OTEC and salinity power: Impact on the biosphere
Giant intakes, cold discharges and what they mean for sea life
The main concerns are the very large water intakes and discharges: organisms caught on screens, nutrient-rich cold water released near the surface, and chemicals used against fouling. Experience is limited to small pilots.
Discharge depth that avoids affecting the upper 40 m (DOE model) 70 m or deeper1 Water or salt consumed by salinity plants None2 Life-cycle emissions, 1 MW hybrid OTEC (prediction) 71.5 g CO2e/kWh5Effects over time
| Life affected | Short term | Medium term | Long term |
|---|---|---|---|
| Humans1 | Little evidence of effect. | Plants can supply fresh water and cooling to islands, and avoid fuel imports. | Little evidence of effect. |
| Animals1910 | Construction disturbance at pipe routes. | Fish and plankton trapped on intake screens or drawn through the plant; pumps may disturb marine mammals; salinity plant intakes pose similar risks. | Little evidence of effect. |
| Plants1 | Little evidence of effect. | Warm or nutrient-rich discharge could cause algal blooms. | Little evidence of effect. |
| Fungi and soil life1 | Little evidence of effect. | Little evidence of effect. | Little evidence of effect. |
| Ecosystems1911 | Small footprint at pilot scale. | Discharge could change local temperature, nutrients and salinity, and upwelled cold water poses unknown risks to seabed and deep-water organisms; biocides are used against fouling. | Large-scale OTEC could alter ocean thermal structure; only modelled. |
How the effects are reduced
Discharging cold water below the thermocline, intake screens and low intake velocities, fencing against fish entrapment, careful biocide dosing, and mechanical pre-treatment or fouling-resistant membranes for salinity plants.
Sources
- Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion: Technology Brief IRENA, 2014
- Salinity Gradient Energy: Technology Brief IRENA, 2014
- Prediction of emission intensity for 1 MW onshore H-OTEC in Malaysia (Phua et al., Grand Renewable Energy proceedings) J-STAGE, 2022
- Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion (OTEC) Environmental Impacts (fact sheet based on NOAA material) PNNL Tethys
- Potential local environmental impacts of salinity gradient energy: A review (Seyfried, Palko and Dubbs, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 102) Elsevier, 2019
- OES-Environmental 2024 State of the Science Report, Chapter 11: Summary and Path Forward PNNL / Ocean Energy Systems, 2024