Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

The solar system: How the solar system formed, and the Sun at its centre

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 21: The solar system Part 4 of 6

How the solar system formed, and the Sun at its centre

The planets share a pattern, and a pattern needs a cause. This part gives the leading account, a collapsing cloud that flattened into a disc, then shows how meteorites fix the date, why the inner and outer planets differ, and what the Sun is. The Sun's life as a star is the subject of module 22.

4.1 A collapsing, spinning cloud explains why the planets share one flat, orderly pattern

List what needs explaining. The planets orbit in nearly one plane. They all circle in the same direction, and the Sun spins that way too. Their orbits are close to circles. The small rocky worlds lie near the Sun and the large gassy ones beyond. A theory must give all of this at once. The nebular hypothesis, first outlined by Kant and Laplace in the 1700s, does.

It starts with a cloud of gas and dust, mostly hydrogen and helium with a trace of heavier elements made earlier in dead stars. Something nudges part of the cloud, perhaps a shock from a nearby exploding star, and gravity makes it fall inward. As it shrinks it must spin faster, because angular momentum is conserved (module 3), just as an office chair spins faster when its rider pulls in outstretched legs. The spin resists collapse across the equator but not along the axis, so the cloud flattens into a disc with a dense, hot ball at the centre. That ball becomes the Sun when its core reaches the temperature for fusion. Everything in the disc already goes round in one direction and in one plane.

Within the disc, dust grains stick together, then clump into lumps of kilometre size, then collide into bodies of a Moon's size or bigger, called protoplanets, within a few million years. Telescopes now see such discs around young stars, with gaps where forming planets have swept up material.

  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 28, 'The Solar System'
  • Standard reference values, not re-fetched; check before reuse · Aryabhata 499 CE, Nilakantha around 1500, Janssen at Guntur on 18 August 1868, Le Gentil in India 1761 and 1769, radar ranging of Venus 1961, IAU 2012 fixing the astronomical unit at 149,597,870,700 m, Patterson's 1956 lead age of Canyon Diablo, Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 billion years, Earth's perihelion 147.1 and aphelion 152.1 million km, Earth's tilt 23.4 degrees, Moon's recession 3.8 cm a year, synodic month 29.53 d, Saros 6,585.3 d, Sun's mass share 99.86 per cent and power 3.8 x 10^26 W, Halley's comet 1986 and 2061, Shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994, Kuiper belt 30 to 50 AU, New Horizons July 2015

4.2 Only rock and metal could survive close to the young Sun, which sorted the planets into two kinds

The young disc was hot near the centre and cold far away. Close in, only materials with high melting points could exist as grains: metals and silicate rock. Beyond a certain distance, the frost line at about 3 to 5 AU, water, ammonia and methane could freeze as well. Ice is much more plentiful than rock and metal, so grains beyond the line were abundant. That gave a head start in growth. The inner planets formed from rock and metal and stayed small. Beyond the line, cores grew to ten or more Earth masses, strong enough in gravity to capture the hydrogen and helium of the disc. That made Jupiter and Saturn. Uranus and Neptune, farther out, ended with less hydrogen and helium and more ices. The sorting is visible in density: rocky planets are above 3,900 kg per cubic metre, giant planets below 1,700 (Part 5).

Solar radiation and the solar wind then cleared the leftover gas in a few million years. After that, planets grew only by collisions. The Earth's Moon came from one, and Uranus lies on its side probably from another. Between Mars and Jupiter, Jupiter's gravity stirred the debris so that bodies collided at high speed and broke apart instead of building a planet. The asteroid belt is debris that never assembled into a planet. The giant planets also built their own mini-discs, in which their larger moons formed, like a small copy of the solar system.

The evidence is the planets' arrangement and the leftover small bodies, which keep the early composition (Part 6).

Value chain From cloud to solar system
  • Cloud of gas and dust collapses under gravity
    • Dense hot centre
      • Core reaches fusion temperature and becomes the Sun
    • Spinning disc
      • Inside the frost line: rock and metal grains
        • Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars (small, dense)
      • Beyond the frost line: rock, metal and ices
        • Jupiter and Saturn: large cores capture hydrogen and helium
        • Uranus and Neptune: ice-rich, less gas
        • Leftovers: comets, Kuiper belt objects
      • Between Mars and Jupiter: debris stirred up by Jupiter
        • Asteroid belt
Source: Calculated from standard values, Arithmetic from the standard values listed in this section's sources
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 28, 'The Solar System'
  • Standard reference values, not re-fetched; check before reuse · Aryabhata 499 CE, Nilakantha around 1500, Janssen at Guntur on 18 August 1868, Le Gentil in India 1761 and 1769, radar ranging of Venus 1961, IAU 2012 fixing the astronomical unit at 149,597,870,700 m, Patterson's 1956 lead age of Canyon Diablo, Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 billion years, Earth's perihelion 147.1 and aphelion 152.1 million km, Earth's tilt 23.4 degrees, Moon's recession 3.8 cm a year, synodic month 29.53 d, Saros 6,585.3 d, Sun's mass share 99.86 per cent and power 3.8 x 10^26 W, Halley's comet 1986 and 2061, Shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994, Kuiper belt 30 to 50 AU, New Horizons July 2015

4.3 Meteorites date the solar system at 4.568 billion years

The oldest rocks on Earth are no use for the solar system's age, because Earth keeps recycling its crust (module 18). The oldest grains found so far are zircon crystals from the Jack Hills of Western Australia, about 4.4 billion years old. Rocks brought from the Moon reach almost as far back. For the whole system's age, one needs material that has never been melted or recycled. Meteorites called chondrites are fragments of asteroids that were never heated enough to melt. They hold some of the oldest solid objects, small light-coloured inclusions rich in calcium and aluminium.

The method is the uranium-lead clock of module 9. Uranium-238 decays to lead-206 with a half-life of 4.47 billion years, and uranium-235 decays to lead-207 with a half-life of 0.70 billion years. A mineral that formed with uranium but no lead starts the clock at zero. Two independent clocks running at different speeds must give the same age, which guards against error. In 1956 Clair Patterson used lead isotopes in the Canyon Diablo iron meteorite to find about 4.55 billion years for the meteorites and Earth. In 2010 Bouvier and Wadhwa reported that a calcium-aluminium-rich inclusion in a meteorite formed 4,568.2 million years ago. This is the best-known date for the start of the solar system. Earth, the Moon and other bodies formed within tens of millions of years of that.

  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 28, 'The Solar System'
  • Bouvier and Wadhwa, The age of the Solar System redefined by the oldest Pb-Pb age of a meteoritic inclusion, Nature Geoscience 3, 637 (2010) · web
  • Standard reference values, not re-fetched; check before reuse · Aryabhata 499 CE, Nilakantha around 1500, Janssen at Guntur on 18 August 1868, Le Gentil in India 1761 and 1769, radar ranging of Venus 1961, IAU 2012 fixing the astronomical unit at 149,597,870,700 m, Patterson's 1956 lead age of Canyon Diablo, Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 billion years, Earth's perihelion 147.1 and aphelion 152.1 million km, Earth's tilt 23.4 degrees, Moon's recession 3.8 cm a year, synodic month 29.53 d, Saros 6,585.3 d, Sun's mass share 99.86 per cent and power 3.8 x 10^26 W, Halley's comet 1986 and 2061, Shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994, Kuiper belt 30 to 50 AU, New Horizons July 2015

4.4 The Sun is a star that turns about four million tonnes of mass into light every second

The Sun is 1.39 million km across, 109 Earths side by side, with 333,000 Earth masses. Its surface is at about 5,800 K. Its core is at about 15 million K, hot and dense enough for hydrogen nuclei to fuse into helium (module 9). Each second about 600 million tonnes of hydrogen are fused, and about 4 million tonnes of that mass become energy, by E = mc squared: 3.8 x 10^26 W divided by (3 x 10^8 m/s) squared is 4.2 x 10^9 kg a second (calculated). This gives a power of 3.8 x 10^26 watts.

The energy leaves in layers. In the core and the radiative zone around it, light is absorbed and re-emitted many times, taking tens of thousands of years or more to cross. In the outer third, hot gas rises and cool gas sinks in convection. The visible surface is the photosphere. Above it lie the thin chromosphere and the corona, a million-degree outer atmosphere seen at total eclipses. Dark sunspots, about 4,000 K against 5,800 K, are regions where strong magnetic fields hold back heat. Being gas, the Sun turns in about 25 days at its equator and over 30 near its poles, which winds up its magnetic field. Sunspots peak every 11 years and the field flips at each peak, so the full magnetic cycle takes 22 years. The corona streams outward as the solar wind, charged particles at about 400 km a second. When the wind meets Earth's magnetic field (module 6), some particles spiral to the poles and make auroras.

The Sun is about 4.6 billion years old, so it is roughly halfway through its hydrogen. Module 22 follows its future as a star. India's Aditya-L1 watches the corona and solar wind from a point where the Sun is never eclipsed, which module 4 describes.

Process flowchart Energy from the Sun's core to Earth
Inputs Hydrogen nuclei in the coreAbout 600 million tonnes fused each second Process steps 1 Fusion in the core

Hydrogen becomes helium; about 4 million tonnes of mass a second turn to energy

2 Radiative and convective zones

Energy random-walks outward for tens of thousands of years or more

3 Photosphere

Light leaves the surface at about 5,800 K

4 Space

Light takes 8.3 minutes to reach Earth

Outputs Sunlight3.8 x 10^26 watts in all directions; about 1,360 watts per square metre at Earth Source: Calculated from standard values, Arithmetic from the standard values listed in this section's sources
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 28, 'The Solar System'
  • Material Insights, module 4 of this course, Gravity, projectiles and orbits · orbits of Chandrayaan-3, Mangalyaan and Aditya-L1 and the Lagrange point L1; not repeated here
  • Standard reference values, not re-fetched; check before reuse · Aryabhata 499 CE, Nilakantha around 1500, Janssen at Guntur on 18 August 1868, Le Gentil in India 1761 and 1769, radar ranging of Venus 1961, IAU 2012 fixing the astronomical unit at 149,597,870,700 m, Patterson's 1956 lead age of Canyon Diablo, Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 billion years, Earth's perihelion 147.1 and aphelion 152.1 million km, Earth's tilt 23.4 degrees, Moon's recession 3.8 cm a year, synodic month 29.53 d, Saros 6,585.3 d, Sun's mass share 99.86 per cent and power 3.8 x 10^26 W, Halley's comet 1986 and 2061, Shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994, Kuiper belt 30 to 50 AU, New Horizons July 2015
  • ISRO, Halo-Orbit Insertion of Aditya-L1 · web

See it in the table

H₂O WaterU UraniumAl AluminiumHe HeliumH2 HydrogenNH3 Ammonia

Check your understanding

Why does the nebular hypothesis predict that planets orbit in the same direction?

Angular momentum is conserved. A spinning cloud that shrinks spins faster and flattens, so everything made from the disc moves one way in one plane.

Why are meteorites, and not Earth's rocks, used to date the solar system?

Plate tectonics and erosion continually recycle Earth's surface. Meteorites from unmelted asteroids keep their original ages.

After about one half-life of uranium-238 (4.47 billion years), what fraction remains?

A half-life is the time for half of the atoms to decay. Of the uranium-238 present at the start of the solar system, about half remains now.
← Part 3: How we know the size of the solar systemMark read · Part 5: The planets: two families and a search for habitable worlds →