Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Structures and materials: stress, stiffness, strength and why things break: Concrete, timber, plastics and composites: building with what each does well

All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 4: Structures and materials: stress, stiffness, strength and why things break Part 4 of 5

Concrete, timber, plastics and composites: building with what each does well

Most structures are made from a few materials, each used where its strengths count and its weaknesses are covered. This part explains why concrete needs steel inside it, how stretching that steel in advance makes concrete beams carry far more, and where timber, plastics and fibre composites fit.

4.1 Reinforced concrete puts steel where the concrete would be pulled apart

Concrete is cement paste, sand and stones that have set to an artificial rock. It is cheap, shapeable, fire-resistant and strong in compression: Indian grade M25 means that 150 mm cubes tested at 28 days crush at 25 MPa or more in at least 95 per cent of tests. In tension it is poor, about 3.5 MPa in a bending test, and it cracks at tiny strains. A concrete beam alone, loaded in bending, would break as soon as the tension at the bottom face cracked, with no warning.

The remedy is to place steel bars in the tension zone. Concrete then does the squeezing at the top, steel does the pulling at the bottom, and the cracks that open in the concrete are held to a hairline by the bars. Three accidents of nature make the partnership work. Concrete grips ribbed bars firmly, so force passes from one to the other. Steel and concrete expand with temperature almost equally, so the bond is not broken by sun and shade. And the lime in cement makes the pore water strongly alkaline, which coats steel in a thin protective film, an effect the site explains under Passivation and corrosion resistance. See the technology nodes Reinforced concrete, Portland cement and the product Steel reinforcing bar for the supply side.

In design, the engineer finds the bending moment, estimates the lever arm between squeezing and pulling forces, and divides the pull by the design stress of the steel. The estimate does this for the beam in Part 3. The answer is a surprise: two 16 mm bars, only 1.3 per cent of the beam's weight, are enough.

The rest is detail: stirrups for shear, enough concrete cover to keep rust away, and ductile detailing at joints so that an earthquake bends a frame instead of breaking it. The trade-off is weight: concrete floors are heavy, so the structure spends a lot of its capacity just carrying itself.

Data Worked estimate 8: steel in a 230 x 450 mm concrete beam carrying the Part 3 floor, span 4 m
StepWorkingResult
Service bending moment (from Part 3)18.3 x 4 x 4 / 836.6 kN m
Design moment, load factor 1.51.5 x 36.655 kN m
Lever arm, about 0.9 x effective depth 400 mm0.9 x 400360 mm
Pull in the steel55,000,000 N mm / 360 mm153 kN
Design stress of Fe500 steel (500 / 1.15)0.87 x 500435 MPa
Steel area needed153,000 N / 435 N/mm2351 mm2
Bars chosen: two of 16 mm (201 mm2 each)2 x 201402 mm2
Steel share of the beam's mass2 bars x 1.58 kg/m = 3.2 kg/m, against 0.23 x 0.45 x 2,400 = 248 kg/mabout 1.3 per cent

All results calculated; load factor 1.5 and steel factor 1.15 are from IS 456. Check: the steel area is 0.44 per cent of width x effective depth (402 / (230 x 400)), above the IS 456 minimum of 0.85 / fy, 0.17 per cent, and far below its maximum of 4 per cent of the whole section. The 0.9 lever arm also checks: the squeezed zone is only about 85 mm deep. The beam's own weight (2.6 kN/m) is extra and would add a few more millimetres of steel in a full design.

Source: Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 456:2000, Plain and reinforced concrete, cl. 5.6.3, 6.2.2, 6.2.5.1, 23.2, 26.4 (table 16), 26.5.1.1, 36.4.2, 38.1 and table 18; https://law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/S03/is.456.2000.pdf
  • Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 456:2000, Plain and reinforced concrete · cl. 5.6.3, 6.2.2, 6.2.5.1, 23.2, 26.4 (table 16), 26.5.1.1, 36.4.2, 38.1 and table 18; https://law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/S03/is.456.2000.pdf

4.2 Prestressed concrete squeezes the concrete in advance so that loads must first undo the squeeze before they can crack it

A row of books can be lifted sideways by squeezing the two end books hard between your palms: the squeeze holds the whole row together, though nothing is glued. Prestressed concrete uses the same idea. High-strength steel strands are tensioned, then anchored to the concrete so that they compress it for ever. When traffic bends the girder, the bottom face, which would have been in tension, only loses some of its squeeze. It does not crack. The site covers it as Prestressed concrete, and the factory-made girders under urban flyovers are among the Precast concrete products.

There are two methods. In pre-tensioning, strands are stretched between fixed ends in a casting bed, concrete is poured round them, and when it hardens the strands are released and grip it through bond. In post-tensioning, strands slide in ducts cast into the concrete and are stretched against it after hardening, then grouted. Bridge decks, slabs without beams and storage tanks are often post-tensioned.

Prestressing requires strong steel for a precise reason. Concrete keeps shortening for years under squeeze, a change called creep, and also shrinks as it dries. Together they may shorten a girder by 0.0005 to 0.0008 of its length, and the strands shorten with it, losing tension. Ordinary Fe500 bar stressed to 300 MPa has a strain of only 0.0015, so a shortening of 0.0006 would erase 40 per cent of the force. A strand at 1,400 MPa carries a strain above 0.007, so the same 0.0006 loses less than 10 per cent. Only very strong steel keeps most of its pull.

The gain is thinner girders and longer spans for the same weight, and cracks stay shut, which protects the steel. The cost is skilled work, anchorages that must be right, and a failure risk that is hard to see because the strands are buried. Post-tensioned ducts that are poorly grouted have corroded in service.

Data Worked estimate 9: precompression in a precast bridge girder
StepWorkingResult
Strands: 20 of 15.2 mm20 x 140 mm22,800 mm2
Initial stress, 75 per cent of 1,860 MPa0.75 x 1,8601,395 MPa
Initial force2,800 mm2 x 1,395 N/mm23,906 kN
Losses (creep, shrinkage, relaxation), 20 per cent0.8 x 3,9063,125 kN
Concrete section areaassumed girder of 0.40 m2400,000 mm2
Average squeeze in the concrete3,125,000 N / 400,000 mm27.8 MPa
Tension the squeeze can cancel before concrete is pulledequal to the squeeze7.8 MPa

All results calculated. Check: M45 concrete crushes at 45 MPa, so a squeeze of 7.8 MPa uses under a fifth of its capacity. Real girders place the strands low, below the middle, so the squeeze is uneven and cancels more tension at the bottom face than this average suggests.

Source: Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 1343:2012, Prestressed concrete, and IS 14268, Uncoated stress-relieved low-relaxation seven-ply strand, 15.2 mm strand of 140 mm2 and 1,860 MPa, modulus about 195 GPa; figures as commonly summarised, not read from the codes
  • Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 1343:2012, Prestressed concrete, and IS 14268, Uncoated stress-relieved low-relaxation seven-ply strand · 15.2 mm strand of 140 mm2 and 1,860 MPa, modulus about 195 GPa; figures as commonly summarised, not read from the codes
  • Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 456:2000, Plain and reinforced concrete · cl. 5.6.3, 6.2.2, 6.2.5.1, 23.2, 26.4 (table 16), 26.5.1.1, 36.4.2, 38.1 and table 18; https://law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/S03/is.456.2000.pdf

4.3 Timber, plastics and composites each cover a weakness of the others, and none is best at everything

Timber is a natural composite of long cellulose fibres glued by lignin, so it is strong along the grain and weak across it. With E around 10 to 12 GPa, it is less than half as stiff as concrete, but it weighs under a third as much. Its strength per kilogram is better than mild steel's. Timber stores carbon, is renewable and can be worked with hand tools, but it burns, rots when damp and varies from board to board. Glued boards crossed in layers, as in Cross-laminated timber, reduce that variation and let floors and walls be built from large panels. The commodity node Timber lists its supply.

Plastics have low stiffness, 0.8 to 4 GPa, and low strength. Their special weakness is creep: under steady load they keep deforming for years, and warm plastics creep faster. A HDPE water pipe is therefore rated by its 50-year strength, which is far below its quick-test value. Their special strength is that they do not rust and are cheap to mould, which is why pipes, tanks and cable ducts are plastic.

Composites embed strong, stiff fibres in a plastic matrix. The fibres carry the load, the matrix holds them in place and passes load between them. Carbon-fibre composites reach stiffness near 135 GPa along the fibres at 1,550 kg/m3. Along the fibres they are the best structural material by weight, across them poor. They are made by laying fibres where the stress will run. This is why aircraft skins, wind-turbine blades and bridge repair wraps use them, and why the site lists Carbon fibre composites and Aramid fibre. Their cost is high, and they often break without warning.

Reinforced concrete is itself a composite, as are plywood and bamboo. The method is old: find two materials with opposite weaknesses and join them. The tree below sorts the main families by what they are best used for.

Value chain Structural materials by family: best at, and watch out for
  • Structural materials Choice follows the load, the weight allowed and the budget
    • Metals Strong in tension and compression; ductile
      • Steel E 200 GPa, yield 250 to 500 MPa; heavy, rusts
      • Aluminium E 70 GPa, a third of steel's density; fatigue-sensitive, welds lose strength
    • Stone-like materials Strong squeezed, weak pulled; brittle
      • Concrete 20 to 60 MPa compression, 2 to 4 MPa tension; heavy
      • Brick and stone Good in compression, poor in tension and shear
      • Glass Brittle, strength set by surface flaws
    • Natural fibre Strong along the fibres
      • Timber E about 10 GPa; burns and rots, creeps over decades
      • Bamboo Hollow tube with strong fibres; local and cheap
    • Plastics Light, rustproof, easy to mould
      • HDPE and PVC E 0.8 to 4 GPa; creep, soften when warm
      • Nylon E about 3 GPa; absorbs water
    • Composites Two materials with opposite weaknesses joined
      • Reinforced and prestressed concrete Steel for pull, concrete for squeeze
      • Carbon-fibre composite E near 135 GPa along fibres; costly, brittle
Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 11, 'Materials Engineering'
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 11, 'Materials Engineering'
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 12, 'Mechanical Engineering' (section 12.4.1, mechanical behaviour of materials)

See it in the table

H₂O WaterSt SteelCem CementCaO LimeTm Timber

Check your understanding

Why do engineers put the steel bars of a simply supported concrete beam near the bottom?

In a simply supported beam under a downward load, the bottom face is in tension. Concrete is about ten times weaker in tension than in compression, so bars are placed there.

Why must prestressing steel be very high-strength steel?

A strand stressed to a high level stretches by a large strain, so the small shortening from creep and shrinkage removes only a small fraction of the force. Low-strength bar has little strain to spare.

Which of these is the main reason a HDPE pipe is rated at its 50-year strength?

Plastics keep deforming slowly under constant stress, so their long-term strength is well below the quick test strength.
← Part 3: Shapes that use material well: beams, tubes, arches, trusses and cablesMark read · Part 5: Why things break: cracks, fatigue, corrosion, creep and the margin that keeps them standing →