Waves: sound, light, colour and the wave-particle puzzle: Sound: pressure waves, loudness, resonance and moving sources
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 7: Waves: sound, light, colour and the wave-particle puzzle Part 2 of 6Sound: pressure waves, loudness, resonance and moving sources
Sound is the longitudinal wave most people meet every day. This part gives its speed in air, water and steel with a reason for each, the decibel scale for loudness, resonance as the way instruments and boxes make sound, and the Doppler effect with its extreme, the shock wave. The engineering side, such as silencers and mounts, is in the engineering module on vibration.
2.1 Sound is a pressure wave, so it needs a material, and its speed rises with the medium's stiffness and falls with its density
Clap once. Your palms squeeze the air between them, that squeezed pocket pushes the pocket next to it, and a pulse of raised pressure runs outward. Behind the pulse the air is briefly thinner. No air travels from your hands to the listener; each molecule only shifts a tiny distance and back.
The speed of a pressure pulse in a fluid is the square root of (bulk modulus / density), where the bulk modulus measures how strongly the fluid resists squeezing. In air at 0 °C this gives 331 m/s, and it rises about 0.6 m/s for each degree, so 343 m/s at 20 °C. The reason is that molecules pass the news by collisions, so sound cannot run much faster than the molecules themselves: it is about two thirds of their typical speed.
Water is over 800 times denser than air, yet sound is over four times faster in it, 1,480 m/s in fresh water and 1,540 m/s in sea water. Water is vastly harder to compress, and that wins. Steel is faster still, about 5,960 m/s for a long bar. Helium, with light atoms, carries sound at about 965 m/s at 0 °C.
| Question | Working | Answer |
|---|---|---|
| A tap on one end of a 1 km steel water main: how much sooner does it arrive through the steel than through the air? | Air: 1,000 m / 343 m/s = 2.9 s. Steel: 1,000 m / 5,960 m/s = 0.17 s (calculated) | about 2.7 s sooner, 17 times faster (calculated) |
| An echo sounder in sea water hears the sea bed after 0.4 s: how deep? | Sound goes down and back, so depth = 1,540 m/s x 0.4 s / 2 | about 308 m (calculated) |
| You clap facing a wall 20 m away: when do you hear the echo? | Round trip 40 m / 343 m/s | 0.12 s (calculated), just long enough to separate from the clap |
Calculated from the table in the source, air at 20 °C.
Source: OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, section 17.2 Speed of Sound, https://openstax.org/books/university-physics-volume-1/pages/17-2-speed-of-sound (air 331 m/s at 0 C; fresh water 1480 and sea water 1540 m/s at 20 C; steel 5960 m/s; speed in a fluid = square root of bulk modulus / density)- OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, section 17.2 Speed of Sound · web
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 8, 'Waves, Sound and Light'
2.2 Pitch follows frequency and loudness follows intensity, and the decibel scale counts factors of ten
Pitch is the frequency your ear attaches to a note. A young adult with typical hearing detects roughly 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz. Below that is infrasound, used by elephants and made by distant storms and earthquakes. Above it is ultrasound, used by bats, dolphins and machines, which find objects by timing echoes.
Loudness depends on the intensity, the sound power passing through each square metre. The faintest tone a normal listener detects at 1,000 Hz is about 10^-12 W/m², and the loudest concert sounds are about a million million times stronger. A scale that spans twelve powers of ten is awkward, so engineers use logarithms. The sound level in decibels is 10 x log10 (intensity / 10^-12 W/m²). Every factor of ten in intensity adds 10 dB, and doubling the intensity adds about 3 dB. Typical values: rustling leaves 10 dB, a whisper 20, quiet room 30, conversation 60, busy traffic 70, rock concert 120.
Sound spreads, so intensity falls with the square of distance from a small source in open air: doubling the distance loses 6 dB. Sound is also tiny in power terms. The pressure change in an ordinary conversation is about 0.02 pascal, against 101,000 Pa of atmospheric pressure, so the ear is a remarkably sensitive detector.
Decibels measure the physical intensity. How loud a sound feels varies with pitch and from listener to listener.
The ear sorts pitch by place. In the cochlea of the inner ear, a coiled membrane is narrow and stiff at the entrance and wide and slack at the far end. Each frequency shakes one stretch of it most, high notes near the entrance and low notes deep in the coil, and the hair cells there signal the brain. It is resonance, the next section's subject, put to work.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Total sound power | 50,000 x 0.001 W | 50 W (calculated) |
| Spread over half a sphere at 100 m | area = 2 x pi x (100 m)² = 62,800 m² (calculated) | intensity = 50 W / 62,800 m² = 8 x 10^-4 W/m² (calculated) |
| Level in decibels | 10 x log10 (8 x 10^-4 W/m² / 10^-12 W/m²) = 10 x log10 (8 x 10^8) | about 89 dB (calculated) |
| Conversation against rock concert | (120 - 60) dB = 60 dB = 6 factors of ten | the concert is one million times as intense (calculated) |
| Two equal 60 dB fans together | 2 x intensity: 10 x log10 2 = 3 dB | about 63 dB (calculated) |
Calculated. Sound power per shouter is an assumed round number; real crowds are not all shouting at once.
Source: OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, section 17.3 Sound Intensity, https://openstax.org/books/university-physics-volume-1/pages/17-3-sound-intensity (level in dB = 10 log10(I / I0), I0 = 10^-12 W/m²; each factor of 10 in intensity is 10 dB)- OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, section 17.3 Sound Intensity · web
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 8, 'Waves, Sound and Light'
2.3 Resonance builds a large vibration from small pushes timed to an object's natural frequency, and it is how instruments are made loud
Ride an old bus and listen to a loose window. At most engine speeds it is quiet. As the engine passes one particular speed it buzzes loudly, then falls quiet again as the engine speeds up. At that speed the engine's shaking repeats at the window's own rhythm, so each shake arrives in time to add to the last. Shaking at any other rhythm often opposes the motion and nothing builds. Every object that can vibrate has natural frequencies set by its stiffness and mass. A periodic push at one of them adds energy each cycle, and the growth stops only when the energy lost per cycle (damping) equals the energy supplied.
In music this is everywhere. On a sitar or tanpura, the sympathetic strings are tuned to notes of the raga. Sound the main string and they ring by themselves. A string on its own is quiet, because something so thin moves very little air. The gourd or wooden body, driven through the bridge, has a large surface and passes far more of the string's energy into the room. That faster drain has a price: the louder note also dies sooner.
Air columns resonate too. A bamboo flute open at both ends supports a standing wave whose wavelength is twice the tube length, so the lowest note is speed / (2 x length). A pipe closed at one end has a wavelength four times its length.
Radio tuners, MRI scanners and microwave filters use the same idea (see the node 'Nuclear magnetic resonance'). For bridges, fans and engines, see the engineering module on vibration.
| Case | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Open tube, 0.50 m, air at 20 °C | wavelength = 2 x 0.50 m = 1.0 m; f = 343 m/s / 1.0 m | 343 Hz (calculated), close to the F above middle C (349 Hz) |
| Tube closed at one end, 0.25 m | wavelength = 4 x 0.25 m = 1.0 m; f = 343 m/s / 1.0 m | 343 Hz (calculated), the same note from half the length |
| Sound speed at 35 °C | 331 m/s + 0.6 m/s per °C x 35 °C | 352 m/s (calculated) |
| The same open tube at 35 °C | 352 m/s / 1.0 m | 352 Hz (calculated), 2.6% higher, about half a semitone sharp |
Calculated. End effects make real tubes sound a little lower than the simple rule.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 8, 'Waves, Sound and Light'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 8, 'Waves, Sound and Light'
2.4 A moving source squeezes the waves ahead of it and stretches those behind, which shifts the pitch and, near the speed of sound, builds a shock wave
When a train sounds its horn and passes you, the pitch drops. The horn has not changed. The Austrian physicist Christian Doppler proposed in 1842 that a source moving relative to a listener changes the frequency received. In 1845 the Dutch scientist Christophorus Buys Ballot tested it on the railway between Utrecht and Maarssen. Trumpeters on an open car held one steady note while musicians beside the track judged the pitch: about a semitone high as the car approached and a semitone low as it moved away.
The reason is plain geometry. Each wave crest leaves the source and then travels at the speed of sound, independent of the source. The source moves forward before it emits the next crest, so crests ahead of it are closer together and those behind are farther apart. For a source of frequency f moving at speed u towards a still listener, the frequency heard is f x v / (v - u), and away from the listener f x v / (v + u).
Light shows the same shift, and astronomers use it to measure how fast stars move along the line of sight (see 'Doppler effect' and 'Spectral lines'). Light from distant galaxies is shifted towards the red, more so the farther they are, which was the first evidence that the universe is expanding. Doppler weather radars follow raindrops in the same way to find wind within storms.
When the source reaches the speed of sound the crests pile up into one front, a shock wave. Faster still, the front becomes a cone with half-angle given by sin(angle) = v / u. Anyone the cone sweeps across hears a boom.
| Case | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 400 Hz horn, train at 30 m/s (108 km/h), approaching | 400 Hz x 343 m/s / (343 - 30) m/s | 438 Hz (calculated) |
| The same train, receding | 400 Hz x 343 m/s / (343 + 30) m/s | 368 Hz (calculated) |
| Drop in pitch as it passes | 438 Hz / 368 Hz = 1.19 (calculated); one semitone is a ratio of 1.059 | about three semitones, a minor third (calculated) |
| Aircraft at Mach 1.5 | sin(angle) = 1 / 1.5 = 0.667 | cone half-angle 42 degrees (calculated) |
| Aircraft at Mach 2 | sin(angle) = 1 / 2 = 0.5 | cone half-angle 30 degrees (calculated) |
Calculated. Mach number is speed divided by the local speed of sound; the cone rule sin(angle) = 1 / Mach number is NASA Glenn's Mach angle relation.
Source: Windows to the Universe (UCAR), Christian Doppler, https://windows2universe.org/people/enlightenment/doppler.html (Doppler's 1842 proposal; Buys Ballot's 1845 trumpeters on a train)- Windows to the Universe (UCAR), Christian Doppler · web
- Physics Today, The fall and rise of the Doppler effect (2015) · web
- NASA Glenn Research Center, Mach angle · web
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 8, 'Waves, Sound and Light'
See it in the table
H₂O WaterSt SteelHe HeliumH2 HydrogenCheck your understanding
A sound's intensity rises from 10^-6 W/m² to 10^-4 W/m². By how many decibels does the level rise?
The intensity is 100 times larger, two factors of ten, so the level rises by 2 x 10 = 20 dB.A 0.50 m bamboo flute open at both ends is played in air at 20 °C. About what is its lowest note?
Open tube: wavelength = 2 x length = 1.0 m, so frequency = 343 / 1.0 = 343 Hz.A 400 Hz horn moves towards you at 30 m/s. Sound speed is 343 m/s. What do you hear?
Approaching source: f x v / (v - u) = 400 x 343 / 313, about 438 Hz.