Building heat recovery: Science and thermodynamics
Why simple exchangers recover most of a room's heat
Why simple exchangers recover most of a room's heatBuildings throw away heat in stale air, shower water, cooking exhaust and air-conditioner condensers. Each stream is lukewarm, so recovery relies on cheap passive heat exchangers or on heat pumps that upgrade it.
Grade of energy
MixedThese are the lowest-grade streams in the recovery stage: exhaust air near room temperature, shower drains that are warm rather than hot, and condensers that reject heat slightly above outdoor temperature. The exception is the superheated refrigerant leaving a chiller compressor, which is hot enough to heat tap water; a 2003 study at a Mumbai hotel heated water from 30 C to 65 C this way on a 60 tonne-of-refrigeration chiller. A heat-pump water heater instead pulls heat from room air and upgrades it.48
Hotel chiller superheat recovery tap water 30 C to 65 C (60 TR chiller)8 Heat-pump water heater max water temperature 140-160 F (about 60-71 C)4Exergy versus energy efficiency
FavourablePassive exchangers recover a share of the heat with almost no added work. US DOE material says ventilation recovery units can recover about 70 to 80% of the energy in outgoing air, and one 2013 Solar Decathlon house used a heat recovery ventilator rated at 92%. Drain-water units are less effective: a University of Waterloo study reported 26 to 39% effectiveness for one common coil type depending on flow. Heat-pump water heaters reach a uniform energy factor (UEF) of 3.3 to 4.0, against 0.9 for an electric tank, meaning roughly 73 to 78% less electricity (calculated).345
ERV/HRV energy recovery about 70-80% (one competition HRV 92%)5 Drain-water unit effectiveness 25.7-39.2% (one tested unit)3 Heat-pump water heater UEF 3.3-4.0 vs 0.9 for electric tank4 Electricity saving vs electric tank about 73-78% (calculated)4Media compatibility and corrosiveness
MixedClean indoor air and potable water make most of these devices simple: drain-water units are a spiral copper tube wrapped round a vertical section of drain, with no moving parts. An energy recovery ventilator (ERV) also moves moisture between the air streams, which suits humid climates such as much of India, whereas a heat recovery ventilator (HRV) moves only heat. Kitchen exhaust is the hard case: grease coats exchanger surfaces and adds fire risk, so kitchens more often cut exhaust flow with demand-controlled ventilation than recover heat directly.16
Drain-water unit construction copper coil round a vertical drain section1Variants compared124578
| Variant | What it recovers | Key figure | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| HRV / ERV | Heat (and moisture for ERV) from exhaust air | About 70-80% energy recovery | Airtight homes and offices; ERV for humid climates |
| Drain-water heat recovery | Heat from shower drain water | About 790 kWh/yr in an Ontario test house; payback 2.5-7 years (DOE) | Homes, hostels, gyms with frequent showers |
| Heat-pump water heater | Heat from room air | UEF 3.3-4.0; about USD 550/yr saving | Replacing electric tank heaters |
| AC and chiller condenser heat | Superheat or condenser heat to hot water | Mumbai hotel case (2003): payback about 3 months | Hotels and hospitals with cooling and hot water demand |
| Kitchen exhaust | Exhaust heat, or less exhaust via demand control | Demand control cut exhaust airflow 23-32% at one US Army kitchen | Commercial kitchens |
Sources
- Drain-Water Heat Recovery (Energy Saver) US Department of Energy, 2024
- Evaluation of Residential Drain Water Heat Recovery Unit (study begun 2010) Sustainable Technologies Evaluation Program (Toronto and Region Conservation Authority), 2017
- Modelling the Steady-State Performance of Coiled Falling-Film Drain Water Heat Recovery Systems Using Rated Data (Manouchehri and Collins), Resources 9: 69 MDPI Resources (University of Waterloo authors), 2020
- Is a Heat Pump Water Heater Right for Your Home? ENERGY STAR (US EPA), 2023
- Technology Spotlight: Energy-Recovery Ventilation Systems (Solar Decathlon 2013 houses) US DOE Solar Decathlon, 2013
- HVAC energy recovery ventilation (Energy Basics) US DOE Building Science Education
- Engineering and Construction Bulletin 2015-3: Demand control kitchen ventilation US Army Corps of Engineers (via WBDG), 2015
- Benefits of superheat recovery on chillers: case study for a hotel installation (Rane and Tandale), 21st IIR International Congress of Refrigeration International Institute of Refrigeration, 2003