Motion and force: from Aristotle to Newton: Forces come in pairs: Newton's third law
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 2: Motion and force: from Aristotle to Newton Part 5 of 6Forces come in pairs: Newton's third law
No force acts alone. Every push or pull is one half of an interaction between two bodies, and the other half acts on the other body. That is the third law. It is easy to misuse, because the two forces of a pair never act on the same body. This part states it, clears up the standard puzzle about why pairs do not cancel, and then shows how animals and rockets move by it.
5.1 A force is half of an interaction, and the two halves are equal, opposite and on different bodies
Sit on a wheeled office chair facing a friend on another, and shove them away. You roll backwards too, though nobody pushed you on purpose. The harder the shove, the faster you both separate. Newton's third law says this is general. Whenever one body exerts a force on a second, the second exerts a force on the first that is equal in size and opposite in direction.
A force is not something a body owns; it is one end of an interaction, and the two forces appear, last and vanish together. Naming them in the form 'A on B' and 'B on A' avoids confusion. Weight, for instance, is the pull of Earth on you. Its partner is the pull of you on Earth, which is equal and upward.
How do we know it is exact? The simplest test is two spring balances hooked together, each held by a different person. Whatever one reads, the other reads the same, whether they pull slowly, quickly or let a trolley hang between them. It also underlies every analysis of a collision and every conservation law of motion, which the next module takes up. No experiment has found an exception for ordinary contact forces.
The partner of the Earth's pull on a falling 1 kg stone is the stone's pull on the Earth, also 9.8 N. Why do we never see the Earth move? Apply the second law. The Earth's acceleration is 9.8 N divided by its mass, about 6 x 10²⁴ kg, which is roughly 1.6 x 10⁻²⁴ m/s². That is about six trillion trillion times smaller than the stone's acceleration (calculated). It is there, but far below any possible measurement.
| Situation | Force on one body | Partner force on the other |
|---|---|---|
| Tractor pulling a trolley | Tractor pulls trolley forward | Trolley pulls tractor backward |
| Magnet and iron nail | Magnet pulls nail | Nail pulls magnet, equally |
| Sun and Earth | Sun pulls Earth | Earth pulls Sun, equally |
| Rocket in flight | Rocket pushes exhaust gas backward | Gas pushes rocket forward |
| Rower | Oar pushes water backward | Water pushes oar, and so the boat, forward |
In each row the two forces act on different bodies, so they never cancel each other's effect on one body.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 3, 'Newton's Laws of Motion'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 3, 'Newton's Laws of Motion'
- NASA NSSDCA, Earth Fact Sheet · web
5.2 Equal forces on two bodies give unequal accelerations, and that explains why pairs do not cancel
A classic puzzle: if a bullock pulls the cart forward and the cart pulls the bullock back with an equal force, how does anything move?
The answer is that the two forces act on different bodies. To decide how one body moves, add up only the forces on that body. Forces on a different body are irrelevant to it. So to analyse the cart, count the bullock's pull forward and the drag of the road backward. If the pull is greater, the cart accelerates forward. To analyse the bullock, count the cart's pull backward and the ground's forward push on the hooves. If that push is larger, the bullock accelerates forward too. The animal gets its help from the ground through friction; on ice it could not push, and would go nowhere.
The reasoning gives a general rule. A pair of forces cancel in their effect on one body only when they both act on that body. Weight and the support force on a book may cancel, but they are not a third-law pair, because both act on the book. The pair of the book's weight is the book pulling the Earth upward.
The same idea decides what counts as a system. Draw a boundary round bullock and cart together and the pull between them is internal: its two halves cancel, and only outside forces, from the ground and the air, can speed the pair up. That is why tugging on your own belt cannot lift you.
The second law then adds the mass. Take a rifle of 4 kg and a bullet of 10 g. When the gas pushes the bullet forward with a force, the bullet pushes the rifle back with the same force. The bullet's mass is 400 times smaller, so its acceleration is 400 times larger. The rifle recoils slowly and weakly while the bullet leaves fast. The same logic explains a small boat drifting backward as you step out of it onto a jetty.
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 3, 'Newton's Laws of Motion'
5.3 Walking, swimming and flying all work by pushing on something and being pushed back
Every animal moves by Newton's third law. It pushes something backward, and the something pushes it forward.
A person walking pushes the ground backward with the foot, using friction to avoid slipping. The ground pushes forward on the foot. Without friction, as on wet algae or smooth ice, the foot slides back and the push fails. A cheetah's claws, which stay out when it runs, act like cleats and raise the grip for the ground push.
A fish sweeps its tail sideways, driving water backward and sideways. The sideways parts cancel as the tail swings back and forth. The backward parts add. The water pushes the fish ahead. A bird's wing drives air downward and backward, and the air pushes the bird upward and forward. Averaged over each beat, the downward push on the air must equal the bird's weight for it to stay level.
A squid and a jellyfish squeeze water from a body cavity. The water leaves in one direction and the animal goes in the other. A snake bends its body, pushing sideways against rocks and rough soil, and the rocks push it forward. A kangaroo pushes the ground down and back, and the ground pushes it up and forward by the same amount, while its springy tendons store energy on landing and give much of it back on the next hop.
| Animal | What it pushes | What pushes back |
|---|---|---|
| Person walking | Ground, backward, through friction | Ground, forward on the foot |
| Fish | Water, backward, with the tail | Water, forward on the fish |
| Bird | Air, downward and backward, with wings | Air, upward and forward on the bird |
| Squid | Water jet from the body | Water jet's reaction, opposite way |
| Snake | Rocks and bumps, sideways | Bumps, forward and sideways |
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 3, 'Newton's Laws of Motion'
See it in the table
H₂O WaterCheck your understanding
A loaded lorry and an auto-rickshaw collide head on. Which is true during the impact?
Newton's third law gives equal and opposite forces. The second law then gives acceleration = force / mass, so the lighter rickshaw accelerates more.A book rests on a table. Its weight and the table's support force are equal and opposite. Are they a third-law pair?
A third-law pair acts on two different bodies. The weight and the support force both act on the book. The partner of the weight is the book's pull on the Earth.Why can a rocket accelerate in empty space?
The reaction partner is the exhaust, which the rocket carries with it. No outside air is needed.