Momentum, energy and why they are conserved: Collisions: two bookkeepers, and how they were found
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 3: Momentum, energy and why they are conserved Part 3 of 6Collisions: two bookkeepers, and how they were found
A collision is the cleanest test of momentum and energy together, because the forces are huge, brief and unknown, yet the outcome can still be predicted. This part uses momentum to settle sticky collisions, adds kinetic energy to settle bouncy ones, and then tells how seventeenth century natural philosophers found the rules and argued about which quantity mattered.
3.1 Every collision keeps total momentum, which is enough to predict how sticky ones end
In a collision two bodies meet, push on each other with huge forces for a very short time, and part or stay joined. During that instant, ordinary outside forces such as friction on the rails are tiny beside the forces between the bodies. So the pair behaves as a closed system, and its total momentum just after equals the total just before. That is true whether the collision is a gentle coupling or a violent crash.
If the bodies stick, momentum alone gives the answer. After joining there is one body, with the combined mass, and one unknown speed. A 60 kg kabaddi raider running at 6 m/s is caught by a 90 kg defender standing still, and the two move off together. The momentum before is 60 x 6 = 360 kg m/s. After, the 150 kg pair has the same momentum, so its speed is 360 / 150 = 2.4 m/s. The raider loses three fifths of his speed and the defender goes from rest to 2.4 m/s.
The direction matters. Two bodies approaching each other have momenta of opposite sign, and the total is the difference. If a 3 kg trolley at 2 m/s meets a 1 kg trolley at 6 m/s head on, the totals are equal and opposite, and if they stick, they stop dead. The engineering module Force, motion and energy applies the same bookkeeping to vehicles that meet in the road and to crumple zones.
| Case | Before | After | Check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Raider (60 kg, 6 m/s) is held by a defender (90 kg, at rest) | 60 x 6 = 360 kg m/s | 150 kg at 2.4 m/s = 360 kg m/s | equal |
| Equal 2 kg trolleys, one at 3 m/s hits one at rest, bouncing perfectly | 2 x 3 = 6 kg m/s | first at rest, second at 3 m/s = 6 kg m/s | equal |
| 3 kg at 2 m/s meets 1 kg at 6 m/s head on, they stick | 3 x 2 minus 1 x 6 = 0 | joined pair at rest = 0 | equal |
Direction is kept by giving one direction a plus sign and the other a minus sign.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 4, 'Momentum and Energy'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 4, 'Momentum and Energy'
3.2 Kinetic energy tells bouncy collisions from sticky ones, and the difference becomes heat and sound
Momentum is enough for a collision where bodies stick. For a bounce it is not, because there are two unknown final speeds and only one momentum equation. A second rule is needed. In a perfectly elastic collision the total kinetic energy is also unchanged. Two equal trolleys give the clean case: the moving one stops and the one at rest takes off at the same speed. Billiard balls and steel balls on strings come close.
Newton's cradle shows how strict this is. Lift one ball and let it strike the row. One ball leaves the far end at the original speed. Why not two balls at half speed? Momentum would allow it: 2m x v/2 = m x v. But the kinetic energy would then be ½ x 2m x (v/2)², which is only half the original ½ m v². The only outcome that keeps both quantities is one ball out at speed v, which is what you see.
When the bodies stick, the loss shows up. The kabaddi pair above had ½ x 60 x 6² = 1,080 J before and ½ x 150 x 2.4² = 432 J after (calculated). The missing 648 J, three fifths of the total, went into heat in muscles and joints, sound and the squeezing of bodies. Most real collisions fall between the two extremes, and engineers describe them with a number between 0 and 1, the ratio of the separating speed to the approaching speed. Perfect sticking gives 0 and a perfect bounce gives 1.
| Outcome | Momentum afterwards | Kinetic energy afterwards | Allowed? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 ball leaves at v | m v | ½ m v² | yes, both kept |
| 2 balls leave at v/2 | m v | ¼ m v² (half is missing) | no, energy lost |
| 3 balls leave at v/3 | m v | ⅙ m v² (two thirds missing) | no, energy lost |
Each ball has mass m. Only the first outcome obeys both rules.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 4, 'Momentum and Energy'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 4, 'Momentum and Energy'
3.3 Descartes counted speed without direction; Huygens, Wallis and Wren found the working rules
René Descartes, in his Principles of Philosophy of 1644, proposed that the total 'quantity of motion' in the world stays constant, and measured it as size times speed. His rules for collisions disagreed with what happened on the table. Christiaan Huygens saw why. Speed has no direction, so Descartes added things that should have been subtracted. Huygens's notes of 1652 and a manuscript of 1656 show the principle working once motion is counted with direction, which is velocity. That is momentum as we now use it.
The Royal Society in London took up the collision problem in 1668 and asked John Wallis, Christopher Wren and Huygens to examine it. Their answers, worked out separately, reached the Society between November 1668 and January 1669. They were printed in 1669, Wallis's and Wren's in the Philosophical Transactions and Huygens's in the Journal des Sçavans in Paris. For bouncy collisions Huygens also showed that mass times speed squared, summed over the bodies, stays the same. Leibniz later called that quantity vis viva, 'living force'.
A long quarrel followed over which measure was the true one. In 1722 Willem 's Gravesande dropped brass balls into soft clay and found that two balls left identical dents when mass times height of fall was the same. The speed gained in a fall goes as the square root of the height, so equal dents meant equal mass times speed squared, not equal mass times speed. Émilie du Châtelet's Institutions de physique of 1740, revised in 1742, carried the argument to a wide audience.
The quarrel faded once people saw that both measures were right. Impulse acts over time and changes momentum. Work acts over distance and changes kinetic energy. They answer different questions about the same motion.
| Property | Momentum | Kinetic energy |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | mass x velocity | ½ x mass x speed² |
| Has a direction? | yes, a vector | no, a plain number |
| Changed by | impulse: force x time | work: force x distance |
| Doubling the speed | doubles it | quadruples it |
| Kept in a sticky collision? | yes | no, some becomes heat |
| Kept in a perfectly bouncy collision? | yes | yes |
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 4, 'Momentum and Energy'
- Descartes, Principia philosophiae (Amsterdam, 1644); Huygens's notes of 1652 and manuscript of 1656, as described in 'On Huygens' derivation of the laws of elastic collisions' (arXiv:2512.22842) · web
- Royal Society Picture Library, Huygens, 'The motion of bodies resulting from impact' · web
- Encyclopedia.com, Christiaan Huygens Makes Fundamental Contributions to Mechanics, Astronomy, Horology, and Optics · web
- Europa-Universität Flensburg, Histolab: demonstration experiment on the model of 's Gravesande · brass balls dropped from different heights into clay; equal imprints mean equal effects, https://www.uni-flensburg.de/en/working-group-physics/histolab/thematical-subsections/mechanics/demonstration-experiment-on-kinematics-on-the-model-of-s-gravesande
- Project Vox, Émilie du Châtelet · web
See it in the table
St SteelCheck your understanding
A 2,000 kg trolley at 3 m/s runs into a stationary 1,000 kg trolley and they couple. What is their speed?
Momentum before is 2,000 x 3 = 6,000 kg m/s. After, 3,000 kg moves with the same momentum, so the speed is 6,000 / 3,000 = 2 m/s.In a Newton's cradle, why do two balls not leave at half the speed after one strikes?
Two balls at half speed would conserve momentum but have only half the kinetic energy. Only one ball at the original speed keeps both.What was wrong with Descartes's quantity of motion?
Using speed alone, opposite motions added instead of cancelling. Counting velocity, with direction, gives momentum, which is conserved.