Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

What engineers do: rules of thumb, the method and the kinds of engineering knowledge: The kinds of knowledge engineers use

All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 1: What engineers do: rules of thumb, the method and the kinds of engineering knowledge Part 2 of 4

The kinds of knowledge engineers use

Watch an engineer at work and you see more than one kind of knowing. Some of it is about purpose: what the device is for and how well it must do it. Some is about the device itself: the idea that makes it work and the layout everyone expects. Some is about quantity: how to calculate and which measured values to trust. And some is about real life: what goes wrong in use and how good designers decide. Naming the kinds shows what a technology still lacks.

2.1 Every device rests on a working idea and a layout that experience has settled

Some knowledge is so basic that engineers never say it aloud. One part is the working idea: the trick by which the device does its job. Take the ceiling fan. Its trick is to swing blades round a vertical shaft so they drive a column of air downward, and moving air carries sweat away faster, so the skin cools. A factory in Kolkata or Hyderabad designing next year's model does not ask whether the fan should work some other way. That question was settled long ago.

The working idea is what makes a fan a fan and not something else. An air conditioner and a fan both serve comfort, yet they rest on different tricks: one moves air past you, the other carries heat out of the room, and a desert cooler humidifies dry air to chill it. Each trick has grown its own family of designs, test methods and typical faults. The working idea also sets the technical test of success. A fan that turns but moves no air has failed as a fan, however cheap or handsome it is.

The working idea does not come out of physics. Once someone proposes spinning blades, physics can say how much air they move and how to shape them better. But the proposal comes from a person with a purpose. A complete account of the copper, steel and air inside a fan would never, by itself, suggest building one.

The second part is the usual layout, which engineers call the normal configuration: the arrangement a whole industry has come to expect. A pressure cooker in an Indian kitchen has a sealed lid with a rubber gasket, a weighted valve that whistles, and a safety plug that melts if the valve blocks. Other layouts are possible, and some makers sell them, but this one won through decades of use because it is cheap, easy to clean and fails safely. Part 3 returns to what happens when designers leave the expected layout behind.

Value chain Five working ideas for keeping a room comfortable
  • A room that is too hot
    • Move air over the body ceiling fan, table fan
    • Evaporate water into dry air desert cooler, matka
    • Pump heat out of the room air conditioner; see 'Heat pumps, air conditioning and refrigeration'
    • Keep heat out insulation, shading; see 'Passive solar and natural cooling'
    • Store coolness for later cold water or ice, night ventilation
Source: Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990), ch. 7, 'The Anatomy of Engineering Design Knowledge'
  • Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990) · ch. 7, 'The Anatomy of Engineering Design Knowledge'

2.2 Targets, calculation methods and measured values turn a wish into numbers

With the working idea and layout fixed, a wish has to become numbers. First comes the target. 'Fill the rooftop tank quickly' is a wish. 'Lift 1,000 litres through 10 m in 10 minutes' is a target an engineer can design to. Knowing which quantities to put targets on is knowledge in its own right, and it can be slow to win. India's star label for ceiling fans, mandatory since 2023, judges a fan by its service value: cubic metres of air delivered per minute for each watt drawn. That single measure tells makers what to improve. In aviation the same search took far longer: American engineers and test pilots worked from about 1918 to 1943 before 'pleasant to fly' became a set of measurable requirements.

Next come calculation methods: formulas, models and procedures for predicting how a design will behave. They need not be deep. The power to lift water is mass flow x gravity x height, which simply says that raising a weight costs energy in proportion to the weight and the height. Then come measured values: facts about real materials, parts and processes that no formula supplies, such as the friction in a given pipe, the efficiency of a small pump, or the strength of a standard bar. The two lean on each other. A formula tells you what is worth measuring, and measurements show where the formula is too simple.

The table works the rooftop pump through. It shows why engineers carry a mental library of typical values: the physics alone gives the power the water needs, but without the efficiency figures the motor would come out too small by a factor of about two and a half.

Data Worked estimate: motor for filling a 1,000 litre rooftop tank
StepWorkingResult
Volume and time1,000 litres is 1 m3 of water; 10 minutes is 600 sFlow about 0.0017 m3/s
Mass flow1,000 kg per m3 x 0.0017 m3/sAbout 1.7 kg/s
Power given to the water1.7 kg/s x 9.8 m/s2 x 10 mAbout 163 W
Shaft powerPump efficiency assumed about 55%: 163 / 0.55About 300 W
Electric powerMotor efficiency assumed about 70%: 300 / 0.7 (pump and motor together about 40%)About 420 W, roughly 400 W
Real choiceMotor rating covers shaft power with margin for frictionHalf to one horsepower

The 55% and 70% efficiencies are round assumptions typical of small domestic pumps, pieces of measured data in the sense of this section; the 10 m lift ignores pipe friction. Results are calculated.

  • Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990) · ch. 7, 'The Anatomy of Engineering Design Knowledge'
  • Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990) · ch. 3, 'Establishment of Design Requirements: Flying-Quality Specifications for American Aircraft, 1918-1943'
  • CEEW, 'How the mandatory standard and labelling programme affects the Indian fan market' (2023) · service value in cubic metres per minute per watt, https://www.ceew.in/blogs/how-mandatory-standard-and-labelling-programme-affects-indian-fan-market

2.3 Lessons from use and the habits of good designers are the quiet half of the craft

A fifth kind of knowledge is what experience in workshops and in the field teaches about the world: facts no formula contains but without which a design fails. A pump sold where the mains sag in the evening must ride out low voltage. A pump lowered into a borewell must swallow some sand and survive the day the water runs out. A part has to be one that the local workshop can actually make to the tolerance drawn, and a bolt must sit where a mechanic's spanner can turn it. Such lessons usually arrive as a complaint, a warranty return or a failure, and they rarely reach textbooks, because they belong to a place and a trade.

The sixth kind is knowing how to design: the working habits and the judgement that turn all the other knowledge into a finished drawing. Some habits can be taught as procedure. Build a quick version, test it, learn, and build a better one. Share the work among teams by giving each a subsystem with clear boundaries. Let teams work at the same time rather than in a queue. Stop when the design clears every requirement instead of chasing a perfect one. Other habits resist being written down: a sense of which assumption is shaky, which shortcut is safe and which part will break first. People gain that sense mainly by doing, and by seeing what failed. A failure is knowledge too, because it marks the edge of what a design can do.

The six kinds work together all the time. Targets need calculations to be met, calculations need measured values, the field decides which values matter, and judgement holds the whole together. Engineering knowledge is less a shelf of separate books than a woven cloth.

The kinds make a handy checklist when you meet a new technology. What is the working idea and the usual layout? What are the targets? Which calculations apply, and which numbers are still unmeasured? What goes wrong in service? What skills does the design call for? A technology that is thin in any one of these is likely to improve slowly.

Data Six kinds of design knowledge, grouped three ways and shown on a water pump
GroupKind of knowledgeQuestion it answersPump example
Purpose and principleTargetsWhat must it achieve, in numbers?1,000 litres through 10 m in 10 minutes
Purpose and principleWorking idea and usual layoutHow does it work, and what does it normally look like?A spinning impeller flings water outward into a spiral casing
QuantityCalculation methodsHow do I predict its behaviour?Power = mass flow x gravity x height, divided by efficiency
QuantityMeasured valuesWhat do real parts and materials do?Efficiency curve from tests; friction per metre of pipe
Real lifeLessons from making and useWhat goes wrong in the workshop and the field?Sand, voltage dips, dry running
Real lifeDesign habits and judgementHow do I carry the design through?Split into motor, impeller and casing; build, test, revise

The six-way division follows Vincenti's analysis of engineering design knowledge; the plain names, grouping and examples are this course's own.

  • Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990) · ch. 7, 'The Anatomy of Engineering Design Knowledge'

2.4 Knowledge comes from desks, test rigs, shop floors and users, and science is only one source

Where does all this knowledge come from? Mostly not from university science. Historians who have traced particular designs find several sources running side by side, and it helps to sort them by place.

In someone's head: invention, the arrival of a new working idea or a new part, whether by long effort or by luck. At the desk: science borrowed and reworked, because a physics result is usually stated for an idealised case and must be recast before a designer can use it; research that builds calculation methods aimed at a design question rather than at understanding for its own sake; and ordinary design work, which keeps exposing gaps that someone then fills. At the test rig: experiments on models and parts in wind tunnels, flow channels and testing machines, done to obtain numbers no theory can give. On the shop floor: production, which shows up joints that cannot be made and tolerances that cannot be held, and sends the drawing back. And with users: the finished machine in service, whose behaviour, including how it fails, teaches what no calculation foresaw.

Much of this happens far from any laboratory, in workshops, depots and fields, often by people without degrees. India's railway workshops, auto-component clusters around Pune and Chennai and small farm-machinery makers in Punjab are full of it.

It also explains why engineering knowledge clings to practice. A tractor maker's knowledge of how a gearbox wears in black cotton soil is real knowledge, used every day, yet no journal will print it.

Value chain Where engineering knowledge is made
  • Sources of engineering knowledge
    • In someone's head invention of new working ideas and parts
    • At the desk
      • Science, borrowed and recast
      • Research on calculation methods for design
      • Everyday design work gaps found and filled
    • At the test rig wind tunnels, flow channels, testing machines
    • On the shop floor what making it reveals
    • With users service, complaints and failures
Source: Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990), ch. 7, 'The Anatomy of Engineering Design Knowledge' (seven knowledge-generating activities, regrouped here by place)
  • Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990) · ch. 7, 'The Anatomy of Engineering Design Knowledge'
  • Hammack, The Things We Make (Sourcebooks, 2023) · ch. 6, 'Science: The Gold Standard for Rules of Thumb'

See it in the table

H₂O WaterCu CopperSt SteelCt Cotton

Check your understanding

A ceiling fan and an air conditioner both cool people. What most clearly separates them in the sense of this part?

A device is defined by how it achieves its purpose. A fan moves air; an air conditioner moves heat. Each has its own tools, data and problems.

The pump estimate gave 163 W of hydraulic power, but about 400 W of electric power. What kind of knowledge supplied the difference?

The efficiencies of small pumps and motors are measured values. The physics gives the minimum power the water needs, and measurements show how much more real parts draw.

Why is a failure in the field counted as engineering knowledge?

Learning where a design breaks is among the main ways practical knowledge grows.
← Part 1: Engineering is not applied scienceMark read · Part 3: Normal design and radical design →