Electric heating: Science and limits
Why every heater is 100% efficient, yet some waste half
Electric heating turns electricity into heat by pushing current through a resistance, inducing currents in metal, striking an arc, or shaking water molecules with microwaves. Nearly all the electricity becomes heat; the question is how much of it reaches the target.
The conversion, step by step
Resistive element (kettle, geyser, space heater)Electrical → Heat in the element · Essentially 100% of electricity becomes heat (first law); losses are heat escaping from the tank or pot2Induction hob: inverter and coil
Electrical (50/60 Hz AC) → High-frequency magnetic field, then eddy-current heat inside the pan · About 85% to the food, versus 75-80% for resistance hobs and about 32% for gas1Electric arc furnace
Electrical (via furnace transformer) → Arc and resistance heat melting scrap steel · 400-500 kWh of electricity per tonne of steel in modern furnaces, against a theoretical minimum of about 370 kWh/t (1.33 GJ/t, calculated) to melt scrap and heat it to 1,600 degrees C511Microwave oven: magnetron
Electrical → Microwaves at 2,450 MHz · About 70% maximum at 2,450 MHz (quoted figures sometimes higher)6Microwave absorption in food
Microwaves → Heat in water molecules · Whole domestic oven 50% or less, electricity to heat in food6
The science
When current flows through a material with resistance, colliding electrons pass energy to the atoms, which vibrate faster: that is heat (Joule heating, power = current squared times resistance). Kettles and water heaters use a metal-sheathed element; arc furnaces pass tens of thousands of amperes through graphite electrodes into the scrap, forming arcs hotter than the steel's melting point. Induction heating uses Faraday's law: a coil carrying high-frequency current makes a changing magnetic field, which induces swirling (eddy) currents inside an iron pan or metal charge, so heat appears in the metal itself rather than in a hot plate. Microwave ovens use a magnetron to make radio waves at 2,450 MHz; water molecules, which have positive and negative ends, try to turn with the rapidly reversing field and their jostling becomes heat. Heating 1 litre of water from 15 to 100 degrees C needs about 356 kJ, or 0.099 kWh (calculated from water's specific heat of 4.18 kJ per kg per degree).
Limits set by science
| Limit | Value | Why it exists | Best today |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conversion ceiling for resistance heating | 100% of electricity becomes heat2 | Energy is conserved, so a resistance heater cannot be more than 100% efficient. But the second law allows a heat pump to move extra heat from the outside air, delivering several units of heat per unit of electricity. | US rules from 2029 for common electric water heaters require heat-pump-level performance, more than doubling efficiency versus resistance tanks |
| Minimum energy to melt scrap steel | About 1.33 GJ, or about 370 kWh, per tonne (calculated) for scrap melted and heated to 1,600 degrees C115 | The heat needed to warm steel to its melting point (about 1,500 degrees C), melt it and superheat it for tapping. No furnace can use less, whatever the heat source. | Modern furnaces use 400-500 kWh/t of electricity; electricity supplies up to about 60% and oxygen and carbon reactions up to about 25% of total energy input. DOE put total practice at 2.1-2.4 GJ/t of liquid steel (2000). |
| Magnetron efficiency | About 70% maximum at 2,450 MHz; 88% at 915 MHz (industrial)6 | Some electron energy ends up heating the magnetron's anode instead of becoming microwaves. Solid-state amplifiers reach up to about 69% but deliver energy more precisely. | Domestic ovens deliver 50% or less of their electricity into food |
| Coupling to the target | Induction about 85% versus gas about 32%1 | The more of the heat produced directly inside the pan or food, the less escapes into the room. | Induction hobs |
Sources
- ENERGY STAR Emerging Technology Award 2021: Residential Induction Cooking Tops US EPA / DOE ENERGY STAR, 2021
- DOE finalizes efficiency standards for water heaters to save Americans over USD 7 billion on household utility bills annually (press release, 30 April 2024) US Department of Energy, 2024
- Article modelling electric arc furnace electrical energy consumption (University of Ljubljana authors), DOI 10.1007/s40831-021-00390-y Journal of Sustainable Metallurgy (Springer), 2021
- Energy issues in microwave food processing: a review of developments and the enabling potentials of solid-state power delivery (Atuonwu and Tassou, Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition; author manuscript) Brunel University London repository, 2019
- Theoretical Minimum Energies to Produce Steel for Selected Conditions (Fruehan, Fortini, Paxton and Brindle, Carnegie Mellon University) US Department of Energy, Office of Industrial Technologies, 2000