEA Bioenergy Task 39 (hosted by DBFZ), 2023
- Biojet fuels: technologies and status of commercialisation (van Dyk and Saddler) IEA Bioenergy Task 39, 2020
- Reaching Zero with Renewables: Biojet fuels IRENA, 2021
- Land-use intensity of electricity production and tomorrow's energy landscape (Lovering, Swain, Blomqvist and Hernandez) PLOS ONE, 2022