The nucleus: radioactivity, half-life, fission, fusion and mass-energy: Clocks in the rocks: radiometric dating
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 9: The nucleus: radioactivity, half-life, fission, fusion and mass-energy Part 4 of 6Clocks in the rocks: radiometric dating
Because the decay of a nucleus runs at a fixed rate that heat and chemistry cannot change, every radioactive isotope is a clock. If you know how much of the parent is left and how much daughter has built up, you can read the time since the clock started. This part sets out two clocks, one for the last fifty thousand years and one for four and a half billion.
4.1 Carbon-14 is renewed in living things and stops being renewed at death, so the fraction left measures the time since
Cosmic rays hit the upper air and free neutrons. A neutron striking nitrogen-14 can knock out a proton and leave carbon-14, which is radioactive with a half-life of 5,730 years. The atoms burn to carbon dioxide and mix through the air within years, and plants take them up in photosynthesis. Animals eat the plants. So as long as something lives, its carbon has the same tiny proportion of carbon-14 as the air, about one atom in a million million. That is a decay rate of about 0.23 becquerel per gram of carbon, or 14 a minute.
At death the supply stops. Nothing new comes in, and what is there decays, halving every 5,730 years. The fraction left gives the age: the age equals 5,730 years times the number of times the original amount has been halved. Willard Libby worked this out at Chicago in 1949 and tested it on wood from Egyptian tombs whose ages were known from written records. The ages matched. He received the 1960 Nobel Prize in Chemistry.
Radiocarbon dates, together with other evidence, place the mature phase of the Indus cities at about 2600 to 1900 BCE. The limit is about 50,000 years, since after nine halvings the signal is a 512th of the start and hard to tell from contamination. The raw dates also need calibration, because the carbon-14 in the air has not been constant: cosmic rays vary, ocean circulation varies, burning fossil fuel since 1850 diluted it, and the bomb tests of the 1950s and 1960s nearly doubled it. Calibration curves built from tree rings, corals and lake sediments, now reaching 55,000 years, correct for this.
| Fraction left | Halvings (log base 2 of 1 / fraction) | Age = 5,730 y x halvings |
|---|---|---|
| 80 per cent | 0.32 | about 1,800 years |
| 50 per cent | 1 | 5,730 years |
| 25 per cent | 2 | 11,460 years |
| 10 per cent | 3.32 | about 19,000 years |
| 1 per cent | 6.64 | about 38,000 years |
| 0.2 per cent | 9 | about 51,000 years, near the limit |
A hearth charcoal that still gives 80 per cent of the modern rate is about 1,800 years old, before calibration.
Source: Nobel Prize in Chemistry 1960, Willard Libby, Facts, https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/chemistry/1960/libby/facts/ (prize for the method of using carbon-14 for age determination)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 10, 'The Atomic Nucleus and Radioactivity'
- Nobel Prize in Chemistry 1960, Willard Libby, Facts · web
4.2 Uranium decays to lead at a known rate, so zircon crystals and meteorites give ages in billions of years
For rocks one needs a clock that runs for billions of years. Uranium-238 has a half-life of 4.47 billion years and ends as lead-206. Uranium-235, with a half-life of 704 million years, ends as lead-207. The mineral zircon is the ideal timekeeper. When a zircon crystal forms in cooling rock, uranium fits into its lattice in place of zirconium, but lead does not fit. So the crystal starts with next to no lead, and nearly every lead-206 and lead-207 atom in it later came from decay. The crystal is a sealed vessel that starts its clock at the moment it crystallises.
The age comes from the ratio of daughter to parent. If D is the number of lead atoms and P the number of uranium atoms still present, the age is the logarithm of 1 plus D over P, divided by the decay constant. The table has some values. Two parent atoms and two clocks run in the same crystal, so each age can check the other. If both agree, the crystal is called concordant; lead lost later makes them disagree.
The first rock ages came in 1905 to 1913 from Rutherford, Bertram Boltwood and Arthur Holmes, and they gave hundreds of millions to more than a billion years, far beyond Kelvin's cooling estimate of tens of millions. Earth's own age needs a trick, since the oldest rocks have been recycled. Clair Patterson compared lead isotopes in a meteorite with those in ocean sediment in the 1950s. The US Geological Survey now gives 4.54 billion years, with an uncertainty under 1 per cent, and more than 70 meteorites that fall between 4.53 and 4.58 billion years. Zircon grains from Western Australia are more than 4.3 billion years old.
| Atoms of lead-206 per atom of uranium-238 | Working: age = ln(1 + ratio) / (1.55 x 10^-10 per year) | Age |
|---|---|---|
| 0.25 | ln 1.25 = 0.223; 0.223 / 1.55 x 10^-10 | 1.4 billion years |
| 0.50 | ln 1.5 = 0.405; 0.405 / 1.55 x 10^-10 | 2.6 billion years |
| 1.00 | ln 2 = 0.693; 0.693 / 1.55 x 10^-10 | 4.5 billion years (one half-life) |
| Cross-check at 2.6 billion years | uranium-235 clock: e^(9.85 x 10^-10 x 2.6 x 10^9) - 1 = e^2.56 - 1 | lead-207 per uranium-235 about 12 |
The decay constant is 0.693 divided by the half-life; for uranium-238 it is 0.693 / 4.47 x 10^9 = 1.55 x 10^-10 per year.
Source: US Geological Survey, Age of the Earth, https://pubs.usgs.gov/gip/geotime/age.html (4.54 billion years with under 1 per cent uncertainty; lead isotopes in meteorites; over 70 dated meteorites 4.53 to 4.58 billion years; oldest zircons 4.3 billion years; Acasta Gneisses 4.03 billion years)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 10, 'The Atomic Nucleus and Radioactivity'
- US Geological Survey, Age of the Earth · web
4.3 Every clock needs a known start, a closed system and a steady rate, and independent clocks that agree show that the method works
Each dating system has a range set by its half-life. A clock is useful when the sample has lost a noticeable share of the parent but still has plenty left to measure, so roughly between a tenth of a half-life and ten half-lives. That is why carbon-14 serves for archaeology, and uranium for the age of the planet.
Potassium-40, the isotope that warms your body, has a second job. It decays, about one atom in nine, to argon-40, an inert gas that stays trapped in volcanic rock only after the rock has solidified. The argon in a lump of volcanic ash is therefore a count of the time since the eruption. Ash layers dated this way have been used to put ages on hominin fossils in the Rift Valley. Rubidium-87 decaying to strontium-87 serves for rocks of billions of years.
Three conditions must hold. The start must be known: no daughter atoms at the beginning, or a way to tell how many there were. The sample must be closed, with nothing gained or lost since. And the rate must be steady. This last one is tested, not assumed. Decay rates depend on the forces inside the nucleus, which are millions of times stronger than chemical bonds, so heat and pressure leave them almost unchanged. If the rates had drifted, clocks that depend on different nuclear processes would drift apart, yet independent clocks on one sample agree, and radiocarbon ages agree with ring counts of trees. Even distant events follow the same law. The light from the supernova of 1987, 168,000 light years away, faded at the rate of cobalt-56 decaying in the laboratory with a half-life of 77 days.
| Clock | Half-life | What it dates | Useful span |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carbon-14 to nitrogen-14 | 5,730 years | Charcoal, bone, wood, cloth | to about 50,000 years |
| Potassium-40 to argon-40 | 1.25 billion years | Volcanic rock and ash | from tens of thousands of years upward |
| Uranium-238 to lead-206 | 4.47 billion years | Zircon, old igneous rock, meteorites | millions to billions of years |
| Rubidium-87 to strontium-87 | about 49 billion years | Very old rocks, meteorites | hundreds of millions to billions of years |
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 10, 'The Atomic Nucleus and Radioactivity'
- US Geological Survey, Age of the Earth · web
See it in the table
U UraniumCo CobaltZr ZirconiumSr StrontiumRb RubidiumAr ArgonCO2 Carbon dioxideCheck your understanding
A seed from an old grain store has one sixteenth of the carbon-14 of living plants. Roughly how old is it, before calibration?
One sixteenth is four halvings, and 4 x 5,730 is 22,920 years. Sixteen half-lives would be the mistake of multiplying by 16.Why is zircon useful for uranium-lead dating?
A clock needs a known start. Zircon begins with next to no lead.Why can carbon-14 not date a 100-million-year-old fossil?
After more than ten half-lives the signal is lost in background. A longer-lived clock is needed.