Electric heating: Engineering methods
Resistance, induction, arc or microwave: which one wins where
Four ways of making heat from electricity, plus the heat pump as the main alternative for low-temperature heat.
Comparison
| Method | Efficiency | Scale | Economics | Limitations | Reliability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resistive heaters, kettles and geysers2 | 100% electricity to heat at the element; tank standing losses reduce delivered heat | 1-3 kW kettles to tens of kW instantaneous heaters and MW-scale industrial boilers | Cheapest to buy; high running cost compared with heat pumps | Large peak loads on the grid | Simple; elements scale up in hard water |
| Induction heating and hobs1 | About 85% for hobs | Domestic hobs to industrial melting and hardening furnaces | Hobs cost more than resistance types but save energy | Needs magnetic (iron-based) cookware | Electronics are the usual failure point |
| Electric arc furnaces3511 | 400-500 kWh/t; a peer-reviewed model uses 450 kWh/t as typical | Tens to hundreds of tonnes per heat; about 560 million tonnes of steel in 2025 (calculated) | Electricity about USD 39/t (calculated); much lower capital than blast furnaces | Needs scrap or DRI; scrap quality limits steel grades | Electrode and refractory wear |
| Microwave ovens610 | 50% or less, electricity to food | Domestic countertop and built-in units; industrial systems at 915 MHz | Small energy use (about 71 kWh a year cooking) | Uneven heating; poor for browning | Magnetron output declines with age |
| Heat pump (comparison)2 | More than double resistance water heaters | Domestic to district heating | Higher purchase price, lower running cost | Hard to reach very high temperatures | Compressor and refrigerant circuit |
For temperatures below about 100 degrees C, resistance heating is simple but uses two or more times the electricity of a heat pump. Induction and microwaves win by putting heat directly into the target. For melting steel, the arc furnace is the only mature all-electric route, already making about 30% of world steel.
How each method works
Resistive heaters, kettles and geysersCurrent through a sheathed resistance element heats water or air directly; storage geysers keep a tank hot, instantaneous units heat on demand.
Induction heating and hobsAn inverter feeds a copper coil with high-frequency current; the changing field induces eddy currents in the pan or metal workpiece.
Electric arc furnacesGraphite electrodes strike arcs into a charge of scrap or directly reduced iron, melting it; oxygen and carbon injection add chemical heat.
Microwave ovensA magnetron produces 2,450 MHz waves that bounce around a metal cavity and are absorbed by water in food.
Heat pump (comparison)Uses electricity to move heat from outside air or ground into water or rooms, rather than making it.
Sources
- ENERGY STAR Emerging Technology Award 2021: Residential Induction Cooking Tops US EPA / DOE ENERGY STAR, 2021
- DOE finalizes efficiency standards for water heaters to save Americans over USD 7 billion on household utility bills annually (press release, 30 April 2024) US Department of Energy, 2024
- World Steel in Figures 2026 World Steel Association, 2026
- Article modelling electric arc furnace electrical energy consumption (University of Ljubljana authors), DOI 10.1007/s40831-021-00390-y Journal of Sustainable Metallurgy (Springer), 2021
- Energy issues in microwave food processing: a review of developments and the enabling potentials of solid-state power delivery (Atuonwu and Tassou, Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition; author manuscript) Brunel University London repository, 2019
- Joint comments to DOE on microwave oven test procedures (ASAP, ACEEE, Consumer Federation of America and others, citing DOE's 2013 proposed rule) Consumer Federation of America, 2018
- Theoretical Minimum Energies to Produce Steel for Selected Conditions (Fruehan, Fortini, Paxton and Brindle, Carnegie Mellon University) US Department of Energy, Office of Industrial Technologies, 2000