Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Motion and force: from Aristotle to Newton: Why Aristotle was wrong and Galileo was right: the idea of inertia

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 2: Motion and force: from Aristotle to Newton Part 1 of 6

Why Aristotle was wrong and Galileo was right: the idea of inertia

For about two thousand years the best-educated people believed that a moving thing needs a continual push to keep moving. It matches daily life: a cart stops when the bullocks stop. This part follows how that belief was tested, why it fails, and what replaced it. The replacement, inertia, is the foundation of everything else in this module.

1.1 Aristotle's rule that motion needs a mover fits daily life and fails at the edges

Push a steel plate across a kitchen floor and it stops the moment you stop pushing. Pull a handcart and it halts when you let go of the handle. From cases like these, Aristotle (384 to 322 BCE) built a physics around a simple rule: a body moves only while something keeps pushing it. He sorted motion into two kinds. Natural motion is a body heading for its proper place: earthy things such as stones sink, smoke and fire rise, and the heavens turn in endless circles under rules of their own. Violent motion is anything imposed from outside by a push or a pull, as when a man drags a cart. He also held that heavier things fall faster than lighter ones.

Its weak point was the thrown stone. Once a stone leaves your hand, nothing touches it, yet it flies on. Aristotle proposed that the air parts in front of the stone and then rushes round to push it from behind. Later writers found that unconvincing. In the sixth century John Philoponus of Alexandria argued instead that the thrower hands the stone a power of motion that it carries with it. In the eleventh century Ibn Sina called the gift an inclination, larger for heavier bodies. In the fourteenth century Jean Buridan named it impetus, and made it grow with both the weight and the speed of the body.

These thinkers still gave the moving stone an inner cause, so they did not yet have inertia. The question that mattered was not what keeps a body going but what changes its motion, and answering it meant removing friction, in thought if not in fact.

1.2 Galileo's ramps and thought experiments showed that motion continues by itself

Galileo (1564 to 1642) did two things that Aristotle's followers had not done together. He measured, and he imagined a world with the friction removed.

His key argument began from something anyone can see. Let a ball run down a smooth slope and up a facing one, and it climbs to nearly the height it started from. Tilt the second slope less, and the ball has to travel farther before it regains that height. Lay the second track flat, and the ball has no height to regain, so nothing in the geometry tells it to stop. Real balls do stop, but because of rubbing and air, not because motion needs a cause. This is the idea of inertia: a body keeps its state of motion, at rest or moving straight at constant speed, unless something acts on it.

To see what falling bodies do, Galileo slowed them down on a long incline. In Two New Sciences (1638) he describes timing the runs by weighing the water that flowed from a vessel while the ball rolled. Distances covered in equal successive intervals came out in the ratio 1 to 3 to 5 to 7. Adding up gives totals of 1, 4, 9 and 16 units, the squares of the numbers of intervals. So distance grows as the square of the time, which is what steady acceleration produces. A museum reconstruction times the ball against the swings of a pendulum and finds the same odd-number pattern. The better-known story, of Galileo dropping balls from the Leaning Tower of Pisa, comes only from a biography by his late assistant Vincenzo Viviani. Galileo's own books do not mention the tower, and historians treat the scene as legend.

Galileo also used inertia to defend a moving Earth. Objectors said that if the Earth turned, a stone dropped from a tower would land far to the west. In his Dialogue of 1632 he answered with a ship: a stone dropped from a mast lands at the foot of the mast, whether the ship is moored or sailing smoothly, because the stone shares the ship's motion. The same holds for the stone, the tower and the turning ground.

Data Galileo's pattern for a ball on a slope
IntervalDistance in that intervalTotal distance so farTotal as a square
1st1 unit1 unit1 x 1
2nd3 units4 units2 x 2
3rd5 units9 units3 x 3
4th7 units16 units4 x 4

Odd numbers added in turn always give squares. That is why steady acceleration gives distance proportional to time squared.

Source: Museo Galileo, Inclined plane (reconstruction of Galileo's experiment), https://brunelleschi.imss.fi.it/itineraries/multimedia/InclinedPlane.html

1.3 Mass measures inertia, and weight is a separate thing that changes with place

If inertia is a body's reluctance to change its motion, we need a number for it. That number is mass. Try shoving an empty pushcart and then the same cart loaded with sacks of grain. The loaded cart is much harder to start and much harder to stop, even on a perfectly level road where weight is not the issue. Mass is the quantity that sets this resistance to a change of motion. It is measured in kilograms.

Mass is not weight. Weight is the force with which a planet pulls on a body, and it is measured in newtons. Near Earth's surface the pull is about 9.8 newtons on every kilogram, so weight is mass times 9.8 N/kg (often rounded to 10 for estimates). A 60 kg person weighs about 590 N on Earth. On the Moon, where surface gravity is 1.62 m/s², about 0.165 of Earth's, the same person weighs 60 x 1.62 = 97 N (calculated), yet pushing that person across a smooth floor is just as hard as at home, because the mass has not changed.

Mass is not size either. A kilogram of iron fits in a fist, while a kilogram of puffed rice fills a shopping bag. The mass packed into each cubic metre is the density: about 1,000 kg for water and close to 7,900 kg for iron.

There is a second, deeper point. The mass that resists a push and the mass that is pulled by gravity are measured in two different ways, yet always agree. Inertial mass comes from how hard a body is to accelerate. Gravitational mass comes from how strongly the Earth pulls it. The French satellite MICROSCOPE, in final results published in 2022, found them equal to about one part in 10¹⁵, and general relativity turns this agreement into a principle. For now, we use one word, mass, for both.

See it in the table

H₂O WaterSt SteelRi Rice

Check your understanding

A bullock cart stops soon after the animals stop pulling. What is the best modern explanation?

Friction with the road and the axles acts against the motion. Without a pull to balance it, the net force is backwards and the cart slows. The cart's tendency to keep moving has not gone anywhere.

Galileo's ramp measurements gave distances in equal time intervals in the ratio 1: 3: 5: 7. What does this show?

Totals of 1, 4, 9 and 16 are the squares of the interval numbers. Distance proportional to time squared is the signature of steady acceleration.

An astronaut and her tools travel to the Moon. Which quantity stays the same?

Mass is a measure of inertia and does not depend on place. Weight depends on the local pull and falls on the Moon.
← Module contentsMark read · Part 2: Describing motion: speed, velocity, acceleration and free fall →