Solar fuels and photosynthesis: Resources and labour
Vast farmland, rare catalysts and sunlight focused 2,500 times
Photosynthesis needs land, water and nutrients on a vast scale. Artificial routes need far less land per unit of fuel but rely on concentrated sunlight, specialised semiconductors, precious-metal catalysts, and water and CO2 as feedstock. Labour figures for these research-stage routes do not exist.
Natural resources
| Resource | How much | Why it is needed |
|---|---|---|
| Land (photosynthesis) | 48 million km2 for agriculture, 80% of it for livestock and 16% for food crops6 | Sunlight is spread thinly and crops convert under 2% of it, so large areas are needed. |
| Land (artificial routes) | No per-unit figure in the sources used5 | Mirror fields or panels must collect enough sunlight; desert land unsuitable for crops can be used. |
| Water and CO2 feedstock | Inputs for every route; jet fuel combustion emitted about 1,027 Mt of CO2 in 201958 | Hydrogen comes from splitting water; carbon for hydrocarbon fuels must come from CO2 captured from air or industry. |
| Catalysts and semiconductors | No per-unit quantities; the record photoelectrochemical device uses rhodium3 | Catalysts lower the energy needed to form hydrogen and oxygen; semiconductors absorb light and separate charge. Scarce metals are a barrier to scale. |
| Concentrated sunlight | About 2,500 suns (thermochemical); concentrated light also used for the photocatalytic record45 | Concentration raises temperatures and reaction rates so that small, expensive reactors produce more. |
Labour
| Phase | How much | Skills | Why it is needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Research and pilot plants | No figure in the sources used5 | Materials scientists, electrochemists, chemical and optical engineers | All artificial routes are still in laboratories and test facilities. |
| Agriculture and forestry (photosynthesis) | No figure in the sources used (see the Biomass tile)6 | Farmers, foresters, agronomists | Planting, tending and harvesting turn photosynthesis into usable energy. |
Sources
- Monolithic Photoelectrochemical Device for Direct Water Splitting with 19% Efficiency (Cheng et al., ACS Energy Letters 3, 1795-1800) American Chemical Society, 2018
- Solar-to-hydrogen efficiency of more than 9% in photocatalytic water splitting (Zhou et al., Nature 613, 66-70) Nature, 2023
- A solar tower fuel plant for the thermochemical production of kerosene from H2O and CO2 (Zoller et al., Joule 6(7), 1606-1616) Cell Press, 2022
- Half of the world's habitable land is used for agriculture Our World in Data, 2024
- Researchers produce jet fuel from sunlight, CO2 and water (citing IEA for 2019 jet fuel emissions) The Chemical Engineer (IChemE), 2022