Structures and materials: stress, stiffness, strength and why things break: Shapes that use material well: beams, tubes, arches, trusses and cables
All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 4: Structures and materials: stress, stiffness, strength and why things break Part 3 of 5Shapes that use material well: beams, tubes, arches, trusses and cables
The same steel can make a floppy bar or a stiff girder depending on its shape. This part shows why deep, hollow and triangulated forms carry more for less metal, how an engineer sizes a floor beam, why long thin columns fold sideways, and how cables, arches and trusses turn bending into plain pull and squeeze.
3.1 A beam works hardest at its top and bottom edges, so good beams put their material there
When a beam bends, the stress at any point depends on its distance from the neutral axis. In words: stress = bending moment x distance from the middle / second moment of area. The bending moment is the turning effect of the loads at that section, introduced under torque in Force, motion and energy. The second moment of area, I, measures how far the cross-section's material sits from the middle. It grows with the cube of depth for a rectangle, so doubling depth makes the section eight times stiffer and four times stronger in bending, for twice the material.
The formula yields a procedure. Find the largest bending moment. For a uniform load w over a simple span L, it is w x L x L / 8, at the middle. Divide it by the stress you allow. The result is the section modulus, I / (half-depth), which the catalogue of rolled sections lists. Choose a section that offers at least that. Then check the sag, which for a uniform load is 5 x w x L to the fourth / (384 x E x I).
The worked estimate does this for a floor beam in an Indian house, using the loads from Part 1. The result shows why I-sections dominate. Thin flanges at top and bottom carry the bending, a thin web joins them and carries the shear. A solid rectangle of equal strength would need nearly three times the steel. Timber floors in older houses use deep, narrow joists for the same reason, and are laid on edge.
There is a trade-off. The deeper a beam, the more storey height it uses up. A very thin web can crumple under a concentrated load, and thin flanges can buckle. Real designs also check shear, local buckling and vibration, the last of which is the subject of the module Vibration, waves and resonance. The site's science node Beam theory gives the formal derivation.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Floor load (from Part 1) | 3.1 slab + 1.0 finish + 2.0 people | 6.1 kN per m2 |
| Load per metre on the beam | 6.1 kN/m2 x 3 m | 18.3 kN/m |
| Largest bending moment | 18.3 x 4 x 4 / 8 | 36.6 kN m |
| Allowed stress (60 per cent of 250 MPa yield) | 0.6 x 250 | 150 MPa |
| Section modulus needed | 36.6 x 1,000,000 N mm / 150 N/mm2 | 244,000 mm3 = 244 cm3 |
| A solid steel rectangle 80 x 135 mm | 80 x 135 x 135 / 6 = 243,000 mm3 | mass 10,800 mm2 x 7,850 = 85 kg/m |
| Rolled I-section ISMB 225 (IS 808: I = 3,440 cm4) | section modulus 306 cm3 | mass 31.2 kg/m |
| Sag of the I-beam | 5 x 18.3 x 4 to the 4th / (384 x 200 GPa x 3,400 cm4) = 5 x 18,300 x 256 / (384 x 200e9 x 3.4e-5) | about 9 mm |
| Sag limit, span / 300 | 4,000 / 300 | 13 mm, so it passes |
Check: the solid bar is 85 / 31 = 2.7 times heavier for the same strength. All results calculated. If a timber beam had the same second moment of area, with E near 12 GPa, the sag would be about 150 mm, so floors in timber use far deeper sections. The beam's own weight (0.3 kN/m) is small enough to ignore here.
Source: Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 800:2007, General construction in steel, E = 200,000 MPa, Euler buckling stress (cl. 7.1.2.1), deflection limits (table 6); figures as commonly summarised, not read from the code- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 3, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 1'
- Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 800:2007, General construction in steel · E = 200,000 MPa, Euler buckling stress (cl. 7.1.2.1), deflection limits (table 6); figures as commonly summarised, not read from the code
3.2 Hollow tubes give much more stiffness per kilogram, but slender columns fold sideways long before they crush
Roll a sheet of A4 paper into a tube and stand a light book on it. Lay the same sheet flat across two cups and it sags under a coin. The tube works because the material is moved away from the middle, where it contributes nothing to bending, to the outside, where it contributes most. Bamboo, bird bones, bicycle frames, scaffolding poles and electric poles all follow this rule. The tradeoff is that the wall can become so thin that it wrinkles locally under load. A rule of thumb is to keep the wall thicker than about one-fiftieth of the diameter.
Columns have a second trap. A column under compression can fail by crushing, when the stress reaches the yield. Or it can fail by buckling, when it bows sideways like a plastic ruler squeezed end to end. Buckling happens at a load that depends on stiffness, not strength. For a column with pinned ends, the buckling load is pi squared x E x I / (length squared). Length is squared in the bottom: double the length and the load falls to a quarter. A short, stubby column crushes, a long, slender one buckles, and which comes first depends on the shape.
The estimate compares a solid steel rod of 20 mm diameter and a steel tube of 40 mm outside diameter with the same amount of steel, for a 3 m column. Both could crush at 78 kN, about 8 tonnes. The rod buckles at only 1.7 kN, about 175 kg, and a person leaning on it would bend it. The tube buckles at 12 kN, seven times the rod. This is why a tall bamboo or steel-tube scaffold is braced at intervals: each brace shortens the buckling length and raises the load sharply.
The same few kilograms of steel can act like a noodle or a pillar, depending on shape.
| Quantity | Solid rod, 20 mm diameter | Tube, 40 mm outside, 2.7 mm wall |
|---|---|---|
| Steel area | 3.14 x 20 x 20 / 4 = 314 mm2 | about 316 mm2 |
| Mass per metre | 314 mm2 x 7,850 kg/m3 = 2.5 kg/m | 2.5 kg/m |
| Second moment of area, I | 3.14 x 20 to the 4th / 64 = 7,850 mm4 | 3.14 x (40 to the 4th minus 34.6 to the 4th) / 64 = 55,300 mm4 |
| Bending stiffness, relative | 1 | about 7 |
| Crushing load at 250 MPa | 250 x 314 = 78 kN | 250 x 316 = 79 kN |
| Buckling load, 3.14 squared x E x I / L squared (E = 200,000 MPa, L = 3,000 mm) | 9.87 x 200,000 x 7,850 / 9,000,000 = 1.7 kN | 9.87 x 200,000 x 55,300 / 9,000,000 = 12 kN |
All results calculated. Check: a 3 m steel rod of 20 mm that carries only 175 kg before bowing matches the familiar flimsiness of a long garden stake. Both columns buckle at under one sixth of the crushing load, so buckling, not strength, sets the design. Fixing both ends instead of pinning them would quadruple the buckling loads.
Source: Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 800:2007, General construction in steel, E = 200,000 MPa, Euler buckling stress (cl. 7.1.2.1), deflection limits (table 6); figures as commonly summarised, not read from the code- Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 800:2007, General construction in steel · E = 200,000 MPa, Euler buckling stress (cl. 7.1.2.1), deflection limits (table 6); figures as commonly summarised, not read from the code
3.3 Arches, trusses and cables avoid bending by sending the load along the member as pure squeeze or pull
A string of beads hangs in a smooth curve, held up only by tension. Turn that curve upside down and you have an arch, held up only by compression. Roman aqueducts and old brick railway bridges rely on this. A well-shaped arch keeps the squeeze line inside the masonry, so the material, strong in compression and weak in tension, is never pulled. The price is a horizontal push at the feet, called the thrust. A solid abutment, a buttress or a tie across the base must resist it, and a failing foundation can open an arch.
A truss uses triangles. Four bars hinged in a rectangle can slide into a parallelogram, while three bars in a triangle cannot change shape without changing length. Join triangles into a frame and each bar carries only tension or compression. Railway girders, factory roofs and the crane jibs in the site's Lifting crane and Tower crane entries are trusses. The saving in metal is large. The cost is many joints, much cutting and welding, and in a corrosive setting many places for rust to start.
A cable can only pull. It has no stiffness against bending, and cannot be squeezed. A suspension bridge hangs the deck from vertical hangers on two main cables slung over towers, as in the Iron suspension bridge entry. A cable-stayed bridge, the site's Cable-stayed bridge entry, runs straight stays from a tower to the deck. For a straight stay, the tension is the vertical load it holds divided by the sine of its angle to the horizontal. A flat angle makes the tension large for the same load, so stays are steep and towers are tall. Everything the cable pulls in, the deck and tower must squeeze.
The worked estimate sizes one stay. It also shows a general design habit: working stress is limited to a fraction of the breaking strength, in this case 45 per cent, because cables are loaded repeatedly and their failure is sudden.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Load on the deck per metre (dead and traffic) | assumed for a wide road deck | 150 kN/m |
| Length of deck hung from one stay | stays 10 m apart | 10 m |
| Vertical load on the stay | 150 x 10 | 1,500 kN |
| Angle of the stay to the horizontal | 30 degrees, sine = 0.5 | tension = 1,500 / 0.5 = 3,000 kN |
| Strand: 15.2 mm, area 140 mm2, strength 1,860 MPa | breaking load 1,860 x 140 | 260 kN |
| Working load per strand at 45 per cent of breaking | 0.45 x 260 | 117 kN |
| Strands needed | 3,000 / 117 | about 26, so use 27 |
| Steel area and stress | 27 x 140 = 3,780 mm2; 3,000,000 N / 3,780 | 794 MPa |
| Length if the tower attachment is 40 m above the deck | 40 / 0.5 | 80 m, mass 3,780 mm2 x 7,850 x 80 m = about 2.4 t |
| Push along the deck from this stay | 3,000 x cos 30 degrees | about 2,600 kN |
All results calculated; 45 per cent of breaking strength is the usual service limit for stay cables in international stay-cable recommendations. Check: a long-span bridge has stays of 50 to 150 strands, so 27 is a plausible middle-sized stay. The horizontal push of 2,600 kN shows how the deck and tower are squeezed, so a cable-stayed deck is designed as a compressed beam as well as a hung one.
Source: Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 1343:2012, Prestressed concrete, and IS 14268, Uncoated stress-relieved low-relaxation seven-ply strand, 15.2 mm strand of 140 mm2 and 1,860 MPa, modulus about 195 GPa; figures as commonly summarised, not read from the codes- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 3, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 1'
- Petroski, To Engineer Is Human (Macmillan, 1985) · ch. 13, 'The Ups and Downs of Bridges'
See it in the table
St SteelTm TimberCheck your understanding
A beam's depth is doubled and its width kept the same. How does its bending stiffness (second moment of area) change?
For a rectangle, I = width x depth cubed / 12, so doubling depth multiplies I by 2 x 2 x 2 = 8. This is why deep shapes are efficient.Why does a 3 m, 20 mm steel rod fail in compression at 1.7 kN when its crushing load is 78 kN?
Euler buckling load = pi squared x E x I / L squared. For a slender rod this is far below the crushing load, so the rod bows out long before it crushes.A stay is changed from a 30 degree angle to a 15 degree angle (sine 0.26), with the same vertical load. What happens to its tension?
Tension = vertical load / sin(angle). Changing the sine from 0.5 to 0.26 raises tension by about 1.9 times, so flatter cables need much more steel.