Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Momentum, energy and why they are conserved: Why momentum and energy are conserved: symmetry

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 3: Momentum, energy and why they are conserved Part 5 of 6

Why momentum and energy are conserved: symmetry

So far conservation has been a finding: nobody has seen momentum or energy vanish. This part asks why nature should keep such accounts. The answer, found by Emmy Noether in 1918, is that each conservation law is the shadow of a symmetry: the laws of nature do not change with time, or from place to place. The argument can be followed without algebra.

5.1 A conserved quantity stays fixed through any change, and its existence needs an explanation

Most things are not conserved. The number of cars on a road changes, so does the money in a wallet, and so does the number of people in a room. A quantity is conserved if a single number, worked out for a closed system, is the same before and after, however violent the change in between. That nature has such numbers at all is surprising, and that two of them, momentum and energy, work in every field from collisions to chemistry to stars calls for an explanation.

For momentum, the explanation so far is the third law: forces come in equal and opposite pairs. For energy, the explanation was the idea of potential energy. Gravity and springs depend only on positions, so lifting and then lowering a body along any path returns exactly the work you put in. Both explanations leave a question. Why do forces come in equal pairs, and why do they depend only on positions? Why not otherwise?

The plain-words answer is this. Suppose gravity were a little stronger on Mondays than on Tuesdays. You could lift a weight on a Tuesday, when it is cheap, and lower it on a Monday, when it gives back more. Repeat each week and you gain energy for nothing. Energy conservation says that no such gain exists. That is the same as saying that the laws of nature are the same on every day. Conservation of energy is that sameness, seen from the other side.

5.2 Noether's theorem links each conserved quantity to a symmetry of the laws

A symmetry, in this sense, is a change you can make without changing the physics. Move an experiment to another room, start it an hour later, or turn it to face another way, and the laws still give the same result. Emmy Noether proved in 1918 that every smooth symmetry of this kind brings a conserved quantity with it, and that a conserved quantity points back to a symmetry. She presented the result to the Göttingen Mathematical Society on 23 July 1918. David Hilbert and Felix Klein had asked her to look at a puzzle about energy in Einstein's general relativity, and her theorem answered it.

The three that matter here are these. Symmetry under a shift in time gives conservation of energy. The laws do not depend on the date, so the energy total cannot drift. Symmetry under a shift in space gives conservation of momentum. The laws do not depend on location, so a closed system cannot push itself along, since the internal forces cannot favour one place over another. Symmetry under rotation gives conservation of angular momentum, which governs spinning bodies and appears in the Gyroscopic effect node.

The symmetries are testable. Joule's experiment gave the same exchange rate in different seasons and in other people's laboratories. A collision on a train gives the same momentum bookkeeping as one on a platform. Laboratories everywhere have been testing time and place symmetry for centuries without meaning to.

Data Symmetry and what it conserves
What you may change without changing the physicsSymmetryConserved quantityEveryday sign of it
The time you startshift in timeenergyJoule's result is the same in any month
The place you standshift in spacemomentuma boat recoils the same way in any harbour
The direction you facerotationangular momentuma spinning wheel keeps its axis whichever way it points

Noether's theorem also yields electric charge conservation from another kind of symmetry, not covered here.

Source: Science News, In her short life, mathematician Emmy Noether changed the face of physics, https://www.sciencenews.org/article/emmy-noether-theorem-legacy-physics-math (lecture of 23 July 1918 to the Gottingen Mathematical Society; Hilbert and Klein; time, space and rotation symmetries)

5.3 A conservation law predicts outcomes without the details, and its apparent failure points to something hidden

Because conservation laws come from such deep symmetries, they are among the sturdiest things in science. They are also a shortcut. You found the slide speed above without knowing the shape of the slide. You found the kabaddi pair's speed without knowing a single detail of the forces in the tackle. Particle physicists apply the same trick to collisions in which new particles appear, using only the totals of energy and momentum.

They also work as a detector. If a measurement appears to break a law with this much support, the first suspicion is a missing part: something unseen has taken away the missing amount. That is a cheaper hypothesis than giving up the symmetry, and it has the great virtue that it can be tested by searching. The next part tells the best case.

There are limits and refinements. Special relativity shows that mass is itself a store of energy, so the two older laws of conserved mass and conserved energy merge into one, as the Mass-energy equivalence node explains. Burning 1 kg of bituminous coal releases about 25.8 million joules, so the lost mass is 25.8 million divided by 9 x 10¹⁶, about 3 x 10⁻¹⁰ kg (calculated). That is too small to weigh, which is why conservation of mass seemed perfect in chemistry. On the scale of the whole expanding universe, the time symmetry is no longer exact, and cosmologists treat the energy of the cosmos with care.

Data Worked estimate: how much mass does burning coal lose?
StepWorkingResult
Energy released by 1 kg of bituminous coalIPCC default net calorific value, 25.8 MJ/kg2.58 x 10⁷ J
Speed of light squared(3 x 10⁸)²9 x 10¹⁶ m²/s²
Mass change2.58 x 10⁷ / 9 x 10¹⁶about 2.9 x 10⁻¹⁰ kg (calculated)
As a fraction of the original kilogram2.9 x 10⁻¹⁰ / 1about 3 parts in ten billion

The figure is for 'other bituminous coal'. High-ash Indian power-station coal holds much less energy per kilogram, so its mass loss is smaller still.

Source: IPCC 2006 Guidelines default net calorific values, as tabulated in Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066, Annex VI, Table 1, https://legislation.gov.uk/eur/2018/2066/annex/VI/2020-12-31/data.xht (other bituminous coal 25.8 TJ/Gg; anthracite 26.7; sub-bituminous 18.9; lignite 11.9)

See it in the table

Tea Tea

Check your understanding

In plain words, why does conservation of energy follow from time symmetry?

If the rules differed from day to day, a cycle of actions could return a net gain. Equal laws on every day rule out such gains, which is conservation of energy.

Which pairing of symmetry and conserved quantity is correct?

Space symmetry gives momentum, time symmetry gives energy, and rotation symmetry gives angular momentum.

A student says, 'Symmetry means the world looks the same everywhere.' What is the fault?

The relevant symmetry is that the same laws apply everywhere and at all times. Local conditions can differ without breaking it.
← Part 4: Conservation of energy: heat, life and machinesMark read · Part 6: The neutrino: the case that saved conservation →