Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Cost, trade-offs and resources: why the best design is rarely the strongest: Choosing a material under cost, weight and carbon

All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 13: Cost, trade-offs and resources: why the best design is rarely the strongest Part 3 of 5

Choosing a material under cost, weight and carbon

Steel, aluminium and carbon-fibre composite each win on a different count. To choose between them an engineer first fixes the job, then compares the materials on that job, and only then adds price and carbon. The same panel is used throughout this part so that every number can be checked against the last.

3.1 A fair comparison fixes the job first, and for a stiff panel the lightest material is not the strongest

Which of steel, aluminium and carbon fibre is best depends on the job. Take a flat panel such as a bus floor, a machine cover or a boot lid, whose main duty is to resist bending without sagging. That is a stiffness job, not a strength job (see the module on Structures and materials).

The bending stiffness of a plate is proportional to its Young's modulus E times thickness cubed. To keep the stiffness fixed, a stiffer material lets the plate be thinner, and thickness must scale as E to the power minus one third. The mass of the plate is density times thickness, so for equal stiffness the mass is proportional to density divided by E to the one third. The lower this index, the lighter the panel.

Take steel at 7,850 kg per cubic metre and 200 GPa, aluminium at 2,700 and 70, and a carbon-fibre laminate at about 1,600 and 60 (a quasi-isotropic layup, with fibres running in several directions; this is a rough handbook figure, and fibres laid in one direction are about twice as stiff along their length). The indices are 1,342, 655 and 409 (calculated). Against a 10 kg steel panel, an aluminium panel of the same stiffness weighs 4.9 kg and the composite one 3.0 kg (calculated).

Now add price. Hot-rolled steel coil sold for about US$1,225 per short ton in the United States in September 2026, about US$1,350 per tonne (calculated), and that is a high-priced market. Aluminium traded at about US$3,100 per tonne on the London Metal Exchange in November 2026, and carbon fibre quoted between about US$27 and US$42 per kg in 2025 and 2026 depending on country. So the metal in the steel panel costs about US$13.50, the aluminium panel about US$15.20 and the fibre in the composite panel about US$80 to US$125 (all calculated). Aluminium is close to steel on metal cost because so much less is needed, but forming and joining it cost more. The composite panel is several times dearer even before resin and labour.

Data Worked estimate 6: a panel of equal bending stiffness, mass and material cost
MaterialDensity (kg/m3) and E (GPa)Index: density / E^(1/3) (calculated)Mass of the equal-stiffness panel (calculated)Price per kgMaterial cost of the panel (calculated)
Steel7,850 and 2001,34210.0 kgabout US$1.35 (US hot-rolled coil)about US$13.5
Aluminium2,700 and 706554.9 kgabout US$3.1 (ingot)about US$15
Carbon-fibre laminate1,600 and 60 (quasi-isotropic, rough)4093.0 kgabout US$35 (fibre only)about US$105

Prices are indicative: steel the US hot-rolled coil price in September 2026, aluminium the London Metal Exchange cash price in November 2026, carbon fibre the range of quoted 2025 and 2026 fibre prices. The composite row prices the whole laminate at the fibre price; resin is cheaper per kg but moulding adds cost. Fabrication costs are not included.

Source: GMK Center, US hot-rolled coil price (15 September 2026); London Metal Exchange cash price via alcircle (6 November 2026); IMARC carbon fibre price series (2025 to 2026); Explore Composites, basic numbers for composites, steel, aluminium and carbon fibre prices; laminate modulus
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 11, 'Materials Engineering' (choosing a material by optimising an index such as weight or cost)
  • Explore Composites, Basic numbers and calculations for composites · quasi-isotropic carbon/epoxy laminate about 60 GPa; unidirectional lamina about 130 GPa at 1.6 g/cc, https://explorecomposites.com/articles/design-for-composites/basic-numbers-and-calculations-for-composites/

3.2 Embodied carbon adds a third axis, and the answer depends on how the metal was made

The carbon emitted in making a material is called its embodied carbon, counted in kg of carbon dioxide equivalent per kg. It is not a fixed property of the material, because it depends on the route and on the electricity used.

For steel, worldsteel's 2025 report on the 2024 data gives a global average of 1.92 tonnes of CO2 per tonne of crude steel, or 2.18 with other greenhouse gases and upstream mining included. The blast furnace route is 2.34 (2.66 on the wider count), the route that melts scrap in an electric arc furnace is 0.69 (0.71), and direct reduced iron with an electric furnace sits between at 1.47 (1.66). For primary aluminium the International Aluminium Institute gives 15.1 tonnes of CO2e per tonne for 2022, from mine to cast house, and recycled aluminium about 0.52, though that figure excludes the burden already carried by the scrap and should not be read as the footprint of recycled metal. Smelters in India run mainly on coal-fired power, so a figure for India would normally be higher than the world average. For carbon fibre, a 2025 meta-analysis found a median of 31 kg CO2e per kg across published studies, with a range from 17 to 154, and the authors concluded the data are too uneven to be reliable.

Multiply these by the mass of each panel. The steel one carries about 22 kg CO2e, the primary aluminium one about 74, and the composite one about 94, with a plausible range from 52 to 470 (all calculated). Applying the fibre's value to the whole laminate overstates it somewhat, since resin carries less carbon per kg. The lightest panel is not the lowest in carbon to make, and the heaviest is. This is a trade-off in its plainest form: weight saved in use is paid for in carbon spent in making.

Data Worked estimate 7: embodied carbon of the equal-stiffness panels
PanelMassCarbon per kg of materialEmbodied carbon of the panel (calculated)
Steel, global average (2.18 kg CO2e per kg)10.0 kg2.18about 22 kg CO2e
Steel by arc furnace on scrap (0.71)10.0 kg0.71about 7 kg CO2e
Aluminium, primary, global average (15.1)4.9 kg15.1about 74 kg CO2e
Aluminium, recycled (0.52, gate to gate)4.9 kg0.52about 2.5 kg CO2e, understated
Carbon-fibre laminate, median (31)3.0 kg31about 94 kg CO2e (range 52 to 470)

The carbon-fibre value is for the fibre, applied here to the whole laminate; resin carries less carbon per kg but moulding adds some. The recycled aluminium value leaves out the burden of the original metal, so the comparison flatters it.

Source: worldsteel Sustainability Indicators 2025; IAI factsheet; Chen et al. 2025, carbon intensities per kg
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 11, 'Materials Engineering'
  • worldsteel, Sustainability Indicators 2025 (data year 2024) · CO2 intensity of crude steel by route
  • International Aluminium Institute, factsheet on recycling and greenhouse gas savings · primary aluminium 2022 and recycled aluminium emissions per tonne
  • Chen, Liddell, Ogale, Miao, Ijeoma and Carbajales-Dale, Resources, Conservation and Recycling vol. 219 (2025), article 108302 · critical review and meta-analysis of carbon fibre energy demand and carbon footprint

3.3 A lighter part pays back its extra carbon only if the product travels far enough

A part that is heavier in carbon to make but lighter in use saves energy every time the product moves. A 2016 ifeu study found that each 100 kg removed from a petrol car saves about 0.24 litre per 100 km in mixed driving, or 0.32 if the engine is downsized to match. Take 0.3. The aluminium panel saves 10 - 4.9 = 5.1 kg, which is 0.015 litre per 100 km. Over the study's family-car life of 200,000 km, or 2,000 lots of 100 km, that is 31 litres of petrol, and at about 2.3 kg of CO2 per litre burned, about 71 kg of CO2 (all calculated).

The aluminium panel cost 74 - 22 = 52 kg CO2e more to make. Dividing, the saving repays the extra at 52 / 71 x 200,000 = about 147,000 km (calculated). The composite panel saves 7 kg and 96 kg of CO2 over the same life, against an extra 73 kg to make it, so it breaks even near 151,000 km (calculated). If an Indian family car covers 10,000 to 12,000 km a year (an assumption), break-even is twelve to fifteen years away (calculated), so lightweighting pays little for such a car.

The result changes with the use. An aeroplane carries its own weight all the way, and the cost of fuel per kilogram saved is far higher, which is why airframes are full of aluminium and carbon composite (see the Aeroplane and Carbon fibre and composite parts entries). For an electric bus the answer depends on the grid: each kWh saved avoids whatever mix of coal and renewables supplied it, so the same kilogram saves a different amount of carbon in different states. A building frame never moves, so lightness saves nothing in use and cost and embodied carbon decide.

Data Worked estimate 8: when does a lighter panel repay its extra carbon in a petrol car?
ItemAluminium panelComposite panel
Mass saved against the 10 kg steel panel5.1 kg7.0 kg
Fuel saved at 0.3 litre per 100 km per 100 kg0.015 litre per 100 km (calculated)0.021 litre per 100 km (calculated)
Over 200,000 km (2,000 units of 100 km)31 litres (calculated)42 litres (calculated)
CO2 avoided at 2.3 kg per litreabout 71 kg (calculated)about 96 kg (calculated)
Extra carbon to make, against steelabout 52 kgabout 73 kg
Break-even distanceabout 147,000 km (calculated)about 151,000 km (calculated)

The ifeu study gives 0.24 litre per 100 km per 100 kg without engine downsizing and 0.32 with it; the value varies with the vehicle and driving. Use the result for orders of magnitude only.

Source: ifeu, Energy savings by light-weighting: 2016 update; carbon values from Part 3 sources, fuel saving per 100 kg and 200,000 km car life
  • ifeu, Energy savings by light-weighting: 2016 update (Heidelberg, December 2016), for the International Aluminium Institute · petrol car, mixed driving: 0.24 litre per 100 km per 100 kg, 0.32 with powertrain resizing; 200,000 km family-car life, https://international-aluminium.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/Energy-savings-by-light-weighting.pdf

See it in the table

Al AluminiumSt SteelCO2 Carbon dioxideEl Electricity

Check your understanding

For a plate that must resist bending with a given stiffness, which index ranks materials by mass?

Stiffness goes with E x thickness cubed, so thickness is fixed by E^(1/3) and mass is density x thickness. The lowest density / E^(1/3) gives the lightest panel.

Why is the 0.52 t CO2e per tonne figure for recycled aluminium not the whole story?

It is a gate-to-gate figure for remelting. The IAI itself says it should not be read as the footprint of recycled aluminium, because the scrap came from primary metal in the first place.

A lighter part saves 80 kg of CO2 over a car's life but costs 50 kg more to make. For a car that is driven only a quarter of the expected distance:

A quarter of the distance saves a quarter of 80 kg, which is 20 kg, below the extra 50 kg. The material that wins on a heavily used vehicle can lose on a lightly used one.
← Part 2: Why things get cheaper: learning, scale and standardsMark read · Part 4: Optimising, Pareto fronts and the price of margin →