The nucleus: radioactivity, half-life, fission, fusion and mass-energy: Mass, energy and the shape of nuclear binding
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 9: The nucleus: radioactivity, half-life, fission, fusion and mass-energy Part 5 of 6Mass, energy and the shape of nuclear binding
The energy given out by a nucleus comes from a loss of mass, and that loss can be measured on a balance of the kind that weighs atoms. This part sets out Einstein's relation, shows how it gives the binding energy of a nucleus, and reads the curve of binding energy to see why both splitting and joining nuclei can release energy.
5.1 Energy has mass, so a system that gives out energy gets lighter by that energy divided by the speed of light squared
A hot cup of tea is slightly heavier than a cold one. A compressed spring is heavier than a relaxed one. The relation E = mc^2, which Einstein published in 1905, says why: the energy a system holds adds to its inertia, and each joule of energy counts as 1.1 x 10^-17 kilogram. The factor c squared is 9 x 10^16 metres squared per second squared, so it takes a huge amount of energy to make a measurable amount of mass.
The same relation read the other way shows how much energy sits in a little mass. One gram is 9 x 10^13 joules, about 25 million kilowatt hours, which is the output of a one gigawatt power station running for just over a day. It also tells us why chemistry alone never showed the effect. Burning a kilogram of coal gives about 3 x 10^7 joules. The mass of the products is lower by 3 x 10^7 divided by 9 x 10^16, or 0.3 microgram out of a kilogram, one part in three billion (calculated). No balance can see that. In nuclear changes the energy is a million times larger, so the mass change is a visible fraction.
The first laboratory test came in 1932. John Cockcroft and Ernest Walton at Cambridge accelerated protons into lithium and found that each reaction produced two alpha particles carrying about 17 MeV in total. The masses of lithium-7 and the proton exceed twice the mass of helium-4 by 0.0186 atomic mass units, and 0.0186 x 931.5 MeV is 17.3 MeV (calculated). The energy matched the missing mass. Modern mass spectrometers weigh nuclei to a few parts in a billion, and the energies of reactions always follow.
| Fuel and change | Energy per kg (J) | Mass change = energy / c^2 | Compared with coal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coal burnt in air | 3 x 10^7 | 0.33 microgram, 3 parts in 10 billion | 1 |
| Uranium-235 fully split | 8.2 x 10^13 | 0.9 g, about 0.09 per cent | about 2.7 million |
| Deuterium and tritium fused | 3.4 x 10^14 | 3.8 g, about 0.38 per cent | about 11 million |
| Hydrogen to helium in the Sun | 6.4 x 10^14 | 7.1 g, about 0.71 per cent | about 21 million |
Real reactors use only part of their fuel. These are the totals available from the nuclear change itself.
Source: Cockcroft and Walton, Disintegration of lithium by swift protons, Nature 129 (1932) 649, protons on lithium gave two alpha particles; the energy released matched the mass lost, an early test of E = mc^2- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 10, 'The Atomic Nucleus and Radioactivity'
- Cockcroft and Walton, Disintegration of lithium by swift protons, Nature 129 (1932) 649 · protons on lithium gave two alpha particles; the energy released matched the mass lost, an early test of E = mc^2
- Nobel Prize in Physics 1951, John Cockcroft, Facts · web
- Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. I (Caltech) · further reading only: https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_04.html, chapter 4 'Conservation of Energy', which discusses mass and energy
5.2 A nucleus weighs less than its separate parts, and that missing mass is its binding energy
Take helium-4. Two protons, with two electrons to make two hydrogen atoms, weigh 2 x 1.007825 = 2.015650 atomic mass units. Two neutrons weigh 2 x 1.008665 = 2.017330 units. Together that makes 4.032980 units. A real helium-4 atom weighs 4.002603 units. The difference of 0.030377 units (calculated), about 0.75 per cent of the total, is the mass defect.
What became of the missing mass? When the four nucleons came together and bound, they gave out energy, and the energy carried off the mass. To pull them apart again, that energy must be put back in. One atomic mass unit is equal to 931.5 MeV, so the binding energy of helium-4 is 0.030377 x 931.5 = 28.3 MeV (calculated). This is about two million times what it takes to ionise a hydrogen atom, which needs 13.6 eV, and the ratio says how much stronger nuclear binding is than electronic binding.
A more useful figure is the binding energy per nucleon, here 28.3 / 4 = 7.07 MeV. It is the average cost of removing one nucleon from the nucleus and tells how tightly packed it is. It lets us compare small and large nuclei on equal terms. Deuterium has 1.1 MeV per nucleon and helium-4 has 7.1, so helium is far more tightly bound. That jump is why helium leaves heavy nuclei as one lump in alpha decay.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Mass of 2 hydrogen atoms | 2 x 1.007825 u | 2.015650 u |
| Mass of 2 neutrons | 2 x 1.008665 u | 2.017330 u |
| Total of the separate parts | 2.015650 + 2.017330 | 4.032980 u |
| Mass of a helium-4 atom | measured (AME 2020) | 4.002603 u |
| Mass defect | 4.032980 - 4.002603 | 0.030377 u |
| Binding energy | 0.030377 u x 931.5 MeV per u | 28.3 MeV |
| Per nucleon | 28.3 MeV / 4 | 7.07 MeV |
Using whole hydrogen atoms includes the electrons on both sides, so their mass cancels. AME 2020 masses: hydrogen-1 1.00782503 u, neutron 1.00866492 u, helium-4 4.00260325 u; its tabulated binding energy is 7.074 MeV per nucleon.
Source: Wang et al., The AME 2020 atomic mass evaluation, Chinese Physics C 45 (2021) 030003, atomic masses used for the binding energy of helium-4 and for the binding energy per nucleon of the nuclei in the tables- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 10, 'The Atomic Nucleus and Radioactivity'
- Wang et al., The AME 2020 atomic mass evaluation, Chinese Physics C 45 (2021) 030003 · atomic masses used for the binding energy of helium-4 and for the binding energy per nucleon of the nuclei in the tables
5.3 Binding per nucleon peaks near iron and nickel, so energy comes from fusing light nuclei and from splitting heavy ones
Plot the binding energy per nucleon against the number of nucleons and a clear shape appears. It climbs steeply from deuterium to helium-4 at 7.1 MeV, then through carbon-12 at 7.7 and oxygen-16 at 8.0. It levels at about 8.8 MeV around mass numbers 56 to 62 and then slowly falls, to 7.9 for lead-208 and 7.6 for uranium-238. Small nuclei bind weakly because many of their nucleons sit at the surface and have fewer neighbours to attract. Large nuclei lose out because the electric push between all their protons grows faster than the short-range strong force can hold.
The top is the iron group. Nickel-62 has the highest binding energy per nucleon, 8.795 MeV, and iron-58 and iron-56 follow closely at 8.79. Iron-56 has the lowest mass per nucleon of all, which is a slightly different measure and the reason iron gets the name.
The curve says which way energy flows. Moving from either side toward the peak raises the binding per nucleon, and each step up releases energy as the nucleons settle into a lower-mass arrangement. Fusing light nuclei climbs the left slope. Splitting a heavy nucleus climbs the right. Splitting uranium into two middling nuclei of about 8.5 MeV per nucleon, up from 7.6, gains about 0.9 MeV for each of 235 nucleons, which is about 210 MeV (calculated), the right size for a single fission.
The curve also explains where elements come from. Stars fuse nuclei up to the iron group and stop, since going past it takes energy in rather than giving it out. Heavier elements such as gold, lead and uranium are built when nuclei absorb neutrons in explosions, including supernovae and the merger of neutron stars. So the gold in a wedding ring was made in such an event, long before the Sun formed.
| Nucleus | Nucleons | Binding energy per nucleon (MeV) | Position on the curve |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deuterium | 2 | 1.11 | Steep rise |
| Helium-4 | 4 | 7.07 | Tightly bound light nucleus |
| Carbon-12 | 12 | 7.68 | Light |
| Oxygen-16 | 16 | 7.98 | Light |
| Iron-56 | 56 | 8.79 (8.7904) | Iron group, top of curve |
| Nickel-62 | 62 | 8.79 (8.7946) | Highest of all |
| Lead-208 | 208 | 7.87 | Falling side |
| Uranium-238 | 238 | 7.57 | Falling side |
Values rounded from the atomic mass evaluation of 2020. Nickel-62 (8.7946 MeV) edges out iron-58 (8.7923) and iron-56 (8.7904).
Source: Wang et al., The AME 2020 atomic mass evaluation, Chinese Physics C 45 (2021) 030003, atomic masses used for the binding energy of helium-4 and for the binding energy per nucleon of the nuclei in the tables- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 10, 'The Atomic Nucleus and Radioactivity'
- Wang et al., The AME 2020 atomic mass evaluation, Chinese Physics C 45 (2021) 030003 · atomic masses used for the binding energy of helium-4 and for the binding energy per nucleon of the nuclei in the tables
See it in the table
U UraniumNi NickelAu GoldLi LithiumHe HeliumTea TeaH2 HydrogenO2 OxygenCheck your understanding
Burning coal releases energy, so its products must have slightly less mass than coal and oxygen. Why can nobody see the difference?
A kilogram of coal gives about 3 x 10^7 J, which is 3 x 10^7 / 9 x 10^16 = 3 x 10^-10 kg of mass.The binding energy of helium-4 is 28.3 MeV. What is the binding energy per nucleon?
There are four nucleons, so divide 28.3 by 4.Uranium nuclei bind at about 7.6 MeV per nucleon and typical fission fragments at about 8.5. Roughly how much energy does one fission of a nucleus with 236 nucleons release?
Each nucleon gains about 0.9 MeV of binding, and 236 x 0.9 MeV is about 210 MeV, close to the measured 200 MeV.