Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Earth's surface: land, water, ice and erosion: Rivers, deltas and the water underground

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 19: Earth's surface: land, water, ice and erosion Part 3 of 6

Rivers, deltas and the water underground

Water runs over the land and through it, cutting valleys and building deltas above, filling the gaps between grains below. This part follows both, and ends with how India is drawing down its aquifers and how a pair of satellites measured it.

3.1 A river carries what its speed allows, and the load grows steeply as the flow quickens

After a monsoon storm a stream turns brown, and a few weeks later it runs clear. The difference is speed. Moving water pushes on grains of sand and stone, and the faster it moves, the larger the grains it can lift and roll. A river carries its load in three forms: dissolved ions from chemical weathering, fine suspended silt and clay held up by turbulence, and a bed load of sand and gravel that bounces and rolls along the bottom.

The link between speed and load is steep. The largest particle that a stream can move rises roughly with the square of its speed. Weight rises with the cube of size, so the weight that can be moved rises with about the sixth power of speed. Doubling the speed makes a stream able to move stones about 64 times heavier. That is why a flood does most of the work in a river's life.

Four quantities describe a stream. Gradient is its slope. Velocity is how fast the water moves. Discharge is the volume passing a point each second, equal to velocity x cross-sectional area: a channel 200 m wide and 4 m deep flowing at 1.5 m/s carries 200 x 4 x 1.5 = 1,200 cubic metres a second (calculated). Load is the sediment carried. Every river cuts down towards a base level, for most the sea.

High in the Himalaya the Alaknanda runs steep and fast and cuts a narrow V-shaped gorge, with rapids where it crosses hard bands of rock that resist wear. With time a river smooths its long profile into a graded curve, steep near the source and gentle near the sea. On the plains it swings from side to side, wearing the outer bank of each bend, where the water is fastest, and dropping sand on the inner bank. Bends grow into meanders and may be cut off as oxbow lakes. In a flood the river spills over and slows, dropping coarse sand beside the channel as low natural levees and fine silt across the floodplain. Sediment that travels far ends up sorted, its grains of one size.

Each river drains a basin, fed by tributaries and bounded by high ground called a divide. The Kosi, which leaves the Himalaya on a steep slope heavy with sand, carries 45 to 50 million tonnes of sediment a year at Baltara.

Data Worked estimate: stream speed and the stone it can move
Stream speedRelative to 1 m/sLargest stone (size rises as speed squared)Weight that can move (speed to the sixth power)
1 m/s11 x1 x
2 m/s24 x (calculated)64 x (calculated)
3 m/s39 x (calculated)729 x (calculated)

A rule of proportion, not an exact law. If a 1 m/s current moves a 100 g pebble, a 3 m/s flood can in principle move 0.1 kg x 729 = about 73 kg (calculated).

Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 25, 'Surface Processes'; Standard physical values and rules of thumb used in the paper estimates, rock density about 2.65 t per cubic metre, settled sediment about 1.6 t per cubic metre, sea water about 1,025 kg per cubic metre, dry salt about 2,160 kg per cubic metre, g = 9.8 m/s2, land area about 1.49 x 10^14 square metres; the rule that stream competence rises with about the sixth power of speed; the Bruun rule that shoreline retreat is roughly sea-level rise divided by shore slope
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 25, 'Surface Processes'
  • Central Water Commission, Bhagirath (2021 annual issue), paper by N. N. Rai and Rajesh Kumar · web
  • Standard physical values and rules of thumb used in the paper estimates · rock density about 2.65 t per cubic metre, settled sediment about 1.6 t per cubic metre, sea water about 1,025 kg per cubic metre, dry salt about 2,160 kg per cubic metre, g = 9.8 m/s2, land area about 1.49 x 10^14 square metres; the rule that stream competence rises with about the sixth power of speed; the Bruun rule that shoreline retreat is roughly sea-level rise divided by shore slope

3.2 Where a river slows it drops its load, and the Ganga and Brahmaputra have built the largest delta on Earth

When a river enters a lake or sea its speed falls to almost nothing, so it can no longer carry its load. The coarse sand drops first and the fine clay last. A fan-shaped body of sediment builds out into the water. This is a delta, from the Greek letter.

The Ganga and Brahmaputra, with the Meghna, deliver about a billion tonnes of sediment a year to the Bengal Basin, according to a standard study. Sampling at stations in Bangladesh puts the Ganges at 262 million tonnes a year and the Brahmaputra at 387 million. The land and seabed built from it, the combined subaerial and submarine delta, cover about 140,000 square kilometres. Roughly 30 per cent of the sediment stays on the shelf in the subaqueous delta, and roughly another 30 per cent runs down the Swatch of No Ground canyon to the Bengal Fan, the vast fan of sediment on the deep sea floor.

The delta is also the Sundarbans, the largest mangrove forest in the world, and the land behind it is among the most densely settled in the world. Its land survives only if sediment arrives faster than the ground sinks and the sea rises. Dams and barrages upstream trap sediment, and water drawn from the ground makes the delta soil sink faster.

3.3 Groundwater sits in the pores of rock, and porosity and permeability decide whether a well can use it

After rain, water soaks into dry ground, which is infiltration, and what the ground cannot take runs off. The water that soaks in sinks until it reaches a zone where every gap between grains is full. The top of that saturated zone is the water table, and the water in it is groundwater. Above it lies the unsaturated zone, where the gaps hold both air and water.

A well needs two things from the ground. It needs storage, measured as porosity, the share of the volume that is open space. And it needs the water to move towards it, measured as permeability, the ease of flow from gap to gap. The two differ. A clay may be 40 to 50 per cent empty space, but its flat flakes leave tiny, poorly joined gaps, so it gives water up at a crawl. Gravel has less space but wide, linked gaps. A layer that stores and yields useful water is an aquifer, and one that blocks flow is an aquitard. An unconfined aquifer is open to the surface. A confined one lies sealed under an aquitard with its water under pressure, so a well into it may flow unpumped.

Groundwater creeps from high ground to low at centimetres to metres a day and may stay underground for centuries. It emerges at springs, and in the dry season it seeps into river beds and keeps rivers flowing. A well pumped hard draws the water table down in a cone of depression, and wells can pull each other dry. Where fine layers drain, they compact and the land subsides.

Only part of the water drains out, the specific yield. India's assessment norms put it at 12 to 18 per cent in sandy alluvium and 5 to 12 per cent in silty or clayey alluvium. So lowering the water table 1 metre under a square kilometre of sandy alluvium frees about 150,000 cubic metres (calculated at 15 per cent), not a million.

3.4 Dissolving limestone makes caves, and India's aquifers are being drawn down faster than rain refills them

Limestone shows another effect of groundwater. Rainwater and soil water carry dissolved carbon dioxide, a weak acid, and it dissolves calcium carbonate along joints. The cracks widen into passages and caverns. Where the roof falls, a sinkhole opens. Terrain with caves, sinkholes and streams that vanish underground is karst. Water dripping into a cave loses carbon dioxide to the air and leaves calcite behind, which builds stalactites from the roof and stalagmites from the floor. Meghalaya has some of India's longest caves.

On the plains of north India the concern is not caves but the water table. The 2024 national assessment by the Central Ground Water Board gives recharge of 446.90 billion cubic metres a year and an extractable resource of 406.19. Extraction is 245.64 billion cubic metres, a stage of extraction of 60.47 per cent (extraction / extractable resource). That average hides a spread: of 6,746 assessment units, 751 are over-exploited and 206 critical.

How do we know the loss is real across such a large region? Wells are patchy. In 2009 Matthew Rodell, Isabella Velicogna and James Famiglietti used the GRACE satellites, a pair launched in 2002 that fly one behind the other and measure tiny changes in the distance between them. Where there is more mass below, the gravity is a little stronger and the leading satellite pulls ahead. Changes in the pull from month to month track changes in the mass of water. After removing soil moisture and other effects, they found that groundwater under Rajasthan, Punjab and Haryana with Delhi fell by a mean of 4.0 cm of water a year from August 2002 to October 2008, a net loss of 109 cubic kilometres, and that human use was almost entirely to blame.

Data Worked estimate: what the GRACE loss means
StepValueWorking
Loss per yearAbout 17.7 km3 (calculated)109 km3 / 6.2 years (August 2002 to October 2008)
Depth of water lost4.0 cm a yearMeasured by GRACE
Area impliedAbout 440,000 km2 (calculated)17.7 x 10^9 m3 / 0.040 m = 4.4 x 10^11 m2, the three states with Delhi
Water-table fall, specific yield 0.1About 0.4 m a year (calculated)0.040 m / 0.1
Wells reportedUp to about 0.3 m a yearAbout 1 foot a year
Share of India's 2024 extractionAbout 7 per cent (calculated)17.7 / 245.64

The water-table fall depends on the specific yield assumed, so it is only a consistency check, but it lands close to what wells showed.

Source: Rodell, Velicogna and Famiglietti, Satellite-based estimates of groundwater depletion in India, Nature 460 (2009), abstract via India Environment Portal and report by UC Irvine, https://indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/articles/satellite-based-estimates-of-groundwater-depletion-in-india and https://news.uci.edu/2009/08/12/india-groundwater (Rajasthan, Punjab and Haryana with Delhi; mean depletion 4.0 plus or minus 1.0 cm of water a year, 17.7 plus or minus 4.5 cubic km a year; August 2002 to October 2008; net loss 109 cubic km; water tables falling up to about 1 foot a year; human use almost entirely to blame); Ministry of Jal Shakti and Central Ground Water Board, Dynamic Ground Water Resource Assessment Report 2024 (released 31 December 2024), as reported by 5 Dariya News and Factly, https://www.5dariyanews.com/news/447828-C-R-Patil-Releases-Dynamic-Ground-Water-Resource-Assessment-Report-of-the-Country-for-the-Year-2024 and https://factly.in/data-marginal-decrease-in-annual-ground-water-recharge-in-2024-with-minimal-increase-in-extraction (recharge 446.90 bcm; extractable 406.19 bcm; extraction 245.64 bcm; stage of extraction 60.47 per cent; of 6,746 units, 751 over-exploited, 206 critical, 711 semi-critical, 4,951 safe, 127 saline); Ministry of Water Resources, Ground Water Resource Estimation Methodology (report of the Ground Water Resource Estimation Committee, 2009), https://cgwb.gov.in/sites/default/files/inline-files/GEC97.pdf (specific yield: sandy alluvial areas 12 to 18 per cent; silty or clayey alluvial areas 5 to 12 per cent)

See it in the table

H₂O WaterCO2 Carbon dioxide

Check your understanding

If the speed of a stream doubles, the weight of the largest stone it can move rises by about

The stone size rises with speed squared, and weight with size cubed, giving speed to the sixth power: 2 to the sixth is 64.

A delta forms where a river meets still water because

Carrying power falls steeply as speed falls, so the load is dropped, coarse grains first.

A material with high porosity but tiny, unconnected pores, such as clay, is

Porosity says how much water is stored, but permeability says how fast it moves. Clay holds water and yields very little.
← Part 2: Rock into soil, and soil down the slopeMark read · Part 4: Ice: glaciers, ice ages and the Himalayan retreat →