The solar system: How we know the size of the solar system
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 21: The solar system Part 3 of 6How we know the size of the solar system
Nobody can unroll a tape measure to Mars. Every distance in this module rests on a short chain of steps, each checking the one before: a shift in viewpoint, a law linking orbit times to distances, a rare alignment of Venus, a radar echo and finally spacecraft tracked by radio. This part follows the chain and ends with a scale model that shows how empty space is.
3.1 Parallax turns a small shift in direction into a distance
Hold a finger at arm's length and close one eye, then the other. The finger jumps against the background. Move it closer and the jump grows. That jump is parallax, and it measures distance. Two quantities are needed: the baseline, the sideways gap between the two viewpoints, and the angle of the shift. For small angles in radians, distance is about the baseline divided by the angle.
Astronomers use the same trick at three scales. For the Moon, the baseline is the width of Earth: observers far apart note where the Moon sits against the stars at the same instant. Greek astronomers of the second century BCE already used the method to put the Moon about 60 Earth radii away, close to the modern 384,400 km. For nearby planets, a long baseline helps, as the next section shows. For stars, the best baseline is the diameter of Earth's own orbit, two astronomical units. A nearby star seems to shift against the farther ones as Earth moves from one side of its orbit to the other six months later.
The shift is tiny. In 1838 Friedrich Bessel measured it for the star 61 Cygni and found 0.314 arcseconds. The modern value is 0.29 arcseconds, the angle of a one-centimetre coin seen from about 7 km. A parallax of one arcsecond defines a distance of one parsec, 3.26 light-years. So 0.29 arcseconds means 1 / 0.29 = 3.5 parsecs, or 11.4 light-years. This is why Tycho Brahe saw nothing in the 1500s: the angles lay beyond the naked eye. It also gave the first direct proof that Earth moves round the Sun.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline for a star | Earth's orbit diameter = 2 AU | About 300 million km |
| Measured parallax angle, 61 Cygni | Half the total shift over six months | About 0.29 arcseconds (Bessel in 1838: 0.314) |
| Distance in parsecs | 1 / 0.29 | About 3.5 parsecs (calculated) |
| Distance in light-years | 3.5 parsecs x 3.26 light-years per parsec | About 11.4 light-years (calculated) |
| Distance in km | 11.4 x 9.46 x 10^12 km | About 1.1 x 10^14 km (calculated) |
One arcsecond is 1/3,600 of a degree, or 4.85 x 10^-6 radians. Check the coin: 0.01 m / (0.29 x 4.85 x 10^-6) = 7,100 m (calculated).
Source: Calculated from standard values, Arithmetic from the standard values listed in this section's sources- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 28, 'The Solar System'
- Standard reference values, not re-fetched; check before reuse · Aryabhata 499 CE, Nilakantha around 1500, Janssen at Guntur on 18 August 1868, Le Gentil in India 1761 and 1769, radar ranging of Venus 1961, IAU 2012 fixing the astronomical unit at 149,597,870,700 m, Patterson's 1956 lead age of Canyon Diablo, Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 billion years, Earth's perihelion 147.1 and aphelion 152.1 million km, Earth's tilt 23.4 degrees, Moon's recession 3.8 cm a year, synodic month 29.53 d, Saros 6,585.3 d, Sun's mass share 99.86 per cent and power 3.8 x 10^26 W, Halley's comet 1986 and 2061, Shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994, Kuiper belt 30 to 50 AU, New Horizons July 2015
- ESA Gaia, Seeing and measuring farther · web
3.2 Kepler's third law draws the map and a measured length sets its scale: transits and radar
Module 4 gave Kepler's third law: the square of the orbital period is proportional to the cube of the average distance. Used with Earth as the unit, a planet's period in years, raised to the power two-thirds, gives its distance in astronomical units. Mars takes 1.88 years: 1.88 to the power two-thirds is 1.52 AU (calculated). Jupiter takes 11.86 years: 5.2 AU. Saturn takes 29.5 years: 9.5 AU. So the proportions were known by Kepler's time, but not the units. The size of the astronomical unit in kilometres had to be measured by something else.
Edmond Halley saw in 1716 how a transit of Venus could do this: Venus passing across the Sun's face. Observers at distant latitudes see Venus follow slightly different tracks across the Sun, and timing them gives the parallax of Venus, hence of the Sun. The transits of 1761 and 1769 brought expeditions from many countries. One was the French astronomer Guillaume Le Gentil, who sailed to Pondicherry in India. In 1761 he was at sea when the transit came, and in 1769 clouds blocked his view. The combined results put the Sun about 150 million km away, within a few per cent of the right value. Transits come in pairs eight years apart, separated by gaps of 121.5 and 105.5 years. The last pair was 2004 and 2012. The next is in 2117.
In 1961 radar did the job more accurately. A radio pulse is sent to Venus and the echo timed. At closest approach, Venus is 1 - 0.723 = 0.277 AU away. The pulse takes about 276.5 seconds there and back. Distance equals speed times half the time, so the AU follows. Today, spacecraft ranging gives it to a few metres. Since 2012 the astronomical unit has been fixed by definition at 149,597,870,700 metres.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Venus at closest approach, in AU | 1 AU - 0.723 AU (Kepler's law gave 0.723) | 0.277 AU (calculated) |
| Round-trip delay of the radar echo | Measured | About 276.5 s |
| One-way distance | 299,792 km/s x 138.25 s | About 41.4 million km (calculated) |
| Size of one AU | 41.4 million km / 0.277 | About 149.6 million km (calculated) |
| Light travel time, Sun to Earth | 149.6 million km / 299,792 km/s | 499 s = 8.3 minutes (calculated) |
Use Venus at its nearest, when the Sun, Venus and Earth are lined up on one side.
Source: Calculated; the 276.5 s delay follows from the accepted AU and Venus's distance, so the table shows the method rather than the 1961 data, https://eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/transit/transit.html (transits and Halley's 1716 method)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 28, 'The Solar System'
- NASA Eclipse Web Site, Planetary Transits Across the Sun · web
- Standard reference values, not re-fetched; check before reuse · Aryabhata 499 CE, Nilakantha around 1500, Janssen at Guntur on 18 August 1868, Le Gentil in India 1761 and 1769, radar ranging of Venus 1961, IAU 2012 fixing the astronomical unit at 149,597,870,700 m, Patterson's 1956 lead age of Canyon Diablo, Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 billion years, Earth's perihelion 147.1 and aphelion 152.1 million km, Earth's tilt 23.4 degrees, Moon's recession 3.8 cm a year, synodic month 29.53 d, Saros 6,585.3 d, Sun's mass share 99.86 per cent and power 3.8 x 10^26 W, Halley's comet 1986 and 2061, Shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994, Kuiper belt 30 to 50 AU, New Horizons July 2015
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, Astronomy: Copernicus, Kepler and Galileo · web
3.3 A scale model shows how empty the solar system is, and how much of it is the Sun
Put a cricket ball, 7.2 cm wide, on the stumps at one end of a pitch and call it the Sun. The scale is 1 cm to 193,000 km. Earth is then a grain of sand 0.7 mm across, about 7.7 m down the pitch. Jupiter is a 7-mm bead about 40 m away, short of the boundary rope. Neptune is a 2.6-mm seed about 230 m away, and Pluto a speck a tenth of a millimetre wide about 300 m out. The nearest other star, Proxima Centauri, would be a 1-cm marble about 2,100 km away, farther than Delhi is from Bengaluru by air.
Two lessons follow. Space is almost entirely empty, and the Sun dominates. It holds 99.86 per cent of the mass of the whole system. Of the remaining 0.14 per cent, Jupiter has more than twice as much as the other seven planets combined: its mass is 318 times Earth's against about 129 for the rest.
The planets also share a pattern. Almost all of the orbits lie within a few degrees of one plane, the plane of the ecliptic. Mercury is the most tilted at 7 degrees. They all go round the Sun in the same direction, anticlockwise when seen from above Earth's north pole, and nearly all spin that way too. The pattern calls for an explanation, which Part 4 gives.
Light makes distance easy to feel. Sunlight takes 8.3 minutes to reach Earth, 43 minutes to Jupiter and 4.2 hours to Neptune.
| Object | Real distance from Sun | Scaled distance (divide by 193,000 km per cm) | Scaled size |
|---|---|---|---|
| Earth | 149.6 million km | 7.7 m (calculated) | 0.7 mm (calculated) |
| Jupiter | 778.5 million km | 40 m (calculated) | 7.4 mm (calculated) |
| Neptune | 4,515 million km | 234 m (calculated) | 2.6 mm (calculated) |
| Pluto | 5,906 million km | 305 m (calculated) | 0.12 mm (calculated) |
| Proxima Centauri | 4.24 light-years = 4.0 x 10^13 km | About 2,100 km (calculated) | About 1.1 cm (calculated) |
Scale: 1.39 million km / 7.2 cm = 193,000 km per cm (calculated). Distances and sizes from the NASA Planetary Fact Sheet; Proxima Centauri is about 0.15 of the Sun's width.
Source: NASA Space Science Data Coordinated Archive, Planetary Fact Sheet, https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/index.html (distances and diameters; scaling calculated)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 28, 'The Solar System'
- NASA Space Science Data Coordinated Archive, Planetary Fact Sheet · web
- Standard reference values, not re-fetched; check before reuse · Aryabhata 499 CE, Nilakantha around 1500, Janssen at Guntur on 18 August 1868, Le Gentil in India 1761 and 1769, radar ranging of Venus 1961, IAU 2012 fixing the astronomical unit at 149,597,870,700 m, Patterson's 1956 lead age of Canyon Diablo, Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 billion years, Earth's perihelion 147.1 and aphelion 152.1 million km, Earth's tilt 23.4 degrees, Moon's recession 3.8 cm a year, synodic month 29.53 d, Saros 6,585.3 d, Sun's mass share 99.86 per cent and power 3.8 x 10^26 W, Halley's comet 1986 and 2061, Shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994, Kuiper belt 30 to 50 AU, New Horizons July 2015
See it in the table
Hg MercuryCheck your understanding
A star's parallax is 0.10 arcseconds. How far away is it?
Distance in parsecs is one divided by the parallax in arcseconds: 1 / 0.10 = 10 parsecs, about 33 light-years.Why did astronomers need the transit of Venus or radar, if Kepler's third law already gave all the distances?
The third law links periods to distances in relative terms. A single measured distance such as Earth to Sun converts the whole map to kilometres.In the scale model with the Sun as a 7.2 cm cricket ball, about how far away is Earth?
149.6 million km divided by 193,000 km per cm gives 775 cm, about 7.7 m.