Momentum, energy and why they are conserved: The neutrino: the case that saved conservation
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 3: Momentum, energy and why they are conserved Part 6 of 6The neutrino: the case that saved conservation
In the 1920s a clean experiment seemed to show energy going missing in radioactive decay. Some of the best physicists were ready to give up conservation. Wolfgang Pauli proposed instead that an invisible particle was carrying the energy away. It took twenty-six years to catch it. The story shows how a well-tested law is tested, defended and, in the end, put to use.
6.1 In beta decay electrons came out with a spread of energies, and energy seemed to be missing
Some atomic nuclei are unstable and change into a different element by firing out a fast electron. This is beta decay, described in the Radioactivity node. When a body splits into two pieces, momentum conservation fixes the split. The pieces must move off in opposite directions with equal and opposite momenta, and energy conservation then fixes how the available energy is shared. Every decay of the same kind should therefore send out an electron with the same energy.
That is not what was seen. The electrons came out with a continuous spread of energies, from nearly nothing up to a maximum. In 1927 Charles Ellis and William Wooster studied radium E, now called bismuth-210, and gave direct proof that the spread was real and not an error of measurement. Most electrons carried far less than the maximum energy that the decay seemed to release.
Some physicists, Niels Bohr among them, suggested that energy might be conserved only on average, not in each individual decay. It was a serious idea. The data seemed to demand it, and it was difficult to refute without finding the missing energy.
| Option | Who held it | What it would cost | Testable? |
|---|---|---|---|
| The measurements are wrong | early sceptics | nothing, if true | settled: Ellis and Wooster 1927 showed the spread was real |
| Energy is conserved only on average | Bohr and others | gives up an exact law, and its link to time symmetry | no clear new prediction |
| An unseen particle shares the energy | Pauli, 1930 | one new, nearly undetectable particle | yes, if it can ever be caught |
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 4, 'Momentum and Energy'
- Neutrino history (in2p3), energy non-conservation hypothesis for the beta decay spectrum · web
6.2 Pauli's 'desperate remedy' of 1930 saved the law by adding a particle nobody could see
On 4 December 1930 Wolfgang Pauli wrote an open letter to the 'radioactive ladies and gentlemen' gathered at a meeting in Tübingen that he could not attend. He called his idea a desperate remedy. Suppose, he wrote, that each beta decay also sends out an electrically neutral particle of spin one half, of tiny mass, the same order as the electron and in any case not above one hundredth of the mass of a proton. The electron and this particle together carry the fixed total energy. Which of them carries more varies from decay to decay, and so the electron's energy is spread.
The idea fits the evidence at once. It restores energy and momentum conservation, and it explains the spread. It also explains why nobody had seen the particle: with no electric charge and very weak interactions, it would pass through matter almost untouched.
The name was a muddle at first. Pauli called his particle a neutron. In 1932 James Chadwick found a neutral particle in the nucleus and used the name, but it was far too heavy to be Pauli's. Enrico Fermi then proposed the name neutrino, 'little neutral one'.
| Decay | Electron energy | Other body or bodies | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Two bodies, always | 1.00 every time | tiny recoil of the nucleus | 1.00 |
| Three bodies, decay A | 0.30 | 0.70 with the neutrino | 1.00 |
| Three bodies, decay B | 0.90 | 0.10 with the neutrino | 1.00 |
| Three bodies, decay C | 0.60 | 0.40 with the neutrino | 1.00 |
These are illustrative numbers. The real maximum is fixed by the decay, and the measured spread runs from near zero to that maximum.
Source: Pauli, W., letter of 4 December 1930 to the radioactive ladies and gentlemen (English text), https://lappweb.in2p3.fr/neutrinos/aplettre.html (neutral particles, spin 1/2, mass not above 0.01 proton masses; 'desperate remedy')- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 4, 'Momentum and Energy'
- Pauli, W., letter of 4 December 1930 to the radioactive ladies and gentlemen (English text) · web
- Symmetry magazine, Neutrino invention (March 2007) · web
6.3 Cowan and Reines caught the neutrino in 1956, and the law that was nearly dropped became a tool
To catch a particle that crosses the Earth almost untouched you need a huge supply of it and a clever signature. Clyde Cowan and Frederick Reines used the flood of antineutrinos from a nuclear reactor, at Savannah River in South Carolina, and a tank of target material. In the rare event that an antineutrino struck a proton, it left a positron and a neutron. The positron met an electron and the pair became two gamma rays at once, which the detector registered as flashes of light. The neutron was captured by cadmium about 15 microseconds later and gave a second burst. Two signals with that fixed delay were the sign of one capture.
On 14 June 1956 they sent Pauli a telegram announcing the discovery, and the report was published in Science on 20 July 1956. Twenty-six years had passed since the letter. Reines shared the 1995 Nobel Prize in Physics for the work.
The lesson reaches beyond particle physics. A law this deep in the structure of physics was not abandoned, even when the data seemed to cut against it. A missing quantity was taken as a clue to a missing thing, and the clue led to a new particle. Had the search failed over decades, the idea of Bohr might have regained force. Neutrinos have since become tools, carrying information from the Sun's core and from exploding stars.
produces a positron and a neutron
2 Positron meets an electrontwo gamma-ray photons at once: the first signal
3 Neutron is captured by cadmiumabout 15 microseconds later: the second signal
Outputs A delayed pair of flashescounted as one antineutrino eventThe fixed delay of the second flash separated true events from stray background.
Source: Neutrino history (in2p3), experimental discovery, https://neutrino-history.in2p3.fr/experimental-discovery/ (Savannah River 1956; 15 microsecond delay; telegram 14 June; Science 124, 20 July 1956)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 4, 'Momentum and Energy'
- Neutrino history (in2p3), experimental discovery · web
- NobelPrize.org, The Nobel Prize in Physics 1995 · web
- Symmetry magazine, Neutrino invention (March 2007) · web
See it in the table
Bi BismuthCd CadmiumCheck your understanding
Why did beta decay seem to break energy conservation?
A two-body decay should send out the electron with a fixed energy. The measured spread, with less energy on average, looked like energy going missing.What was the strongest scientific argument for Pauli's neutral particle over Bohr's 'conserved on average' idea?
The particle hypothesis preserved the symmetry-based conservation law and could be tested, while the average idea gave up the law without new predictions.How did Cowan and Reines recognise an antineutrino reaction?
The positron gave two simultaneous photons, then the neutron's capture by cadmium gave a second burst about 15 microseconds later. The fixed delay marked a true event.