Waves: sound, light, colour and the wave-particle puzzle: Waves meeting waves: interference, diffraction, Young's experiment and polarisation
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 7: Waves: sound, light, colour and the wave-particle puzzle Part 5 of 6Waves meeting waves: interference, diffraction, Young's experiment and polarisation
Particles bounce off each other. Waves pass through each other and add. That difference gives the tests that proved light to be a wave, and the limits on every lens. This part follows the sum of overlapping waves, their spreading at openings, Young's experiments from 1801 and the evidence from polarisation.
5.1 Overlapping waves add point by point, so crests can cancel troughs: silent spots, beats and noise cancellation all follow
Drop two stones into a still pond. The ripples cross and pass through each other unchanged, but where they overlap the water level is the sum of the two. This is superposition. If crest meets crest, the result is a bigger crest: constructive interference. If crest meets trough, they cancel: destructive interference.
The path decides which. Place two loudspeakers 3 m apart, both playing a pure 343 Hz tone, wavelength 1.0 m. At a spot equally far from both, the waves arrive in step and the sound is loud. At a spot half a metre farther from one speaker, the crests of one meet the troughs of the other and the sound nearly vanishes. Walk across the room and it swells and fades.
In time, two tones of close pitch, say 440 Hz and 444 Hz, drift in and out of step four times a second and you hear a swelling called beats, at a rate equal to the difference of the frequencies. Musicians tune strings until the beats slow and stop. Noise-cancelling headphones sample sound outside and play the inverse, working best on steady, low-pitched drones that are easy to predict.
Standing waves are interference between a wave and its own reflection. They fix the notes of strings and pipes. Part 2 used them in the flute.
| Case | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Two speakers playing 343 Hz (wavelength 1.0 m), listener equally far from both | path difference 0 | loud, intensity 4 times one speaker |
| Same, listener 0.5 m farther from one | path difference = half a wavelength | quiet, near zero |
| Same, listener 1.0 m farther from one | path difference = one wavelength | loud again |
| Tones of 440 Hz and 444 Hz together | beat frequency = 444 - 440 | 4 swells per second (calculated) |
| Two equal sound waves, average over space | (4 + 0) / 2 = 2 times one wave | energy is conserved |
Calculated with sound speed 343 m/s.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 8, 'Waves, Sound and Light'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 8, 'Waves, Sound and Light'
5.2 Waves spread when they pass an opening about their own size, and that sets the sharpness limit of every telescope and microscope
Sound goes round a doorway, and you hear the person you cannot see. Light seems to go straight and make sharp shadows. Both are waves, so the difference is in size. Each point of a wave front acts as a source of new wavelets, as the Dutch physicist Huygens proposed around 1678. Through a wide opening the wavelets cancel to the sides, leaving a beam. Through a gap about a wavelength wide, only a few wavelets exist and the wave spreads widely. The spreading angle is about wavelength / opening width. Light has wavelengths of about half a micrometre, so ordinary doors and windows hide the spreading.
Spreading limits detail. A lens or mirror of diameter D cannot separate two points closer than an angle of 1.22 x wavelength / D, because each point makes a blur. A bigger aperture and a shorter wavelength give a sharper picture. This is also why a microscope with visible light cannot show structures smaller than a few hundred nanometres (see 'Diffraction limit of resolution'), why electrons with much shorter wavelengths see atoms, and why X rays, with wavelengths like atomic spacing, are diffracted by crystals (see 'X-ray diffraction by crystals').
Radio astronomers get around it by joining many dishes. India's Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope near Pune has 30 dishes of 45 m spread over about 25 km. Joined together, they behave as one huge lens with a sharpness set by the 25 km spread, not by one dish.
| Instrument | Wavelength / aperture | Smallest angle |
|---|---|---|
| 10 cm amateur telescope, green light | 1.22 x 550 x 10^-9 m / 0.10 m | 6.7 x 10^-6 rad, about 1.4 arcseconds (calculated) |
| Hubble Space Telescope, 2.4 m mirror | 1.22 x 550 x 10^-9 m / 2.4 m | 2.8 x 10^-7 rad, about 0.058 arcseconds (calculated) |
| One GMRT dish, 45 m, 21 cm radio wave | 1.22 x 0.21 m / 45 m | 5.7 x 10^-3 rad, about 20 arcminutes (calculated) |
| GMRT dishes combined over 25 km | 0.21 m / 25,000 m | 8.4 x 10^-6 rad, about 1.7 arcseconds (calculated) |
Calculated. One arcsecond is 4.85 x 10^-6 rad. For the array, the wavelength divided by the longest baseline gives the approximate best angle.
Source: National Centre for Radio Astrophysics (TIFR), Introducing GMRT, https://www.gmrt.ncra.tifr.res.in/gmrt/intro_gmrt.html (30 steerable dishes of 45 m; longest baseline about 25 km; about 80 km north of Pune; 50 to 1500 MHz)- National Centre for Radio Astrophysics (TIFR), Introducing GMRT · web
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 8, 'Waves, Sound and Light'
5.3 Young's experiments, begun in 1801, made light cancel light, which only a wave can do
For a century, two pictures of light competed. Newton, in his Opticks of 1704, favoured streams of tiny particles. Huygens had favoured waves.
In 1801 Thomas Young told the Royal Society that light shows interference, and in 1807 he published the decisive test: light from a single source passing through two close, narrow openings. On a screen beyond them he saw not two bright stripes but a pattern of many: bright where the two beams arrive in step, dark where a crest meets a trough. Particles passing through two holes would make two bands, never dark places where both holes are open. Only waves can cancel each other.
The geometry gives the spacing. Bright fringes lie where the two paths differ by whole wavelengths, so the spacing on a screen a distance L away from slits separated by d is wavelength x L / d. Measured fringes thus give the wavelength, and Young's values were near the modern ones: of the order of half a micrometre. Red, with the longest wavelength, makes the widest spacing, so white light yields coloured fringes.
The same principle makes colours in a soap film or in oil spread on a wet road. Light reflects from the top and bottom surfaces of the film and the two reflections interfere, with the result depending on film thickness. A coating on a camera lens, about a quarter of a wavelength thick, is chosen so the two reflections cancel.
| Colour | Wavelength | Working | Spacing between bright fringes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Violet | 400 nm | 4.0 x 10^-7 x 2 / 5.0 x 10^-4 | 1.6 mm (calculated) |
| Green | 550 nm | 5.5 x 10^-7 x 2 / 5.0 x 10^-4 | 2.2 mm (calculated) |
| Red | 700 nm | 7.0 x 10^-7 x 2 / 5.0 x 10^-4 | 2.8 mm (calculated) |
| Anti-reflection film on glass (index 1.38) | 550 nm | thickness = 550 nm / (4 x 1.38) | about 100 nm (calculated) |
Calculated.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Young's experiment, https://www.britannica.com/science/Youngs-experiment (first performed by Thomas Young in 1801; peaks and troughs reinforce or cancel)- Encyclopaedia Britannica, Young's experiment · web
- American Physical Society, This Month in Physics History: Thomas Young and the nature of light (May 2008) · web
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 8, 'Waves, Sound and Light'
5.4 Polarisation shows that light waves shake across their path in a chosen direction, which sound waves cannot do
Shake a rope through a gap in a picket fence. A vertical shake passes; a horizontal shake is blocked. Only a transverse wave can be sorted like this. Light from the Sun or a bulb has electric fields in all directions across its path, but a polarising filter passes only one direction. In 1808 Étienne-Louis Malus noticed that light reflected from a window or water was partly polarised. Glare from roads and water is mostly horizontally polarised, so polarising sunglasses with a vertical axis cut it. Sky light is partly polarised too, by the scattering of Part 4, most strongly at 90 degrees from the Sun; a camera filter uses this to darken the sky. The screens of many phones and laptops give out polarised light: tilt a pair of polarising glasses and the screen darkens at one angle.
Two filters give Malus's law: the fraction passed is cos² of the angle between their axes. A single filter halves unpolarised light. A second at 90 degrees blocks everything. Put a third in between at 45 degrees and some light returns, because each filter makes the light polarised along its own direction.
Sound waves are longitudinal, so they cannot be polarised. That light can be gave Young and Fresnel their reason, around 1817, to conclude that light is transverse.
| Setup | Working | Fraction passed |
|---|---|---|
| One filter | 1/2 | 50% |
| Second filter, same direction | 1/2 x cos² 0° | 50% |
| Second filter at 45 degrees | 1/2 x 0.5 | 25% (calculated) |
| Second filter at 90 degrees | 1/2 x cos² 90° | 0% (calculated) |
| Filters at 0°, 45°, 90° | 1/2 x 0.5 x 0.5 | 12.5% (calculated) |
Calculated for ideal filters.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Light: unpolarized light, https://britannica.com/science/light/Unpolarized-light (Malus 1808; polarisation by reflection and by Rayleigh scattering; polarising sunglasses)- Encyclopaedia Britannica, Light: unpolarized light · web
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 8, 'Waves, Sound and Light'
See it in the table
H₂O WaterCheck your understanding
Two speakers play a 343 Hz tone (wavelength 1.0 m). A listener is 1.5 m farther from one speaker than from the other. What do they hear?
1.5 m is three half wavelengths, so crests meet troughs and the sound nearly cancels.Young's double-slit pattern could not have been produced by streams of particles because
Particles through two slits give two bright bands. Dark regions where both beams arrive require cancellation, which only waves do.Two crossed polarising filters block all light. A third filter is placed between them at 45 degrees. What fraction of an unpolarised source reaches the end?
The first filter passes 50%, the second at 45 degrees passes cos² 45° = half of that, and the third again half: 0.5 x 0.5 x 0.5 = 12.5%.