Structures and materials: stress, stiffness, strength and why things break: Loads and load paths: how weight finds its way to the ground
All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 4: Structures and materials: stress, stiffness, strength and why things break Part 1 of 5Loads and load paths: how weight finds its way to the ground
A structure has one job: to hand every force it receives down to the ground without breaking or moving too much. This part follows weight through a building, names the four ways a member can be loaded, and defines stress and strain, the two ideas that let an engineer compare a thin wire with a thick column on the same footing.
1.1 Every structure is a chain of members that hands weight down to the ground
Stand in a flat on the fifth floor. Your weight goes into the floor tiles, and the tiles pass it to a concrete slab. The slab does not stop there. It leans on beams, the beams rest on columns, the columns stand on footings, and the footings press on soil. That sequence is the load path. If any link is too weak, too flexible or badly connected to the next, the chain fails, however strong the other links are.
Engineers separate the loads on a building by how they behave. Dead load is the weight of the building itself, which never goes away. Live load is people, furniture and stored goods, which come and go. Wind and earthquake loads are pushes that act sideways, so the load path must also carry them down. Settlement of soil and changes of temperature load a building too, quietly, by forcing parts to move when they are not free to.
The first surprise is that dead load usually dominates. Concrete weighs about 25 kN per cubic metre, so a 125 mm slab already weighs about 3.1 kN for every square metre of floor. Add 1.0 kN/m2 for floor finish and the Indian loading standard IS 875 (part 2) sets 2.0 kN/m2 for people in a home, and the people are the smaller share. A building mostly carries itself. This is the same weight = mass x g from the module Force, motion and energy, now added up over a whole floor.
The second idea is equilibrium. Each member pushes down on the one below, and the one below must push back up equally, or the whole thing would accelerate. Tracing a load path is therefore a bookkeeping job: at every joint, what comes in must go out. The worked chain on this page does that for one column of a small eight-storey building.
The trade-off appears at once. Longer spans give open rooms and flexible layouts, but they make the beams deeper and heavier, and a heavier floor adds to the dead load that every member below must carry.
one bay is 4 m x 3 m = 12 m2, so 6.1 x 12 = 73 kN per floor
2 Column, 8 floors8 x 73 = about 590 kN at the foot, roughly 60 tonnes-force, before walls and the column itself
3 Footingsoil safe at 150 kN per m2, so area = 590 / 150 = 3.9 m2, about 2 m x 2 m
Outputs Pressure on soilabout 150 kN per m2, about 15 tonnes-force per m2All results calculated. Check: real columns also carry brick infill walls, which can double the load, so footings of 2.5 m x 2.5 m are common for such buildings. The estimate puts you in the right range.
Source: Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 875 (Part 2):1987, Imposed loads, table 1, imposed floor loads; https://law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/S03/is.875.2.1987.pdf- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 1, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 1'
- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 3, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 1'
- Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 875 (Part 2):1987, Imposed loads · table 1, imposed floor loads; https://law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/S03/is.875.2.1987.pdf
1.2 A member can be pulled, squeezed, slid or bent, and each way asks something different of the material
Pick up a pencil, a rubber band and a ruler. Pull the rubber band and you load it in tension: the material is being stretched along its length. A stone pillar under a temple roof is in compression: it is being shortened. Cut paper with scissors and you apply shear, two forces side by side acting in opposite directions so that one layer slides on the next. Rest the ruler across two books and press down in the middle, and you bend it. Twist a wet towel and you apply torsion, the fifth way, which matters for shafts and not so much for buildings.
Bending is the one to understand well, because it is not a new kind of force. It is tension and compression at the same time. When the ruler sags, its top face is shortened and its bottom face is stretched. Somewhere between them lies a layer that is neither, called the neutral axis. A plank across a drain is a bending member, and so is every floor beam and bridge girder.
The four actions matter because materials are not equally good at all of them. Brick, stone and concrete resist squeezing well and pulling badly: concrete can take about ten times as much compression as tension. A rope or a chain takes only tension. A long, thin steel rod handles tension well and may fold sideways in compression. Timber is strong along the grain and weak across it. Choosing a material and choosing a member shape are the same decision.
Pure tension and pure compression are efficient, because every part of the cross-section works equally hard. Bending is wasteful, because the material near the neutral axis is hardly stressed while the edges do all the work. That single fact explains much of structural engineering. Beams are given shapes that move material to the edges, and whole structures such as trusses, arches and cables are shaped so that the load travels as plain pull or squeeze instead of bending.
| Action | What happens inside | Everyday case | Material it suits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tension | Material pulled apart along its length | Hanging rod of a ceiling fan; a cable | Steel, rope, timber along the grain |
| Compression | Material shortened and squeezed | Column of a building; a brick pillar | Concrete, brick, stone, steel in short lengths |
| Shear | Layers slide past each other | A bolt joining two plates; scissors | Ductile metals; bolts sized by area |
| Bending | Tension on one face, compression on the other | Floor beam; a plank across a drain | Deep shapes: I-sections, reinforced concrete |
| Torsion | Twisting about the long axis | A drive shaft; a spanner on a nut | Round tubes and shafts |
Most real members carry a mixture. A column in a frame is usually squeezed and a little bent.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 3, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 1'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 3, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 1'
1.3 Stress is force per area and strain is stretch per length, so both ignore the size of the part
Hang a 1 kg weight from a thread and from a thick rope. The thread may snap, the rope will not notice. The weight is the same, but the rope has far more material to share the load. What the material feels is the force per unit area, called stress: stress = force / area. The unit is the pascal, one newton per square metre. It is tiny, so engineers use the megapascal, MPa, which is exactly one newton per square millimetre. That makes arithmetic easy: 1,000 N on 100 mm2 is 10 MPa.
Strain is the fractional change in length: strain = change in length / original length. It is a pure number, with no unit. A strain of 0.001 means a metre-long rod has stretched by one millimetre. Engineers also write it as a percentage or as microstrain, millionths.
Why bother? Because strength is a stress, not a force. A material fails when the stress reaches a limit that belongs to the material, whatever the size of the part. Mild structural steel yields at about 250 MPa. A bar with 100 mm2 of cross-section yields at 25 kN, and one with 1,000 mm2 at 250 kN. Stress separates what the material can do from what the designer chose.
Stress also explains the scaling rule from Thinking in estimates. If you double every dimension of a part, its area grows four times and its weight eight times, so the stress from its own weight doubles. Large structures spend an ever bigger share of their strength just holding themselves up.
The worked estimate checks the steel hook above a ceiling fan. Hooks are cheap and tiny, yet nobody fears them, and the stress shows why: the steel in the rod is barely working. The weak point of a fan mount is usually elsewhere, in how the hook is anchored into the slab or how the bent portion is formed.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Fan weight | 4 kg x 9.8 m/s2 | 39 N |
| Allowance for wobble, starting and a hard knock (a factor of 3) | 39 x 3 | 118 N |
| Cross-section of an 8 mm round steel hook rod | 3.14 x 8 x 8 / 4 | 50 mm2 |
| Stress in the rod | 118 N / 50 mm2 | 2.3 MPa |
| Yield stress of mild steel | given | 250 MPa |
| Ratio, yield over stress | 250 / 2.3 | about 100 |
All results calculated. Check: 118 N on 50 mm2 is far below the limit, so the rod could carry about 100 times the assumed load before yielding. A hook that fails in service has nearly always pulled out of its anchorage or been bent open at the curve.
Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 11, 'Materials Engineering'- Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 11, 'Materials Engineering'
- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 3, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 1'
See it in the table
St SteelTm TimberCheck your understanding
A bar of cross-section 200 mm2 carries a pull of 10 kN. What is the stress?
Stress = force / area = 10,000 N / 200 mm2 = 50 N/mm2, which is 50 MPa. The other numbers come from slips with the 1,000 in kilonewtons or from inverting the division.Why is bending described as a wasteful way to load a member?
In bending, stress rises from zero at the neutral axis to a maximum at the outer faces, so much of the cross-section is lightly used. Pure tension or compression stresses all of the section equally.In the worked chain for the eight-storey block, which load is the biggest share of the 6.1 kN/m2 floor load?
A 125 mm concrete slab weighs 25 kN/m3 x 0.125 m = 3.1 kN/m2, more than people and finishes together at 3.0. Dead load usually dominates buildings.