Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

The nucleus: radioactivity, half-life, fission, fusion and mass-energy: Splitting and joining: fission, nuclear power and fusion

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 9: The nucleus: radioactivity, half-life, fission, fusion and mass-energy Part 6 of 6

Splitting and joining: fission, nuclear power and fusion

The binding curve says that energy can be had by splitting the heaviest nuclei or by joining the lightest. Both were found in the twentieth century. This part gives the discovery of fission, the idea of a chain reaction, nuclear power and India's plan for it in outline, and the fusion that lights the Sun and the status of the attempt to copy it. Weapons appear only as history and policy.

6.1 Hahn and Strassmann found barium among the products of uranium in 1938, and Meitner and Frisch explained that the nucleus had split

In 1934 Enrico Fermi fired neutrons at uranium and believed he had made heavier elements. In Berlin the chemists Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassmann repeated and extended the work, with the physicist Lise Meitner as their long-time partner. In 1938 Meitner, who was of Jewish descent, had to flee Germany for Sweden. In December Hahn and Strassmann found something they could hardly believe. Their careful chemistry showed barium, an element with 56 protons, roughly half of uranium's 92.

Meitner and her nephew Otto Frisch talked it over during the Christmas holiday. They used the liquid drop picture of the nucleus, in which the nucleons act like molecules in a charged drop, held by something like surface tension. A neutron sets the heavy drop wobbling. It stretches into a dumbbell, the electric push between the two ends wins over the short-range pull across the neck, and the drop pinches in two. The table estimates the energy of that push. Frisch borrowed a word from biology, where cells divide, and called the process fission. Their paper appeared in Nature on 11 February 1939, after Frisch's test in Copenhagen found large bursts of ionisation from the flying fragments.

Each fission also frees two or three neutrons, which was soon measured. Hahn alone was given the Nobel Prize in Chemistry for 1944, for the discovery of the fission of heavy nuclei.

Data Worked estimate: the electric energy of two fission fragments (calculated)
QuantityWorkingResult
Fragment each, about half of uranium92 / 2 protons; 236 / 2 nucleonsZ = 46, A = 118
Radius of each, 1.2 fm x A^(1/3)118^(1/3) = 4.9; 1.2 x 4.95.9 fm
Centre to centre when they touch2 x 5.9 fm11.8 fm
Electric energy1.44 MeV fm x 46 x 46 / 11.8 fmabout 260 MeV
Observed energy of one fissionmeasuredabout 200 MeV in all

The real fragments are stretched, not touching spheres, so the push is a little smaller; the estimate shows that the electric push is the right size to supply the energy.

Source: American Physical Society, APS News, This Month in Physics History: 1939, Meitner and Frisch and nuclear fission (February 2015), https://www.aps.org/apsnews/2015/02/1939-meitner-frisch-nuclear-fission (Hahn and Strassmann's puzzling lighter elements; Meitner and Frisch's liquid drop explanation published 11 February 1939, Nature 143, 239; the term fission coined by Frisch)

6.2 A chain reaction goes on only if each fission causes, on average, one more, and that single number decides between steady and runaway

A uranium-235 nucleus that splits gives out two or three neutrons. Those neutrons can strike other nuclei. Call k the average number of neutrons from one fission that go on to cause another. If k is below 1 the reaction dies away. If it is exactly 1 the rate is steady. If k is above 1 the rate grows with each generation. The table shows how a small difference in k builds up.

In principle, k depends on what happens to each neutron. Some are lost, and some are captured by nuclei that do not split, as uranium-238, which makes up 99.3 per cent of natural uranium, often does. Slow neutrons are much more likely to split uranium-235 than fast ones. So a power reactor has a moderator, such as water, heavy water or graphite, whose light nuclei slow the neutrons, and control rods that absorb neutrons to hold k at 1.

Leo Szilard conceived of a neutron chain reaction in 1933. On 2 December 1942 Fermi's team in Chicago made the first self-sustaining one. The United States dropped two fission bombs, on Hiroshima on 6 August 1945 and on Nagasaki on 9 August. Hiroshima city estimates roughly 140,000 deaths there by the end of 1945, and Nagasaki city uses a figure of more than 70,000; exact counts will never be known. The Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons was opened for signature on 1 July 1968 and entered into force on 5 March 1970. India is not a party to it.

Data Worked estimate: neutrons after 100 generations, from one starting neutron (calculated)
Average kWorkingAfter 100 generationsMeaning
0.980.98^1000.13Dies away
1.001.00^1001Steady
1.021.02^100about 7Grows
1.101.10^100about 14,000Grows fast

Growth by a fixed factor each generation is exponential growth, the mirror image of radioactive decay.

Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 10, 'The Atomic Nucleus and Radioactivity'

6.3 A nuclear power station is a steam station that takes its heat from fission, and India's three-stage plan is built around thorium

In a nuclear station the fission heat boils water, the steam drives a turbine and a generator makes the electricity. Apart from the heat source, it is like a coal station. The energy per kilogram is the difference. Full fission of a kilogram of uranium-235 gives 8.2 x 10^13 joules. A one gigawatt electric station that is one third efficient makes 3 gigawatts of heat, 2.6 x 10^14 joules a day, which is about 3 kilograms of uranium-235 split (calculated). The same heat from coal at 3 x 10^7 joules a kilogram needs about 8,600 tonnes a day (calculated), close to three million times the mass. Understanding Energy goes deeper on cost and place among other sources, in 'Making electricity: thermal, nuclear, hydro, wind and solar', and on land use in 'Power density: why land and space matter'.

India had 24 nuclear power plants in commercial operation, excluding RAPS-1, with a total of 8,780 MW, the government told Parliament in December 2025. In 2024 to 2025 nuclear supplied about 3.1 per cent of the country's electricity, and the target is 100 GW by 2047. The fission fragments left in used fuel have too many neutrons for their size, so they are radioactive, and they must be stored and shielded for a long time. India reprocesses used fuel to recover plutonium and uranium for later stages. The plan behind this, drawn up in the 1950s under Homi Bhabha, has three stages, chosen because India has modest uranium but large thorium. Stage one uses pressurised heavy water reactors on natural uranium. Neutron capture in uranium-238 followed by two beta decays makes plutonium-239, a transmutation of the kind met in Part 3. Stage two uses fast reactors that burn that plutonium and breed more. The 500 MWe Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor at Kalpakkam reached first criticality on 6 April 2026. Stage three uses thorium-232, which on absorbing a neutron and undergoing two beta decays becomes uranium-233, a fuel that splits.

Thorium estimates depend on definitions. In 2014 the Department of Atomic Energy reported 11.93 million tonnes of monazite in the beach sands, the same Kerala-type sand met in Part 2, holding about 1.07 million tonnes of thorium. In 2023 it put the monazite resource at 13.07 million tonnes.

Process flowchart India's three-stage nuclear power programme
Inputs Natural uraniumalmost all uranium-238 Thoriumfrom monazite sand Process steps 1 Stage 1: heavy water reactors

fission of uranium-235 gives heat; neutron capture in uranium-238 makes plutonium-239

2 Stage 2: fast breeder reactors

burn plutonium; a blanket of uranium and thorium breeds more plutonium and uranium-233

3 Stage 3: thorium reactors

uranium-233 made from thorium-232 becomes the main fuel

Outputs Electricity8,780 MW in operation (December 2025); 100 GW targeted by 2047

Stage 2 began with first criticality of the 500 MWe PFBR at Kalpakkam on 6 April 2026.

Source: Department of Atomic Energy, India, Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor at Kalpakkam attains first criticality (April 2026), https://dae.gov.in/prototype-fast-breeder-reactor-at-kalpakkam-tamil-nadu-attains-first-criticality (first criticality on 6 April 2026; 500 MWe; designed to use thorium-232 in the blanket; uranium-233 from thorium to fuel the third stage); Lok Sabha answer of the Department of Atomic Energy on the nuclear programme (answered 17 December 2025), https://cdnbbsr.s3waas.gov.in/s35b8e4fd39d9786228649a8a8bec4e008/uploads/2026/04/202604201352695736.pdf (24 nuclear power plants in commercial operation excluding RAPS-1, total capacity 8,780 MW; Nuclear Energy Mission envisages 100 GW by 2047); Press Information Bureau, Department of Atomic Energy, Thorium reserves in country (27 November 2014), as reprinted by Business Standard, https://business-standard.com/article/government-press-release/thorium-reserves-in-country-114112700867_1.html (AMD has established 11.93 million tonnes of in situ monazite, containing about 1.07 million tonnes of thorium); Lok Sabha, Starred Question No. 293, answered 9 August 2023 (Department of Atomic Energy), https://eparlib.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/2504240/1/AS293.pdf (13.07 million tonnes of in situ monazite in coastal beach placer sands)

6.4 The Sun fuses about 600 million tonnes of hydrogen a second by quantum tunnelling, and ITER is a test of doing the same on Earth

Burning the Sun's mass as coal (2 x 10^30 kg at 3 x 10^7 J a kilogram) would sustain its output of 3.8 x 10^26 watts for only about 5,000 years (calculated), while geology needed billions. In 1920 Arthur Eddington proposed that hydrogen turns to helium and that the lost mass is the energy source. In 1939 Hans Bethe worked out the steps, and he won the 1967 Nobel Prize in Physics.

Four protons end as one helium-4 nucleus, two positrons and two neutrinos, with 26.7 MeV released, or 0.7 per cent of the mass. The difficulty is the electric push. At the Sun's core temperature of about 15 million kelvin the typical proton has about 2 keV of motion, while two protons must come within about 1.4 femtometres, against a barrier of about 1 MeV. Almost none can climb that. The few that do get through do so by quantum tunnelling, the wave behaviour met in the module 'Atoms, the periodic table and the quantum idea'. And the first step needs a proton to turn into a neutron through the weak force, which is so slow that a typical proton waits billions of years. The result is a gentle burn: averaged across the Sun it gives only 0.27 watt per cubic metre (calculated), much less than a person gives off, since 100 watts from 0.07 cubic metres is about 1,400 watts per cubic metre, and the Sun simply has a huge volume.

On Earth, the easiest fuel is deuterium and tritium, which fuse to helium-4 and a neutron with 17.6 MeV. It needs about 150 million degrees, so the plasma is held by magnetic fields in a doughnut-shaped tokamak. ITER, being built at Cadarache in France by a partnership that includes India, aims to produce 500 MW of fusion power from 50 MW of heating. In July 2024 its organisation reported a new schedule: start of research operation in 2034 and deuterium-tritium operation in 2039, as first plasma in 2025 was no longer achievable. No fusion plant supplies electricity today.

Data Worked estimate: the Sun's mass loss (calculated)
QuantityWorkingResult
Power radiatednominal solar luminosity3.828 x 10^26 W
Mass lost each second3.828 x 10^26 J / 9.0 x 10^16 m^2/s^24.3 x 10^9 kg, about 4 million tonnes (NASA gives 4.26 x 10^9 kg/s)
Mass lost each year4.3 x 10^9 kg x 3.16 x 10^7 s1.3 x 10^17 kg
Mass lost in 4.6 billion years (upper estimate, constant output)1.3 x 10^17 x 4.6 x 10^96 x 10^26 kg, about 100 Earth masses
As a share of the Sun's mass6 x 10^26 / 2.0 x 10^300.03 per cent
Hydrogen fused each second4.3 x 10^9 kg / 0.00716 x 10^11 kg, 600 million tonnes
Fuel life for a tenth of the mass0.1 x 2.0 x 10^30 x 0.0071 x 9.0 x 10^16 J / 3.8 x 10^26 W3 x 10^17 s, about 10 billion years

The Sun was dimmer in its early life, so the true loss to date is a little less than the constant-output figure.

Source: International Astronomical Union, Resolution B3 on recommended nominal solar and planetary conversion constants (2015), nominal solar luminosity 3.828 x 10^26 W; nominal solar mass parameter, giving a solar mass of about 1.989 x 10^30 kg; NASA Goddard, Sun Fact Sheet, https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/sunfact.html (mass 1,988,400 x 10^24 kg; luminosity 382.8 x 10^24 J/s; mass conversion rate 4,260 x 10^6 kg/s; central temperature 1.571 x 10^7 K; volume 1,412,000 x 10^12 km^3)

See it in the table

H₂O WaterU UraniumGr GraphiteTh ThoriumHe HeliumH2 HydrogenO2 OxygenEl Electricity

Check your understanding

Hahn and Strassmann found barium among the products of neutron bombarded uranium. Why did that point to splitting?

A nucleus with 56 protons from one with 92 means a split into big pieces, which Meitner and Frisch then explained.

A chain reaction has k = 0.9. What happens to the reaction rate?

With k below 1 each generation has fewer neutrons than the one before.

Why does India's plan put thorium reactors in the third stage?

The earlier stages make the plutonium and the neutrons that the thorium cycle needs.
← Part 5: Mass, energy and the shape of nuclear bindingMark read · Wrap-up →