Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

The solar system: The sky from Earth, and why the Sun sits at the centre

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 21: The solar system Part 1 of 6

The sky from Earth, and why the Sun sits at the centre

Every idea in this module started as something a person could see from a roof or a field: stars turning overhead, a Sun that rises further north in summer, a bright planet that sometimes drifts backwards. This part reads those motions, shows how a Sun-centred plan explains them, and explains the seasons, which most people still get wrong.

1.1 The sky turns once a day, the Sun slides through the stars each year, and five planets wander

Watch the stars for an hour and they wheel about a fixed point: in India's northern sky, the Pole Star, Dhruva in Sanskrit. The wheeling is Earth's spin seen from inside. One full turn takes 23 hours 56 minutes relative to the stars, so a star rises about four minutes earlier each night and, over a year, the whole pattern shifts west. The reason is that Earth also circles the Sun once a year, covering about one degree of its orbit a day. The Sun therefore seems to creep eastward against the stars at about one degree a day and return to the same place after 365 days. Its yearly path is the ecliptic, and the constellations along it are the zodiac.

The Moon and the planets keep to a narrow band around that path. They do so because the whole solar system is roughly flat: the planets orbit in nearly the same plane as Earth, so from Earth they seem to stay near the ecliptic. Five planets are bright enough to see without a telescope: Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter and Saturn. The ancients called them wanderers, because unlike stars they change position from week to week.

One observation turns out to be useful anywhere. The height of the Pole Star above the northern horizon equals your latitude. In Delhi, at 28.6 degrees north, it sits 28.6 degrees up. Constellations, finally, are patterns on a flat-looking sky. The stars in one pattern may be tens or hundreds of light-years apart in depth.

Data How fast things seem to move against the background stars
ObjectApparent motionTime for one round of the sky
The stars as a wholeAbout 15 degrees an hour westward (360 degrees / 23.93 h, calculated)One day
The SunAbout 1 degree a day eastward (360 / 365.25 d = 0.99 degrees a day, calculated)365.25 days
The MoonAbout 13.2 degrees a day eastward (360 / 27.3 d, calculated)27.3 days
JupiterAbout 30 degrees a year eastward on average (360 / 11.86 yr, calculated)About 12 years
SaturnAbout 12 degrees a year eastward on average (360 / 29.46 yr, calculated)About 29.5 years

Each rate is the full circle divided by the period, so you can redo any row with a calculator.

Source: Orbital periods from NASA Planetary Fact Sheet; sidereal day and sky rates calculated, https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/index.html
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 28, 'The Solar System'
  • Standard reference values, not re-fetched; check before reuse · Aryabhata 499 CE, Nilakantha around 1500, Janssen at Guntur on 18 August 1868, Le Gentil in India 1761 and 1769, radar ranging of Venus 1961, IAU 2012 fixing the astronomical unit at 149,597,870,700 m, Patterson's 1956 lead age of Canyon Diablo, Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 billion years, Earth's perihelion 147.1 and aphelion 152.1 million km, Earth's tilt 23.4 degrees, Moon's recession 3.8 cm a year, synodic month 29.53 d, Saros 6,585.3 d, Sun's mass share 99.86 per cent and power 3.8 x 10^26 W, Halley's comet 1986 and 2061, Shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994, Kuiper belt 30 to 50 AU, New Horizons July 2015

1.2 A Sun-centred plan explains the backward loops, and Galileo's telescope settled the argument

For over a thousand years the standard picture was Ptolemy's, from about 150 CE: Earth at the centre, everything circling it. It had a problem. Mars, for a few weeks every two years or so, stops, moves backward against the stars, stops again and moves on. Ptolemy fitted this with small circles riding on big circles, called epicycles. It predicted positions well.

In 1543 Nicolaus Copernicus published the Sun-centred plan, with Earth as one planet that also spins daily. The loops now need no extra machinery. Earth, on the faster inner track, overtakes Mars. As you pass a slower car on a highway, it seems to slide backward against the distant hills, and then forward again as you pull ahead. Copernicus still used circles, so his plan was not yet simpler in detail, and Tycho Brahe objected that the stars showed no yearly shift. The reply, true but unprovable then, was that the stars are far beyond reach of the naked eye.

The telescope gave direct evidence. In 1610 Galileo saw four moons circling Jupiter, so not everything orbits Earth. He also saw Venus pass through phases, from a small full disc to a large thin crescent. If Venus always lay between Earth and the Sun and circled Earth, it could never show a full disc. If it circles the Sun, it must. Meanwhile Johannes Kepler used Tycho's careful Mars data to show that orbits are ellipses, not circles. Module 4 gives the three laws and Newton's explanation.

Data Five steps from Earth-centred to Sun-centred
YearWhoWhat changedKind of evidence
About 150 CEPtolemyEarth-centred model with epicyclesPredicts positions well
1543CopernicusSun-centred model; loops from overtakingSimpler explanation of loops
1610GalileoFour moons of Jupiter; full set of Venus phasesTelescope observation
1609 and 1619KeplerElliptical orbits; periods and distances linkedFit to Tycho's Mars data
1729 and 1838Bradley, BesselAberration of starlight; first stellar parallaxDirect measurement of Earth's motion
Source: Calculated from standard values, Arithmetic from the standard values listed in this section's sources
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 28, 'The Solar System'
  • Standard reference values, not re-fetched; check before reuse · Aryabhata 499 CE, Nilakantha around 1500, Janssen at Guntur on 18 August 1868, Le Gentil in India 1761 and 1769, radar ranging of Venus 1961, IAU 2012 fixing the astronomical unit at 149,597,870,700 m, Patterson's 1956 lead age of Canyon Diablo, Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 billion years, Earth's perihelion 147.1 and aphelion 152.1 million km, Earth's tilt 23.4 degrees, Moon's recession 3.8 cm a year, synodic month 29.53 d, Saros 6,585.3 d, Sun's mass share 99.86 per cent and power 3.8 x 10^26 W, Halley's comet 1986 and 2061, Shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994, Kuiper belt 30 to 50 AU, New Horizons July 2015
  • Encyclopaedia Britannica, Astronomy: Copernicus, Kepler and Galileo · web
  • ESA Gaia, Seeing and measuring farther · web

1.3 The seasons come from the tilt of Earth's axis, not from its distance from the Sun

Earth's axis is tilted 23.4 degrees from the perpendicular to its orbit, and it keeps pointing the same way as the planet goes round. For half the year the northern end leans towards the Sun, and for the other half away. Two things follow. When the north leans towards the Sun, the Sun climbs higher at noon, so a given beam of sunlight is spread over less ground. Days also last longer, so the ground has more hours to warm.

Take Delhi, at 28.6 degrees north. On the June solstice the noon Sun stands 90 minus 28.6 plus 23.4, which is 84.8 degrees high, almost overhead. On the December solstice it stands 90 minus 28.6 minus 23.4, which is 38 degrees. Sunlight on level ground is proportional to the sine of the Sun's height: 1.00 in June against 0.62 in December. A noon beam is 60 per cent stronger in June, before counting the longer day. The Tropic of Cancer, at 23.4 degrees north, passes through eight Indian states, from Gujarat to Mizoram. On the June solstice the noon Sun is directly overhead along that line.

Distance cannot be the cause. Earth is nearest the Sun in early January, at about 147.1 million km, and farthest in early July, at about 152.1 million km. Sunlight weakens as the square of distance, so the January beam is only about 7 per cent stronger than the July one, and it arrives in the northern winter. Australia, in the southern half, has its summer in January. Both halves of the planet share one distance at one moment, yet they have opposite seasons, so distance cannot explain them. The tilt does. Its long, slow wobble also contributes to the ice-age cycles of module 19.

Data Worked estimate: noon sunlight at Delhi, and the effect of distance
QuantityWorkingResult
Noon Sun height, June solstice90 - 28.6 + 23.4 degrees84.8 degrees (calculated)
Noon Sun height, December solstice90 - 28.6 - 23.4 degrees38.0 degrees (calculated)
Relative beam strength on level groundsin 84.8 = 0.996; sin 38.0 = 0.616June about 1.6 times December (calculated)
Distance effect, January against July(152.1 million km / 147.1 million km) squaredAbout 1.07 times, and in the opposite season (calculated)

The tilt effect on the ground (a ratio of about 1.6) is about nine times larger than the distance effect (about 1.07), and it has the right sign. Delhi's latitude is rounded.

Source: Calculated from Earth's tilt and orbit distances (NASA Planetary Fact Sheet), https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 28, 'The Solar System'
  • Standard reference values, not re-fetched; check before reuse · Aryabhata 499 CE, Nilakantha around 1500, Janssen at Guntur on 18 August 1868, Le Gentil in India 1761 and 1769, radar ranging of Venus 1961, IAU 2012 fixing the astronomical unit at 149,597,870,700 m, Patterson's 1956 lead age of Canyon Diablo, Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 billion years, Earth's perihelion 147.1 and aphelion 152.1 million km, Earth's tilt 23.4 degrees, Moon's recession 3.8 cm a year, synodic month 29.53 d, Saros 6,585.3 d, Sun's mass share 99.86 per cent and power 3.8 x 10^26 W, Halley's comet 1986 and 2061, Shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994, Kuiper belt 30 to 50 AU, New Horizons July 2015

See it in the table

Hg Mercury

Check your understanding

Why does a star rise about four minutes earlier each night?

Relative to the stars Earth turns in 23 h 56 min. Its yearly orbit means a solar day is 24 h, so the star pattern gains about four minutes a day.

Which observation was impossible in a model where Venus always stays between Earth and the Sun and circles Earth?

Seen from Earth, a full disc needs Venus to be on the far side of the Sun. In the Earth-centred model that never happens, but Galileo saw it.

A city is at latitude 20 degrees north. How high is the noon Sun on the day it is directly overhead at 23.4 degrees north, 3.4 degrees away?

Height is 90 minus the angular distance between the city's latitude and the latitude of the overhead Sun: 90 - 3.4 = 86.6 degrees.
← Module contentsMark read · Part 2: The Moon: phases, eclipses and a world next door →